Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The state of the NHS laid bare in one video... Pinderfields General Hospital, Wakefield, West Yorkshire

205 replies

PeppaPigOinkOinkOink · 28/12/2022 20:55

m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=pfbid02EXdzzP9pPRadKzq2xN4pGBTakAs5DAGf6i38XDW32zdvREyAYmYURFM6k9FBPx2Fl&id=535801985

Video posted outside Pinderfields General Hospital a couple of hours ago. No capacity in resus areas, no trollies to offload patients from ambulances. Which in turn means people in the community waiting hours and hours for emergency 999 calls.

People say health care professionals went into the job knowing what they was getting into.. not one nurse I know (or Dr or paramedic or HCA) went into their job knowing this would be their reality. This is why people are leaving, why people are striking. Its not just about pay, its about working conditions. Pay does play a part admittedly, the pay doesn't marry up with the level of responsibility, the level of stress, the level of upset caused by knowing you're going home after knowing not one patient has had your absolute best all day.. because its impossible to achieve.

This is the reality of the NHS 💔

OP posts:
vera99 · 01/01/2023 12:07

Hospitals are also beginning to run out of portable oxygen.
At Nottingham University Hospitals Trust junior doctors were told there was a risk it could run out of cylinders this weekend because of a surge in demand. The chief nurse, Michelle Rhodes, told staff to avoid using oxygen cylinders wherever possible.
At Hull University Teaching Hospital Trust on Friday night, the trust warned staff that “due to supply issues, the trust is experiencing short-term disruption to its supply of large oxygen cylinders.” Staff were told patients who needed oxygen should be moved to beds where oxygen could be piped.
There were also reported problems with supply at hospitals in Liverpool, Crewe, Derby and Durham.
One NHS worker in the southwest of England said: “We are now at the stage where there is not enough oxygen in cylinders to treat patients in corridors, ambulances and in our walk-in area in A&E. Combined with flu, Covid and other respiratory conditions this is beyond Third World medicine.”

vera99 · 01/01/2023 12:05

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/a-amp-e-crisis-portable-oxygen-running-out-as-patient-waits-99-hours-for-bed-52ks096bs

Hospitals are running out of portable oxygen because they are overwhelmed with patients suffering from flu, Covid and other respiratory illnesses.
The Sunday Times has been told of chaos across the country, including in:
• Surrey, where GPs were told in an email from Surrey Heartlands Integrated Care Board that hospital mortuaries in the area were nearing capacity.

• Bedfordshire, Luton and Milton Keynes Health and Care Partnership, where staff were told that hospitals were so busy “there is a real possibility we will need to erect tents in hospital grounds”. It appealed for staff willing to take on extra work to come forward.

• York, where a patient waited 40 hours in A&E for a bed on a ward.

• Shropshire, where a patient waited more than 30 hours in an ambulance outside the Princess Royal Hospital in Shrewsbury.

• Walsall, West Midlands, where hospital leaders told staff of “unprecedented” pressure and a “grossly overcrowded” A&E. At times there were more than 40 patients waiting for a bed with some waiting longer than 24 hours and being looked after in corridors.
The longest wait reported for a bed was at Great Western Hospital, Swindon, where a patient spent 99 hours waiting for a bed last week. The patient came in as an emergency case by ambulance but was left on a trolley for more than four days until a bed became available.
One clinician there said: “We’re broken and nobody is listening.” Jon Westbrook, Great Western’s chief medical officer, told staff in a leaked message: “We are seeing case numbers and [sickness] that we have not seen previously in our clinical careers.”

izimbra · 31/12/2022 21:19

"People really do need to start looking after themselves. Having the attitude of "oh it's just a bit of blood pressure I'll take a tablet" should no longer be tolerated. "

What do you suggest? That people should be prosecuted for not taking their medication?

"Maybe we need to start thinking radically and encouraging community exercise sessions like walking groups, go knock on for a neighbour at 1030 and drag them out for a daily walk. Or tai chi on the green at 2."

People already do this, but the reality is that most people who are capable of working are out there earning for as many hours as they can. We're going to see much less volunteering over the next decade as more and more older people (who are the largest group of volunteers) are forced to delay retirement. And the idea of a pool of well qualified volunteers willing to take over responsibility for the health of people in their area, when the worst ill-health is found in the poorest communities, the ones already facing the selling off of local parks, huge price rises in leisure centres, and the closure of community centres - BECAUSE COUNCILS HAVEN'T GOT ANY BLOODY MONEY!

"We also need to start recognising we can't save everyone". Echoes of Rishi Sunak there 😞

DarkKarmaIlama · 31/12/2022 20:31

*honestly

DarkKarmaIlama · 31/12/2022 20:31

@MalteserGeezee

You could say the same about education which is another political football that has been absolutely obliterated during this Tory reign. It’s honesty just shocking how people voted for this.

MalteserGeezee · 31/12/2022 20:28

The time has come for an apolitical national debate about the future of healthcare in this country. A cross-party group should run the delivery of an evolved/reimagined NHS so it's not a political football, nor an untouchable totem.

The current situation terrifies me. Surely we should be cared for better than this?

DarkKarmaIlama · 31/12/2022 20:17

@izimbra

I don’t need to explain thanks. I never voted Tory. Have they destroyed it? Of course they have so there’s no point harping back to 2010.

I don’t claim to know the absolute logistical nightmare of privatisation, does anyone?? The whole thing is a colossal, complex beast and no one on Mumsnet has those answers. But the way it is currently is not fit for purpose. Something RADICAL needs to happen. Even charging for a GP appointment would be a good start to hopefully weed out some of the GP hobbyists who spend their lives there for incredibly minor ailments. A more European system would clearly be better than an American one.

Hopefully a new party could potentially change recruitment. Was a fucking disaster the moment they removed the nursing bursary. My mother and sister are both nurses and were able to train under labour. I believe a similar bursary system is possible but obviously not under these numpties.

izimbra · 31/12/2022 19:50

"Give over. The NHS has had its day. Sooner it’s privatised the better.|". Do you want to explain how it's been trashed in 12 years? Because it was performing well by international standards in 2010 - so clearly 'the system' hasn't 'had its day', or at least hadn't until the Conservatives got hold of it.

Also - do you want to explain how this 'privatisation' will happen? You're thinking that the private sector will lease out hospitals from the state, get rid of national pay scales, trash all the terms and conditions of NHS staff.

So we'll have the same buildings. The same staff - including the same shortage of staff. And somehow this will somehow make revolutionise the provision of healthcare in the UK?

Because the biggest problem we have is a shortage of clinical staff.

How do you suggest privatisation will address this, without increasing costs?

MissyB1 · 31/12/2022 12:14

LakieLady · 31/12/2022 09:22

Can’t say I noticed any improvement under Blair.

They threw money into reducing waiting lists, and allowed the NHS to use private hospitals for additional capacity.

I had an ENT operation in 2000, and the surgeon joked that Blair was keeping them very busy.

We significantly reduced our waiting lists in the cancer diagnostic unit I worked in, Labour put a lot of money into early diagnosis, and we launched the national bowel cancer screening program. We had suspected cancers seen within 1-2 weeks and routine appointments within 6 weeks. It was really motivating and gave a lot of job satisfaction.

Yeah needless to say the waiting lists are shockingly long now, and cancer targets are being routinely missed.

Notanotherone123 · 31/12/2022 09:28

What the NHS needs is to wipe the slate clean with staff, systems and resources. There are, contrary to popular belief, many many people in jobs who shouldn't be there, are doing the bare minimum and covering their arses in the process.

We can't complain about lazy clinical staff because they're akin to demi-gods at the moment but there are more of these sat in high paying posts than people will admit to. Why? Because it's so hard to recruit so they take anyone who will take the post, no matter how good (or bad) they are at the job.

People really do need to start looking after themselves. Having the attitude of "oh it's just a bit of blood pressure I'll take a tablet" should no longer be tolerated. Maybe we need to start thinking radically and encouraging community exercise sessions like walking groups, go knock on for a neighbour at 1030 and drag them out for a daily walk. Or tai chi on the green at 2.

We also need to start recognising we can't save everyone. It's gut wrenching to lose loved ones at any age but we are prolonging life with really poor outcomes for what reason? Because we don't want to grieve? How selfish is that? It's not fair on our loved one and it's not fair on society either. We need to have difficult conversations about whether it's appropriate to do something just because we can or whether we actually should.

LakieLady · 31/12/2022 09:22

Can’t say I noticed any improvement under Blair.

They threw money into reducing waiting lists, and allowed the NHS to use private hospitals for additional capacity.

I had an ENT operation in 2000, and the surgeon joked that Blair was keeping them very busy.

LakieLady · 31/12/2022 09:10

In 2010 70% of us were satisfied with NHS care. There was a 48 hour target for GP appointments and waiting lists were at a historical low.

This.

I saw my GP with longstanding shoulder pain in Autumn 2010. Had an x-ray, and was referred to a consultant in November.

At the consultant appt 2 months later, he sent me for a scan which was done there and then, he looked at it, and decided I needed surgery. Had the op in early April, so all sorted in barely 6 months.

It was a completely different story 8 years later, when my knee pain became intolerable. The pathway for orthopaedics here now involves referral to a physio service, who royally piss you about refer patients on if they need surgery. It was a 6 month wait for a physio appt, then 4 months to see a senior physio as only they can refer on to a surgeon. Then Covid happened and held things up by about a year. I saw the surgeon in December 2020, and waited another 10 months for the operation. It took 3.5 years.

And I think I was lucky it wasn't longer. The surgeon was doing 2 NHS operations on the day he did private surgery, so mine was done at a private hospital.

Angeldelight81 · 31/12/2022 08:50

Saying that the Australian economy is a High wage one, so there’s just less poor people anyway.

Angeldelight81 · 31/12/2022 08:49

nosyupnorth · 30/12/2022 22:53

Love all rich the people in this thread like 'yay we should move to a subsidised private model' as a solution for capacity issues like people are too thick to know that translates to 'the poor can't afford the partial fees for that system so they'll die leaving more capacity for us'.

That quite simply doesn’t happen in Australia. If anything the poor people get far better care because the Rich ones don’t go for the partially funded Medicare option. If you’ve got private health care you use it and therefore make room for those that gone contribute anything at all. I will agree that the American model appears to be shit though.

vera99 · 31/12/2022 06:23

Poor old Clav c&p's some irrelevant nonsense and every body ignores the post. That's how it ends Clav that's how it ends.....

handbagsandholidays · 31/12/2022 01:35

Experienced this hospital multiple times over the last year due to a high risk pregnancy and NiCU stay for my son,... the care and conditions are terrible! It's a new hospital- they have fancy things like being offered snacks 3 times a day as an inpatient and being offered your bedsheets changing twice a day but often miss out basic health/welfare checks and medical care.

sst1234 · 31/12/2022 01:29

nosyupnorth · 30/12/2022 22:53

Love all rich the people in this thread like 'yay we should move to a subsidised private model' as a solution for capacity issues like people are too thick to know that translates to 'the poor can't afford the partial fees for that system so they'll die leaving more capacity for us'.

Do the Europeans and Australians? kill their poor this way? Ok, then.

sst1234 · 31/12/2022 01:28

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/12/2022 22:05

By that logic we should be copying these successful countries you speak of. Why aren't we? Oh yes because their health services (although generally better than the NHS) are hugely more expensive both in tax and in individual contributions, and that's not a vote winner in the UK.

The bottom line is that there is no magic cheap but excellent system. All good systems need proper funding, which we don't have in the NHS. The details of exactly how the system is run probably don't make that.much difference. The amount of money is the thing that matters.

The details of exactly how the system is run probably don’t make a difference?

Still trying to figure out if that was a typo?

Notaflippinclue · 30/12/2022 23:24

Nosyupnorth - no it's about those that can pay through their insurance do so, those that can't are subsidised by tax payers.

Capri3 · 30/12/2022 23:17

TrimTheTree · 30/12/2022 20:07

Our trust has just put out a message saying there isn’t enough room in the waiting room and only someone can accompany if needed for care so they can monitor patients and you might be seen in another area of the hospital not designed for that purpose. That they are as high admission for covid and flu and a lot of staff off sick as well because of this.

but people will complain doctors and nurses on much needed days off should give up their one day off a week and volunteer to work for free.

Nurses work three 12 hour shifts per week, so have four days off, not one.

nosyupnorth · 30/12/2022 22:53

Love all rich the people in this thread like 'yay we should move to a subsidised private model' as a solution for capacity issues like people are too thick to know that translates to 'the poor can't afford the partial fees for that system so they'll die leaving more capacity for us'.

DarkKarmaIlama · 30/12/2022 22:41

@fiftiesmum

It was me. I’ve spent many a year working for the NHS so I am now back on planet Earth. Thankfully. 🌎

fiftiesmum · 30/12/2022 22:40

I wonder if the private healthcare systems have problems in being able to discharge medically fit (but physically/mentally frail) people from their wards. It would make such a difference in hospitals if there was a reasonable and doable care package in place within 24 hours of decision to discharge a patient. It leads to prolonged lengths of stay - a hospital bed isn't a good place to be when you are basically well and there is someone in desperate need for that bed.
As for a PP asking what planet I am on - I am never quite certain after a long NHS shift and a bus journey home

RemindMeAgain · 30/12/2022 22:26

Some of these accounts from people working on the front line are eye opening, it sounds absolutely harrowing. I’m so sorry you’re all having to deal with this when I’m 100% sure that you all only went into doing what you do to help people. What you’re dealing with every day is literally life and death and I can’t imagine how stressful that must be in the current conditions, no wonder so many people are leaving. I don’t know what the solution is but I just hope it gets sorted soon ❤️

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/12/2022 22:05

dontjudgeafish · 28/12/2022 22:59

Yep

By that logic we should be copying these successful countries you speak of. Why aren't we? Oh yes because their health services (although generally better than the NHS) are hugely more expensive both in tax and in individual contributions, and that's not a vote winner in the UK.

The bottom line is that there is no magic cheap but excellent system. All good systems need proper funding, which we don't have in the NHS. The details of exactly how the system is run probably don't make that.much difference. The amount of money is the thing that matters.

Swipe left for the next trending thread