Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so disappointed in my son

360 replies

abrandnewhumbug · 28/12/2022 19:56

I’m a single mum to one son. He’s 10.

I didn’t get a single Christmas gift. I don't have a partner and my family only do gifts for the kids, so there's no one to buy me one.

My family gifted my son cash (that was what he wanted) and my brother commented to not forget to buy his mum something with it (he ended up with nearly £500 as we’re a big family and people were really generous). He told my brother he would definitely buy me something.

He hasn’t. He’s spent the lot on rubbish. He’s just had a trip to Lapland too (my gift to him).

He’s a really good boy but I’m so disappointed in him. Lots of my friends are single parents with even younger kids and all those kids found a way buy their mums a little gift.

Now, I don’t need anything and money definitely isn’t an issue but I’m so disheartened that he’d be so ungenerous. It feels very greedy and entitled especially after such a lavish Christmas (his dad isn’t on the scene at all - I do all of it). Even a £1 box of chocolates would’ve proved he had a good heart. He’s had tons and tons of opportunity to buy something since he got the money (he got it before Christmas as we were in Lapland after that).

I’m not sure how to broach this with him, if at all. This feels like a good learning moment but it also feels really wrong to tell my child off for not buying me a gift.

OP posts:
Notanotherone6 · 28/12/2022 22:06

Your 10 year old has spent £500, in cash, on rubbish, between Christmas and now?

Sure he has.

spirit20 · 28/12/2022 22:05

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 28/12/2022 21:57

You should DEFINITELY tell him that he's disappointed you. He's been selfish and entitled and needs to be pulled up on it. I taught my DS to buy Christmas gifts from age 5 when we used to go a charity/junk shop and he'd choose 50p things for everyone, to when I made him 'earn' the money to buy gifts with chores to now when he's 14 and he spends his own saved money. And he gets them for the whole extended family who he sees - this year it was 11!
how is he going to learn to be unselfish and think of others if you don't use these moments to teach him?!

What on earth is wrong with you to describe a 10 year old with words like that. You said it yourself, you taught your DS that it was customary to buy presents, so he knew it was expected. If no-one has told the OPs DS, then he's not going to know. Children aren't mind-readers, but they are a product of they way they're brought up.

SuckItNietzsche · 28/12/2022 22:05

It's completely irrelevant if every other post on this thread is "Well, MY ten-year-old has been buying thoughtful presents without being asked since they were two!!!" Because newsflash, all 10yos are different Xmas Hmm Doesn't make group A amazing, selfless angels and group B selfish, ill-brought-up little shits. My DD likes thinking of and giving presents. My DS would give you absolutely anything in his power to give, but you'd have to ask .

It is unfair to hold secret expectations and consider a child to have failed when they didn't even know they were being tested. K.I.S.S - "keep it simple, stupid". Take kid to suitable shop. Provide money. Say "I'd like you to buy me a little Christmas present. I would love a nice warm scarf or a box of chocolates." Wait outside shop till kid emerges. Job done.

OooScotland · 28/12/2022 22:05

YANBU for wanting a present at Christmas (though loads of adults just buy themselves something nice) but your brother should have taken him to buy you a present and show him how to wrap it, not just tell him to buy you something, at 10 years of age how would he have done that?

You should have a word with your brother and tell him that next year his nephew will only be 11 and you’d like him to take him Christmas shopping.

And when ds gets cash gifts again, outdated as it may sound, put it in a savings account and show him how a savings book works. Do not give him a cash card. There was a thread recently where an OP’s ds had a cash card and there was all sorts of emotional fallout from him having spent all his £100 savings on snacks for his friends.

This won’t get better if you don’t start teaching him basic life skills. 10 is plenty old enough.

topcat2014 · 28/12/2022 22:05

Christ I'm not even sure I bought presents for my parents at 17.. never mind 10.

All sounds a bit high maintenance to me.

ACynicalDad · 28/12/2022 22:04

YABVU

Hesma · 28/12/2022 22:04

OP you are being ridiculous… he is 10!
I am a single mum with 2 DDs aged 10 and 12. They bought me a couple of small presents because I took them into town, found someone working in M&S to help them and gave them my debit card with a limit to spend. I certainly wouldn’t expect them to spend their gift money on me. Sounds like you need to grow up!

Sunnytwobridges · 28/12/2022 22:03

Butchyrestingface · 28/12/2022 20:01

I was buying gifts for my parents at Christmas unprompted, using my own pocket money, at the age of 10. Didn't think this was unusual but the consensus here seems to be it is. Confused

Same. I actually looked forward to it as I loved buying gifts as much as receiving them, even at that age.

spirit20 · 28/12/2022 22:03

He's 10 years old. Unless someone has specifically said to him that it's normal to buy presents for the adults in his life, then he won't know he's expected to do so.

Next time it's your birthday, have a word with another adult relative in advance and ask them to arrange with him so that he buys you something small.

But don't be upset with him for not realising he should buy you a present, how on earth was he supposed to know that.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 28/12/2022 22:00

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 28/12/2022 21:57

You should DEFINITELY tell him that he's disappointed you. He's been selfish and entitled and needs to be pulled up on it. I taught my DS to buy Christmas gifts from age 5 when we used to go a charity/junk shop and he'd choose 50p things for everyone, to when I made him 'earn' the money to buy gifts with chores to now when he's 14 and he spends his own saved money. And he gets them for the whole extended family who he sees - this year it was 11!
how is he going to learn to be unselfish and think of others if you don't use these moments to teach him?!

Exactly. You TAUGHT your DS, so he has that knowledge,experience and habit.

Bluerisotto · 28/12/2022 22:00

I had similar with my son....I didn't want to make him feel bad or use guilt as a tool to make him buy me presents. He is now in his 20's and still doesn't bother.

I think you do need to tackle this but it is for other family members to take him aside / take him shopping and teach him how to choose presents for someone and think about what they would like. So I'd speak to another family member and ask them to help him in this regard.

Miss03852 · 28/12/2022 22:00

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 28/12/2022 21:57

You should DEFINITELY tell him that he's disappointed you. He's been selfish and entitled and needs to be pulled up on it. I taught my DS to buy Christmas gifts from age 5 when we used to go a charity/junk shop and he'd choose 50p things for everyone, to when I made him 'earn' the money to buy gifts with chores to now when he's 14 and he spends his own saved money. And he gets them for the whole extended family who he sees - this year it was 11!
how is he going to learn to be unselfish and think of others if you don't use these moments to teach him?!

What a vile comment about a ten year old. God help your kids. OP should maybe make some friends, be nicer to her family or get a partner instead of completely relying on her child to give her her only present. My parents didn’t rely on me as a ten year old to give them their sole present then have a strop if I didn’t do it right. Just let him be a kid.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 28/12/2022 21:57

You should DEFINITELY tell him that he's disappointed you. He's been selfish and entitled and needs to be pulled up on it. I taught my DS to buy Christmas gifts from age 5 when we used to go a charity/junk shop and he'd choose 50p things for everyone, to when I made him 'earn' the money to buy gifts with chores to now when he's 14 and he spends his own saved money. And he gets them for the whole extended family who he sees - this year it was 11!
how is he going to learn to be unselfish and think of others if you don't use these moments to teach him?!

Miss03852 · 28/12/2022 21:57

Psychonabike · 28/12/2022 20:34

You may feel people have been unkind. The thing is though, this:

"Even a £1 box of chocolates would’ve proved he had a good heart"

...really is very unpleasant, in the context of a child of just 10.

Yes exactly. OP doesn’t have a good heart she seems like a weirdo using her son to make up for her other lack of relationships.

Spellcheck · 28/12/2022 21:55

I don’t think you can expect a 10 year old to get you anything. I don’t think he should, either.
My concern is that he’s spent it all on rubbish. Has he saved any of it? Have you had a conversation with him about how to look after money? That’s a lot of money for a 10 year old!

TimeToFlyNow · 28/12/2022 21:55

Weller123 · 28/12/2022 21:52

If infantilising a 10 year old is not expecting them to go shopping alone to buy adults presents with their own Christmas money, then I’m quite comfortable to be infantilising children. Primary school aged children should not be going shopping alone, presumably with pocketfuls of cash, to make the adults in their life feel better about themselves.

What? Not even to the corner shop . Anyway op has already said he's been to the shops with her plenty of times since before Christmas

Miss03852 · 28/12/2022 21:54

I can’t remember buying my mum presents as a 10 year old? Is that normal?

Why did none of your huge family who gave your son £500 get you anything? This story makes no sense. You’re trying to parentify your child as you have no one else in your life you are close to and imo it’s creepy.

Bestcatmum · 28/12/2022 21:53

Goodness, I thought he was 18 plus.

Get christmas completely over and then have a word with him about how its nice to get your mum a present at christmas and that you were hurt you didn't get anything.

He shouldn't have been allowed to spend £500 on rubbish at that age anyway. Most of it should have gone into savings with a small amount given to him to spend.

He needs to learn the value of money from an early age and that money isn't just there to be wasted.

Weller123 · 28/12/2022 21:52

saraclara · 28/12/2022 21:37

What 10 year old boys are taking their own Christmas money, popping themselves to the shops and selecting gifts for others?! Then there’s the extra skills that would go into wrapping these gifts, hiding them and presenting them at the correct time. Those that think this is a reasonable expectation, or that the child is spoilt for not doing so, have probably not spend much time around 10 year old children.

This is exactly what I mean by underestimating and infantilising double digit kids. And yes, I've had my own ten year olds and I've taught bucketloads of them. They are way more capable than many here seem to think. The low expectations around here are actually quite worrying.

If infantilising a 10 year old is not expecting them to go shopping alone to buy adults presents with their own Christmas money, then I’m quite comfortable to be infantilising children. Primary school aged children should not be going shopping alone, presumably with pocketfuls of cash, to make the adults in their life feel better about themselves.

toocold54 · 28/12/2022 21:51

I think you need to be questioning how a 10 year old has spent £500 in a matter of days.

There is no way he should have had free rein with that sort of money.

You need to be careful you’re not treating him like a replacement for your adult boyfriend and make sure you’re treating him like the child he is.

TimeToFlyNow · 28/12/2022 21:49

Iwantamarshmallowman · 28/12/2022 21:48

I remember my mother going apeshit at me for not buying her a birthday present when I was around the same age. I had no money or opportunity to get her anything. I now know she's a nassasist but it took me years to get over the guilt.

Well that's really sad but hardly the same. Op hasn't gone apeshit and he has his own money

Iwantamarshmallowman · 28/12/2022 21:48

I remember my mother going apeshit at me for not buying her a birthday present when I was around the same age. I had no money or opportunity to get her anything. I now know she's a nassasist but it took me years to get over the guilt.

PrincessScarlett · 28/12/2022 21:45

You shouldn't be disappointed in your son. You should be disappointed in yourself for allowing him to spend £500 on rubbish. How is this teaching him how to be responsible with money? No wonder he didn't buy you anything as it sounds like he's had no financial guidance. I'm just so shocked you've allowed him to waste such a huge amount of money, particularly when many people are in such financial hardship at the moment.

Theneverendingdrama · 28/12/2022 21:45

TheOrigRights · 28/12/2022 21:39

How is your 9 yo able to buy things online?

I already explained how in the post you quoted. I didnt say he 'buys things online'. I said he picks something online, gives me the cash, then I pay for it with my bank card.

toocold54 · 28/12/2022 21:45

YABVU

I’m in the exact same situation as you and I’d never want my DD to worry about getting me something.

I am an adult.
If I want something I will buy it.
It’s not for a child to buy it for me.

You chose to take your child to Lapland.
Please don’t try and make him pay you back like he owes you for doing something nice for him.

You should be teaching your child that material things don’t equal love or appreciation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread