Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think how I discipline my dog is no-one else’s business?

239 replies

1Childand1Dog87 · 28/12/2022 21:17

I have a 3 year old dog, had him ever since he was a puppy. I am quite strict with him - he isn’t allowed to jump up at people, he isn’t allowed to approach other dogs without the owner’s permission, he is sent to his bed when the family eat so he doesn’t beg for food, he is told no when he touches something he shouldn’t like the children’s toys etc - and occasionally if I have had to tell him more than once about something (he has a habit of getting distracted when guests are over) then he goes to his bed for some time out etc.

Because of this, he is generally a really well behaved dog and I’ve never really had any issues with him apart from if he gets distracted and overwhelmed with loads of people or loads going on, he can struggle to concentrate on what is being said to him - but that is something that is a work in progress. In a normal environment he is very good at listening, etc.

The issues I have had however are with family members making comments every time I do put these boundaries into place - because basically they think he should be able to just do whatever he wants to do. Like an example from earlier today - his behaviour has been all over the place the last few days from being quite overwhelmed with Christmas and busy households - this is normal for him and will settle back down when everything else quietens down. He had something in his mouth that he shouldn’t have done and could have easily caused an issue to himself had he swallowed it - I told him to drop it a couple of times and he didn’t - so I VERY lightly tapped him on the nose and he dropped it straight away and went back to playing with his toys. I very rarely do that unless it’s something he needs to let go of right that second for his own sake and safety and he isn’t listening to verbal commands because of distractions etc rather than trying to drag it out of his mouth. But my family said I should have just left him and he might have dropped it eventually etc.

One family member has a similar dog and she lets him get away with murder and then constantly moans about it - he doesn’t let her sleep and rules the household basically - and yet she criticises me for actually having rules and boundaries with my dog.

Any advice for how I handle this situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JMSA · 19/02/2023 15:31

My first thought was that life for your dog doesn't sound much fun. But my dog isn't fantastically well-behaved, so what the hell do I know?! Grin
Don't worry OP - I'm sure you're not the evil dog abuser you're being painted as.

Nanny0gg · 19/02/2023 14:39

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 28/12/2022 22:12

You sound abusive and cruel. Punishing another living being isnt right, ever.

What??

Beastieboys · 19/02/2023 14:18

Think you are doing fine.......it's a pity that people don't use your method with their kids !!!!

Thelnebriati · 30/12/2022 12:30

So much simpler to teach them 'fetch' and reward them for handing it over.

Wdib78 · 30/12/2022 12:20

hookiewookie29 · 30/12/2022 11:43

I'm sure a light tap on the nose would have caused him a lot less stress and harm than having a drawing pin removed surgically.....

Try telling that to the know it all do good perfect dog owners on here 😆

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 30/12/2022 12:17

hookiewookie29 · 30/12/2022 11:43

I'm sure a light tap on the nose would have caused him a lot less stress and harm than having a drawing pin removed surgically.....

Short-term, absolutely, but it should never get to the stage where you need to tap your dog on the nose to discipline them or get them to obey you.

Having to resort to that kind of behaviour tells me the dog isn't particularly well trained to begin with. Long-term, tapping your dog on the nose or face is a recipe for disaster.

BlueLabel · 30/12/2022 12:15

Or hookiewookie29 engage your brain and consider option 3: the dog is trained to drop on command.

hookiewookie29 · 30/12/2022 11:43

I'm sure a light tap on the nose would have caused him a lot less stress and harm than having a drawing pin removed surgically.....

SomePosters · 30/12/2022 11:26

Many dogs are not taught no is not the same as dogs cannot understand no.

the latter implies to people they shouldn’t bother to try and many don’t… hence so many horrendously behaved dogs ending up in shelters when they become unmanageable or all these people who walk their dog on two leads in the dead of night as they’re actually frightened of it.

you teach them no right early on and then later you can add joining words
that they know.

For example teaching them to jump on command is easy as they are inclined as pups to jump when excited.
So once they have the word no and the word jump you can combine and give ‘no jump’ once you have taught them to bark/howl on command you can use speak/no speak

You have to decide what prompt word you’re using and stick to it consistently as they are recognising a sound/combination of familiar sounds you make rather than truly understanding you speak.

That said mine is a very smart working breed and yesterday when she got given a treat she took it outside to bury it in the rain. I called her back in and she stood with it in her mouth looking at the door and then me for ages (which would usually be enough to get the door opened) until I said (in normal talking to people voice) I’m not letting you outside to bury that, why don’t you go hide it upstairs and with a last forlorn look between me and the door went of upstairs and came down a few mins later I think she understands more than I give her credit for after 11 years by my side

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 30/12/2022 11:19

The problem with using physical discipline is that you risk the dog becoming touch aversive and disliking human hands. They don't understand why they're being hit on the nose, so over time, their thought process changes.

Hands by my face sometimes mean I get hit on my nose.
I don't like getting hit on my nose.
I don't know whether the hand near my nose is friendly or not, but I don't want to get hit, so I'll make sure it can't touch me by biting it. That should work.
It does work! The hand goes away and I don't get hit on my nose.
Therefore the only way to stop me from getting hit on my nose is to bite hands that come near me.

SirSniffsAlot · 30/12/2022 10:54

Lots of the dogs I help with hate hands near their head, or move past growling to snapping and physical discipline is a factor in this.

The nose tapping is a nice example of how this comes about...

The human thinks: if I tap his nose, the dog will know I don't like him having that thing in his mouth.

The dog thinks: if I let that human put their hand near my face, they might tap me with it.

First step in training a dog is to think about how you make sure the dog is learning what you think they are learning.

BlueLabel · 30/12/2022 10:49

Aquasulis you've said it yourself, you don't tap them on the nose. If it came to forcing their mouth, it's because its an emergency and their training failed - forcing their mouth becomes the lesser of two evils by a significant margin. But it obviously isn't your go to and you train to avoid that

I think a lot of the posters in this thread have confused the message that tapping a dogs nose is wrong with dogs are fragile creatures that cannot stand physical play or touch. That's not the case - it's that their nose is an especially sensitive area and tapping (or let's just call the euphemism what it is, lightly hitting the dog) causes them discomfort, sometimes pain and increases the likelihood they'll come to fear hands near their face. Lots of the dogs I help with hate hands near their head, or move past growling to snapping and physical discipline is a factor in this.

It's in the "tell me you don't understand how to train a dog without telling me" list alongside:
*Belief in alpha dynamics
*Rubbing their noses in pee/excretement
*Whacking with a newspaper
*Using flexileads and a collar fastening
*Calling out "he's friendly" instead of recalling the dog
*Allowing the dog to jump over strangers and visitors

LlynTegid · 30/12/2022 10:43

OP nice to read about someone who believes in responsible dog ownership. If only all people were like you, perhaps fewer people would be injured by dogs and also less instances of cynophobia.

SirSniffsAlot · 30/12/2022 10:24

Very few people ever suggest sending a cat to it's bed as a way to dissuade them from doing something.

Funny that Grin

freckles20 · 30/12/2022 10:23

@Wdib78 my dogs are all impeccably behaved. I've already outlined why I think that is and I wouldn't call it discipline.

However, maybe we have different interpretations of the word "discipline".

I'd interpret it along these lines: .
"the practice of training people to obey rules or a code of behaviour, using punishment to correct disobedience."

Maybe yours is a gentler interpretation.

No matter, I see you won't ever be owning a dog so let's leave this now.

SirSniffsAlot · 30/12/2022 10:03

I disagree if he had something dangerous for himself in his mouth eg paracetamol
Voice first, second, third and then I would put my hand down towards the mouth and hold the collar gently and repeat but yes if they had something that could hurt them (and no I don’t leave paracetamol hanging around)

Yup, I get that. In an emergency you've got to do what you've got to do. But it is not training - it is a sign that your training has failed or was incomplete.

I had to stomp on the dog's lead the other day as they'd slipped the owner's hand and were running to the road. So that dog was stopped by a sudden jolt on the neck. The jolt was, by far, better that being hit by a car.

But it is also a sign that dog needs better training in less perilous circumstances.

My own dog would not have required that. He would have
a) never run off it I dropped the lead, not least because a dropped lead is something we previously trained for

b)would have recalled if he had run because recall in a variety of circumstances is someting we have trained for

c) would have also performed an emergency DOWN if asked, because being able to stop him right in his tracks without him trying to get back to me is something we have trained for

The pin was an emergency and required emergency intervention. Now the OP knows she needs to work on the drop behaviour in a variety of contexts with a variety of objects. That will mean that the tap is not required next time, all that is will be a gentle 'drop' and the emergency is averted. TBF to the OP, despite initially describing it as discipline she's since gone on to say it was not planned training, it was an act of panic.

Aquasulis · 30/12/2022 10:00

SirSniffsAlot · 30/12/2022 09:55

But I think in your exmaples @SomePosters you are using the word NO is very specific circumstances and, by the sound of it, your dog has slowly wittled out all the possible wrong options for that word and come to understand the intention you have behind it.

When people talking about dogs not understand the word NO it is because it comes loaded with a couple of potential pitfalls. Very few people bother to think about the specific circumstances they might use it is or the specific behaviours they want from the dog in those circumstances. They use it off the cuff as a 'don't do whatever you are doing' word and that tells the dog nothing.

The dog probably hears that word in such a wide variety of circumstances that they struggle to apply it to anything other than, perhaps, the sense that it precedes something bad (as in, humans can feel the dog ignores the word NO and so requires some greater punishment to stop them).

They also don't follow it with anything additonal information to tell the dog what they want instead. In reality, mostly people mean 'I don't mind what you do as long as you don't do that' but that's a hard meaning to convey to a dog.

It is also a very frustrating way to learn. There is a great (dog) training exercise in which something attempts to get you to do a motion by only using the word NO, leaving you to have to guess and get it wrong plenty of times before you get it right. It's is a really stressful way to learn and it takes a bit of willpower not to shout "what the hell do you want!!" after a few minutes of it.

You sound like you may have taught youe dog that word in a different way but the above is how the majority of dog woners attempt to use it and it is rarely helpful in that way.

This is true I say drop for anything in their mouth
No means they tend to look at me for a further instructions eg lie down, bring it, sit, wait, come, heel, leave, silent, bark, gentle etc

they have a very large vocabulary actually

Aquasulis · 30/12/2022 09:57

BlueLabel · 28/12/2022 21:22

I was with you until you said you tapped him on his nose. That's honestly vile. You need to learn better ways of training a drop command that doesn't involve a physical punishment on one of his most sensitive areas.

I disagree if he had something dangerous for himself in his mouth eg paracetamol
Voice first, second, third and then I would put my hand down towards the mouth and hold the collar gently and repeat but yes if they had something that could hurt them (and no I don’t leave paracetamol hanging around)
I don’t tap my dogs on the nose but they do it to each other 😂and compared to what I do eg tap on the bum to remind them to sit down and I mean a gentle tap is nothing compared to how they deal with each other.
Oldest keeps the others in line with full on pin them down when they were puppies. So the puppy would jump up at them and he would use his paws and physically push him down (if he didn’t want to play) now they are much older the eldest will usually give a warning growl if the youngest is too playful and he’s had enough but once of twice he has pinned him down and sat on him. The three of them are currently curled up with their paws around each other

SirSniffsAlot · 30/12/2022 09:55

But I think in your exmaples @SomePosters you are using the word NO is very specific circumstances and, by the sound of it, your dog has slowly wittled out all the possible wrong options for that word and come to understand the intention you have behind it.

When people talking about dogs not understand the word NO it is because it comes loaded with a couple of potential pitfalls. Very few people bother to think about the specific circumstances they might use it is or the specific behaviours they want from the dog in those circumstances. They use it off the cuff as a 'don't do whatever you are doing' word and that tells the dog nothing.

The dog probably hears that word in such a wide variety of circumstances that they struggle to apply it to anything other than, perhaps, the sense that it precedes something bad (as in, humans can feel the dog ignores the word NO and so requires some greater punishment to stop them).

They also don't follow it with anything additonal information to tell the dog what they want instead. In reality, mostly people mean 'I don't mind what you do as long as you don't do that' but that's a hard meaning to convey to a dog.

It is also a very frustrating way to learn. There is a great (dog) training exercise in which something attempts to get you to do a motion by only using the word NO, leaving you to have to guess and get it wrong plenty of times before you get it right. It's is a really stressful way to learn and it takes a bit of willpower not to shout "what the hell do you want!!" after a few minutes of it.

You sound like you may have taught youe dog that word in a different way but the above is how the majority of dog woners attempt to use it and it is rarely helpful in that way.

Wdib78 · 30/12/2022 09:45

freckles20 · 30/12/2022 09:31

@Wdib78 my most recent post was in response to your comment "If she asks why then tell her cos you actually discipline your dog."- your suggested reason that a poster should use to explain her well behaved dog.

Apologises if I misunderstood. To me your comment sounded like you advocated the type of discipline that the OP and others on this thread are into.

I'm an owner of, and enjoy the company of, both cats and dogs. From your tone I think it is a blessing to the dog species that you dislike them and won't be owning one during your lifetime.

I would never hit a dog! I'm referring to sending it to bed if it has done something wrong! I'm assuming you let your dog run amok then

freckles20 · 30/12/2022 09:31

@Wdib78 my most recent post was in response to your comment "If she asks why then tell her cos you actually discipline your dog."- your suggested reason that a poster should use to explain her well behaved dog.

Apologises if I misunderstood. To me your comment sounded like you advocated the type of discipline that the OP and others on this thread are into.

I'm an owner of, and enjoy the company of, both cats and dogs. From your tone I think it is a blessing to the dog species that you dislike them and won't be owning one during your lifetime.

SomePosters · 30/12/2022 09:14

Just here to laugh at people talking so knowledgeable about things they clearly have no real experience of.

Dogs don’t understand no 😂😂😂😂😂

Well sure if you don’t teach them.

Everyone always comments on what an astoundingly well behaved dog I have.
They ask how I do it but when I tell them that she’s only allowed in my bed/the couch if invited, is never allowed to jump up at people and that I don’t remove the source of every temptation but have helped her learn self restraint they don’t really want to hear that they would have put in consistent and regular effort in to changing their own behaviour so now I say she’s naturally inclined and I’m very lucky.

Truth is I had a clear idea of what I needed and expected and enough experience with dogs to know how to communicate that.
I have used the same words consistently all her life so now I can tell her wether she is staying (being left for a while) waiting (being left for a very short time) or coming and she will respond appropriately

the idea that she doesn’t understand no in different contexts is laughable. I’m sure many dogs don’t especially some of the dimmer breeds but when we come across your lead dog who is not allowed to come and say hi all I have to say is a firm no and she will come sit by me and wait while the others pass. She knows plenty of words because they have been used clearly and consistently.

Not as many as that mad collie they taught over 200 toy names

Wdib78 · 30/12/2022 08:42

freckles20 · 30/12/2022 08:16

@Wdib78 you are completely missing the point that those of us who abhor your types of discipline do not need convincing that it can work.

We accept that it can work. It can teach a dog not to do something because the consequence of doing 'the thing' is pain, or discomfort or anger from its owner.

But that doesn't make it right, or optimal in terms of training methods.

There are other, more effective, less unkind methods. These train without fear or discomfort.

They can take longer, require repetition and the results are often gradual. However, the results are also longer lasting, achieved without fear, generally increase a dogs confidence, and do not damage the bond between dog and owner.

The proof in the pudding is that the majority of trainers who used to use your type of methods have changed their practises and evolved into force free kind methods. Many of them were absolutely convinced that the old school methods were best, but as they began to see and understand the different results that each method had, the tide gradually turned and then gathered pace and they changed their mind and their methods.

If these people can and have changed surely it is something worth seriously considering? We now see three types of people who haven't changed their methods:

  1. Those whose main requirement is swift results. Often seen in 'trainers' who charge a lot of money and promise results in one or two sessions. Their results tend to be short lasting, damaging, and way less effective than others.
  1. People who unable or unwilling to think critically about both methods for whatever reason. Often these people are out of touch with the wider world of dog training and don't have an interest in change or progression.
  1. People who unfortunately get some sort of feel good experience out of shaping a dog using fear or force. These are dangerous, nasty people who get a kick out of this.

The problem sometimes seems to be that most people who still use these methods are so busy convincing the rest of us that they don't fall into category 3 (which of course most of them don't) that they can't process the fact that things have changed, better methods exist and it is such a shame that they won't consider them.

Change to force free methods has happened in every section of dog training including the army, police, guide dogs, search dogs and assistance dogs. Surely this tells you something- most of these people and organisations used to train in the old way but have changed and won't go back......

Interestingly, the main dog training area where there has hasn't been full acceptance of force free methods is the gun dog training community. However, even here it is gathering pace and the tide is gradually turning.

I wonder if the analogy of teaching a child not to steal food by hurting them or frightening them as opposed to a more humane method means anything to people like you?

Both methods would have results, and the former might teach the child the lesson more quickly- probably on its first application. Yet we don't teach children or shape their behaviour in that way. Ask yourself why?

What is the difference between children taught via fear and pain, and those taught in a kind way?

The difference isn't seen in terms of behaviour- both children most likely be well behaved (although the one taught using fear or pain probably became well behaved more quickly than the one taught in a different way).

Ontop of all of this we should bear in mind that usually the most undesirable behaviour in dogs is aggression. In the vast vast majority of cases aggression is rooted in fear. Fearful dogs are at risk of becoming aggressive. This can have catastrophic results.

As such it follows that training methods which cause fear or pain are much more likely to result in a fearful dog which will always have a greater risk of becoming aggressive.

YOU'RE missing the fact I'm not OP, SHE tapped the dog LIGHTLY on the nose, the rest of the discipline is sending it to its bed, are you off you're fucking rocker lecturing me about dogs, I hate them, would never have one, had a,cat for 19 years, never again, too much heartache when he died, you need to quote the OP, not me.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 30/12/2022 08:19

Excellent post by @freckles20 👏

freckles20 · 30/12/2022 08:16

@Wdib78 you are completely missing the point that those of us who abhor your types of discipline do not need convincing that it can work.

We accept that it can work. It can teach a dog not to do something because the consequence of doing 'the thing' is pain, or discomfort or anger from its owner.

But that doesn't make it right, or optimal in terms of training methods.

There are other, more effective, less unkind methods. These train without fear or discomfort.

They can take longer, require repetition and the results are often gradual. However, the results are also longer lasting, achieved without fear, generally increase a dogs confidence, and do not damage the bond between dog and owner.

The proof in the pudding is that the majority of trainers who used to use your type of methods have changed their practises and evolved into force free kind methods. Many of them were absolutely convinced that the old school methods were best, but as they began to see and understand the different results that each method had, the tide gradually turned and then gathered pace and they changed their mind and their methods.

If these people can and have changed surely it is something worth seriously considering? We now see three types of people who haven't changed their methods:

  1. Those whose main requirement is swift results. Often seen in 'trainers' who charge a lot of money and promise results in one or two sessions. Their results tend to be short lasting, damaging, and way less effective than others.
  1. People who unable or unwilling to think critically about both methods for whatever reason. Often these people are out of touch with the wider world of dog training and don't have an interest in change or progression.
  1. People who unfortunately get some sort of feel good experience out of shaping a dog using fear or force. These are dangerous, nasty people who get a kick out of this.

The problem sometimes seems to be that most people who still use these methods are so busy convincing the rest of us that they don't fall into category 3 (which of course most of them don't) that they can't process the fact that things have changed, better methods exist and it is such a shame that they won't consider them.

Change to force free methods has happened in every section of dog training including the army, police, guide dogs, search dogs and assistance dogs. Surely this tells you something- most of these people and organisations used to train in the old way but have changed and won't go back......

Interestingly, the main dog training area where there has hasn't been full acceptance of force free methods is the gun dog training community. However, even here it is gathering pace and the tide is gradually turning.

I wonder if the analogy of teaching a child not to steal food by hurting them or frightening them as opposed to a more humane method means anything to people like you?

Both methods would have results, and the former might teach the child the lesson more quickly- probably on its first application. Yet we don't teach children or shape their behaviour in that way. Ask yourself why?

What is the difference between children taught via fear and pain, and those taught in a kind way?

The difference isn't seen in terms of behaviour- both children most likely be well behaved (although the one taught using fear or pain probably became well behaved more quickly than the one taught in a different way).

Ontop of all of this we should bear in mind that usually the most undesirable behaviour in dogs is aggression. In the vast vast majority of cases aggression is rooted in fear. Fearful dogs are at risk of becoming aggressive. This can have catastrophic results.

As such it follows that training methods which cause fear or pain are much more likely to result in a fearful dog which will always have a greater risk of becoming aggressive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread