Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my husband needs to contribute more?

186 replies

BorisJohnsonsBarbershop · 29/12/2022 16:20

I work between 40-50hrs a week doing shifts, occasionally more if work are really short staffed, in a very stressful job as an A&E doctor. I have to work these hours as I earn quite a lot more than my husband and pay most of the bills, but I also do the majority of housework.

He works roughly 37.5hrs a week flexitime in an office job, does pick up for the kids three days a week and puts them to bed most nights. He empties bins when they're overflowing, puts a load of laundry on when he runs out of clothes, and puts a load of dishes on when there's no clean ones left. He won't hoover, change beds, clean bathrooms, put laundry away, sweep or mop floors, or even tidy up at the end of a day.

If I challenge him about this he says he doesn't care, it's my job to do the cleaning, and he doesn't mind if it's done or not anyway because it's "not important". If we argue, which is frequently at the moment, he calls me lazy and complains that I'm always grumpy. I've just cleaned the toilets and found that he's left one in a disgusting state and not even attempted to clean it, but says "it doesn't matter, it's a toilet".

AIBU to expect household jobs to be shared more equally? Or is he right and I'm just a moany cow?

OP posts:
JonahAndTheSnail · 29/12/2022 18:50

YANBU, IMO part of childcare should involve a general tidy up of toys left out and wiping down tables etc so smeared food doesn't dry in. It's hardly hardcore, time consuming housekeeping. Obviously, if the kids are ill etc it may not get done, but the default stance of it's wimmin's work is shit.

If your youngest is 5, ideally he would be encouraging the older ones to pick up after themselves with small age appropriate chores, otherwise you're signing yourself up to be picking up after three additional people as well as lazy ass husband for a considerable length of time.

I wouldn't worry about tidying up for the cleaner if you decide to go down that route. However, the hiring of, paying of and general admin of having a cleaner becomes another job you'll probably end up taking responsibilty for, which seems unfair.

HandlebarLadyTash · 29/12/2022 18:49

No one needs an extra child. It totally kills desire and makes me sad.

Buildingthefuture · 29/12/2022 18:47

It’s YOUR job to do all the housework is it? Well, if we've suddenly time warped back to 1950, then surely, it’s HIS job to earn all the money? Oh, but it seems you are doing that! He cannot have it both ways. Get a cleaner and then have a very cold, hard look at what he actually brings to your table….he sounds like a man -baby, spoiled and frankly hard work. Not only that, but if my DH said to me that the housework was MY job…..my libido would shrivel up and die. On the spot. Honestly, does he make YOUR life better, yes or no? Decide that then go from there….

Walkaround · 29/12/2022 18:45

I think I would clean the toilet with his toothbrush.

mbosnz · 29/12/2022 18:36

Also, as far as I'm concerned, if you're doing tea, you clear away the dishes, even if you don't do the handwashing, you wipe the benches, wipe the table, and rid the floor of food remnants, as a general rule. It's one thing to say, 'look, sorry hun, shit day at work, I was knackered', every so often, another to say 'that's your job'. It's just part of 'The' Job.

I say that as someone who has worked full time, studied full time, and been a SAHP. And the support parent, when it comes to less pressured role and lower earning. But that was a shared view with the other parent, who would also do the same.

I reckon it's topic, not issue, re the cleaning.

monsteramunch · 29/12/2022 18:34

@Onnabugeisha

And in some houses, cleaning the toilet is one persons job only..it all depends on what division of household chores have been agreed on. It is in my house…I do laundry and DH does the bathrooms. Always. I haven’t cleaned a toilet in 28yrs.

If it's one persons 'job' to clean the loo as part of the household's chore assignment, that doesn't mean it's anywhere close to vaguely acceptable for the other person to not clean up their own shit from the toilet. And not be embarrassed but double down saying it's not their job. Cleaning something in general is different to any 'real time' cleaning that needs doing due to accidents etc.

It's not 'my job' at home to clean the kitchen floor (it's one we've agreed is my partner's) but if I spill some milk on the floor I don't just walk over it and get on with my day, I clean up after myself. It would be disrespectful and rude to do so with milk. Let alone shit.

Baffled as to why you seem to be trying to find a loophole in which he isn't being absolutely disgusting and treating her with total contempt when it comes to the toilet issue.

fetchacloth · 29/12/2022 18:33

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 29/12/2022 16:27

Your job to clean, do the housework is it?

Then, using the same tired old stereotypes, it is his job to be the main breadwinner.

He needs to think that through.

Then he needs to grow up and get off his arse and do some housework.

This, Absolutely.
Anything else wouldn't be acceptable to me in your shoes.😡

Bs0u416d · 29/12/2022 18:32

Could you get a cleaner for a few hours a week to keep the house ticking over? We both work busy jobs and find this makes running the house much easier as we just have superficial tidying up/light hoovering etc to do in order the get us through the week.

mbosnz · 29/12/2022 18:31

He does pick up three days a week. Who is doing the drop-offs five days a week and the pick ups the other two? (Apologies if this has been answered, I have read the whole thread, but may have missed it, in amongst all the argy bargy!)

RosesAndHellebores · 29/12/2022 18:31

To be fair @Onnabugeisha whilst my desk job is not in the league of Surgeon/pilot genre, having worked my way up the greasy pole for the last 20 years it was fairly gratifying during covid and wfh that DH realised that I have far more professional responsibility than pushing pens.

CantGetDecentNickname · 29/12/2022 18:28

Onnabugeisha · 29/12/2022 17:31

From the OP he "does pick up for the kids three days a week and puts them to bed most nights"

Some have translated this into him doing the bulk of the childcare (how?)

Basic maths. 100% of drop offs, 60% of pick ups plus dinners plus homework plus bedtimes. Plus weekend shifts in updates. = bulk of childcare.

Also, basic logic. The parent with the 40-50yrs A&E doctor job or the parent with the 37.5hr flexible working job…which do you think has obviously reduced their career prospects and earning potential in order to ensure their 3 children have care?

I can only suggest that OP tells him that she is considering separating and this means living independent lives. 😂🤣🤣 terrible advice.

Where does OP say that he does 100% drop-offs and homework? Childcare does usually involve cleaning up after them not just playing with them. Also why should working 37.5 hours a week in a flexible role reduce your career prospects? Is there evidence for this?

No problem with you not agreeing with the advice I gave. Would like to hear what your advice is? OP is unhappy in the current situation and it won't go away. Her DH has stated that it is her job to clean his shit off the toilet and continue to do cleaning generally as he won't. How do you think OP should resolve this situation?

Liorae · 29/12/2022 18:28

ShellsOnTheBeach · 29/12/2022 16:41

replace him with a cleaner...

It's not easy to find a cleaner who will do the bulk of the childcare for three children.

Wigglefish123 · 29/12/2022 18:26

It’s simple …either get a cleaner or LTB as he won’t change !!

Onnabugeisha · 29/12/2022 18:24

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/12/2022 18:11

@Onnabugeisha he says it’s her job to clean? In what possible universe is that not a sexist statement? Even if you assume for the sake of argument that he’s just got the hump because he thinks he’s doing all the work, it still beggars belief that he could feel that the work of cleaning a toilet is one persons job only.

It’s only sexist if he thinks it is her job because she is a woman. Nothing in the OPs posts indicate he thinks this. It is more likely that the division of household chores isn’t working and he is saying it’s her job because he thinks OP should contribute more. If OP were a man and they were gay, he’d likely have said the same thing given the overall situation of two parents working FT, one in a stressful job with long shifts and overtime plus 3 young DC. Most families find there are not enough hours in the day to keep up and usually standards are lowered or fights happen (like here) or outsourcing is done (cleaner).

It is sexist to assume he said that these were her household jobs because she is a woman.

And in some houses, cleaning the toilet is one persons job only..it all depends on what division of household chores have been agreed on. It is in my house…I do laundry and DH does the bathrooms. Always. I haven’t cleaned a toilet in 28yrs.

mbosnz · 29/12/2022 18:24

Well, a divorce is one option for a husband who isn't 'keen' on his share of the housework.

Or there's communication, negotiation, and compromise. Difficult if one party is adamant that anything they feel they shouldn't have to do (like cleaning their shit after laying one down, or wiping the table and putting the dishes in the dishwasher after doing the kids tea) is the other person's job.

Or there's hiring a cleaner. Who is going to make sure the house is in a fit state for the cleaner to do the job required/wanted, hire the cleaner, organise the cleaner?

RosesAndHellebores · 29/12/2022 18:22

As the child of two parents who grew to detest each other, it would have been far preferable if they had separated well before I was 12.

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 29/12/2022 18:20

Your husband despises you.

cherry2727 · 29/12/2022 18:19

The op doesnt need a divorce for crying out loud! She just needs some advise on how to deal with a husband who isn't very keen on his share of the housework! I do wonder where all these perfect Mumsnet relationships are!!!

Deathraystare · 29/12/2022 18:17

If he befouls the toilet again , put some of those hazardous stickers on the door!

Good idea though to get a cleaner.

RosesAndHellebores · 29/12/2022 18:15

@BorisJohnsonsBarbershop regardless of the sexes involved DH worked far longer hours than my 37.5 when the dc were small. He was the main breadwinner.

I picked up far more stuff at home because that made our individual input equal and we worked as a team. He was always happy to pay for a cleaner a couple of times a week. Very early in the relationship he was clear that he wouldn't be cleaning or ironing but was always happy to pay someone else. Equally, he appreciated that I was not brought up to clean.

When I went back to work full-time, I had an au-pair because he was simply not available. Think pilot/surgeon genre.

His career benefitted from my commitment, his earnings benefitted us all. 32 years on it worked for us.

Your DH sounds as though he needs a kick up the backside. It's rarely that I suggest an op should ltb but would you not be better off on your own to give an intelligent, hard working, professional woman the opportunity to find a partner who deserves her.

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/12/2022 18:11

@Onnabugeisha he says it’s her job to clean? In what possible universe is that not a sexist statement? Even if you assume for the sake of argument that he’s just got the hump because he thinks he’s doing all the work, it still beggars belief that he could feel that the work of cleaning a toilet is one persons job only.

Blackandwhites · 29/12/2022 18:10

You both sound burned out. What you are trying to do is not possible. It’s not his fault, it’s not your fault, it’s just not possible. You need to get a cleaner in asap, but one of you clearly has to go part time to take on the other life admin and jobs otherwise this is going to end in divorce. 37.5 hours is longer than the standard working week of 35, and he’s taking on a lot of the other life admin too. He’s not getting a break and neither are you.

mbosnz · 29/12/2022 18:08

Christ, it's one thing to train your kids (it's a parents' job), but I really don't know if I could be bothered cleaning up someone else's lazy arsed child rearing, training a fellow adult and parent, not just how to run a household, but how not to be a passive agressive and/or lazy and/or sexist misogynist and/or slovenly pig.

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 29/12/2022 18:06

Autumntimeagain · 29/12/2022 17:38

  1. If you have more than 1 bathroom, give him sole use of (and cleaning !) one of them. (Never buy him deoderant/shampoo/razors etc)
  2. Never, ever wash,dry or iron his clothing. (Also never buy him anything !) If he puts a load on for himself, leave it wet in the basket if you need to use the machine. If he hangs his washing up, leave it in a heap on the floor if you need to hang yours/DC washing up.
  3. Refuse to buy him anything when you're doing the shopping, so none of his 'favourite' brands/items or anything ! (No beer/snacks/coffee/milk)
  4. Make sure there's always plenty 'kids' food available.(That he hates)
  5. Buy (and keep in your car, not at home) plastic cutlery and paper plates for you and the kids to use when there's bugger all clean. He'll have to wash dishes when there's none for HIM.
  6. Sign the kids up for lots of after school activities that he'll need to take them to.
  7. Hire a cleaner (preferrably a quite attractive one), and if at all possible, a MALE one ! Make sure H is present and listening when you discuss what cleaning you want done, making SURE to inform them that H has his OWN bathroom ! (Hopefully will embarrass him !)

Basically, make HIS life as uncomfortable for him, as he's making yours ! He won't like it when it's crappy for HIM rather than you !

Wtf?! That’s a lot of effort for op to go to when she is already at the end of her tether.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 29/12/2022 18:05

What is even the point of men like that? Want to live like it's the 1950s and that housework is beneath them but equally rely on their wife to be the breadwinner.