Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Think Joey Maynard (Of Chalet School Fame) Was Insufferable

986 replies

TheShellBeach · 28/12/2022 17:11

.............with her eleven children, infuriating husband and bizarre tendency to move house (and country) to live next door to the school her sister inexplicably started when Joey was a child.

She also managed to write (at least) two books a year, have a series of multiple pregnancies and poke her nose into the Chalet School's business on a daily basis.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
FelicityBeedle · 24/01/2023 00:56

It’s amazing how quickly everything gets attributed to Joey, Simone thinks of corn flour in the hair, Freida fetches it and five pages later it’s all ‘Ph isn’t Jo the edge for inventiveness!”

ZeldaFighter · 22/01/2023 21:44

I LOVED the Chalet School books! I also have a love of languages, desperately want to be trilingual and want to be a writer. I don't care how bad or unrealistic they were - they were an ocean of girls and women in an unrelenting sea of male characters.

It's lovely to know the books still have fans :-)

Forthelast · 22/01/2023 19:25

LiteralSycamore · 22/01/2023 10:50

At least (!) now there’s a more general recognition that it’s an appallingly tasteless thing to say to someone struggling or bereaved — but even taking into account the different mores of the time period, my sense is that EBD was probably a tactless, if well-meaning person, and that characters she clearly intends to be ideal and wonderful, are frequently intrusive, interfering and tactless in their dealings with other people.

It often also sounds to me as if she desperately wanted someone to come in and take all her responsibility off her shoulders in her own life, there’s so much stress across the whole series on collapsing, being sedated and put to bed and ‘looked after’.

I heard it a lot following a bereavement a few years ago - people are surprisingly conventional in the face of loss imo. Her characters tend not to people please and to be forthright. Very unlike Anne Shirley or similar who are always winsome. I agree it seems unlikely EBD had a winsome bone in her body but as she's enthusiastic and kind spirited in her writing, it doesn't seem to matter much.

Interesting you think there's an emphasis on being cared for - I find EBD is most at home with characters like Mary Lou who don't need much maintenance. The bed after an adventure seems like a useful way to wind up an adventurous episode that would otherwise be rather alarming to dwell on.

hels71 · 22/01/2023 18:56

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 22/01/2023 14:33

A six-year-old. I remember that but don’t know which book.

I think she is called Linda, and it's in Tom Tackles...

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 22/01/2023 14:33

A six-year-old. I remember that but don’t know which book.

TheShellBeach · 22/01/2023 14:30

Can anyone remember which book has Joey doing her usual "tell me about all the news girls" stunt at the beginning of term, and Miss Annersley mentions a Junior (whose name I cannot recall) whose parents both recently died in a plane crash?

Miss Annersley tells Joey the girl is completely over it and very happy, so not to worry.....................

As far as I remember, this girl is never mentioned again. But it does seem odd that a child whose parents are both dead is "very happy and completely over it."

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 22/01/2023 11:36

People said that and other platitudes to my sister that were at best worthless "God chose you to be a special mother" when my baby nephew died.

That wasn't very long ago. I don't think people think very differently, although it's expressed with the current fad language of the day.

CorporateBull · 22/01/2023 11:30

So true, all of it.

LiteralSycamore · 22/01/2023 10:50

CorporateBull · 22/01/2023 09:01

I think even now we look for ‘at least’ statements when people are suffering. (I once read something advising avoiding those words when trying to find something to say!). We want to alleviate someone’s grief and it’s a misguided but well meant thing to do. Probably the unrealistic bit is people accepting what she says, because, as you say, in reality it’s usually hurtful.

At least (!) now there’s a more general recognition that it’s an appallingly tasteless thing to say to someone struggling or bereaved — but even taking into account the different mores of the time period, my sense is that EBD was probably a tactless, if well-meaning person, and that characters she clearly intends to be ideal and wonderful, are frequently intrusive, interfering and tactless in their dealings with other people.

It often also sounds to me as if she desperately wanted someone to come in and take all her responsibility off her shoulders in her own life, there’s so much stress across the whole series on collapsing, being sedated and put to bed and ‘looked after’.

TheShellBeach · 22/01/2023 10:38

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 22/01/2023 08:55

There’s also a brief, positive reference to Phoebe and her husband adopting two children because she couldn’t have them.

On people being better off dead - I’m suddenly wondering if Jo genuinely believes that, or if it’s just her go-to way of ‘comforting’ bereaved people.

I think that’s her argument every single time, one way or the other, including when it’s someone’s aunt who’s worked incredibly hard all her life to support her niece and died in her 40s or 50s, & Jo says something along the lines of ‘She was worn out and now she can rest.’

I also wonder how she’d have taken it if someone had said that to her when she thought Jack was dead.

I bet Jack would have been worn out and in need of a rest, being married to Joey.

OP posts:
CorporateBull · 22/01/2023 09:01

I think even now we look for ‘at least’ statements when people are suffering. (I once read something advising avoiding those words when trying to find something to say!). We want to alleviate someone’s grief and it’s a misguided but well meant thing to do. Probably the unrealistic bit is people accepting what she says, because, as you say, in reality it’s usually hurtful.

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 22/01/2023 08:55

There’s also a brief, positive reference to Phoebe and her husband adopting two children because she couldn’t have them.

On people being better off dead - I’m suddenly wondering if Jo genuinely believes that, or if it’s just her go-to way of ‘comforting’ bereaved people.

I think that’s her argument every single time, one way or the other, including when it’s someone’s aunt who’s worked incredibly hard all her life to support her niece and died in her 40s or 50s, & Jo says something along the lines of ‘She was worn out and now she can rest.’

I also wonder how she’d have taken it if someone had said that to her when she thought Jack was dead.

CorporateBull · 22/01/2023 08:51

I think now we realise that joy can be found in even very challenging lives and saying that severely disabled people are better off dead is quite offensive.

Back when EBD was growing up it would have been far more common to lose children especially with illnesses and disabilities and for people to say it was for the best as comfort, if nothing else. I imagine her thinking didn’t move on much from there.

Jourdain11 · 22/01/2023 00:22

Phoebe Wychote (the cellist, I believe) has rheumatoid arthritis, I think?

Completely take the point about it being a different world when EBD started the Chalet School, but by the time Jessica Wayne's stepsister is written it must be at least the late 50s and there's very definitely an NHS in England!

Forthelast · 22/01/2023 00:01

LiteralSycamore · 21/01/2023 23:17

Naomi is cured (related to her sudden belief iIf in God, problematically), Phoebe Wychcote is cured (by virtue of meeting Joey), Stacey is cured, Cherry Christie recovers, Mary-Lou recovers miraculously fast — the only lifelong ‘invalids’ (horrible word, but absolutely reflective of EBD’s ideas about disability) I can think of are offstage characters like Herr Laubach’s wife for whom Joey makes jigsaws at the Hobbies Club, and Rosamund Sefton, Jessica Wayne’s stepsister, who’s just there as a backstory for Jessica being a ‘difficult new girl’.

( In fact, Jessica was horrifically badly treated by her mother remarrying and prioritising her new stepdaughter over her own child, and then sending her child abroad to boarding school when she isn’t thrilled with a ‘blended family’ situation that marginalises her — EBD clearly intends us to think Jessica is wrong and her mother right, but in fact Jessica is outrageously mistreated. I think EBD was fond of ‘explaining’ second marriages as down to anything other than ‘two people fell in love’ — she more or less gives the impression Mrs Wayne marries her bank manager because she wants to look after his disabled daughter…)

You know much more than I do about all the different characters - I wasn't thinking of all the miraculous cures at all actually. The only one that comes to mind at this moment is the lady Joey meets on holiday in England -is she a writer or a cellist?- who comes to Switzerland for treatment and marries a doctor but it's never really cured as she's always treated as an invalid.

I just disagree that there's an assumption people with disabilities are better off dead - I think it's clear she was talking about people who genuinely have been spared a great deal of suffering and looking at it in the most positive light. People still do it! We have to remember there were more chronic conditions.

Elle54321 · 21/01/2023 23:59

Yes Joey's daughter did pretty much recover from polio but back to Jessica's sister, it isn't that EBD was saying that if you can't walk you're better off dead - its a reference to the horrific pain that some people were in, when EBD started the chalet school there was no NHS, so no chance of a doctor or medical care if you were poor, no antibiotics, no pain relief. Seven of my grandfathers siblings died because they couldn't afford medical care, not the dreaded TB or measles etc just poverty.

NameChange005 · 21/01/2023 23:37

Did Joeys daughter recover form Polio as well?

LiteralSycamore · 21/01/2023 23:17

Forthelast · 21/01/2023 21:22

Nothing odd about the use of the word crippled at that time and there are some conditions fraught with pain where it's true that life will very difficult and poor quality. Disabilities of that kind are often used as a reason for termination. I don't see the problem. People still say things like this but not if the individual is living. On the other side EBD has characters with short and long-term disabilities who go on to achieve and find happiness.

Naomi is cured (related to her sudden belief iIf in God, problematically), Phoebe Wychcote is cured (by virtue of meeting Joey), Stacey is cured, Cherry Christie recovers, Mary-Lou recovers miraculously fast — the only lifelong ‘invalids’ (horrible word, but absolutely reflective of EBD’s ideas about disability) I can think of are offstage characters like Herr Laubach’s wife for whom Joey makes jigsaws at the Hobbies Club, and Rosamund Sefton, Jessica Wayne’s stepsister, who’s just there as a backstory for Jessica being a ‘difficult new girl’.

( In fact, Jessica was horrifically badly treated by her mother remarrying and prioritising her new stepdaughter over her own child, and then sending her child abroad to boarding school when she isn’t thrilled with a ‘blended family’ situation that marginalises her — EBD clearly intends us to think Jessica is wrong and her mother right, but in fact Jessica is outrageously mistreated. I think EBD was fond of ‘explaining’ second marriages as down to anything other than ‘two people fell in love’ — she more or less gives the impression Mrs Wayne marries her bank manager because she wants to look after his disabled daughter…)

JoanOgden · 21/01/2023 22:21

I'm reminded of one of the Little Women books where a boy who has a hunchback, but is bright, delightful and well loved, dies between books for no particular reason except that Louisa May Alcott clearly thought it was right and kind to kill him off.

NameChange005 · 21/01/2023 22:14

Yikes! I don't remember reading that book- thats a horribly callous thing to say!

StitchesInTime · 21/01/2023 22:00

Jourdain11 · 21/01/2023 21:32

Not the use of the word crippled - but the fact that it's assumed that since she can't walk, she's better off dead!

This is, I think, in the late 50s/early 60s (Swiss books).

It does sound rather brutal, doesn’t it?
That’s not the only time the notion that the deceased is better off dead crops up.

There’s one of the Swiss books - can’t remember which right now - where Nina is involved in a car crash. The man driving the other car dies, and Jo comforts Nina by basically telling Nina that the man’s death is for the best because his mother’s just died and he hasn’t any other relatives.

Jourdain11 · 21/01/2023 21:32

Not the use of the word crippled - but the fact that it's assumed that since she can't walk, she's better off dead!

This is, I think, in the late 50s/early 60s (Swiss books).

Forthelast · 21/01/2023 21:22

Jourdain11 · 21/01/2023 21:09

For some reason, this has just reminded me of troublesome new girl (Jessica Wayne?) having a stepsister who is "crippled" and later dies. Either Joey or ML tells Jessica that it's a blessing because she'd only have known a hopeless and helpless life of suffering. Even by the standards of the time... ugh.

Nothing odd about the use of the word crippled at that time and there are some conditions fraught with pain where it's true that life will very difficult and poor quality. Disabilities of that kind are often used as a reason for termination. I don't see the problem. People still say things like this but not if the individual is living. On the other side EBD has characters with short and long-term disabilities who go on to achieve and find happiness.

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 21/01/2023 21:09

Just Googled. Full brother, their father left home when EBD was 3 and Henzell was 2, then Henzell died in 1912. EBD was born in 1894 so he’d have been about 17. www.chaletschool.org.uk/elinor-brent-dyer/

Jourdain11 · 21/01/2023 21:09

For some reason, this has just reminded me of troublesome new girl (Jessica Wayne?) having a stepsister who is "crippled" and later dies. Either Joey or ML tells Jessica that it's a blessing because she'd only have known a hopeless and helpless life of suffering. Even by the standards of the time... ugh.