Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is repeating incorrect facts the same as lying?

34 replies

SausageGate · 29/12/2022 15:47

Somewhat lighthearted.

DH and I have a disagreement on this and would like to clarify. Already asked my DM and DF - they disagree with each other and one agrees with me and one with DH.

If you state a fact that isn’t true and that you should know isn’t true, is that a lie? And does it become a lie if you keep repeating it? Or if you refuse to check to see if you’re wrong and keep insisting on it?

For example, if one person’s commute is 15 miles on a 50mph road but they insist their commute only takes 10 minutes. Clearly they’re wrong - but are they lying or just incorrect? Does it become lying if they keep saying it after being corrected or challenged?

Another example, NDN is called Jack but one person thinks he’s called John. Both got a Christmas card from Jack and so should know his name. After discussing it and checking the card, both agree he’s called Jack. If the person keeps saying he’s called John, is that a lie?

Essentially, can a lie be reckless or must it be malicious?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KousaMahshi · 29/12/2022 19:21

TheYearOfSmallThings · 29/12/2022 19:09

I would call those inaccuracies rather than lies. Loads of people say "I moved to Chelmsford - it's only a 40 minute commute, you know", and I don't say "LIAR! LIAR! Door to door it's at least an hour, and I can PROVE it!". And if I were calling a random neighbour the wrong name and my DP dug out a card and said "SEE? I TOLD you his name was Jack", I might keep calling the neighbour John just for the hell of it.

It would annoy me to be around someone who got wound up about stuff like this and kept correcting me and trying to make me say their "correct" or "Non Lying" version.

Its not a simple inaccuracy if it can't possibly be true and its really obvious. If you tell me you commute from Edinburgh to London in an hour, that is patently and obviously not true, and not possible. It doesn't matter if you have somehow managed to convince yourself it is, does it?

People, and I mean generally men, who talk absolute nonsense and expect everyone to nod along with them are extremely annoying idiots. I don't see why we should nod along and let them prattle on with their nonsense unchalleged

5128gap · 29/12/2022 19:17

Sometimes when people have inadvertently said something incorrect, like underestimating their commute, they're embarrassed at being corrected so stick to the original version. It's less a lie in the traditional sense, and more of a refusal to accept the truth or admit they're wrong.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 29/12/2022 19:09

I would call those inaccuracies rather than lies. Loads of people say "I moved to Chelmsford - it's only a 40 minute commute, you know", and I don't say "LIAR! LIAR! Door to door it's at least an hour, and I can PROVE it!". And if I were calling a random neighbour the wrong name and my DP dug out a card and said "SEE? I TOLD you his name was Jack", I might keep calling the neighbour John just for the hell of it.

It would annoy me to be around someone who got wound up about stuff like this and kept correcting me and trying to make me say their "correct" or "Non Lying" version.

foxp3 · 29/12/2022 18:55

This is such an interesting question OP!
I totally get your examples. It's sort of - low level importance stuff that makes you a bit confused as to why someone is not interested in being truthful.
I'd go further and question (in my mind!) where else they were being frugal with reality tbh!
I assume you know these specific people irl so not directing this at them at all but maybe some people get a minor thrill out of it. A bit bizarre maybe but I have definitely been on nights out before where I've pretended to have a totally different life!
Following for other ideas though.

KousaMahshi · 29/12/2022 16:40

As has been said above, Jack is actually short for John

It's not though, is it? Think about it.

OP, I can't believe how many people have completely misunderstood your post. It's both baffling and depressing.

AliceOlive · 29/12/2022 16:35

Gaslighting is not a GenZ word.

ILoveeCakes · 29/12/2022 16:34

SerenaTee · 29/12/2022 15:50

If you say something you think is true but turns out to be false, that’s a mistake/you’re mistaken.

If you have proof or evidence something isn’t true but you continue to insist it’s true, then you’re lying/gaslighting.

Post number 2 and the favourite word of Gen Z makes an appearance......Gaslighting.

PenanceAdair · 29/12/2022 16:31

On the other hand, if you say something that's incorrect but you didn't realise that it's incorrect, then no you're not lying. You're mistaken though but not lying. Lying is deliberate.

PenanceAdair · 29/12/2022 16:28

If you say something that's incorrect and you know it's incorrect but repeat it anyway as if it's true, then yes you're lying.

SausageGate · 29/12/2022 16:27

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/12/2022 16:27

You mean you were lying?

Here's a way to solve the conundrum then. Were you lying about the names maliciously? You know they weren't the names - and there's more than one person called Alice or maybe Helen or have changed their name from one to the other or prefer their middle name (etc, etc) in the world, so it's hardly outing.

😂

OP posts:
watchfulwishes · 29/12/2022 16:27

There are lies and then there is just talking bollocks. Technically your examples are both lies, but I would just Hmm at them as neither affect me. People do convince themselves of all sorts of crap. Presumably I do that sometimes too, but wouldn't know it!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/12/2022 16:27

SausageGate · 29/12/2022 16:20

Jesus, it was an example. For the avoidance of doubt, the NDN is really called Alice but the person thinks their name is Helen. 😂

You mean you were lying?

Here's a way to solve the conundrum then. Were you lying about the names maliciously? You know they weren't the names - and there's more than one person called Alice or maybe Helen or have changed their name from one to the other or prefer their middle name (etc, etc) in the world, so it's hardly outing.

lottiegarbanzo · 29/12/2022 16:26

I think you're mixing up lying and being mistaken. People can be repeatedly, incorrigibly mistaken, because they have imperfect memories.

Many people make stuff up then believe it themselves. Some people just don't seem to have space for uncertainty in their heads. They'd rather believe a guess than acknowledge that they're guessing.

Psychology is more complex than you allow.

Lying is deliberate. Mistakes are not deliberate misrepresentations. Suppositions and their representation are more interesting territory.

Jack and John are the same name, (like Harry & Henry etc).

AliceOlive · 29/12/2022 16:26

If you know something isn’t true, but keep saying it anyway, you are lying. If you don’t know you are lying when you say untrue things, then you probably need professional help.

I suspect most people who do this fail at personal awareness and responsibility in many facets of their lives.

WendelineTestaburger · 29/12/2022 16:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LondonQueen · 29/12/2022 16:22

Both of those examples are lies, but just because a commute takes you 15 minutes, doesn't mean it takes someone who drives faster than time. I used to live in the same area as a colleague and would arrive much earlier despite taking the same route as she drives like miss daisy whereas I'm a bit of a girl racer.

SausageGate · 29/12/2022 16:20

Jesus, it was an example. For the avoidance of doubt, the NDN is really called Alice but the person thinks their name is Helen. 😂

OP posts:
WhenYouWalkThroughTheGarden · 29/12/2022 16:19

Is the one with the commute always ten minutes late for work?

ElspethTascioni · 29/12/2022 16:18

Jack is a nickname for John #missespointofthread

RandomPerson42 · 29/12/2022 16:18

As has been said above, Jack is actually short for John.

Just like…

Daisy and Peggy are short for Margaret
Sally is short for Sarah
Polly is short for Mary
Chuck is short for Charles
Buffy and Betty are short for Elizabeth

etc.

imho it would only be a lie if known to be false, i.e. an intentional falsehood.
A lie is different to an untruth.

SausageGate · 29/12/2022 16:18

Wonnle · 29/12/2022 16:16

Is this thread

A bollocks

B bollocks

C complete bollocks

Whatever smug, witty remark you were supposed to be making has gone over my head. What point are you trying to make exactly?

OP posts:
Wonnle · 29/12/2022 16:17

Sorry are you Donald Trump ?

Wonnle · 29/12/2022 16:16

Is this thread

A bollocks

B bollocks

C complete bollocks

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 29/12/2022 16:16

If you're knowingly/ deliberately repeating or perpetuating false information, it's a lie.

If you are repeating or perpetuating false information without realising, it's ignorance/ stupidity.

Fairislefandango · 29/12/2022 16:13

It's hard to say without knowing their motive for continuing to get it wrong. In both cases are you saying that the person grudgingly admits they're technically wrong and yet on some level continues to hold the same opinion and think they're right? Or is it that they absolutely admit they are wrong but keep saying the untrue thing because it fits better with some narrative they wish to perpetuate?

If it's the former, they're just deluded. If it's the latter, they are lying. Lying doesn't have to be 'malicious' as such, imo, but it does have to be deliberate.