Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that with enough notice, he shouldn't have to give a reason

31 replies

ifwetookaholidaaay · 29/12/2022 13:56

DS17 started a new job about 6 weeks ago.

He has told me today that he has put in a holiday request for next month, and that it has been declined as he didn't give a reason for it. He put this request in a few weeks ago, giving about 6 weeks notice in total. He gets his shifts only a week in advance.

There's been a few issues with this job and I've already told him he should start looking for another, but I've never worked anywhere where I've had to give a reason for taking a holiday with so much notice. Is this something which I should be making him aware is quite normal practice?

Thanks.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
daisyjgrey · 29/12/2022 16:20

That's madness. It's nobody's business if he wants two days off to go to Berlin or two days off to lay on the sofa eating wotsits.

ifwetookaholidaaay · 29/12/2022 14:48

It's a request for a Saturday off in a fast food type place, so I can see Saturdays would be busy.

However, he applied for this job on the basis of it being 30 hours per week, and for the last two weeks, he has been given only two shifts each week and been let go early on one shift each week.

I guess all he can do is request again with a reason, and then wait and see if he gets accepted or declined, or whether he'll even been rostered on that day.

It could well be that he won't have accrued enough leave by the the time the requested date comes around, but it would have made far more some for them to say that.

Shall look at the policy with him.

Thanks again.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 29/12/2022 14:41

Six weeks notice and for almost all jobs I cannot see mid-January being the issue either (there will be exceptions).

You could argue it could be unfair. Why for example someone taking a day off for a child's or parent's medical appointment have to tell you that, for example (single parents with their children resident are more likely to be women)?

I am having time off to go to an event marking the anniversary of a family member being deported by the Nazis. Not something I should have to declare unless of my choosing.

ifwetookaholidaaay · 29/12/2022 14:31

namechange3394 · 29/12/2022 14:24

I'm really surprised by the responses on this thread.

"Next month", when it's the 29th today, is hardly loads and loads of notice. I've worked for employers who wouldn't have cared about a reason and it would have been fine, but I've certainly worked for others who'd be wanting to know if there was an important reason if it's a busy period for that employer, or several others are also off.

Have none of you ever worked in places where there were restrictions on time off? When my manager is off, at least one of the two of us that report to her has to be in. And I can't generally take much leave in July because it's super busy. This is normal, surely?

The holiday is next month (20th), but he put the request in about 3 weeks ago now.

I appreciate business needs etc, but they have specifically declined his request citing 'no reason given' as the justification. When others have told him they have requested holidays with no reason given before.

OP posts:
namechange3394 · 29/12/2022 14:24

I'm really surprised by the responses on this thread.

"Next month", when it's the 29th today, is hardly loads and loads of notice. I've worked for employers who wouldn't have cared about a reason and it would have been fine, but I've certainly worked for others who'd be wanting to know if there was an important reason if it's a busy period for that employer, or several others are also off.

Have none of you ever worked in places where there were restrictions on time off? When my manager is off, at least one of the two of us that report to her has to be in. And I can't generally take much leave in July because it's super busy. This is normal, surely?

DuplicateUserName · 29/12/2022 14:22

ifwetookaholidaaay · 29/12/2022 14:03

There is apparently a box to fill in when booking the holiday. His friend told him he doesn't always fill it in, so DS didn't.

I've told him to put the request in again and give the reason, but it's not a very important reason, so I can seen them declining it again. And I've told him not to lie as it's a big event in our town, so no doubt he'll be found out .

The old system we had at work had a box like that.

We'd just select 'vacation' and leave it at that.

TeenDivided · 29/12/2022 14:19

xpost!

TeenDivided · 29/12/2022 14:19

If he has already had a couple of days off, has he 'earned' enough leave yet?

EATmum · 29/12/2022 14:18

Will he have earned enough leave by then, if he's already taken several days that were prebooked? It's probably automatically declined because he won't have accrued enough.

Agapornis · 29/12/2022 14:18

There was a 'reason' box at my last employer - I just filled in annual leave and that was good enough.
Another former employer had separate registration for medical appointments and family emergency so it wouldn't come out of your annual leave, so that might be why?

namechange3394 · 29/12/2022 14:17

AreOttersJustWetCats · 29/12/2022 14:12

Employees have a legal right to time off even if all they do with it is sit at home in their underwear, eating ice cream from the tub and watching Gogglebox repeats. Employment rights aren't dependent on the employee having a good reason.

They don't have a legal right to choose exactly when they take it though.

gogohmm · 29/12/2022 14:16

Some employers require long lead times for annual leave without a reason, check the policy. Also some places have a bar on certain periods of the year or 2 people off at once

AreOttersJustWetCats · 29/12/2022 14:14

There are some exceptions. E.g. I worked a job where January was our busiest month of the year. For that reason, leave was only approved during January if you had a really, really important reason. Feb-Dec was fine though.

Temese · 29/12/2022 14:13

What kind of work is it? Is it for a time when they need 'all hands on deck?'

I work in hospitality and wouldn't approve holidays at certain times of year, unless they put a reason like family wedding or something, then I would do my best to fit it in.

Other than that though I wouldn't expect people to put reasons down for their holiday.

katmarie · 29/12/2022 14:13

Bear in mind as well it might be an auto decline by the online booking system if it has a mandatory requirement for the 'reason' field to be completed. I've seen annual leave systems where that is the case. In which case if I was him I would put the reason in as 'wish to take annual leave' or something equally generic.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 29/12/2022 14:12

Employees have a legal right to time off even if all they do with it is sit at home in their underwear, eating ice cream from the tub and watching Gogglebox repeats. Employment rights aren't dependent on the employee having a good reason.

ifwetookaholidaaay · 29/12/2022 14:12

Sirzy · 29/12/2022 14:09

If it’s a big event in the area could it be that there are already the quota booked it off so anyone else off would be an issue - hence wanting to know if it’s important. (Should have been explained to him that way if so)

Perhaps, but he says he put his request in within minutes of hearing the event was going ahead.

OP posts:
StarbucksSmarterSister · 29/12/2022 14:11

This was for two days? 😲

He needs to find another job. And the "reason" for taking holiday is "holiday", no specifics should be required.

Is it a small company and if so, do they have an actual HR department?

ifwetookaholidaaay · 29/12/2022 14:10

I should say, he has already had a couple of days holiday that he told them he needed before he started.

But yes, I will sit and look over the policy with him, and look at his booking in case he's misinterpreted something.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 29/12/2022 14:09

If it’s a big event in the area could it be that there are already the quota booked it off so anyone else off would be an issue - hence wanting to know if it’s important. (Should have been explained to him that way if so)

Nikla · 29/12/2022 14:07

Definitely not normal.

It's none of their business why he wants a couple of days off.

Hard to say anything when you're 17 years old so I would help him to get another job.

My partner worked for a company for years. They had a change in management and the manager questioned staff as to why they wanted time off. He was checking whether he thought it was a good enough reason to have time off. My partner told him that it's not actually any of his business and ended up moving to another job within a couple of months.

Fufumcgoo · 29/12/2022 14:07

It really is non of their business. Like you op I would only expect to have to justify very last minute holiday (within a week) as planning is usually done by then and your potentially causing a problem.

katmarie · 29/12/2022 14:06

There should be a holiday policy he can look at, which will say what the process is for booking.

In my experience, bookings where a reason is required come under a few rare scenarios. If it's very short notice, a very long time (more than a couple of weeks), comes in a very busy period, or the company is very understaffed at that time, eg other people already on leave, then a manager might reasonably ask what the leave is for, but really the employer doesn't have a right to know what you're planning to do in your time off.

Check the holiday booking policy, and if he's followed it correctly, get him to politely query the declined booking with someone who has the authority to make decisions on his leave.

SomethingOriginal2 · 29/12/2022 14:04

I don't think you have to give a reason. For a holiday request unless it's at notice or at a time leave wouldn't usually be granted, it's none of their business what he does in his time off and they're legally required to give him a set amount of holiday.

ifwetookaholidaaay · 29/12/2022 14:03

There is apparently a box to fill in when booking the holiday. His friend told him he doesn't always fill it in, so DS didn't.

I've told him to put the request in again and give the reason, but it's not a very important reason, so I can seen them declining it again. And I've told him not to lie as it's a big event in our town, so no doubt he'll be found out .

OP posts: