Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The state of the NHS laid bare in one video... Pinderfields General Hospital, Wakefield, West Yorkshire

205 replies

PeppaPigOinkOinkOink · 28/12/2022 20:55

m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=pfbid02EXdzzP9pPRadKzq2xN4pGBTakAs5DAGf6i38XDW32zdvREyAYmYURFM6k9FBPx2Fl&id=535801985

Video posted outside Pinderfields General Hospital a couple of hours ago. No capacity in resus areas, no trollies to offload patients from ambulances. Which in turn means people in the community waiting hours and hours for emergency 999 calls.

People say health care professionals went into the job knowing what they was getting into.. not one nurse I know (or Dr or paramedic or HCA) went into their job knowing this would be their reality. This is why people are leaving, why people are striking. Its not just about pay, its about working conditions. Pay does play a part admittedly, the pay doesn't marry up with the level of responsibility, the level of stress, the level of upset caused by knowing you're going home after knowing not one patient has had your absolute best all day.. because its impossible to achieve.

This is the reality of the NHS 💔

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 29/12/2022 00:09

Ch3wylemon · 28/12/2022 22:02

And the burden on the NHS is the elderly. Not immigrants FFS.

They can be both though ? I did a home visit to an elderly man last week who came over from India to live with his son about 3 years ago. In that time he has been treated in hospital numerous times for stroke, heart attacks etc and is now bedbound and reliant on carers 4 times a day. Family live in tiny hose and are very poor so I can only think that the care is being paid for ? To be clear he has never ever worked in the UK. Now I completely understand that a compassionate society cannot just leave him without care but in my home town, over 50% of the population are of asian heritage and this happens over and over.

izimbra · 29/12/2022 00:09

sst1234 · 28/12/2022 21:21

When extremists like you OP, jump on the word ‘privatization’ this is what policy makers do - coerce us into reform. Next you’ll be telling us NHS is going to be like the healthcare in the US. There is no in-between for the hystericals and no way of accepting that this system is not fit for the 21st century with the population and demographics. If it was such a great system, successful European countries would be copying us.

Ever considered that the system doesn’t need more money, it needs ripping up and starting again.

In 2010 70% of us were satisfied with NHS care. There was a 48 hour target for GP appointments and waiting lists were at a historical low.

The figures for today are that only 36% (and falling) are satisfied with the NHS, there's a 336 hour target for a GP appointment, and waiting lists are at a historic high.

This has happened in 12 years.

It's not 'the system' that's the problem - if it was the NHS wouldn't have been performing so well 12 years that it was deemed in independent research to be one of the most effective, accessible and best value for money healthcare systems in the world.

The problem isn't the method of funding. It's not just hospitals. The problem is that the meltdown in A&E and primary care is how 12 years of austerity has manifested. Conservatives have trashed public services, destroyed the morale of public sector workers and damaged public health to the extent that hour healthcare system is now in collapse. Ditto social care. Ditto social services. Ditto children's service. Ditto prisons. Ditto the probation service. Ditto addiction services. Ditto youth services. And where does all the crap end up? In A&E, on the shoulders of the police, and in primary care.

The devastating thing is that that they've damaged the social fabric of this country to the point that I can't imagine anyone every being able to put it right. It's tragic.

Rilkescat · 29/12/2022 00:02

Livelovebehappy · 28/12/2022 22:56

The public need to be educated as to when it’s appropriate to use A&E. A lot of people use it like a drop in medical centre when they should be using their GP. Contributing to this is the fact that GPS are still refusing to see patients face to face, and as a result aren’t utilising proper surgeries, not manning phones adequately, etc. The NHS is badly managed, with top heavy management rather than front line nurses. Once upon a time things used to be lead by Matrons, but now we have office managers far removed from the hub of the wards,who don’t have a clue what’s happening most of the time.

Absolute bollocks regarding top heavy management. Most managers otherwise known as senior nurses are clinically based be it in the community or in hospitals.
Absolutely agree with the comments re inappropriate use of A/E and hoards of family members gawping at unfolding events, hangers on eager to watch some 'reality TV' type entertainment at first hand. events
The NHS has slowly been stealthily and not so stealthily privatised for years. Hinchingbrooke hospital anyone ? Now that was a success.
What is ironic is the fact the elderly who voted in their droves for the Conservatives and Brexit are the ones to be hardest hit by the chaos in the NHS and social care system.

MerryChristmasTree · 28/12/2022 23:55

We can’t retain the staff we have, let alone train and recruit more.

Rainsdropskeepfalling · 28/12/2022 23:52

We don't train enough doctors to cover our current needs. And if doctors in training are already thinking of leaving (as in the papers), well that means we need to train even more. We are reliant on doctors trained overseas. And I can't see that changing.

Summerfun54321 · 28/12/2022 23:42

We need a new government to fix this mess, the tories just don't give enough shit about average people.

Nat6999 · 28/12/2022 23:33

NameChagaiiiin ask to be referred choose & book to your nearest private hospital, I don't blame you for not wanting to go back.

iswintercoming · 28/12/2022 23:25

We need proper funding at an education and training level to encourage more people to train as nurses / medical professionals.

We need more hospitals and clinics to actually be built, in order to serve the growing population.

We don’t need the Tory’s.

Ch3wylemon · 28/12/2022 23:20

Ch3wylemon
And the burden on the NHS is the elderly. Not immigrants FFS.

Have you been to A&E recently?

GrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

JoyBeorge · 28/12/2022 23:16

It almost feels like they are running the system we do have down so much that private health care will seem like the better option.

sst1234 · 28/12/2022 23:12

Delectable · 28/12/2022 23:10

Govt has got people focused on immigrants. They're stealing jobs. Landlords make rents too expensive for NHS staff. The fact is the RF and more particularly Charles and William own the largest amount of land in this country. They not only don't need it as all their expenses are fully paid for for life; they don't pay any taxes. Yet the government not only keeps going after the commoner trying to make a living, they pitch us against eachother, distract us and program us using the media, asking for higher taxes. Tenants are fighting landlords, socialists want everyone on the same pay etc. We're all paying them and now they say Charles is refusing a slimmed down coronation. Ofcourse he is and makes sure his brother Andrew is well taken care of with tax payers money. This is a man who can't put toothpaste on his toothbrush nor move paper away from his desk. He has servants who dress him, drive him, cook, clean etc. Yet he needs more to be spent on him but we can't afford to pay nurses or heat our homes!

I think you’re on the wrong thread. This one is about the NHS. Not republicanism.

Delectable · 28/12/2022 23:10

Govt has got people focused on immigrants. They're stealing jobs. Landlords make rents too expensive for NHS staff. The fact is the RF and more particularly Charles and William own the largest amount of land in this country. They not only don't need it as all their expenses are fully paid for for life; they don't pay any taxes. Yet the government not only keeps going after the commoner trying to make a living, they pitch us against eachother, distract us and program us using the media, asking for higher taxes. Tenants are fighting landlords, socialists want everyone on the same pay etc. We're all paying them and now they say Charles is refusing a slimmed down coronation. Ofcourse he is and makes sure his brother Andrew is well taken care of with tax payers money. This is a man who can't put toothpaste on his toothbrush nor move paper away from his desk. He has servants who dress him, drive him, cook, clean etc. Yet he needs more to be spent on him but we can't afford to pay nurses or heat our homes!

InfluenzalA · 28/12/2022 23:07

SecretDoor · 28/12/2022 23:01

My message was agreeing with @Ch3wylemon

We rely on fantastic immigrant nursing staff and clinical fellow junior doctors who all work so hard.
Migrants are not the issue in ED in my experience.

I've just been in hospital and nearly every single member of nursing staff was fairly newly arrived in the UK. It was lovely hearing their stories of home and how Christmas may be celebrated there or what their nursing background there was...but it struck me that there was no way that ward would be open or running without these international staff. I'm not sure I actually met a nurse who wasn't openly talking about "home" being somewhere other than the UK. So I wouldn't be knocking immigration here ..

festiveoverwhelm · 28/12/2022 23:07

sst1234 · 28/12/2022 21:21

When extremists like you OP, jump on the word ‘privatization’ this is what policy makers do - coerce us into reform. Next you’ll be telling us NHS is going to be like the healthcare in the US. There is no in-between for the hystericals and no way of accepting that this system is not fit for the 21st century with the population and demographics. If it was such a great system, successful European countries would be copying us.

Ever considered that the system doesn’t need more money, it needs ripping up and starting again.

100% agree. Such a relief hearing some people talk sense. I sometimes worry we’ve been brainwashed in this country, the NHS is like a cult in the way people talk about it now.

Bestcatmum · 28/12/2022 23:05

Poppiesway1 · 28/12/2022 22:57

Same.. Ive been on 6 day weeks for months. I’m shattered. I refused to work extra hours over Christmas. I had 4 very much needed days off to sleep. I started in the nhs over 25years ago.. I knew what I was going into then.. and what I went into is not what I am dealing with now.
We’re all going over and above what we should be doing and still get grief and abuse from patients and their families.
I have a family member who recently waited 17 hours for an ambulance.. unable to attend the local hospital as they were full and closed to ambulances, they taken to a hospital 60 miles away.
I have paramedic friends who have spent all shift in the ambulance bay just waiting to hand over a patient to A&E.. and they are as distraught as we, the staff working inside the hospital are. But the hospitals are now too small for the population they serve, understaffed, and inadequate.

also..

what really doesn’t help staff morale is the people / patients in A&E clapping every time a patient is called from the waiting room in to see staff. Staff have resigned from A&E due to this and treatment they’re receiving from patients. we now have security guards in A&E to stop the abuse on staff.

I've worked in the NHS for 41 years and have NEVER seen it so bad.
Commiserations.

SecretDoor · 28/12/2022 23:01

My message was agreeing with @Ch3wylemon

We rely on fantastic immigrant nursing staff and clinical fellow junior doctors who all work so hard.
Migrants are not the issue in ED in my experience.

deflatedbirthday · 28/12/2022 23:01

I work here. It's heartbreaking. I feel for all staff at the moment. It is just horrendous

sst1234 · 28/12/2022 23:01

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 28/12/2022 22:53

But we need people. Thinking about this in a very numbers way, the young men coming into the country is exactly he kind of low skilled labour we need.

so the ‘young men’ who speak very limited English and are semi literate ( being charitable here) in their own language and script are the solution for a shortage of nurses, radiographers, etc….. okay 😹

I’m going to hazard a guess that your answer to every problem is that we need to curb immigration. Basically an extreme view, at the other end of the spectrum from the extremists whose solution to a broken system is to pump more money into it and scream ‘privatization’ like they’re onto some big conspiracy.

Illegal Immigrants need to work or be sent back. Not put up in hotels at a cost of £7million a day. We need both unskilled immigrants and skilled ones, since the indigenous population sees full time work as an inconvenience, partly due to the welfare dependency culture created and perpetuated by successive governments in the last 25 years.

But hey, why bother with a bit critical thinking, when you can regurgitate lazy soundbites.

dontjudgeafish · 28/12/2022 22:59

sst1234 · 28/12/2022 21:21

When extremists like you OP, jump on the word ‘privatization’ this is what policy makers do - coerce us into reform. Next you’ll be telling us NHS is going to be like the healthcare in the US. There is no in-between for the hystericals and no way of accepting that this system is not fit for the 21st century with the population and demographics. If it was such a great system, successful European countries would be copying us.

Ever considered that the system doesn’t need more money, it needs ripping up and starting again.

Yep

Poppiesway1 · 28/12/2022 22:57

Bestcatmum · 28/12/2022 22:09

I've been working 6 days a week for months to get the waiting lists down for new patients to be seen. I'm in my 60's and don't know how much longer I can do it.
people with really serious problems are having appointments taken from them i.e being seen every 3 weeks instead of every week.
I often see people in my lunch break because I am scared they will die if they are not seen.
Yes the tories are shit but also people need to start taking responsibility for their own health, the majority of my lot are sick because they smoke, drink too much and are obese and have medical problems directly to do with their lifestyle. We simply cannot afford not to care for ourselves any more because there are no resources left for those that do not.
We are fire fighting every single day.

Same.. Ive been on 6 day weeks for months. I’m shattered. I refused to work extra hours over Christmas. I had 4 very much needed days off to sleep. I started in the nhs over 25years ago.. I knew what I was going into then.. and what I went into is not what I am dealing with now.
We’re all going over and above what we should be doing and still get grief and abuse from patients and their families.
I have a family member who recently waited 17 hours for an ambulance.. unable to attend the local hospital as they were full and closed to ambulances, they taken to a hospital 60 miles away.
I have paramedic friends who have spent all shift in the ambulance bay just waiting to hand over a patient to A&E.. and they are as distraught as we, the staff working inside the hospital are. But the hospitals are now too small for the population they serve, understaffed, and inadequate.

also..

what really doesn’t help staff morale is the people / patients in A&E clapping every time a patient is called from the waiting room in to see staff. Staff have resigned from A&E due to this and treatment they’re receiving from patients. we now have security guards in A&E to stop the abuse on staff.

SecretDoor · 28/12/2022 22:57

Totally agree - I also work in ED and by far it is the over 75”s that are being brought in by ambulances and admitted. They stay on trolleys for hours getting poor care as it is so busy. One RN and he HCA for 26 patients in the overflow area today. The elderly are all living longer but many are in poor health with multi-morbidities and take massive amounts of prescription drugs.

MerryChristmasTree · 28/12/2022 22:57

We’ve had children queuing for beds because there aren’t any. We’re completely swamped with patients and haven’t got enough staff to look after them. It’s unmanageable. Colleagues that have worked for years and are so dedicated have had enough. It’s relentless.

Its not just about the money.

Livelovebehappy · 28/12/2022 22:56

The public need to be educated as to when it’s appropriate to use A&E. A lot of people use it like a drop in medical centre when they should be using their GP. Contributing to this is the fact that GPS are still refusing to see patients face to face, and as a result aren’t utilising proper surgeries, not manning phones adequately, etc. The NHS is badly managed, with top heavy management rather than front line nurses. Once upon a time things used to be lead by Matrons, but now we have office managers far removed from the hub of the wards,who don’t have a clue what’s happening most of the time.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 28/12/2022 22:53

But we need people. Thinking about this in a very numbers way, the young men coming into the country is exactly he kind of low skilled labour we need.

so the ‘young men’ who speak very limited English and are semi literate ( being charitable here) in their own language and script are the solution for a shortage of nurses, radiographers, etc….. okay 😹

Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 28/12/2022 22:50

Today was the first day I saw ambulance trollies physically queuing out of the front door at the hospital where I work, and privacy screens put up around the queue to stop the general public gawking. Thank god the planned strike had been called off.

Every day is awful in the hospital lately. People think the ambulance service is under capacity, when the reality is they can't unload and get back on the road until the hospital can magic up some beds.