Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that lots of companies won't take cash

334 replies

sicknote26 · 29/12/2022 01:20

Hi,

Been to lots of places that don't take cash, but starting to get really annoyed at not having the option of paying by cash.

Been to a couple of places today, first a well known activity place and a well known restaurant. Both completely cashless.

Aibu or is this a sigh of the times now.

What about the older generation who prefer to pay with cash.

OP posts:
KousaMahshi · 29/12/2022 12:05

sicknote26 · 29/12/2022 11:58

My sister is home from abroad for Christmas with her children, she's not been home since before covid. She's and the kids have brought spending money with them that they have gotten changed into pounds. She also can not believe only card payments are a thing here. As it's back to normal where she lives.

Also I never said the elderly where unable to pay by card. Just that I know my parents and grandparents prefer to pay cash .

Also a lot of these places only let you know it's card payment only when you are getting ready to pay. Quite embarrassing when you only have cash on you .

But why one earth would you go to the effort and expense of changing cash into pounds, with the possiblity of more effort and expense to change it back if youj have to? Just use a revolut card or whatever with free exchange and multiple currency accounts.

The more wieldy, expensive way is not better, its much worse. Why do people make life so hard for themselves?

Alwayswonderedwhy · 29/12/2022 12:02

I never carry cash. The older generation were young when debit/credit cards became popular so it's not an issue. My parents in their 80s are perfectly capable of using Google pay etc.

Getting cash out is an inconvenience for a lot of people. Much easier to do everything electronically.

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/12/2022 12:00

CosyScentedCandles · 29/12/2022 11:53

@AbreathofFrenchair i open the app and it unlocks with Face ID, I don’t see how that is more difficult than opening your purse? Also it’s not exactly practical to say I’m only going to spend £100 this week but oh dear this takes me to £101 so I won’t be able to get it🙄

You've tagged me and quoted someone else's post.

taxguru · 29/12/2022 11:58

@Weleaiig

I don’t agree with it and surely it’s made things more expensive because the charges mad3 on debit and credit cards have to be paid for by the buyer to a large degree.

Businesses accepting, processing, administering, storing and banking cash, risking forgeries and theft, also has a cost, in fact, often it's more expensive to deal with cash, as card processing fees are very competitive and can be pretty cheap, as is the equipment.

sicknote26 · 29/12/2022 11:58

My sister is home from abroad for Christmas with her children, she's not been home since before covid. She's and the kids have brought spending money with them that they have gotten changed into pounds. She also can not believe only card payments are a thing here. As it's back to normal where she lives.

Also I never said the elderly where unable to pay by card. Just that I know my parents and grandparents prefer to pay cash .

Also a lot of these places only let you know it's card payment only when you are getting ready to pay. Quite embarrassing when you only have cash on you .

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 29/12/2022 11:55

Unfortunately, not everywhere in the UK has a good enough signal to use one @JassyRadlett. I agree that they are simple to use though. When we were fundraising for the local hospice recently the vast majority of donations were in cash. When people said they never carried cash they were told that we could accept card payments, but 98% of the donations were still in cash.

Yep, fair enough @RampantIvy - I was just responding to the suggestion that people selling at market stalls wouldn't want to use them.

We had a totally opposite experience at a fundraising day recently - we took a fair amount in cash but the vast majority was on the card machines.

Weleaiig · 29/12/2022 11:55

I don’t agree with it and surely it’s made things more expensive because the charges mad3 on debit and credit cards have to be paid for by the buyer to a large degree. Definitely makes me spend a lot less than I used to. I often wonder if I’m in a minority though. It makes me spend less because I’m more cautious of going overdrawn because sometimes I need to stop and think what direct debits might be coming out around the time of spending so I’m extra cautious about buying things I didn’t go in for and buying things I see and would have previously just bought to treat myself or someone else. I’ve noticed that our children are growing up with the same attitude so not a bad thing in some ways.

OoooohMatron · 29/12/2022 11:55

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/12/2022 09:27

I think you've been watching too many crime dramas to now believe that a business accepting cash is dodgy.

ONLY cash. Read what I said.

Badbadbunny · 29/12/2022 11:54

luckylavender · 29/12/2022 11:43

You're in a busy part of London. That's not the whole country.

Internet improvements are constantly happening. I never used to be able to get a mobile phone signal in my office (converted barn with think stone walls in a hollow in a village). Quite surprised the other day when my phone rang - first time it's ever rung in the office. Looked at it to see 4 bars of the signal, now it's fully functional, even with 4g internet! They've clearly upgraded the mobile masts or put up another as I've got the same phone, same provider, etc. I was happily surprised!

CosyScentedCandles · 29/12/2022 11:53

RampantIvy · 29/12/2022 11:43

Brilliant post. I agree with you.

Online banking these days is remarkably simple, more so with mobile phone apps.

For you and me, yes. For someone with dementia they would struggle. My late MIL couldn’t even remember how to use her non smart simple to use mobile phone to just make a phone call when her memory started to go.

Debit cards started to come into use in the early 1970's though

Are you sure you aren’t confusing them with credit cards that you could use in an ATM? I remember being excited to get a debit card in the mid 1990s.

Also’ I never understand why people say it is easier to budget with cash? It just…isn’t?

In some ways it is @CosyScentedCandles. If you take £100 out of a cash machine to last a week it is much easier to stay within your budget than just getting a debit card or using your phone every time to pay for something. The temptation to overspend using modern payment methods is much greater. It is much quicker and simpler to open your purse and see how much you have left than to log into your banking app multiple times a day.

The buskers and the people on market stalls all have SumUps round here!

Unfortunately, not everywhere in the UK has a good enough signal to use one @JassyRadlett. I agree that they are simple to use though. When we were fundraising for the local hospice recently the vast majority of donations were in cash. When people said they never carried cash they were told that we could accept card payments, but 98% of the donations were still in cash.

Don’t you get charged for every time you use your card? I do. Small amount but it all adds up.

No. I’m with Nationwide. They don’t charge for transactions.

For the record I use my debit card for 99.99% of any payments I make. However, I always have a couple of banknotes in my phone case. I tend not to carry a purse around with me any more as all my store cards are on my phone as well, making a purse redundant.

@AbreathofFrenchair i open the app and it unlocks with Face ID, I don’t see how that is more difficult than opening your purse? Also it’s not exactly practical to say I’m only going to spend £100 this week but oh dear this takes me to £101 so I won’t be able to get it🙄

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/12/2022 11:49

luckylavender · 29/12/2022 11:43

You're in a busy part of London. That's not the whole country.

To them it probably is though. They think beyond the m25 is abroad

luckylavender · 29/12/2022 11:45

NoelleSnowman · 29/12/2022 06:35

YABU. They don’t have to take cash. You don’t have to shop/go there.

The older generation have had decades to get used to cards when they weren’t even part of the “older” generation. They’ve no excuse not to use them.

Terrible argument. I actually rarely use cash but think it's very dangerous to lose it.

KousaMahshi · 29/12/2022 11:45

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 29/12/2022 02:34

YANBU.

My grandad is 88 and fairly savvy but he os visually impaired and can’t see the numbers of the chip and pin machine. So he goes into the bank once a week and takes enough cash out to last him. He’s very sad that increasingly he can’t enjoy places because they won’t take his cash.

I always think places that do this are run by privileged people who don’t think of those who may not be able to always pay by card and that they must alienate so many potential customers

These responses are so daft. Your grandad would find it much easier to pay contactless than with cash, and would be much safer too. Instead of letting him carry around large amounts opf cash and be sad about not being able to use it, simply help him to get a contactless card or use a a phone.

Honestly, the fuss poeople make when there are simpler better alternatives so easily available.

luckylavender · 29/12/2022 11:43

JudyGemston · 29/12/2022 02:33

I’ve never encountered a situation where the “machines were down” and I use Apple Pay or contactless for just about every transaction I make. I’m in a busy part of London and I have no use for cash.

You're in a busy part of London. That's not the whole country.

RampantIvy · 29/12/2022 11:43

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/12/2022 09:20

This thread and being cashless just highlights again how selfish people are because they cannot comprehend how people may struggle being cashless and are therefore ridiculous and behind the times. Because they "have no need for cash" they think it should be done away with completely and then the faux ignorance that goes along with it "where on earth are you shopping where the card machine goes down" as though that never happens!

Our nearest lounge pub is card only, m&s has gone quiet because they accept cash but don't always have cash and Poundland refuse cash payments. The lounge is ridiculous because they have to carry the card machine around to pick up signal

Things like car boot sales, school fairs, tips for hairdressers, bar staff etc will all be a thing of the past soon.

But who cares, as long as those that are super proud about not carrying or needing cash are ok, crack on. Everyone else is just stupid and needs to get with the times.

Brilliant post. I agree with you.

Online banking these days is remarkably simple, more so with mobile phone apps.

For you and me, yes. For someone with dementia they would struggle. My late MIL couldn’t even remember how to use her non smart simple to use mobile phone to just make a phone call when her memory started to go.

Debit cards started to come into use in the early 1970's though

Are you sure you aren’t confusing them with credit cards that you could use in an ATM? I remember being excited to get a debit card in the mid 1990s.

Also’ I never understand why people say it is easier to budget with cash? It just…isn’t?

In some ways it is @CosyScentedCandles. If you take £100 out of a cash machine to last a week it is much easier to stay within your budget than just getting a debit card or using your phone every time to pay for something. The temptation to overspend using modern payment methods is much greater. It is much quicker and simpler to open your purse and see how much you have left than to log into your banking app multiple times a day.

The buskers and the people on market stalls all have SumUps round here!

Unfortunately, not everywhere in the UK has a good enough signal to use one @JassyRadlett. I agree that they are simple to use though. When we were fundraising for the local hospice recently the vast majority of donations were in cash. When people said they never carried cash they were told that we could accept card payments, but 98% of the donations were still in cash.

Don’t you get charged for every time you use your card? I do. Small amount but it all adds up.

No. I’m with Nationwide. They don’t charge for transactions.

For the record I use my debit card for 99.99% of any payments I make. However, I always have a couple of banknotes in my phone case. I tend not to carry a purse around with me any more as all my store cards are on my phone as well, making a purse redundant.

luckylavender · 29/12/2022 11:41

DairyDiary · 29/12/2022 01:22

YABU. There’s literally no downside and about a million upsides.

There are lots of downsides

tasamoon · 29/12/2022 11:37

Personally I found it much more annoying when places were cash only and didn't take card, or card only over a certain amount.

I hate cash. It's dirty and heavy, and inconvenient to have to go and get it out.

Happily since covid you can use your card everywhere.

budgiegirl · 29/12/2022 11:33

My DH takes his wages out of the bank in cash every week and only leaves enough in his account to cover his phone bill. He pays cash or he doesn’t shop there. He’s always done it, he’s 54. Just prefers cash. Once it’s accumulated into a few hundred pounds spare I’ll get it from him as I don’t like it in the house and pay it into the savings account. After 26 years I’m not going to try and change him

You may not try to change him, but he might find that society as a whole does. It will become increasingly difficult for him to function by only spending cash, it will limit his choices. Change is not always a bad thing, and usually we just have to move with the times, or get left behind.

To those saying it's unfair on older people, I'd much rather my elderly mother carried only a card with her, and not wads of cash. If her card is stolen, she can stop that straight away, but if cash is stolen, it's gone for good. Mum is 90, and is perfectly capable of doing online banking, using contactless cards etc. She hasn't forgotten her pin yet, but worries that she could do, and has it written down, but she keeps it separately in her coat pocket (disguised as a phone number) , so it would be unlikely to be stolen at the same time as her card.

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/12/2022 11:26

Quisquam · 29/12/2022 10:16

I think you've been watching too many crime dramas to now believe that a business accepting cash is dodgy.

Money laundering? Tax evasion? What is the black economy worth now. According to HMRC:

www.gov.uk/government/publications/hmrc-issue-briefing-hidden-economy-conditionality/hmrc-issue-briefing-hidden-economy-conditionality

The latest estimate was that £2.6 billion tax revenues were lost, due to it?

I'm not saying that it doesnt happen but to work on the premise that everyone business that accepts cash is the front for a dodgy business is pretty ridiculous.

You all act like online is infinitely risk free, safe and eradicated all illegal activity yet cyber terrorism is the next big threat and very much real risk where they could wipe out entire money stocks

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/12/2022 11:19

Badbadbunny · 29/12/2022 10:11

The quote you replied to said "cash only" - did you miss that?

Did you miss the bit where I did a second post acknowledging that I missed it?

Preraph · 29/12/2022 11:15

PortiasBiscuit · 29/12/2022 07:43

I am finding it really difficult to get a lamplighter to come round regularly, also have my horse shoed and my black bombazine cleaned..
Times change, gotta change with them.

Exactly...progress is inevitable, it has me in mind of a Victorian drama (based on the author's reminiscences) I was watching some time ago, where they were discussing the new 'flying machines'...one of the characters responded with "If it was decreed that we should fly we'd have been given wings". Seems some things never change.

thingumybob · 29/12/2022 11:07

Jasmino1o · 29/12/2022 02:41

I personally don’t mind because I tend to pay with Apple Pay, however, I have worked in retail
in the past where there have been older customers forgetting their pin at the checkout and then blocking their card, or who have asked me to type in their pin for them because they couldn’t see the keypad, this could potentially put them in a vulnerable position.

My GM has her pin written in a little book that she’ll take in her handbag if she’s taking her debit card with her, so if she had her handbag stolen then the thief would have access to all the money in her bank (we live in a rural area so not able to quickly pop into the bank to cancel the card), whereas if she was shopping with cash she wouldn’t be carrying all her bank account’s contents.

You don't need to go into the bank to cancel the card. You can do it on the phone.

thingumybob · 29/12/2022 11:05

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 29/12/2022 02:34

YANBU.

My grandad is 88 and fairly savvy but he os visually impaired and can’t see the numbers of the chip and pin machine. So he goes into the bank once a week and takes enough cash out to last him. He’s very sad that increasingly he can’t enjoy places because they won’t take his cash.

I always think places that do this are run by privileged people who don’t think of those who may not be able to always pay by card and that they must alienate so many potential customers

Surely if he can see well enough to use cash he can do contactless payments? Or is he regularly spending over £100 in a transaction?

thingumybob · 29/12/2022 11:00

ILoveeCakes · 29/12/2022 01:44

All the time, I feel I have 2 separate conversations:

  • People who proudly tell me they dont carry cash
  • People moaning that the card machine was down

Do these sets of people never meet?

I don't buy lots but I experience a "card down" situation at least once a month........so I always have cash.......... Is it just me? Feels like it sometimes!!

You must be very unlucky because I can't remember the last time that happened to me. It must be years ago!

Badbadbunny · 29/12/2022 10:56

WineDarkNo308 · 29/12/2022 06:48

My DH takes his wages out of the bank in cash every week and only leaves enough in his account to cover his phone bill. He pays cash or he doesn’t shop there. He’s always done it, he’s 54. Just prefers cash. Once it’s accumulated into a few hundred pounds spare I’ll get it from him as I don’t like it in the house and pay it into the savings account. After 26 years I’m not going to try and change him.

His stubbornness will come back and bite him on the bum in a few years. As he gets older, he'll find it more difficult to adapt and will find himself more and more alienated in so many ways.

I'm sure he's made the effort to do the "techy" things he wants to such as smart phone, social media, car sat nav etc.

It's people like him who need to be forced into moving forward rather than being a luddite. At the end of the day, it's him who'll suffer and you're just facilitating his luddite behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread