Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think how I discipline my dog is no-one else’s business?

239 replies

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 21:17

I have a 3 year old dog, had him ever since he was a puppy. I am quite strict with him - he isn’t allowed to jump up at people, he isn’t allowed to approach other dogs without the owner’s permission, he is sent to his bed when the family eat so he doesn’t beg for food, he is told no when he touches something he shouldn’t like the children’s toys etc - and occasionally if I have had to tell him more than once about something (he has a habit of getting distracted when guests are over) then he goes to his bed for some time out etc.

Because of this, he is generally a really well behaved dog and I’ve never really had any issues with him apart from if he gets distracted and overwhelmed with loads of people or loads going on, he can struggle to concentrate on what is being said to him - but that is something that is a work in progress. In a normal environment he is very good at listening, etc.

The issues I have had however are with family members making comments every time I do put these boundaries into place - because basically they think he should be able to just do whatever he wants to do. Like an example from earlier today - his behaviour has been all over the place the last few days from being quite overwhelmed with Christmas and busy households - this is normal for him and will settle back down when everything else quietens down. He had something in his mouth that he shouldn’t have done and could have easily caused an issue to himself had he swallowed it - I told him to drop it a couple of times and he didn’t - so I VERY lightly tapped him on the nose and he dropped it straight away and went back to playing with his toys. I very rarely do that unless it’s something he needs to let go of right that second for his own sake and safety and he isn’t listening to verbal commands because of distractions etc rather than trying to drag it out of his mouth. But my family said I should have just left him and he might have dropped it eventually etc.

One family member has a similar dog and she lets him get away with murder and then constantly moans about it - he doesn’t let her sleep and rules the household basically - and yet she criticises me for actually having rules and boundaries with my dog.

Any advice for how I handle this situation?

OP posts:
Wdib78 · 30/12/2022 06:08

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 21:21

@TheLightSideOfTheMoon honestly it’s every time I speak to them, the first thing I hear is oh that dog has had me up all night, yet they never take any advice from anyone or try anything to correct the dog’s behaviour… drives me nuts!

Then just say "oh we never have that problem" 😊

If she asks why then tell her cos you actually discipline your dog.

WiddlinDiddlin · 30/12/2022 05:30

Adult dogs... vary in their skill at teaching young dogs because their interests are all about themselves, not the other dog.

Some are excellent and will respond appropriately by walking away or ignoring unwanted/unappreciated behaviour (which doesn't teach the puppy what they SHOULD do, just teaches them 'this won't work', insufficient on its own but helpful if a person is involved who can step in and redirect)..

These will often do a polite lip curl/freeze/stare/grr and if really pushed, a bit of a roar if the walking away/ignoring doesn't work. It's smart not to let it get to that point though.

Some are utterly rubbish and either play wildly and allow puppies to bite and rag on them to the point of blood shed and pain, and some are the other way, totally intolerant and aggressive. Neither is useful.

The key point to take away though is that other dogs don't care what a puppy does, as long as it's not bothering THEM.

So they don't care if the puppy doesn't recall, is scared of them, doesn't trust them, won't walk on a lead, doesn't take food nicely etc etc. All things one hopes humans do care about.

Interesting to note (well it is if you're a dog behaviour consultant or dog owner)..

Normal, healthy, happy bitches do not discipline puppies by scruffing, shaking, biting muzzles, in fact any of the things people routinely claim they do and thus humans should mimic.

Scruffing is done in tiny puppies to move them to safety - a bitch doing this in a home (vs a wild canid doing it) is very stressed and anxious!

Scruffing and shaking a puppy is a sign the bitch is extremely distressed and scared of her own puppies, she should not have been bred and she should be removed from the litter for their safety and her welfare!

Muzzle mouthing/biting isn't a thing in happy, normal bitches. Puppies trying to get Mom to open her mouth and regurge food IS, and as the puppies get older you may see her trying to walk away from that.

Puppies playing 'bitey face' with one another or other older dogs who are not Mom are simply playing, though its a rather wormy creepy sometimes pushy 'I can do this I am a baby you aren't allowed to complain' behaviour in some contexts (ie, pup is horribly rude and bounces all over then the adult dog stiffens up and lip curls and the puppy does this in response).

BlueLabel · 29/12/2022 17:22

Adult dogs don't teach puppies drop commands RedHelenB but in areas of etiquette rather than commands puppies learn by mimicking adult dogs (where to pee, things to eat).

In rough play, puppies learn to interpret body language and vocalisations but funnily enough that doesn't involve hitting each other on the nose. Healthy puppy play has bowing, rolling and switching roles. Older dogs normally will bring themselves to the puppies level, maybe lying down for example and most commonly either disengaging or showing a warning sign (teeth, a growl) if they need to correct.

They don't smack each other in the nose and where responsible owners are integrating new or young dogs it shouldn't become aggressive.

RedHelenB · 29/12/2022 17:07

BlueLabel · 28/12/2022 21:22

I was with you until you said you tapped him on his nose. That's honestly vile. You need to learn better ways of training a drop command that doesn't involve a physical punishment on one of his most sensitive areas.

How do adult dogs teach puppies?

Quveas · 29/12/2022 16:02

Nosleepforthismum · 29/12/2022 07:06

Crikey, I’m wondering if half these posters have ever had a dog the way they are talking! Dogs are all different with different personalities. In my own family, my MIL has a sensitive little westie who would probably cower at a raised voice and is impeccably behaved. You then have dogs like mine who are robust little arseholes who will constantly push boundaries so they can do exactly what they want. Mine is a food thief and I can’t even tell you how many times over the last 10 years I’ve had to rugby tackle her to the floor and prize her jaws open to remove whatever dodgy thing she was trying to eat. There is no amount of bribery that will make her drop a stolen “prize”. Even my mum’s dog once caught a squirrel, killed it and refused to drop it and carried it all the way home. My mum had to throw the lead over a tree branch in the garden to hoist her on to her back legs and essentially strangle her to force her to drop it. I’m pretty sure your spaniel is not scarred at all from a tap on the nose and in general he sounds beautifully well behaved for a three year old dog.

I see. So since children are all different, with different personalities, it would be fine to leather one or grab them by the throat if you deemed it appropriate? Or is that only reserved for pets?

If you want to see a dog that constantly pushes boundaries, then you haven't met one until you have a Border Collie in the house. They not only push the boundaries, but work out where the next one will be and push that one too! The way that you manage this is called "training" and does not involve rugby tackles, physical punishment, or hanging a dog from a tree by its throat.

You do not deserve to own dogs, and it's a shame that your mother wasn't seen and reported for animal cruelty. That is truly disgusting behaviour, and judging by the way you are talking, you should never be allowed near a dog.

Aprilx · 29/12/2022 15:40

Nosleepforthismum · 29/12/2022 07:06

Crikey, I’m wondering if half these posters have ever had a dog the way they are talking! Dogs are all different with different personalities. In my own family, my MIL has a sensitive little westie who would probably cower at a raised voice and is impeccably behaved. You then have dogs like mine who are robust little arseholes who will constantly push boundaries so they can do exactly what they want. Mine is a food thief and I can’t even tell you how many times over the last 10 years I’ve had to rugby tackle her to the floor and prize her jaws open to remove whatever dodgy thing she was trying to eat. There is no amount of bribery that will make her drop a stolen “prize”. Even my mum’s dog once caught a squirrel, killed it and refused to drop it and carried it all the way home. My mum had to throw the lead over a tree branch in the garden to hoist her on to her back legs and essentially strangle her to force her to drop it. I’m pretty sure your spaniel is not scarred at all from a tap on the nose and in general he sounds beautifully well behaved for a three year old dog.

You and your mother are absolute disgraces, although I am not surprised you seem to support the OP with her disgusting treatment of her dog (and I don’t only mean the hitting in the face or “tapping on the nose” as she likes to put it).

You need to train your dogs not rugby tackle, wrestle with or half strangle them. If I say “Drop” in a firm manner my dog will drop anything, because I have trained him to do so and we still practice it from time to time.

Bicurator · 29/12/2022 15:34

Carlycat · 29/12/2022 15:32

If you wouldn't hit your child on the nose don't do it to your dog 😡

And if you would, do?

Carlycat · 29/12/2022 15:32

If you wouldn't hit your child on the nose don't do it to your dog 😡

SirSniffsAlot · 29/12/2022 10:07

fwiw @freckles20 , that's a beautiful description of the way training methods influence behavour and the relationship between handler and dog.

freckles20 · 29/12/2022 10:05

I own two Labradors, both with the common traits of over exuberance and eating anything.

I am also a dog walker and take dogs of all shapes, sizes and personalities out every day either alone or in small groups of 4.

I have never ever tapped any dog on the nose, or used any kind of force to train them or get my own way.

I also don't raise my voice other than to be heard if things are loud. I do have different tones of voice- but shouty isn't one of them.

My dogs are impeccably behaved. My own dogs do all that the OP describes and more. My work dogs are all very well behaved. Some newer ones are still a work in progress but we are getting there.

There is just no need to train a dog using any kind of fear, force, or physical 'tap', slap or poke. I'm not saying those methods don't work because they do. But they are unnecessary, and create a different relationship with the dog to one created without these methods.

My dogs trust me. They do as I ask because they have an inbuilt desire to please, because they trust me and because they have come to understand what is expected of them- this last one is key as it's not always as easy as people expect for a dog to know what is desirable vs undesirable behaviour.

They are happy, healthy dogs and that is a joy to see. If anything upsets them or they are unsure about anything (a loud noise in the distance, or an unfamiliar sight) they come to me out of choice because that's where they feel safe.

Enidcat5 · 29/12/2022 08:13

Pack theory was debunked some years ago now. There are some excellent dog behaviour books available, written by actual experts. It would be so good to see more dog owners read them.

Nosleepforthismum · 29/12/2022 07:06

Crikey, I’m wondering if half these posters have ever had a dog the way they are talking! Dogs are all different with different personalities. In my own family, my MIL has a sensitive little westie who would probably cower at a raised voice and is impeccably behaved. You then have dogs like mine who are robust little arseholes who will constantly push boundaries so they can do exactly what they want. Mine is a food thief and I can’t even tell you how many times over the last 10 years I’ve had to rugby tackle her to the floor and prize her jaws open to remove whatever dodgy thing she was trying to eat. There is no amount of bribery that will make her drop a stolen “prize”. Even my mum’s dog once caught a squirrel, killed it and refused to drop it and carried it all the way home. My mum had to throw the lead over a tree branch in the garden to hoist her on to her back legs and essentially strangle her to force her to drop it. I’m pretty sure your spaniel is not scarred at all from a tap on the nose and in general he sounds beautifully well behaved for a three year old dog.

Highlighta · 29/12/2022 06:54

OP I think your biggest crime is posting in AIBU about disciplining a dog. It was never going to go well.

SirSniffsAlot · 29/12/2022 06:51

Dogs are not pack animals and, even if they were, packs do not have bottoms.

A pack is not a description of hierarchy. It's a description of the closeness and stability of the bonds between the Individuals. A pack is a close knit group of animals that very rarely changes.

Dogs left to organise themselves form loose and fluid social groups. The membership of them changes regularly. There is no top or bottom, there is just whoever wants a resource more at any moment in time.

If you see dog behaviour through the lens of them trying to form a linear hierarchical pack you are missing much about what makes dogs, dogs.

Elvira2000 · 29/12/2022 06:30

There are some proper self-righteous busybodies on here. And people who have never owned a dog and/or don't appreciate that dogs are different to each other and humans.

Dogs need to know their place in the pack. And it should be at the bottom. This actually gives them security. It is possible to give them boundaries and affection. They are not mutually exclusive.

SirSniffsAlot · 29/12/2022 06:01

Words like discipline and boundaries are almost always human interpretations of behaviour and are rarely correct imo.

Dogs don't like boundaries. They like predictable worlds in which they already know what will happen. We use the word boundary because it feeds into a human interpretation of the world in which we impart control. But that's not how the dog sees it, imo. Dogs like consistency and routine. So we might interpret never letting them in the sofa as a boundary but it's not that for them. They just don't like something bad happening when they do jump on the sofa one day when nothing happened when they did it the day before.

Discipline is almost always a euphemism for the application of some sort of punishment. Even the word punishment is a euphemism of sorts because it suggests some sort of balance of scale in which the dog did something to deserve it. What we are describing is the act of doing something unpleasant (physically or psychologically) as a way to dissuade a dog from doing whatever it is they are doing. Lots of studies available on the impact and effectiveness (or not) of using punishment as a training tool.

All animals adhere to the basic rules of learning:

  1. If I do something and then something I want happens, or something I don't want goes away, I am more likely to do that thing again. Positive and negative reinforcement
  2. If I do something and something I don't like happens, or something I do like goes away, I am less likely to do that thing again. Positive and negative punishment.
  3. If I do something and nothing at all happens, I am less likely to do that thing again.

A tap on the nose is not something the dog wants, so is a punishment. And you are adding or applying it so it is a positive punishment. (Positive meaning added, not meaning good).

Zanatdy · 29/12/2022 05:39

I much prefer positive reinforcement to be honest that ruling through fear. Each to their own, but don’t complain if someone comments when you hit your dog as I personally would have to say something too

WiddlinDiddlin · 29/12/2022 05:34

When your training methods potentially put other people in danger - and using aversive methods does indeed do that, then yep thats a problem and yes it should be brought up.

It doesn't matter how gentle or whatever the 'tap' is, what matters is how aversive the dog finds, and how they process that.

Telling your dog 'no' and tapping them in the face is not necessary, and it is risky.

Why would you want to justify and defend that when there are better, more effective and safer methods?

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 29/12/2022 05:08

upfucked · 28/12/2022 21:32

Just like parenting it’s no one else’s business up to the point where you are hitting your pet or child.

Well said.

Welfare is everybodies business.

Whatmarbles · 29/12/2022 04:54

I like a nicely trained dog but not to the extent that their spirit is broken. He sounds like he has quite a sad existence.

Is he ever allowed to have fun, or is that not allowed?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 29/12/2022 04:35

Ah… to be a dog owner it garners the same scrutiny as being a parent, don’t worry you will always be doing it wrong. I’ll put this here and in big bold letters for the reading challenge among us. I DO NOT CONDONE HITTING ANIMALS OR ABUSING THEM. Now that we’ve got that out of the way.

@1Childand1Dog87

No you don’t sound too strict. My dog was raised similar. Probably a little less strict than you, but she definitely had boundaries. And yes there we’re times in a large gathering she would be made to sit at my heel. And if she started to bark she would get a tap a.k.a me putting my finger on her noggin and tapping like one would do on a table to get her attention so she would hear the command. (Typically ‘No Bark’).

Side story: She had this weird thing and would start barking at someone if she didn’t expect them to be there… think she would be fine with Aunt Betty all night, but would bark when Aunt Betty came out of the kitchen… it was odd and we never did figure that little behavior quirk out.

She also was not allowed on the sofa until my husband or I sat down first. This started as she growled at me after I woke her up by sitting next to her one morning startling her from a deep sleep. Seemed like the a good idea to avoid that going forward by making her wait to get on the sofa. She suffered no I’ll affects by waiting for me to get settled before she jumped up. We also did resets where she was taken out of a room if she got overexcited and stopped listening.

She was a happy well adjusted doggo who was spoiled by our neighbors where she spent 1/2 of her time at their request. And was smart enough to know different houses, different rules (they didn’t have the same sofa rule for example).

I will admit our semi-feral cat did a lot of the training for us, including no inappropriate chewing of anything that wasn’t her toy or going into certain areas of the house. And I can guarantee that the cat did not stop to wonder if he was too strict.

2FelisCatus · 29/12/2022 00:34

Tapping his nose is fine. People are insane. If I touched as in literally tapped our dogs nose she would drop what she had and I certainly would do if she had a pin in her mouth! Honestly Mumsnet is hopeless if your post involves animals. I just use stick phases "yes we do have a different approach. I'm glad your way is working for you." And just repeat....they will get the hint eventually

k1233 · 28/12/2022 23:55

It's interesting, I'm all for trained dogs and use sending dog to bed as an effective way to deal with eg barking. You bark, you're called inside and directed to your bed. If you want to play outside you do it quietly. Very effective IME. I'm not understanding people saying dogs don't get cause and effect. Of course they do. Otherwise how would they link receipt of a treat to a random word?

I don't agree with ignoring undesired behaviour until the dog guesses the correct answer. As with children, tell the dog what you want them to do. If you want them sitting, then say sit and reward the response with a pat.
No is not a command. Instead tell the dog what you want and reward. Being consistent will have the dog offer the correct response without you needing to give any command.

A happy dog is a dog who has consistent boundaries which are kindly enforced. The dog can be as cheeky as it likes within boundaries (I love cheeky dogs). I use dog beds as a target. They have a bed in every room, so being directed to their bed doesn't mean they miss out, it just gives them their place in the room where they can chill out or snooze. They seek their beds out now they're older.

One of the posters said spaniels took ages to mature. I've got a westie and it took him until he was 7 yo to be reliably obedient. Right little rascal up to then if you called him for something he didn't want to do - he'd look at you and go the other way irrespective of treats etc. Interestingly he had a pretty solid Stop command. Cheeky boy. But I can handle him all over including removing things stuck between his teeth, checking his eyes, ears, mouth, feet without issue. That's all been trained with games. I was playing with my cockers mouth over Christmas and, lifting her front lip, I've spotted a decaying tooth. Because we play mouth games I've spotted it before it's hurting her and she's off to the vet to get it taken out.

magicthree · 28/12/2022 23:55

I must admit it’s exhausting trying to get him to behave all of the time but I just worry about having a problem dog later on that is out of control sort of thing!

I find this rather sad. Yes, dogs do need a certain amount of training, but they are supposed to be friends and companions, not robots. I often see people out walking their dogs, issuing comands, and it all seems rather joyless to me, and as though they are trying to get their dogs to behave as humans. Our dogs, except for one, were rescues and we never did much in the way of training, however they certainly weren't "out of control".

I can understand about the tap on the nose in this situation however

AlwaysArty · 28/12/2022 23:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread