Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think how I discipline my dog is no-one else’s business?

239 replies

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 21:17

I have a 3 year old dog, had him ever since he was a puppy. I am quite strict with him - he isn’t allowed to jump up at people, he isn’t allowed to approach other dogs without the owner’s permission, he is sent to his bed when the family eat so he doesn’t beg for food, he is told no when he touches something he shouldn’t like the children’s toys etc - and occasionally if I have had to tell him more than once about something (he has a habit of getting distracted when guests are over) then he goes to his bed for some time out etc.

Because of this, he is generally a really well behaved dog and I’ve never really had any issues with him apart from if he gets distracted and overwhelmed with loads of people or loads going on, he can struggle to concentrate on what is being said to him - but that is something that is a work in progress. In a normal environment he is very good at listening, etc.

The issues I have had however are with family members making comments every time I do put these boundaries into place - because basically they think he should be able to just do whatever he wants to do. Like an example from earlier today - his behaviour has been all over the place the last few days from being quite overwhelmed with Christmas and busy households - this is normal for him and will settle back down when everything else quietens down. He had something in his mouth that he shouldn’t have done and could have easily caused an issue to himself had he swallowed it - I told him to drop it a couple of times and he didn’t - so I VERY lightly tapped him on the nose and he dropped it straight away and went back to playing with his toys. I very rarely do that unless it’s something he needs to let go of right that second for his own sake and safety and he isn’t listening to verbal commands because of distractions etc rather than trying to drag it out of his mouth. But my family said I should have just left him and he might have dropped it eventually etc.

One family member has a similar dog and she lets him get away with murder and then constantly moans about it - he doesn’t let her sleep and rules the household basically - and yet she criticises me for actually having rules and boundaries with my dog.

Any advice for how I handle this situation?

OP posts:
1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 22:49

@Pocketfullofdogtreats if it hadn’t of been something so dangerous that’s what I would have done - or used the drop command effectively - I have already explained that I don’t use this as a training technique and it happened out of panic - I have already said that before and it’s getting tiring repeating myself because people either don’t read or pay attention to PP

OP posts:
PurpleBurglarAlarm · 28/12/2022 22:49

There are better and more humane ways to teach a dog to
drop something the first time
you ask so that you don’t need to
use punitive methods. I usually use Chirag Patel’s method although there are other positive ways.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 28/12/2022 22:48

I agree with the point about distracting rather than hitting - offer something else and take away the thing you don't want him to have.

JoyBeorge · 28/12/2022 22:46

The tapping on the nose I don't agree with. What you do is use a high value treat as a bribe. If he has something he shouldn't have then use a tiny piece of cooked meat or cheese or something you know he'll do anything for, something high value to him which he will gladly drop the other item for without any argument. It's much easier and avoids any conflict because the dog doesn't want to give it up. To be honest if he's still a 'work in progress ' after 3 years and your having to get physical to get him to obey you then maybe that's a sign your methods aren't working. My dog often gets things he knows he shouldn't and I get them back off him in seconds with no tapping on the nose or dramas. He gives them up willingly because I produce something else even tastier that he will do anything for. It has to be something that is of higher value to him than the item he shouldn't have. It's not ideal but it works.

Ginsloth · 28/12/2022 22:44

MadameDe · 28/12/2022 22:35

It depends on the dog. If I were to continually reward my dog with positive reinforcement I would have a problem on my hands. When I used it as my main tool he just came to expect it for everything even when he hadn't listened.

I've realised over the years that you need more than one technique and part of it is about knowing your dog. I know my boy gets anxious around other dogs sometimes - when I can see him feeling that way I know just maintaining eye contact helps him feel calmer. He also knows hand signals for stop, left, right and no. I find my biggest barrier to him behaving well is always the do-gooder / groups of people. Every time he gets a treat or reward for doing nothing, he then expects it the next time. The message here is that unless you see something abusive don't interfere. It causes more problems than it's worth.

But it’s a gradual process. What started with my pup as a food treat for staying on the ground, reduced to a “yes” (which he knows is a praise due to previous games to teach him this), and over time now I just treat or say yes in a specific situation that I know he finds hard to keep calm and controlled in, for example when welcoming lots of people into our home. I also would focus on one thing at a time for a few weeks, so it wasn’t rewards all over the place for anything and everything.
Not all dogs are the same, you’re right. I was sharing a method that worked for me on the advice of a dog trainer, as what the OP has been doing is well-meaning but clearly not as effective as she’d like. I’m not suggesting that for the rest of the dog’s life he gets a treat everytime he stays on the ground, they do learn over time.
You’re definitely right in that you have to get to know your dog. Our boy is 2 and is still very over excited around other dogs and we are working on that. We find distraction, and like you say getting his eye contact, with the “look at me” command helps him to regain his composure. Still not perfect on that, especially when another dog is off lead and comes bounding over!

shockthemonkey · 28/12/2022 22:43

How you discipline your dog is other people's business if there is abuse going on.

However, from the lovely rosy picture you've painted of your exemplary training, on the face of it on a normal day I don't think there is any abuse going on.

What is key is this "tap". It was, you say, the lightest of taps... and I don't agree with pps who seem to say that dogs' noses are so tender that the lightest of taps would hurt. Mine loves to be scratched right there, with quite a bit of pressure, and if you don't scratch hard enough she leans in for more. So sensitive yes, but a light finger tap won't hurt really.

Yet... the tap was enough to elicit a comment. So someone thought that how you disciplined your dog was their business.

I must say I'm on the fence here. What we need is to know the Newtons measurement of this tap. If my DD had picked up a tack I would have been over like a shot and would have gently opened her mouth to get it out. She would have thought it was all a splendid game, but she would have given up the tack immediately.

tillyandmilly · 28/12/2022 22:43

Nope - sorry don’t agree with your actions.

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 22:42

@justasking111 when he is in a calm environment and there is little distractions around he listens really well but as soon as things get busy etc it’s like all sense just goes out the window! Plus it’s the first Christmas we’ve had with everyone around because of COVID etc so it was definitely a bit overwhelming for him, so that’s a lesson in itself for next year and how to handle the plans etc!

OP posts:
BlueLabel · 28/12/2022 22:42

Inextremis No, I own a collie and a terrier and for the past 3 years I've fostered rescue dogs.

I'm frustrated that half the poor souls I end up having are the result of shitty dog training techniques and idiot owners.

FlamingGalar · 28/12/2022 22:42

Having had a puppy that ended up having open stomach surgery from swallowing a drawing pin, I completely understand your actions OP. Recovering from a serious op would be far more painful than a tap on the nose. Our dog had snuffled it before any of us had the chance to do anything about it, but if giving him a tap on the nose had encouraged him to spit it out I would have done this in a heartbeat.

Inextremis · 28/12/2022 22:42

Also, @Ginsloth speaks sense - one of the few posters on this thread to do so :)

Fuaran · 28/12/2022 22:42

You need to work on the ‘drop’ command, your dog is 3 years old and should know this command by now. Personally I would never tap a dog on its nose, however, you appear to find it acceptable and are trying to justify your actions. A lot of what you’ve said in your OP suggests your dog isn’t as perfectly trained as you think.

I very rarely do that unless it’s something he needs to let go of right that second for his own sake and safety and he isn’t listening to verbal commands

So this isn’t a one off is it? He should know to drop an item by age 3. We have working labs and spaniels and they drop items easily when you train them. We’ve also never had to put any dog in ‘time out’, they’re not children for goodness sake.

There’s no need to be ‘strict’ with dogs if they’re properly trained with kindness from a young age, especially working breeds and training takes a LOT of work.

justasking111 · 28/12/2022 22:41

Our spaniel whenever the grandchildren come round goes crazy, he adores them but gets overload with all the excitement of little people. I do put him away for his own peace sometimes.

Christmas is a crazy time for pets. The cat disappears as soon as humans arrive. Especially little ones

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 22:40

@Inextremis I remember one time when one of my kids was really young and they reached towards a hot drink someone was holding - it happened so quick I very quickly and gently tapped their hand away from the cup - had it been something that wasn’t an immediate threat and she had properly and reliably understood the word no (she was toddler stage) then it wouldn’t have happened - but it certainly didn’t cause her any harm or damage (she didn’t even cry, just gave me a funny look) but it stopped a potentially serious burn from happening which would have been a lot worse - but I’m sure people will equate that to being a horrible parent and beating my child every day too 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Inextremis · 28/12/2022 22:39

@BlueLabel - do you perhaps own Pomeranians? You made me laugh, cos my dogs are the softest, floppiest, happiest beings in this house, both snoring happily and about to go to bed with me - honestly they've done more damage to me (knocked a tooth out!) than I have ever done to them! Am now going to the aforementioned bed with the aforementioned dogs - night all - and OP, don't spend any more time worrying about it :)

Weirdinbetweentime · 28/12/2022 22:39

You sound overly strict to me, poor dog, let him be a dog and have some fun in a nice environment

MadameDe · 28/12/2022 22:35

Ginsloth · 28/12/2022 22:18

As a previous poster has very kindly advised you regarding your specific dog’s breed and over-training etc. do you not think maybe your family have a point?
I know of a couple of family’s who think they’re doing best by their dog by being very strict. The sending the dog to its bed when it’s done something wrong is something they also do. But that’s not a very effective way of training. Reinforcing good behaviour is much more effective than punishing “bad” behaviour. Quite often they won’t even understand what they’ve done wrong to be sent to bed.
When you say, for example, you’re strict about him jumping up, how do you mean? Do you take him away from the situation? Do you send him to bed? Do you raise your voice and tell him no? All of these things won’t make sense to him. The best thing to do is reward for paws on the floor. Everytime he greets someone and stays on the ground, reward.

It depends on the dog. If I were to continually reward my dog with positive reinforcement I would have a problem on my hands. When I used it as my main tool he just came to expect it for everything even when he hadn't listened.

I've realised over the years that you need more than one technique and part of it is about knowing your dog. I know my boy gets anxious around other dogs sometimes - when I can see him feeling that way I know just maintaining eye contact helps him feel calmer. He also knows hand signals for stop, left, right and no. I find my biggest barrier to him behaving well is always the do-gooder / groups of people. Every time he gets a treat or reward for doing nothing, he then expects it the next time. The message here is that unless you see something abusive don't interfere. It causes more problems than it's worth.

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 22:34

@Ginsloth i didn’t actually know that - so thank you I’ll definitely take that on board - it’s so hard sometimes knowing the right way to do things because there are so many conflicting techniques around - but I will definitely give this a try so thanks again!

OP posts:
Inextremis · 28/12/2022 22:33

A world where we don’t hit our dogs and have an issue with those that do.

In what world does a tap equate to a hit? Please explain? You do understand what a tap is, don't you? Like if you were rambling on about something and irritating people, and I leaned over and tapped you on the wrist - would you fall to the floor screaming in agony?

BlueLabel · 28/12/2022 22:32

Inextremis that would be me. Honest to God, you obviously know you're wrong because otherwise why are you piddling on about rubbing your dogs nose instead of tapping as first discussed?

Educate yourself on why you shouldn't tap your dogs nose as a way of disciplining them and slink off. It has as much to do with the psychology of fog training as it does the pain and discomfort it causes them.

At least OP here has admitted it was done in a panic, which is something that can be fixed.

Eyesopenwideawake · 28/12/2022 22:31

Inextremis · 28/12/2022 22:27

To the idiot who told me that tapping my own nose was nothing like the trauma a dog would experience if I tapped theirs - I just scritched my 12 yr old collie on the nose - like a gentle tapping scratch - and she wanted more! Just went and did the same to our 10 yr old lab cross, and she loved it too. Dogs' noses are very sensitive to smells - 10000s of times more than ours are, but they are not such delicate flowers that actually touching the nasal area gives them pain. A gentle tap does not cause them to writhe in agony, FFS. Some people seem to live in another world!

Quite. If any of the people howling about a tap on the nose had ever watching a dog using their snout as a shovel to fill in a hole they'd know how ridiculous they are being.

Ginsloth · 28/12/2022 22:31

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 22:21

@Ginsloth he does also know the down command so sometimes I do have to say down then wait until he is sitting etc and then reward him with the attention etc

I did this, with our Labrador, it wasn’t until I saw a dog trainer that I realised the very obvious mistake.
He jumps, either gets ignored until he’s calm or you say down and he complies with that and gets rewarded. There is no link in his brain here between the first act of jumping and the second act of sitting down and getting rewarded. He jumps, you say down, he gets down and gets attention/reward. He’s being rewarded for the “down”, and rightly so. But nothing about that reward is linked in his mind to the initial jumping. So, to him, he can jump, be told to get down, get down, and all is fine. You have to reward a calm greeting.
The same applies to ignoring until he’s calm and then rewarding with attention/treat, although a slightly less problematic approach, it’s still confusing for him. Look up positive reinforcement. Start with people he’s more familiar with first as it’s easier. Reward for a greeting with all feet on the floor and move on. If he jumps, leave the room, wait a few minutes and return, if he jumps do the same again. When you return and he doesn’t jump, reward. Reward good behaviour and remove any confusion about what the reward is for.
I hope this helps.

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 22:31

@Greenfairydust just incase I didn’t make it clear - I don’t use it as a training technique - I did it out of panic to get a sharp object out of his mouth.

OP posts:
BluebirdRobin · 28/12/2022 22:29

Oh wow op you are a fabulous dog owner! This is exactly the way I would train my dog if I had one! I'm not a huge fan of dogs because people don't train them like you, they just let them annoy other people because "it's cute" or "just what dogs do." 🙄 A well trained dog is excellent!

AlwaysArty · 28/12/2022 22:29

Inextremis · 28/12/2022 22:27

To the idiot who told me that tapping my own nose was nothing like the trauma a dog would experience if I tapped theirs - I just scritched my 12 yr old collie on the nose - like a gentle tapping scratch - and she wanted more! Just went and did the same to our 10 yr old lab cross, and she loved it too. Dogs' noses are very sensitive to smells - 10000s of times more than ours are, but they are not such delicate flowers that actually touching the nasal area gives them pain. A gentle tap does not cause them to writhe in agony, FFS. Some people seem to live in another world!

A world where we don’t hit our dogs and have an issue with those that do.