Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To please check children's books!!

119 replies

MrsTermites · 29/12/2022 10:08

It seems The Boy and the Dog by Seishu Hase is being bought by some older family members for children in the belief it's a lovely story like The Incredible Journey. It is not a children's book - a fifth of it is about a prostitute who gives blow jobs and hand jobs and there is a LOT of other detail. None of this comes up in the blurb, which of course is fine if you know it's an adults book, but it is getting some very shocked young readers I understand.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/12/2022 13:23

Whatever way you approach the website the all important category listing is there at the top of the screen

I know, Needmorelego, but it doesn't alter the point that some will look at a cover, read the blurb and think that's enough without checking the category at all

Which is why I said that considerable care is needed ...

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/12/2022 13:22

I wonder if some of the people who only work in binary - 100% child or 100% adult - are the same ones we see on MN who propose turning your children out of home on their 18th birthday and sending them out to face the world on their own.

Surely people realise that human childhood (and into the teen and young adult years) is a long, gradual process and not just like a caterpillar turning into a butterfly?

YouHaveAnArse · 29/12/2022 13:22

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/12/2022 13:10

But why should an ADULT book found in the ADULT section of a bookstore need to detail everything in its blurb? There is an assumption that an adult can deal with mature themes.

To be fair, I've been an adult for a long time now, and am fully capable of dealing with all mature themes; but a book that ends up spending so much time going on about blow jobs, when the title and synopsis suggest a much less tacky and porny experience all-round, would leave me feeling very short-changed.

As I said before, I hate how 'adult' has been co-opted to mean 'porn/smut'. The internet is full of porn for those who want it - I can't imagine many people wanting to get their jollies deliberately eschewing all that and instead buying a book that looks like this.

Not all writing that involves sex or sexual themes is intended to be erotic, even writing about what a sex worker does for a living. I've read a number of novels with sex scenes/content that was there to make a point or make the reader uncomfortable, and it would be a bit weird to dismiss that sort of writing as 'porny' just because some of the things that happened in it also take place in slash fiction.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/12/2022 13:19

Have you actually read this book?

No, I'm just going on OP's description - but I'm talking about books (and other media sources) in general, not just this one.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/12/2022 13:17

So if you were wanting to buy a child a book online, would you not first filter by category for their age range? Child, young adult etc? It's really not difficult.

Then you'd be automatically excluding a whole load of classic books that are quality literature for all ages (except little ones), but which have not been marked as 'children's'.

I think the OP will be in for a shock when she discovers what books are on secondary school/GCSE reading lists.

I would hope that educators will be choosing suitable books that deal with much more of the gamut of human emotions - including grown-up and other tricky themes - than just something focusing so heavily on tedious sexual acts; but it's certainly not unknown for predatory adults who get into responsible teaching roles to deliberately introduce inappropriate books of all kinds which whatever intentions they have.

Ericaequites · 29/12/2022 13:15

Some mysteries are suitable for children. In the States, there’s the cozy mystery genre. The Cat Who series by Lilian Jackson Braun is suitable for 9+. The is not intimacy beyond hugging and kissing, all murders take place offstage with no gory details, and the plots are clear. All the characters are adults with pro social attitudes. The Siamese cats who help solve the mysteries are so charismatic that they make the reader want one.
To Kill a Mockingbird is badly written and a poor choice for everyone.

Confusion101 · 29/12/2022 13:14

MrsTermites · 29/12/2022 13:05

Or would you do what this relative has clearly done which is to go online and just blindly press buy now because they saw a picture of a dog
**
And also read the blurb, which makes it sound like The Incredible Journey

Surely if you were buying a book online for a child you would click on the "children's books" link and not the "adult books". Step 1 of buying books online, surely???

please check children's books
Please check adult books bizarrely gifted to children

Needmorelego · 29/12/2022 13:11

@Puzzledandpissedoff I just typed in the book title then clicked on the book - which is where it gives more details (ie the category).
If I typed in 'books about dogs' 1000s would come up but surely you would click on the information before pressing 'buy'.
Whatever way you approach the website the all important category listing is there at the top of the screen.

pharaohrocher · 29/12/2022 13:11

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/12/2022 13:10

But why should an ADULT book found in the ADULT section of a bookstore need to detail everything in its blurb? There is an assumption that an adult can deal with mature themes.

To be fair, I've been an adult for a long time now, and am fully capable of dealing with all mature themes; but a book that ends up spending so much time going on about blow jobs, when the title and synopsis suggest a much less tacky and porny experience all-round, would leave me feeling very short-changed.

As I said before, I hate how 'adult' has been co-opted to mean 'porn/smut'. The internet is full of porn for those who want it - I can't imagine many people wanting to get their jollies deliberately eschewing all that and instead buying a book that looks like this.

Have you actually read this book?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/12/2022 13:10

But why should an ADULT book found in the ADULT section of a bookstore need to detail everything in its blurb? There is an assumption that an adult can deal with mature themes.

To be fair, I've been an adult for a long time now, and am fully capable of dealing with all mature themes; but a book that ends up spending so much time going on about blow jobs, when the title and synopsis suggest a much less tacky and porny experience all-round, would leave me feeling very short-changed.

As I said before, I hate how 'adult' has been co-opted to mean 'porn/smut'. The internet is full of porn for those who want it - I can't imagine many people wanting to get their jollies deliberately eschewing all that and instead buying a book that looks like this.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/12/2022 13:06

That's fair enough, Needmorelego, though it only works if buyers search by an age category instead of using keywords like "dog" for example - which they could easily do for a younger reader who's known to love them

I guess it just goes to show that considerable care's needed when buying for this age group

Wellthatwasreal · 29/12/2022 13:06

Pinkflipflop85 · 29/12/2022 10:11

It's not sold as a children's book.

It is sold in the crime and thriller section.

You would have to be a bit dense to buy that for a child.

Have a quick look on Amazon (where a lot of people buy books!).
No suggestion this is an adult fiction book, or of content that might be inappropriate for this age group.
But please don't let that deter from you from posting snarky comments questioning other people intelligence. 🙄

MrsTermites · 29/12/2022 13:05

Or would you do what this relative has clearly done which is to go online and just blindly press buy now because they saw a picture of a dog
**
And also read the blurb, which makes it sound like The Incredible Journey

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 29/12/2022 13:04

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll I think the OP will be in for a shock when she discovers what books are on secondary school/GCSE reading lists.

pharaohrocher · 29/12/2022 13:03

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/12/2022 12:58

I’ve just looked on Waterstones and it sounds like it would be suitable for children and I can see how easily someone could buy it for a child

You beat me to it by posting the Waterstones synopsis, but reading that I can see exactly why some would believe it suitable for younger readers and even the cover lends to this

Admittedly bookshops may not have it in the kids' section, but that's not much use if buying online

So if you were wanting to buy a child a book online, would you not first filter by category for their age range? Child, young adult etc? It's really not difficult.

Or would you do what this relative has clearly done which is to go online and just blindly press buy now because they saw a picture of a dog

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/12/2022 13:02

The OP hasn't mentioned the age of their child

This discussion isn't just about the OP's situation and child(ren)'s age(s) - hence OP specifically seeking to warn all other parents; but it's clearly not going to be bought for a 5yo, is it? Normal thickness chapter books with no/very few illustrations are obviously not going to be confused for little children's books; secondary school and up, quite possibly, though.

PuttingDownRoots · 29/12/2022 13:01

The Waterstones I use has separate adult and children sections... but also has random displays with books on offer, award winners, recommendations etc. So if it was on one of the plinths instead of the shelves....

Needmorelego · 29/12/2022 13:01

@Puzzledandpissedoff the picture I shared above is from the Waterstones website. It clearly shows what category it is under.
It would say "children's and young adult" if it was suitable. It doesn't. Quite clearly.

pharaohrocher · 29/12/2022 13:00

MrsTermites · 29/12/2022 12:56

I googled it, To me it does look like a kid's book just going on cover design alone...But surely people buying online would read the blurb about it?

None of the blurb mentions the very active prostitute

Why should it?

Because that was relevant to the question asked

But why should an ADULT book found in the ADULT section of a bookstore need to detail everything in its blurb? There is an assumption that an adult can deal with mature themes.

Honestly, this is just ridiculous.

Needmorelego · 29/12/2022 12:58

@Stripedbag101 what I meant though is Mockingbird was never originally published as a "children's" book - but is established enough now to be known as ok for more mature children to read.
When it's a book you don't know so much you would surely check - who is the publisher, what section in the bookshop is it in etc before buying it.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/12/2022 12:58

I’ve just looked on Waterstones and it sounds like it would be suitable for children and I can see how easily someone could buy it for a child

You beat me to it by posting the Waterstones synopsis, but reading that I can see exactly why some would believe it suitable for younger readers and even the cover lends to this

Admittedly bookshops may not have it in the kids' section, but that's not much use if buying online

MrsTermites · 29/12/2022 12:56

I googled it, To me it does look like a kid's book just going on cover design alone...But surely people buying online would read the blurb about it?

None of the blurb mentions the very active prostitute

Why should it?

Because that was relevant to the question asked

OP posts:
pharaohrocher · 29/12/2022 12:55

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/12/2022 12:52

Why do you think it looks like a children's book? Because there's an illustration of a dog on the cover? The word boy?

Nothing about that cover screams children's book imo - the style of illustration, the typeface, the colour - it's all very understated. It doesn't look like a Julia Donaldson book does it.

Teenagers don't want books with the Gruffalo or Peppa Pig on the cover! It's a challenging transitional time when they naturally want to start leaving 'kid' stuff behind but are not yet mature enough for adult-only themes.

The OP hasn't mentioned the age of their child

Needmorelego · 29/12/2022 12:53

Waterstones have it categorised like this. (Compared to Boy in Stripped pyjamas).
Clearly....NOT a children's book.

To please check children's books!!
To please check children's books!!
YouHaveAnArse · 29/12/2022 12:53

TBF, I read the first few volumes of Adrian Mole between ages 9 and 11, and that started when I picked up the first diary in our primary school library, and eventually got The Wilderness Years out of the adult library in town.

Swipe left for the next trending thread