Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL policing clothes she's bought for my kids..

168 replies

snowies · 29/12/2022 10:33

Is this weird ?

MIL buys kids clothes and asked me to put them in them on specific days. I had already bought their Christmas outfits and put my kids in those, but put them in MIL clothes on other days. MIL claims I've not put my kids in the clothes she bought. I told her that I did, but that they were a bit big for them on Xmas day. ( which is true ).

So she said that she thinks I should put DD in the clothes on her birthday. I don't really want to, I like the clothes and happy to put her in it on a Sunday, but was looking for something different for her birthday.

I am very Lucky and get given lots of clothes for them by MIL and my own mum and ALWAYS put the kids in their clothes as often as I can. I don't distinguish and don't even remember who gave them what / or which ones I bought, I'm just happy I have clothes for them. MIL mentioned she had not seen DD in a dress she'd bought her and I know for a fact that she had worn the dress, but MIL just hasn't seen her in it yet. MIL sends me a pic of the dress, she takes pics of all the clothes she buys them and then double checks if they've been worn. I find that a bit strange and controlling.

Especially because they always wear the clothes, but a dress isn't worn as often, so MIL just missed it. I'm a bit miffed at the insinuation that they don't wear her clothes AND the fact that she wants them worn on certain days- like the birthday and then seems offended if I don't do it.

I just need to reiterate again, that my kids wear the clothes daily - except dresses, as I don't put them in dresses as often, so I don't know where it's coming from that there's a need to police it. Apart from taking a daily pic of what they're wearing and sending it to MIL, I'm not sure what to do !

OP posts:
MavisMcMinty · 29/12/2022 12:02

@WeepingSomnambulist ·
"I really dont understand why you keep sending me pics of clothes you have bought them. I know. We have the clothes. They wear the clothes. I am not organising clothes to be worn to your schedule. Please stop being so weird about clothes. I'm not having this conversation with you again. I have tried to be gentle about this but it doesnt seem like you're going to stop unless I am blunt about it. We're very grateful for all the things that you buy the children, and we dont waste things so the clothes are used and enjoyed. That is all we need to say about them. Dont bring them up again."

I know you’ve dismissed this as a response, OP, but it sounds good to me - assertive and to the point.

TrentCrimm · 29/12/2022 12:02

Why is all this on you, and why are you both putting up with it?

She called him a traitor? Well boohoo 🙄

snowies · 29/12/2022 12:01

Lexi868 · 29/12/2022 11:52

You haven't said anything about DH stance on all this. He should be the one to tell his mum to calm down and stop being so controlling.

Well, in general he just complains that I'm just moaning about it. He doesn't do much about it. Sometimes he does. But it's the same for him, if he brings anything up with her, she gets quite aggressive / plays the victim. She's accused me of ruining his relationship with the family and putting bad thoughts about them in his head and just generally being a bad influence. Apparently before he met me he was lovely with his family etc etc.

I literally have stood up to her a couple of times.. it's not been a lot. But she shouts and cries and plays the victim, even though she's the one that's upset me in the first place ! Once when I was pregnant she kept saying my bum was getting big and I ended up asking her not to say that. She made such a fuss about me taking it the wrong way, that I ended up apologising for having upset her! She never ever takes any responsibility for upsetting me. It's always my fault I'm upset because of weird hang ups. The whole family start a character assassination on me. Excluding DH of course.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 29/12/2022 12:00

I avoid any confrontation at all costs.

you have decades of this ahead of you if you don't put in boundaries. If your DH won't step in for you, you have to do it for yourself
If she calls him a traitor, his answer should be "I would be a traitor to my own wife if i didn't stick up for her, butt out". That is the only acceptable answer from him.

35965a · 29/12/2022 12:00

snowies · 29/12/2022 11:54

It's just hard when no one is on my side. DH has stood up for me before, but she called him traitor. I avoid any confrontation at all costs.

It is hard to stand up to people like her - calling your DH a traitor for agreeing with you is pathetic, so you know how pathetic she is. Instead of confronting her, if that’s difficult, have you tried just not contacting or speaking to her? Ignore texts, don’t contact her. If she whines about it in person just say oh I am busy and change the subject. She sounds like a bully, don’t let her bully you. They’re your dc and you can put them in whatever clothes you want.

justgettingthroughtheday · 29/12/2022 11:58

Let her go nuts! She will only make herself look like a fool! It's going to happen sometime anyway. If not now then when your kids do start choosing what they wear.
Set a firm boundary and then ignore. For as long as need be.
In terms of other people in all probability they are just agreeing with her for a quiet life. In reality they probably think she's batshit too

snowies · 29/12/2022 11:54

35965a · 29/12/2022 11:51

Don’t be a pushover. So what if they slag you off? You say she will go nuts? Who cares! That’s her problem, not yours.

It's just hard when no one is on my side. DH has stood up for me before, but she called him traitor. I avoid any confrontation at all costs.

OP posts:
Lexi868 · 29/12/2022 11:52

You haven't said anything about DH stance on all this. He should be the one to tell his mum to calm down and stop being so controlling.

35965a · 29/12/2022 11:51

Don’t be a pushover. So what if they slag you off? You say she will go nuts? Who cares! That’s her problem, not yours.

Brefugee · 29/12/2022 11:50

she and her family sound awful. Push all contact with them onto DH. She asks you about clothes, refer her to him. Just step right back.

Block her number if you have to. But you don't have to let her treat you like this. (I had zero contact with my MIL and most of my ILs because they were - meh, nasty and i wouldn't have chosen to have them in my lives) it had zero impact on my relationship with my DH and made my life so much easier

snowies · 29/12/2022 11:49

Gazelda · 29/12/2022 11:48

This is why your DC need an Instagram account to post their daily outfits.

Joke.

I'd forward all messages to your DP. Get him to respond.

If she brings it up in convo, say that you appreciate the gifts and the DC wear the outfits frequently. But as a mum, you enjoy picking their outfits for special occasions and find the pressure about who wears what on which days overbearing. Tell her her generosity is lovely but please stop adding more stress to your day.

Or give her the DC's laundry to do each day. Make sure each outfit is suitably stained with paint, bolognese etc to prove they've been worn.

Oh she'd let me know she would be very annoyed if I allowed her outfits to get ruined.... Confused

OP posts:
Lexi868 · 29/12/2022 11:48

MIL is being a bit petty and controlling on this one. You are still putting them in her clothes so she shouldn't now dictate when they are worn.

Gazelda · 29/12/2022 11:48

This is why your DC need an Instagram account to post their daily outfits.

Joke.

I'd forward all messages to your DP. Get him to respond.

If she brings it up in convo, say that you appreciate the gifts and the DC wear the outfits frequently. But as a mum, you enjoy picking their outfits for special occasions and find the pressure about who wears what on which days overbearing. Tell her her generosity is lovely but please stop adding more stress to your day.

Or give her the DC's laundry to do each day. Make sure each outfit is suitably stained with paint, bolognese etc to prove they've been worn.

snowies · 29/12/2022 11:47

StaunchMomma · 29/12/2022 11:33

You sound like a bit of a pushover, OP - maybe MIL will chill a bit if you give her some boundaries?

The good old Mumsnet chant of 'Sorry, that doesn't work for us' is a great way to start!!

You won't sound 'horrible' (your words) if you start sticking up for yourself. If you already have an outfit in mind, tell her it's already sorted. You do not have to give explanations or reasons.

It sounds like she's expecting bragging rights for buying what they wear on important occasions but they are YOUR children, OP. Yiu want them to be comfortable and yes, on 'dressy' days it's lovely to pick an outfit - don't let her take that from you.

It's just every time I've tried to put up a boundary, for years, she and her entire family have called me unreliable, crazy, bad intentioned etc. we've had so many fights, I guess I just don't want another confrontation, so I try to let stuff go or ignore it.

OP posts:
Chooksnroses · 29/12/2022 11:46

Just do what I did. Immediately try on the clothes and take photos, and send them to her. It's easy now. When my kids were small I had to use a film camera, get the photos developed and send them by snail mail!

BreatheAndFocus · 29/12/2022 11:46

If she won’t respond to tactful messages, just have a stock response you send her, eg thank her, say the DC will get lots of wear out of the lovely clothes she’s bought them - and you’ve already bought an outfit for them to wear for their birthday/Christmas/Easter/first day at nursery, etc.

She’s over-invested in this and needs to understand that she can’t dictate what they wear. Repeating that you already have an outfit for whatever occasion she mentions should reduce her pushing for the DC to wear her clothes. She’ll give up eventually.

StaunchMomma · 29/12/2022 11:33

You sound like a bit of a pushover, OP - maybe MIL will chill a bit if you give her some boundaries?

The good old Mumsnet chant of 'Sorry, that doesn't work for us' is a great way to start!!

You won't sound 'horrible' (your words) if you start sticking up for yourself. If you already have an outfit in mind, tell her it's already sorted. You do not have to give explanations or reasons.

It sounds like she's expecting bragging rights for buying what they wear on important occasions but they are YOUR children, OP. Yiu want them to be comfortable and yes, on 'dressy' days it's lovely to pick an outfit - don't let her take that from you.

snowies · 29/12/2022 11:30

ThinWomansBrain · 29/12/2022 11:27

she sounds slightly bonkers.
I think I'd keep a note of her gifts and put the children in them when she is going to see them - but beyond that - batshit.

She also comments on all the clothes I buy for them being too small. That's slightly irritating as well, I must say.
I need to Stress again, that the clothes she actually buys my kids are gorgeous and they really do wear them, day in and day out.

OP posts:
snowies · 29/12/2022 11:29

Nikla · 29/12/2022 11:24

Yeah, that's really weird and controlling.

Could your husband have a word with her? Just sort of asking her to reign it in with the messages about clothing etc.

I would start ignoring her messages if she is asking about the clothes. If she asks you to your face say that you do put them in the clothes and that you are finding it quite stressful her always mentioning it.

My MIL did this for a little bit. I think it's almost losing control of the old family life. No longer in charge of her Son and can't control your life with the kids.

Mine told me she had bought a dress for my eldest and that she was to wear it on Xmas day. I just put her in the dress that I'd bought and didn't mention it. She did make a few comments about how I hadn't dressed them in her clothes and when one had a rip in it she said that it had been done on purpose 🙈. She grew out of it by 2nd child though but doesn't sound like yours has 😩.

I think unfortunately it will need a conversation/nice message and hope for the best!

She'll go nuts if I say anything. She'll say I'm horrible / sensitive / ungrateful and that she just means well. She always says that when I bring anything up. I have stopped bringing things up and just try to ignore her ways. But this clothes things is starting to bug me now. She is very confronting about it.

My mum sometimes suggests outfits for certain days, but never takes it to heart if I don't use those outfits, thankfully !

OP posts:
ThinWomansBrain · 29/12/2022 11:27

she sounds slightly bonkers.
I think I'd keep a note of her gifts and put the children in them when she is going to see them - but beyond that - batshit.

Nikla · 29/12/2022 11:24

Yeah, that's really weird and controlling.

Could your husband have a word with her? Just sort of asking her to reign it in with the messages about clothing etc.

I would start ignoring her messages if she is asking about the clothes. If she asks you to your face say that you do put them in the clothes and that you are finding it quite stressful her always mentioning it.

My MIL did this for a little bit. I think it's almost losing control of the old family life. No longer in charge of her Son and can't control your life with the kids.

Mine told me she had bought a dress for my eldest and that she was to wear it on Xmas day. I just put her in the dress that I'd bought and didn't mention it. She did make a few comments about how I hadn't dressed them in her clothes and when one had a rip in it she said that it had been done on purpose 🙈. She grew out of it by 2nd child though but doesn't sound like yours has 😩.

I think unfortunately it will need a conversation/nice message and hope for the best!

snowies · 29/12/2022 11:24

CeciliaMars · 29/12/2022 11:08

This is extremely controlling of her. You don't give gifts to then tell people when and how to use them. Maybe just say politely that whilst you appreciate the gifts, it is up to you and your children (heaven forbid they have a say in what they wear!) when they wear then, and if she is not OK with her, she needs to stop buying your family clothes. I wonder whether she is controlling in other ways too?

Ha ha yeah... my MIL will think I'm a push over if I let them decide what to wear... they're still a bit small to decide, but once they can, she will not appreciate me giving in to that.

OP posts:
snowies · 29/12/2022 11:21

keri17 · 29/12/2022 11:14

send Her a doll

GrinGrin

OP posts:
keri17 · 29/12/2022 11:14

send Her a doll

Beamur · 29/12/2022 11:13

Is your MIL trying to dress the kids on all their special occasions? If so, she's not really doing that to be nice to you or the kids, it's about her - she's had her turn with her own kids, it's yours now.
If you otherwise get on well with her, I'd either not reply immediately to her texts or just say that you've already got the child something you want them to wear and you'll use her clothes another time. Rinse and repeat.
Same for the queries about other clothes, just say it's been worn at another occasion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread