Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Think Joey Maynard (Of Chalet School Fame) Was Insufferable

986 replies

TheShellBeach · 28/12/2022 17:11

.............with her eleven children, infuriating husband and bizarre tendency to move house (and country) to live next door to the school her sister inexplicably started when Joey was a child.

She also managed to write (at least) two books a year, have a series of multiple pregnancies and poke her nose into the Chalet School's business on a daily basis.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
funnelfan · 29/12/2022 13:22

I’m currently watching an old film on Talking Pictures called White Cradle Inn. It’s from 1947 and filmed in the Swiss Alps. I’m paying very little attention to the plot (something to do with a runaway French evacuee boy) but am enjoying the scenery and the depictions of domestic life given that it must reflect the intentions of EBD in at least the early Swiss era books

SingedToast · 29/12/2022 12:57

CitronVert22 · 29/12/2022 11:05

Jo fainting at the Oberammergau Passion Play amazed me. I couldn't imagine a girl my age being overcome by religious fervour.

Religious fervour in that time, fainting at the Beatles in the 60s, obsessing over whoever is current now. We just express the same thing slightly differently, mediated through the norms of the society we live in.

I don’t think it has anything to do with early 20thc religious fervour, more EBD’s idea that the ideal schoolgirl heroine was highly imaginative, delicate and emotional (while also being jolly, good fun and mischievous). She’s clearly setting up Joey as a future literary genius, so it always interests me that she downgrades this into Joey being a much more ordinary, very popular school story writer. Presumably she thought that being the foremost novelist of her age was incompatible with 11 children and being an eternal Chalet School girl.

Bloatstoat · 29/12/2022 11:56

I love the books and enjoy a reread of my favourites for comfort whenever I'm having difficult times. I may well be critical in discussions of the books and see their absurdities, and I'm not (and never really was) a big fan of Joey, but it comes from a place of real affection, EBD may not be the world's greatest writer but these books have been a great source of enjoyment for me for many years.

CitronVert22 · 29/12/2022 11:05

Jo fainting at the Oberammergau Passion Play amazed me. I couldn't imagine a girl my age being overcome by religious fervour.

Religious fervour in that time, fainting at the Beatles in the 60s, obsessing over whoever is current now. We just express the same thing slightly differently, mediated through the norms of the society we live in.

MargaretThursday · 29/12/2022 10:55

Also on appendicitis, now it's normally keyhole surgery, which it wouldn't be then.

Ds had it during covid when they couldn't do keyhole surgery and I was told to keep him very quiet (they said it would have been no school if he'd had any) for a fortnight, and treat him as vulnerable for 6 months.

It had been a particularly difficult op-his appendix was in the wrong place and twisted too, but a bracing holiday by the sea would have been good for him.

I've a friend whose appendix burst inside him and he missed a year of school in the 80s too.
So EBD wasn't necessary being ott.

icanwearwhatiwant · 29/12/2022 10:13

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 29/12/2022 09:16

Or maybe there was a proportion of the other pupils who loathed Joey, or were wary of her because of her grudges and short temper and connections with the management, but EBD didn’t give those views airtime…

I imagine anyone who disliked Joey would feel they’d better keep quiet.

Exactly, doesn't this quite often happen with "popular" people though? They get away with murder because nobody wants to be the one to overtly disagree with them?
Was Jo a classic "mean girl"

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 29/12/2022 09:16

Or maybe there was a proportion of the other pupils who loathed Joey, or were wary of her because of her grudges and short temper and connections with the management, but EBD didn’t give those views airtime…

I imagine anyone who disliked Joey would feel they’d better keep quiet.

StitchesInTime · 29/12/2022 08:29

MissyB1 · 29/12/2022 07:20

I agree with @MissTrip82 Jo could be quite unpleasant as a child at school. She would hold grudges against people, and particularly anyone that refused to worship Robin. And the way she behaved towards Eustacia (a recently bereaved younger child) was really nasty.
And yet everyone thought she was wonderful?!

Maybe Joey was blessed with a good portion of charisma?
A magnetic personality powerful enough to draw her peers in and causing them to either overlook or minimise Joey’s flaws?

Or maybe there was a proportion of the other pupils who loathed Joey, or were wary of her because of her grudges and short temper and connections with the management, but EBD didn’t give those views airtime…

MissyB1 · 29/12/2022 07:20

I agree with @MissTrip82 Jo could be quite unpleasant as a child at school. She would hold grudges against people, and particularly anyone that refused to worship Robin. And the way she behaved towards Eustacia (a recently bereaved younger child) was really nasty.
And yet everyone thought she was wonderful?!

marcopront · 29/12/2022 06:59

I'm reading the Chalet School and Jo, thanks to the Dropbox link.

I am amazed at the plans they had for Biddy O'Ryan. Train her up to be a ladies maid. Then they send her off to a local school - why not just join the Chalet School. The costs of having join class would be minimal compared with keep and clothing.

110APiccadilly · 29/12/2022 06:49

Were there still strong anti-Catholic prejudices in England in the mid 20th century? I know it was a problem for some centuries after the Reformation, but I’m not sure when it died down.

To respond to this, from the last thread, there was very strong anti-Catholic prejudice in my mum's background (she was born in the mid fifties). But my grandparents were fairly unusual people in a number of ways, so maybe that was just one of them. My mum certainly wouldn't have been allowed to go to a Catholic assembly, and my gran briefly helped in some way or other with a Billy Graham crusade (in a very low key way, think making the tea!) but dropped it like a hot potato when she realised Catholics were allowed to be involved.

friskybivalves · 29/12/2022 06:40

SingedToast · 29/12/2022 00:18

We like the series because it’s often so demented, and because she’s so invested in every nutty detail from the (frankly unworkable) trilingualism, the ‘dainty’ cubicles, ritual curtsying, obsession with Old Girl fertility, cream cakes and ‘delicacy’ (no character EBD considered interesting was ever a robust, bouncing healthy type — she even gave previously ‘sturdy’ Mary-Lou a makeover via sledging accident that nearly killed her AND made her tall, slim and curly-haired).

I think Cornelia (?) was quite a healthy sort wasn't she? Haven't read these for years but I loved them so much.

SockQueen · 29/12/2022 02:39

TinselAngel · 28/12/2022 23:26

I would really have enjoyed several months off
I have a very well thought out fantasy about being sent to an Alpine sanatorium for absolute rest.

One of my best friends was in ICU in Switzerland with Covid in 2021. Thankfully she made a good recovery, and she was actually sent to a sanatorium in the Alps for rehab afterwards! She was also a CS fan and we joked later on that she was just fulfilling a childhood ambition.

Regarding Miss Ferrars' appendix, while I don't dispute EBD's utter lack of medical knowledge, it's worth remembering anaesthesia was much harsher back then, and it was a considerably bigger op than nowadays. Plus no/minimal antibiotics if there was superimposed infection, which could otherwise take months to cure (if it didn't kill you). Miss F's is in the latter books, so you'd hope they'd at least have some penicillin, but for Julie Lucy earlier on, it's quite realistic that she might die and would be out of action for a long time.

MissTrip82 · 29/12/2022 00:51

I find the books so soothing. I re-read them when I’m sick or sad. Like others, I did embrace some values from them also. Sometimes there’d be a sad/angry new girl and one of the main characters would spend time thinking about how to help them - not just doing the right thing in reaction to someone/something, but actively setting out to show kindness to someone off their own bat.

Joey as a child was quite unpleasant. Always getting weirdly jealous/possessive of the robin then being very dismissive towards Simone for the same thing. Bad tempered. But that all made her seem more real than the ‘spirit of the school’ adult who must surely have annoyed many many people.

Tilllly · 29/12/2022 00:38

BlushAngryAngry

TKRedLemonade · 29/12/2022 00:23

Tilllly · 29/12/2022 00:11

He threw them out?!! Why...???

They were in my parents house and he “decluttered” without checking with me or mam 😕 also a mini suitcase full of old buntys

SingedToast · 29/12/2022 00:18

TinselAngel · 28/12/2022 18:58

Does anybody on these threads actually enjoy EBD's work? They always seem so critical.

We like the series because it’s often so demented, and because she’s so invested in every nutty detail from the (frankly unworkable) trilingualism, the ‘dainty’ cubicles, ritual curtsying, obsession with Old Girl fertility, cream cakes and ‘delicacy’ (no character EBD considered interesting was ever a robust, bouncing healthy type — she even gave previously ‘sturdy’ Mary-Lou a makeover via sledging accident that nearly killed her AND made her tall, slim and curly-haired).

Tilllly · 29/12/2022 00:11

TKRedLemonade · 29/12/2022 00:05

Is it too late to get the Dropbox link? My dad threw all my chalet school out and it’s just what I need now when work is a nightmare.

He threw them out?!! Why...???

TKRedLemonade · 29/12/2022 00:05

Is it too late to get the Dropbox link? My dad threw all my chalet school out and it’s just what I need now when work is a nightmare.

RobinHumphries · 28/12/2022 23:50

TheShellBeach · 28/12/2022 23:10

Thank you! He is actually DD's cat. DH and I have two cats ourselves but none that eat Doritos

I was musing about Miss Ferrars and her appendicitis. She has her operation and then spends forever in the San, then comes back to school for a day, then her auntie comes and takes her back to England to recover for an extended period of time.

FFS. When I had my appendix out I was back at work five days later, looking after an Old Lady with dementia. I would really have enjoyed several months off (paid, presumably).

I’ve just read ‘shocks’ and it’s 6 weeks quarantine for scarlet fever. Which then made me think what did quarantine actually mean back then….I wonder how many weeks they’d have given Covid if it had been around?
Matey also goes around sedating pretty much everyone in shocks and gives miss annersley a hot toddy doctored with 4 aspirin to ward off a potential cold as well

TinselAngel · 28/12/2022 23:27

Whose hair turned white in an instant?
Miss Wilson. Not in an instant, in the time it took to go through a secret passage (a few hours?)

TinselAngel · 28/12/2022 23:26

I would really have enjoyed several months off
I have a very well thought out fantasy about being sent to an Alpine sanatorium for absolute rest.

friskybivalves · 28/12/2022 23:20

Whose hair turned white in an instant?

And wasn't the Robin always vying with Jo to be more delicate? I felt it was a contest who could go down first with raging pleurisy simply for having heilige wasser instead of heisse wasser ( or whatever)

I did enjoy Princess at the chalet school. Am sure elisaveta of belsornia inspired all those shonky minor royal plotlines in eg Dynasty.

TheShellBeach · 28/12/2022 23:10

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 28/12/2022 23:01

Ah-ha - another blanket-camouflaging cat. My two are great at that! Sebastian is beautiful.

Thank you! He is actually DD's cat. DH and I have two cats ourselves but none that eat Doritos

I was musing about Miss Ferrars and her appendicitis. She has her operation and then spends forever in the San, then comes back to school for a day, then her auntie comes and takes her back to England to recover for an extended period of time.

FFS. When I had my appendix out I was back at work five days later, looking after an Old Lady with dementia. I would really have enjoyed several months off (paid, presumably).

OP posts:
PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 28/12/2022 23:01

TheShellBeach · 28/12/2022 22:19

........................................and here is Sebastian, showing his appreciation afterwards:

Ah-ha - another blanket-camouflaging cat. My two are great at that! Sebastian is beautiful.