Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL policing clothes she's bought for my kids..

168 replies

snowies · 29/12/2022 10:33

Is this weird ?

MIL buys kids clothes and asked me to put them in them on specific days. I had already bought their Christmas outfits and put my kids in those, but put them in MIL clothes on other days. MIL claims I've not put my kids in the clothes she bought. I told her that I did, but that they were a bit big for them on Xmas day. ( which is true ).

So she said that she thinks I should put DD in the clothes on her birthday. I don't really want to, I like the clothes and happy to put her in it on a Sunday, but was looking for something different for her birthday.

I am very Lucky and get given lots of clothes for them by MIL and my own mum and ALWAYS put the kids in their clothes as often as I can. I don't distinguish and don't even remember who gave them what / or which ones I bought, I'm just happy I have clothes for them. MIL mentioned she had not seen DD in a dress she'd bought her and I know for a fact that she had worn the dress, but MIL just hasn't seen her in it yet. MIL sends me a pic of the dress, she takes pics of all the clothes she buys them and then double checks if they've been worn. I find that a bit strange and controlling.

Especially because they always wear the clothes, but a dress isn't worn as often, so MIL just missed it. I'm a bit miffed at the insinuation that they don't wear her clothes AND the fact that she wants them worn on certain days- like the birthday and then seems offended if I don't do it.

I just need to reiterate again, that my kids wear the clothes daily - except dresses, as I don't put them in dresses as often, so I don't know where it's coming from that there's a need to police it. Apart from taking a daily pic of what they're wearing and sending it to MIL, I'm not sure what to do !

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cherrysoup · 26/01/2023 19:51

So much to unpack here, but you need to start being much firmer with her and put in much stronger boundaries. Your mil sounds like a total trauma.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 26/01/2023 19:50

Just tell her you have a particular outfit in mind for dd b’day. And each time her clothes are worn, take a quick snap and ping it over to her.

PifandHercule · 26/01/2023 19:24

Lilliflip · 29/12/2022 10:55

Tell her you appreciate her buying you clothes, but don’t have time for this shit.

This! 😂😂

Forgooodnesssakenow · 26/01/2023 19:11

My mil passive aggressively acted like this about everything she eve got the kids, on top of being insanely jealous if someone else bought them something. However I too am petty and reacted by never putting her in clothes she'd bought them when she was there. She's much better now there are 2 of them and she's less insanely focussed on the idea of herself as an amazing granny

Wibbly1008 · 26/01/2023 19:04

Lilliflip · 29/12/2022 10:55

Tell her you appreciate her buying you clothes, but don’t have time for this shit.

This. Absolutely this. Treat her nonsense with the brush off it deserves.

Kevinyoutwat · 05/01/2023 09:26

OM82 · 05/01/2023 09:23

An aside question, what does everyone do with the clothes that no longer fit ? Does a charity shop take them ? I have so much stuff and don't know what to do with it. No younger cousins / siblings on the horizon.

Most charity shops will take them out you might have a specialist baby/kid charity shop locally which definitely would. Or just post on local Facebook group. If you'd like to get money back and have the time you can sell them on vinted or somewhere similar.

Any charity shop where I am will take them.

I used to try and sell bundles on ebay but the hassle wasn’t worth it for a few quid.

Peachyscream · 05/01/2023 09:24

I was gifted a lot of clothes when I had my youngest, alot of them for when she was older. I put the gifters name on a tiny bit of masking tape and stuck it to each outfit before hanging up in wardrobe. Otherwise I wouldn't have remembered who gave what. When the baby wore the outfit I'd send a pic to the person of baby wearing outfit, with a "thank you Auntie N I love my outfit".

OM82 · 05/01/2023 09:23

An aside question, what does everyone do with the clothes that no longer fit ? Does a charity shop take them ? I have so much stuff and don't know what to do with it. No younger cousins / siblings on the horizon.

Most charity shops will take them out you might have a specialist baby/kid charity shop locally which definitely would. Or just post on local Facebook group. If you'd like to get money back and have the time you can sell them on vinted or somewhere similar.

Kevinyoutwat · 05/01/2023 09:18

And I always told her thank you, but they suitable for dd/to her taste when she was older and she would always act like I’d just kicked her puppy.

Kevinyoutwat · 05/01/2023 09:17

I had this shit with my MIL.

After a few years dh shut it down and WW3 kicked off and it’s one of the reasons she hates me.

She insisted on buy all dds clothes. Only, they weren’t to my taste (think either a baby dressed like a sequinned cheerleader, or clothes for a 6 month old that they can’t move in comfortably), and more importantly, when dd was around 4, she decided she didn’t like the very girly clothes that MIL bought (all unicorns and sparkly dresses by then when dd preferred dinosaur tracksuits from the “boys” (grrrr) section.

We couldn’t return clothes either as she would buy them a year or so in advance, cut of labels.

She still does it on a smaller scale each Christmas and birthday now dd is 9, and it’s all still the same stuff that dd would never wear (pink dresses for a girl who lives in jeans!)

snowies · 05/01/2023 09:06

EthicalNonMahogany · 05/01/2023 08:48

That instead of being clear about your own needs and articulating them assertively, you are getting pleasure by vicariously living through others - by going along with your silly family thing of "dressing the babies" and that being important to you. Your MIL feels good when she sees your children in her clothes. You feel good when your children are dressed "up to the standard" of your family. They are babies now, so they are going along with it. But part of parenting is dealing with what happens when your little people start to behave in ways that you're uncomfortable with. Your MIL has never come to terms with this and is controlling all of you like you're her babies she can dress & play with.

I'm just saying - start to own your own needs now, get them met now. When you said about dressing your own kids, I sense a tiny hint of you living through how your children look rather than things that make you happy in your own life.

I may be wrong, maybe the clothes are a red herring. But I stand by the point that people have to have good boundaries- having too few is as dysfunctional as having too many, so in that respect you and MIL aren't that different.

Oh OK. Well, dressing the children and babies nicely is actually totally my thing. I like it, I always have. I'm not appeasing them by doing it.

OP posts:
EthicalNonMahogany · 05/01/2023 08:48

That instead of being clear about your own needs and articulating them assertively, you are getting pleasure by vicariously living through others - by going along with your silly family thing of "dressing the babies" and that being important to you. Your MIL feels good when she sees your children in her clothes. You feel good when your children are dressed "up to the standard" of your family. They are babies now, so they are going along with it. But part of parenting is dealing with what happens when your little people start to behave in ways that you're uncomfortable with. Your MIL has never come to terms with this and is controlling all of you like you're her babies she can dress & play with.

I'm just saying - start to own your own needs now, get them met now. When you said about dressing your own kids, I sense a tiny hint of you living through how your children look rather than things that make you happy in your own life.

I may be wrong, maybe the clothes are a red herring. But I stand by the point that people have to have good boundaries- having too few is as dysfunctional as having too many, so in that respect you and MIL aren't that different.

snowies · 05/01/2023 08:41

Or you'll end up like your MIL! You are more similar than you think...both getting a sense of power over others to make up for your own lack of agency in your lives.

I'm not saying you're wrong haha, but please explain how I am getting a sense of power- you mean by how I treat my MIL/ or that I don't get let my older one choose her clothes ?

OP posts:
JFDIYOLO · 05/01/2023 08:39

Grey rock sounds the perfect solution! Give them nothing to latch onto, nothing to trigger ''you're unreasonable".

snowies · 05/01/2023 08:38

WestBridgewater · 05/01/2023 06:25

It would get on my last nerve if either set of grandparents kept buying my DC clothes randomly, not for a birthday or Christmas. Can you not afford to clothe your children? Because that would be the only circumstances that I could find it acceptable.

They got a lot of the clothes for Christmas and the time before that, both MIL and my mum had gone abroad for trips and bought them there. So in the last six months or so, I got one load of clothes from my MIL then one from my mum ( they brought the clothes back from being abroad ) and then both MIL and mum gave them clothes for Christmas..

Before that, they hadn't actually bought that much stuff. Well, my mum did buy some stuff, but she doesn't police it at all. She never remembers what she even bought.

Oddly enough, I've just also put in a big order at h and m myself... as I'm running out of practical clothes, like pyjamas and comfy clothes. They tend to buy thick jumpers and thick sets that can't be worn for sleep, as they get too hot.. they also buy shirts for the baby. It's cute, but highly impractical. I would only put him in a shirt on a very special occasion.

An aside question, what does everyone do with the clothes that no longer fit ? Does a charity shop take them ? I have so much stuff and don't know what to do with it. No younger cousins / siblings on the horizon.

OP posts:
WestBridgewater · 05/01/2023 06:25

It would get on my last nerve if either set of grandparents kept buying my DC clothes randomly, not for a birthday or Christmas. Can you not afford to clothe your children? Because that would be the only circumstances that I could find it acceptable.

Pompom2367 · 05/01/2023 05:58

Mil is definitely controlling I would just ignore her send the odd photo of her in the outfits

EthicalNonMahogany · 05/01/2023 05:35

Really important for children to develop their individuality and resilence and start to learn they are their own person. They should choose whatever they can.

Clothes are part of that.

Get them to choose their clothes as early as possible. Along with food, books, the lot.

The sooner you learn that your child's choices don't reflect on you, the better OP.

A toddler SHOULD be in wellies, fairy wings, a mismatched Christmas jumper in June - and a jumper with a stain on just because they love it and won't let it go in the wash. Whatever they like as long as they are warm,
broadly hygienic and decent.

Or you'll end up like your MIL! You are more similar than you think...both getting a sense of power over others to make up for your own lack of agency in your lives.

JbJ87 · 05/01/2023 03:37

Mil sounds like a narcissist, look up traits / signs of a narcissists & see if more signs fit, if so, lots of good info out there how to deal with / respond to narcissistic behavior (boundaries have to be set, as it will only get worse otherwise & ruin many events, holidays, etc), very difficult & not the same approach as dealing with normal people works, took me 30+ years to realize how to deal with my narcissistic mom. Good luck!

mustgetoffmn · 05/01/2023 00:06

mustgetoffmn · 05/01/2023 00:04

Yes this is a good point. When my Dd was about 4 she got fixated on a particular jumper and skirt I just gave in . She had what I thought were nicer things but I quite liked that she had an interest in her own look an independent streak developing. No problem with school uniform because all her friends were wearing it so think they like the group identity. Grey rock sounds like the perfect response sounds like you’re tackling a big issue so we’ll done and good luck

But the mystifying objection to wearing a warm coat when it’s cold. Big struggle forcing it on 😂

mustgetoffmn · 05/01/2023 00:04

snowies · 04/01/2023 16:16

How do you get your kids to wear their uniforms if they're so fussy ? Just out of interest ? I've never really given my older one a choice yet of what to wear. Perhaps very occasionally... but she has to wear a uniform every day anyway for preschool.. that must be a real struggle if they refuse to wear anything you need them to wear !

Sounds like it's very common and something I can look forward to...

Yes this is a good point. When my Dd was about 4 she got fixated on a particular jumper and skirt I just gave in . She had what I thought were nicer things but I quite liked that she had an interest in her own look an independent streak developing. No problem with school uniform because all her friends were wearing it so think they like the group identity. Grey rock sounds like the perfect response sounds like you’re tackling a big issue so we’ll done and good luck

antipodeancanary · 04/01/2023 21:18

Yup, this. Even if it's the only time they wear the outfit!

BluIsTheColour · 04/01/2023 21:15

Only my eldest has school uniform and she likes it because it's dresses! She's not as bad as my 3yr old u can reason a bit more with the older one although does sometimes refuse to wear some things 🙈 mainly because she wants to wear something else.

snowies · 04/01/2023 16:16

BluIsTheColour · 04/01/2023 15:54

She's a nightmare! I mean nice she buys them things but it def comes with a price! I'd really have to bite my lip!

She wld love me as a dil as I often take things back and exchange 😆 I'd be telling her, it got a rip in it, a stain etc Or more likely the kids are very fussy & refusing to wear it!

My 2 kids are 3 and 5 both very picky about their clothes it's a nightmare. My just turned 3yr old has been very picky about her clothes since she was 2 1/2. It's very difficult to get her to wear anything but a dress 🙈 my older dd wasn't like that though at that age she didn't start being opinionated about clothes until about 4.

Now u might think no way but maybe take a pic of the kids in them. Then whatsapp to her. To be fair I often send a pic of the kids wearing outfits the family have bought them. Usually saying something like oh look how cute she is in the dress you bought her. Maybe different when it's on my terms though if I want to lol. It might stop her harassing u though!

How do you get your kids to wear their uniforms if they're so fussy ? Just out of interest ? I've never really given my older one a choice yet of what to wear. Perhaps very occasionally... but she has to wear a uniform every day anyway for preschool.. that must be a real struggle if they refuse to wear anything you need them to wear !

Sounds like it's very common and something I can look forward to...

OP posts:
BluIsTheColour · 04/01/2023 15:54

She's a nightmare! I mean nice she buys them things but it def comes with a price! I'd really have to bite my lip!

She wld love me as a dil as I often take things back and exchange 😆 I'd be telling her, it got a rip in it, a stain etc Or more likely the kids are very fussy & refusing to wear it!

My 2 kids are 3 and 5 both very picky about their clothes it's a nightmare. My just turned 3yr old has been very picky about her clothes since she was 2 1/2. It's very difficult to get her to wear anything but a dress 🙈 my older dd wasn't like that though at that age she didn't start being opinionated about clothes until about 4.

Now u might think no way but maybe take a pic of the kids in them. Then whatsapp to her. To be fair I often send a pic of the kids wearing outfits the family have bought them. Usually saying something like oh look how cute she is in the dress you bought her. Maybe different when it's on my terms though if I want to lol. It might stop her harassing u though!

Swipe left for the next trending thread