Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter's friends never say thank you

108 replies

TheUnconsoled · 29/12/2022 17:35

A couple of years ago we hosted our (18 year old) daughter's friends for three weeks in our home in Italy. We cooked for them, took them sightseeing, took them to the beach, etc etc. They didn't wash up a single time, didn't buy us - I don't know - an ice cream - as a token thank you, and after we had driven them three hours to the airport, turned their backs on us and walked away into the airport! I was furious but basically I'd let it go and forgotten about it. This year my daughter brought a different friend home (in the UK) for Christmas. We fetched her from the train station, cooked for her for 8 days, took them to the cinema, bought her Christmas presents so she wouldn't feel left out. She has spent her entire visit looking at her phone, like the previous guests hasn't offered even one time to wash the dishes or help out in any way. Today she got up at 2pm and has ignored the rest of us. Not a 'hello', not a 'how is everybody'. And yet again, not a single 'thank you'. She's leaving tomorrow and I am waiting to see if she says thank you for the visit to our home during which we have done everything we can to host her and make her feel welcome. I seriously doubt it. And to compound it all, our daughter doesn't seem to see anything wrong with this behaviour, or say anything to her friend(s)! It's on the tip of my tongue to say to her 'you know people normally show a little graciousness and gratitude after being offered hospitality' but ... I know that my daughter will be furious, and basically there's no point.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
moita · 31/12/2022 19:51

C1N1C · 29/12/2022 19:21

Gonna be slammed for this, but it's this generation. They're SO self-absorbed. They've been raised from a young age to post their entire lives on the Web, seek constant reassurance and approval, and unless the world revolves around them, they're not happy.

I'm 'only' mid 30s and I was raised so differently. I'd probably be more annoying to a host for offering too much help! ... I feel your pain.

I'm 36 and don't think this is true. A group of teenagers came rushing to my 4 year old's aid when she fell over in front of them in Primark yesterday. One of them cheered her up by complimenting her dolly.

These particular children the OP is talking about have bad manners - lots of people in different age groups do.

WiddlinDiddlin · 31/12/2022 18:47

Bloody tell her, on her own and kindly but tell her:

'That's twice now that we have hosted YOUR guests and they have behaved appallingly rudely, not offering to help, not saying please/thankyou or showing any common gratitude towards us. You are responsible for the behaviour of your guests and unless you're willing to ensure they do behave pleasantly and politely, we will not be welcoming guests of yours again!'

NeedToChangeName · 31/12/2022 18:11

BadNomad · 30/12/2022 01:24

I'm confused about your daughter. If your daughter is so polite and well-mannered, why does she not think there is something wrong with her friend's manners? Does she say "thank you" and help out when her friend is there? Or could the friend just be copying what she sees?

I have a lot of trouble with this stuff (I'm autistic as heck). I went away to a gorgeous cabin with my friend and her parents when we were 16. We (friend and I) didn't cook or do anything helpful, really. I was kinda shy and didn't want to impose. I didn't know what was expected of me, so I pretty much just stayed out of the way. When we went home, I did thank them for taking me away with them. But later, my friend told me her parents were shocked that I didn't buy them a gift. I had no idea this was a thing! I had no idea it was ok to insert yourself in to someone else's routine, a routine which was unknown to me. If they'd just said "Right, your turn to cook/clean/do dishes" I would have done it happily because I wasn't actually a rude, obnoxious teenager. Just quite oblivious to "the rules".

That was long. TLDR: was the friend actually being rude, or could she just have been unaware of what is expected in those types of situation?

@BadNomad i agree with you. As a teenager, I stayed with various families for a week or so. I would happily do any chores requested, but wouldn't necessarily know that a gift might be expected, or how much to spend

AnneElliott · 31/12/2022 17:39

It will be the lack of parenting. DS always offers to pay for something if he's taken anywhere (I insist on it) and would definitely have said thank you for lifts and for having him to stay - we'd have sent a gift afterwards anyway.

Agree it is more prevalent now but it does depend on how they're raised. I wouldn't be hosting friends again.

SleeplessInEngland · 31/12/2022 17:03

C1N1C · 29/12/2022 19:21

Gonna be slammed for this, but it's this generation. They're SO self-absorbed. They've been raised from a young age to post their entire lives on the Web, seek constant reassurance and approval, and unless the world revolves around them, they're not happy.

I'm 'only' mid 30s and I was raised so differently. I'd probably be more annoying to a host for offering too much help! ... I feel your pain.

You’re way too young to be giving any credence to the ‘kids today’ bullshit. As soon as you start (wrongly) believing it, you’re truly old.

mynamesnotMa · 31/12/2022 16:57

I took a my dad's friend camping paid for everything. She was polite but her mother didn't text me to say thank you. Manners seem to no longer be important. My own children are extremely polite and well mannered. I drilled it into then to say thank you and show appreciation.

Maray1967 · 31/12/2022 16:26

I’m so glad that she said thank you and left a card - sounds as though she was awkward but not ungrateful. With friends of ours (DS2 is 14) there is usually a ‘thank you ‘ but often prompted by the collecting parent …

TheUnconsoled · 31/12/2022 16:07

And a PS. This may sound weird to some of you who regularly join discussions here but ... I don't have a huge number of friends and my family is small - just myself, DH, DD and my mum. I don't have a social / other place in which to discuss issues / family dynamics / etc so I found it very interesting and helpful and supporting to 'chat' with so many people who I don't know, and to hear other people's experiences and advice!

OP posts:
TheUnconsoled · 31/12/2022 16:02

@LucyAutumn and to everybody else that has posted their views. First of all, thank you. This is the first time I've joined Mumsnet or posted anything and I found everything everybody said to be really helpful - esp. the suggestions about doing too much for DD and perhaps expecting too much for young people who maybe just don't know any better (as per the poster who is autistic and said how they just didn't know what was expected of them as a 16 year old). I also found the tips very helpful about how to nudge DD's friend in a friendly way into contributing. AND I would like you all to know what happened in the end and I was very very pleasantly surprised so I hope that everybody else out there will be pleased to. I DID drive her to the train station, and before she left she carefully went to find my mother and thanked her for her stay. On the station platform she thanked me and then turned to my DH (who had done all the cooking throughout the visit) and thanked him also 'for everything' and 'for making me feel so welcome' and when we got home we found a home-made card from her thanking us. So of course all my own ill-will has disappeared into the air. She was an awkward guest, and didn't help at all, and did sit looking at her phone a lot of the time, and stayed closeted in her room but ... a kind and thoughtful note and personal thank you has wiped all that away. It's brought lots of great happy post-Christmas feelings! Thank you everyone and I will try to be more positive in future!

OP posts:
LucyAutumn · 30/12/2022 22:32

How did it go today OP? Did you get a thank you in the end?

Opaljewel · 30/12/2022 13:16

So incredibly rude. I hate bad manners, I would definitely pitch in and say thank you. Some people are just entitled.

UsingChangeofName · 30/12/2022 13:11

C1N1C · 29/12/2022 19:21

Gonna be slammed for this, but it's this generation. They're SO self-absorbed. They've been raised from a young age to post their entire lives on the Web, seek constant reassurance and approval, and unless the world revolves around them, they're not happy.

I'm 'only' mid 30s and I was raised so differently. I'd probably be more annoying to a host for offering too much help! ... I feel your pain.

You should be slammed.

What a ridiculous generalisation.

I have 3 dc in their 20s and have had many, many of their friends staying over here for one reason or another over the las 8 -10 years and none of them have ever behaved like this.

wonkylegs · 30/12/2022 13:05

RealBecca · 29/12/2022 20:17

I voted yabu. Not because you are, its rude of them and would wind me up. But I'd try to look at ot through the lens that youre giving your daughter a warm family home where she feels able to have people home and that's what she will remember. That's more important. Maybe just pull back a little if it annoys you too much. But just remember its for your daughter and not them. When they grow up another 10 years they will be mortified and probably posting on mumsnet. What goes around!

That's not inevitable.... some people are just as rude as adults as well. I always thought my sister would grow out of being so entitled and rude but actually it's now worse and I resent it more.
It's not a generation thing it's a rudeness thing.
DS is a shy and awkward 14yo but still manages to mutter please and thank yous and help out because he's been brought up to know it's basic manners.
There is a group of his friends from school that are rude and don't even acknowledge my presence when giving lifts/ sorting stuff out for them. I find it irritating and annoying.
However he has other friends from scouts who are polite, helpful and try even awkwardly to make small talk. They are all the same age.
I know I cannot control how others behave so I concentrate on trying to ensure my kids are nice human beings and hope for the best.

Wallywobbles · 30/12/2022 12:58

My DCs coach their mates on acceptable politeness for our home. We also model vocal thank you for cooking etc.

They are all teens so I tend to be largely invisible for their visits. I just leave instructions like make lunch.

Oldraver · 30/12/2022 12:52

Yes over the last few months I've entertained many of DS's friends and barely a thank you

Last night's person has been a few times and didn't even say goodbye

RedHelenB · 30/12/2022 12:50

C1N1C · 29/12/2022 19:21

Gonna be slammed for this, but it's this generation. They're SO self-absorbed. They've been raised from a young age to post their entire lives on the Web, seek constant reassurance and approval, and unless the world revolves around them, they're not happy.

I'm 'only' mid 30s and I was raised so differently. I'd probably be more annoying to a host for offering too much help! ... I feel your pain.

Not true. My dc and their friends all say thank you for lifts, sleep overs etc.

UsingChangeofName · 30/12/2022 12:44

And why - as you say - does she not coax them along into more appropriate behavious?

But equally, why didn't you ?
I don't get why you cooked for them for 3 weeks.
I don't get why - on either or these occasions - you didn't say "Well, I've cooked so you two clear up / wash up / load the dishwasher".

No, you shouldn't need to, the guest should offer, but if they didn't, then I would very clearly reset their expectations at the beginning.

Throughabushbackwards · 30/12/2022 12:43

your daughter and*

Throughabushbackwards · 30/12/2022 12:42

Why don't you ever ask your daughter these young guests to help? You're being a bit of a doormat IMO.

A breezy "you two can clear the table and stack the dishwasher tonight, thanks!" works on my lazy teen family members. Small, directed tasks given in front of everyone so they're shamed into helping.

NaturalBae · 30/12/2022 12:41

Lazy

Entitled

Lack of empathy

Bad parenting

You’re doing too much. They’re adults. Don’t you want to relax a bit yourself and have a nice time or do you enjoy waiting on other people/playing the martyr?

I wouldn’t enjoy that, so I wouldn’t do it.

Miajk · 30/12/2022 12:28

TheUnconsoled · 29/12/2022 20:39

@MadMadMadamMim My own DD is like your DS - she washes up, helps with cooking, unfailingly thanks people for help or lifts of whatever. So I can't understand why she fails to see that her friends' behaviour is unacceptable, or why she doesn't have a quiet word with them.

Probably because you enable her.

Why are you doing all this crazy hosting?

Your DD is an adult. They can buy food, cook, clean, strip their beds, sort their own travel arrangements. Leave them to it.

If DD asks why, explain exactly why. Because they're ungrateful & don't help out. Easy.

Miajk · 30/12/2022 12:25

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 29/12/2022 20:44

Having just witnessed my young adult nieces and nephews behave the same way I’m inclined to agree with you. They’re perfectly pleasant, and so a good job of keeping their younger cousins who adore them entertained, but my god they don’t lift a finger and seem to expect to be waited on for days at a time.

Well anecdotal evidence isn't great is it. I know older relatives who behave like this so it's not an age think, it's an individual thing.

undernotover · 30/12/2022 11:26

Some of what you're posting is completely reasonable. Of course not one 'thank you' is incredibly rude.

However the more you post the more I think your expectations are a little warped. Your daughter is 20 so I'm presuming her friends are adults too yet you're talking about receiving flowers and thank you notes from parents? You and DD were out all day and you're offended that her friend (who presumably made the visit to see and spend time with your DD) didn't chat to your mother (who she presumably doesn't know and would feel awkward left alone with) and instead kept out of the way in DD's room? You're annoyed that you only see this friend when she's 'trailing your DD'? That's not weird, the friend is here to spend time with your DD, not become a fully fledged member of the family, of course she's spending her time with her.

At their age all your talk of 'hosting' is abit weird too. They're young adults, this girl is here to see and stay with her friend. Her (and I bet your DD) don't want to be hosted by you, they just want somewhere to crash for the few days they see their mate. Stop being such a martyr, leave them to it.

Now of course not saying thanks for having me at all/upon leaving is incredibly rude. And not excusable at all. You have every right to be pissed off. But it does sound like in other areas you are taking it too far.

BadNomad · 30/12/2022 01:24

I'm confused about your daughter. If your daughter is so polite and well-mannered, why does she not think there is something wrong with her friend's manners? Does she say "thank you" and help out when her friend is there? Or could the friend just be copying what she sees?

I have a lot of trouble with this stuff (I'm autistic as heck). I went away to a gorgeous cabin with my friend and her parents when we were 16. We (friend and I) didn't cook or do anything helpful, really. I was kinda shy and didn't want to impose. I didn't know what was expected of me, so I pretty much just stayed out of the way. When we went home, I did thank them for taking me away with them. But later, my friend told me her parents were shocked that I didn't buy them a gift. I had no idea this was a thing! I had no idea it was ok to insert yourself in to someone else's routine, a routine which was unknown to me. If they'd just said "Right, your turn to cook/clean/do dishes" I would have done it happily because I wasn't actually a rude, obnoxious teenager. Just quite oblivious to "the rules".

That was long. TLDR: was the friend actually being rude, or could she just have been unaware of what is expected in those types of situation?

antipodeancanary · 30/12/2022 01:01

I would tackle the perpetrating CF. I absolutely would and have done so. In fact I made one of DS cheeky fucker friends cry when I told him he was treating me like shit. I also told him that I was a real life person, who was every bit as important as he was. I have no regrets and he came with flowers the next day. I honestly don't think some of them notice that we are actual people rather than just support systems. Tell your CFs!!