Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to do something about my weight, before I gain anymore

106 replies

JJ213 · 28/12/2022 22:45

Hi

So basically during 2020 I lost 4 stone. I went from 13st something and got down to 9st. I'm 5'6/7 ish. I did this through 16:8 intermittent fasting, reducing sugar etc and exercising.

I managed to stay around 9st until the last few months. I'd say over the last 4-5 months I've gone up to 10st 11. I'm still doing 16:8 and the exercise. But I'm gaining weight.

I've been thinking about doing something different such as joining slimming world or doing a vlcd to get the weight off asap.

I'm not sure how I'm gaining as my diet and everyday routine is the same.

I had a shock when I tried to get into my size 8 jeans a few months back.

So I'm now thinking whether to stay at the heavier weight or do something about it and get back down to 9 stone.

Any ideas?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Billslills · 11/01/2023 07:17

This has clearly been a long term ongoing issue for you which you can’t resolve. Why don’t you seek out professional help and hire a nutritionist?! Much smarter course of action than getting random people (with no qualifications) from the internet giving their two cents.

Mumsanetta · 10/01/2023 13:14

@MarshaBradyo i hadn’t heard about it either but it’s based on recent research and set out very clearly in Why We Eat (Too Much). It explains why people have different metabolisms, what what you eat is just as important as how much and why energy in vs energy out doesn’t work for most yo-yo dieters.

EndlessRain1 · 10/01/2023 12:32

JJ213 · 10/01/2023 12:10

Yes low or no carb diets seem to be the way to eat these days.

Not really. Whole grain carbs is recommended as part of every meal. My point is stop obsessing about dieting - fasting, calorie counting etc, because the evidence suggests none of these things last long term. And instead focus on fuel your body with a nutritionally balanced and healthy diet.

JJ213 · 10/01/2023 12:23

@HelenHywater I'm 5ft6

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 10/01/2023 12:23

Btw the posts were interesting , so am intrigued

MarshaBradyo · 10/01/2023 12:22

Mumsanetta · 04/01/2023 15:56

You won the battle to lose weight but lost the war because you didn’t change your weight set point. You need to change what you eat to change your weight set point otherwise you will always eventually put the weight back on because it’s impossible to win against a biological process. Have a read of Why We Eat (Too Much) if what I am saying sounds like mumbo jumbo and to learn how to change your weight set point.

I’ve not heard of this set point before

Changing what you eat - is this just cut out processed etc

HelenHywater · 10/01/2023 12:20

Are you logging the number of calories that you're taking in? I think a sandwich porridge, curry, rice and naan all in 16 hours of eating is quite a lot of calories isn't it? I don't know how tall you are, but what is the number of calories that you need to be taking in to lose weight?

I won't lose weight on anything more than 1500 calories and probably need to stick to around 1200 to lose weight. I wouldn't eat all those carbs (because I would get more hungry on them) in a normal day. I'd also do some proper exercise (on top of my steps) most days although I won't count the calories that I burn up doing that).

Jimboscott0115 · 10/01/2023 12:17

JJ213 · 29/12/2022 09:28

The whole of 2021 I was a size 8 and 9stone. So I don't think it is.

But I do agree with you, when you say the body tends to find a weight it's comfortable with.

That doesn't make the initial post irrelevant OP, it may be that your natural weight isn't 9st and the body nearly always corrects itself, even if it takes a year or two.

I'm not saying that is it, but 9st is very light and not all bodies are built to be that size. You're on the right track in terms of monitoring etc as ultimately calories and diet will be the determining factors of whether there's much you can do.

One more word of advice, I'd focus on the size rather than weight - when working in a gym our mantra was always 'inches not pounds' - you could weigh more but be a smaller size, bodies are weird like that, particularly if you have a regular exercise regime which will naturally change your body shape.

JJ213 · 10/01/2023 12:12

I think I'm going to get my size 8 jeans out. Try them on and see how far they are from fitting me.

Hopefully give me some extra motivation today!!

OP posts:
JJ213 · 10/01/2023 12:10

EndlessRain1 · 10/01/2023 11:10

I feel there has been a real change to advice recently. It's well documented that dieting almost never results in longlasting weight loss - you might lose it but it comes back. Sometimes + more. Recently I've seen far more advice about looking at what you eat rather rather than how much. So really focusing on getting engouh fruit and, especially, veg, eating fish and lean protein, healthy fats etc.

Yes low or no carb diets seem to be the way to eat these days.

OP posts:
RelentlessForwardProgress · 10/01/2023 11:30

I used to be morbidly obese and am slim.

May I make a suggestion?

I would try and really thoroughly add up my calories for a day. I'm not suggesting living like this, because life's too short, but just do it absolutely meticulously for one day and see what numbers you come up with.

Reading your posts, the 16:8 is fine, the steps are fine, but the food intake for the day you listed is a lot more food than I'd eat in a day to lose or even maintain, tbh.

With your lunch you also ate a bowl of porridge.
With your curry, you ate rice and naan.

If I'm maintaining my weight I don't weigh and measure food, I try to be pretty relaxed about what I'm eating, but I have in the back of my mind, that I need to be moderate in my choices rather than go overboard.

So If i'm having a curry, I would have a portion of rice OR a naan. Not both at the same time. Because that is the same as eating a sandwich AND a bag of chips at the same meal. Which is delicious but a lot of food and I can't eat like that very often without gaining weight.

And if I am trying to lose, I would still have the curry and if I felt like a naan, I'd look up the Kcals, weight it and eat 85g of it, which is about half a big one. This is about 280 Kcals. If I eat the whole big one, it would be 500+ kcals, which is too much for me when added up with the calories in the curry itself. Next time I wanted a naan, I probably wouldn't weigh it as I'd know if I have half a big one that's about right when I'm trying to lose weight.

Trying to eat a 'cleaner' diet is good because you get more food for your calories, (1 bar of a kit kat is more calories than a whole punnet of raspberries which would take me 10x as long to eat, for example), and I think if you are eating lots of protein and good veggies it does help you to crave the crap less BUT 'eating clean' ie only eating the good stuff is deadly, in my experience, as I can't keep it up and its just a binge waiting to happen. Trying to eat moderately, feeding your body good stuff with some more indulgent treaty food factored in is sustainable in the way that 'regime's' of any kind are not.

EndlessRain1 · 10/01/2023 11:10

I feel there has been a real change to advice recently. It's well documented that dieting almost never results in longlasting weight loss - you might lose it but it comes back. Sometimes + more. Recently I've seen far more advice about looking at what you eat rather rather than how much. So really focusing on getting engouh fruit and, especially, veg, eating fish and lean protein, healthy fats etc.

JJ213 · 10/01/2023 11:06

Thecaravan · 09/01/2023 18:27

If you've not already, read Fast Feast Repeat by Gin Stevens. I've been doing 16:8 for a while as well as low carb but Decenber was a write off so have gained a couple of kilos. Am now going to try clean fasting as per the book as I've always allowed a splash of milk in my tea which messes up the fasting apparently. Like you, not loads of weight to lose but just want to feel comfier. I'm 5'9" and happy at around 9 stone 4 (59kg) which for many people would be too light but still makes me a size 12! I swear my bones are filled with air or something.

You're a few inches taller than me. I guess we all carry weight differently.

At 9 stone I was a comfy size 8.

OP posts:
JJ213 · 10/01/2023 11:05

I'm going to be quite strict today. Going to weigh everything I eat.

Also only drank water this morning.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 10/01/2023 10:52

Chazx · 09/01/2023 17:31

@thisplaceisweird - yes, the sooner people wake up to that fact and concentrate on what they eat, the better.

I spend a 3-4 hours per week (according to Garmin and Strava based on my height/weight/heart rate) doing running, zone 2 cardio/weights and light work outs and burn about 400 calories per hour. So by anyone's analysis, i do proper exercise.

I also walk about 8k minimum -10k steps a day.

I keep putting on weight or hovering around 10 stone because i eat about 800 cals of junk daily. I'm addicted. for example 6 pack of wotsits , 3 curly wurly bars and all my normal meals each day, so total of 2700 cals every day.

I don't lose weight despite all the exercise because i eat too much.

Yes, it's been known for a while that maintaining a healthy weight is 95% diet.

It's correlation not causation that people who workout a lot are thin - they usually eat well too.

thisplaceisweird · 10/01/2023 10:42

Tim Spector is great on nutrition, watch this short what I eat in a day video

FlowerArranger · 09/01/2023 20:13

And whilst it is true that exercising has a limited effect on weight, it can be a powerful motivator.

Muscles are good, @JJ213 . Try Caroline Girvan.

FlowerArranger · 09/01/2023 20:09

What @thisplaceisweird said! Or the short version:

"Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants."

Plus moderate amounts of lean protein.

Thecaravan · 09/01/2023 18:27

If you've not already, read Fast Feast Repeat by Gin Stevens. I've been doing 16:8 for a while as well as low carb but Decenber was a write off so have gained a couple of kilos. Am now going to try clean fasting as per the book as I've always allowed a splash of milk in my tea which messes up the fasting apparently. Like you, not loads of weight to lose but just want to feel comfier. I'm 5'9" and happy at around 9 stone 4 (59kg) which for many people would be too light but still makes me a size 12! I swear my bones are filled with air or something.

Mumsanetta · 09/01/2023 18:16

Some types of exercise will help you burn fat. If you are already eating whole foods with minimal processed foods and sugar then lifting weights will get you into your size 8 jeans quicker than any other form of exercise. You might not see any movement on the scales but you will be slimmer as a pound of muscle looks very different to a pound of fat. As an added bonus, muscle requires more energy to maintain so you should also increase your metabolism.

JJ213 · 09/01/2023 17:48

thisplaceisweird · 09/01/2023 16:53

Exercise has almost no affect on weight loss. Try no snacks for a few weeks, and doing intermittent fasting properly, and then see how you get on.

Will do. Thanks Grin hopefully I see a difference

OP posts:
Chazx · 09/01/2023 17:33

it's much quicker and easier to chug the calories down your mouth than it is burn them off.

Chazx · 09/01/2023 17:31

@thisplaceisweird - yes, the sooner people wake up to that fact and concentrate on what they eat, the better.

I spend a 3-4 hours per week (according to Garmin and Strava based on my height/weight/heart rate) doing running, zone 2 cardio/weights and light work outs and burn about 400 calories per hour. So by anyone's analysis, i do proper exercise.

I also walk about 8k minimum -10k steps a day.

I keep putting on weight or hovering around 10 stone because i eat about 800 cals of junk daily. I'm addicted. for example 6 pack of wotsits , 3 curly wurly bars and all my normal meals each day, so total of 2700 cals every day.

I don't lose weight despite all the exercise because i eat too much.

thisplaceisweird · 09/01/2023 16:53

Exercise has almost no affect on weight loss. Try no snacks for a few weeks, and doing intermittent fasting properly, and then see how you get on.

JJ213 · 09/01/2023 15:55

My average step count is 13,000. My phone and watch says I do around 9.8km daily.

OP posts: