Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Think Joey Maynard (Of Chalet School Fame) Was Insufferable

986 replies

TheShellBeach · 28/12/2022 17:11

.............with her eleven children, infuriating husband and bizarre tendency to move house (and country) to live next door to the school her sister inexplicably started when Joey was a child.

She also managed to write (at least) two books a year, have a series of multiple pregnancies and poke her nose into the Chalet School's business on a daily basis.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
RobinHumphries · 31/01/2023 21:07

It’s funny how they don’t have a dedicated German teacher. There’re French teachers teaching French but no German teachers teaching German.

what also gets me is if one pupil is helping another pupil with school work they just give hints rather than the answer. Like in one of the books MaryLou is struggling with her German or Latin and another girl says something like you’re muddling up your verbs and adjectives

HagridTheGiant · 31/01/2023 20:53

TheShellBeach · 31/01/2023 10:04

I read this on another thread last night and immediately thought of the CS.

"For me it's like asking an adult who's only done gcse French to answer essay questions in French eg. Tell me about ww1 in French. You'll be able to get something out, but the quality of the answer will always be limited by how much French you know and it will take you six times as long to get a sentence out . Of course you could put effort into learning French but that takes away the effort from learning the subject its self"

The practicalities must have been crazy.
Eg, prep set on a French day to be handed in on a German day. Do they write it in French or German? Do they have separate text books for each language? (eg history textbook in French, German and English?)
And why do none of the new girls seem to know about it before they get there?!

TheShellBeach · 31/01/2023 10:04

I read this on another thread last night and immediately thought of the CS.

"For me it's like asking an adult who's only done gcse French to answer essay questions in French eg. Tell me about ww1 in French. You'll be able to get something out, but the quality of the answer will always be limited by how much French you know and it will take you six times as long to get a sentence out . Of course you could put effort into learning French but that takes away the effort from learning the subject its self"

OP posts:
HagridTheGiant · 30/01/2023 00:16

TinselAngel · 29/01/2023 23:00

He was 100% a spy.

Definitely.
I read a fan fiction once where Robins mother was a Romanov in hiding/exile. Explains why she sung her daughter the red sarafan....

Howyoualldoworkme · 29/01/2023 23:55

Debtknell · 28/01/2023 23:10

Not forgetting Grizel and Joey walking through Portsmouth with a ‘graceful swing that drew the eyes of passers-by to them’, AND making unEnglish hand gestures as they went, which suggests they looked weirdly conspicuous! I think we’re told somewhere else that the ‘graceful swing’ is from continually practising English folk dances, which cracks me up…

I'd pay good money to see them try to do that in Pompey nowadays 😂

TheShellBeach · 29/01/2023 23:51

2023istheyearigetmyacttogether · 29/01/2023 23:22

Mollie & Dick's behaviour doesn't strike me as being that unusual as it was still of an age where people went to India but wanted an English education and, often more importantly, English climate for their children. Sometimes the wife would remain in the U.K. with the children but I think it was common for the children to stay by themselves. Nowadays, it seems like such a bizarre idea, especially as they didn't have telephones let alone WhatsApp & FaceTime and things. News of a death could take weeks to travel to relatives in the U.K.
I have spent far too much time over the years speculating what class Madge, Dick & Joey were. Whatever you think about whether the U.K. is class based now, it certainly was when EBD was growing up. Do they own whatever business Dick does in India or is he an employee? I think this has some relevance to Madge's comment about Kevin & Kester being in the army & navy as, amongst the gentry at least, the eldest son (Rix) would inherit the house/land with the other sons having to make their own way in life. I think it was usually the second sons who went into the forces and the third sons who went into the church. This doesn't quite explain why they're both going into the forces but perhaps that's because of the patriotism at the time. Or simply because they're twins. Going into the RAF might not have been suggested as an option as it was seen as a bit nouveau being so much more recently established than the army & navy.

Madge's eldest son is baby David.
It always makes me think of the Royle Family.

OP posts:
Debtknell · 29/01/2023 23:41

Dick is just an employee in the forestry service in the Deccan in southern India, isn’t he? Molly is the daughter of his boss — he marries into money, clearly (though it’s less clear why Mollie is depicted as Irish, complete with stage ‘brogue’ and mercurial changes of temperament, but her family homes seem to be in England and of long habitation.

I would say the Bettanys are vaguely UMC, but penniless. If it weren’t for Joey, Madge would presumably have gone out to India with Dick to ‘housekeep’ for him and to husband-hunt on her own account in a genteel way.

2023istheyearigetmyacttogether · 29/01/2023 23:22

Mollie & Dick's behaviour doesn't strike me as being that unusual as it was still of an age where people went to India but wanted an English education and, often more importantly, English climate for their children. Sometimes the wife would remain in the U.K. with the children but I think it was common for the children to stay by themselves. Nowadays, it seems like such a bizarre idea, especially as they didn't have telephones let alone WhatsApp & FaceTime and things. News of a death could take weeks to travel to relatives in the U.K.
I have spent far too much time over the years speculating what class Madge, Dick & Joey were. Whatever you think about whether the U.K. is class based now, it certainly was when EBD was growing up. Do they own whatever business Dick does in India or is he an employee? I think this has some relevance to Madge's comment about Kevin & Kester being in the army & navy as, amongst the gentry at least, the eldest son (Rix) would inherit the house/land with the other sons having to make their own way in life. I think it was usually the second sons who went into the forces and the third sons who went into the church. This doesn't quite explain why they're both going into the forces but perhaps that's because of the patriotism at the time. Or simply because they're twins. Going into the RAF might not have been suggested as an option as it was seen as a bit nouveau being so much more recently established than the army & navy.

TinselAngel · 29/01/2023 23:00

KatherineParr · 29/01/2023 22:53

Wasn't Ted Humphries going to work in Russia and he didn't want to take Robin? What he would have been doing there I have no idea.

He was 100% a spy.

KatherineParr · 29/01/2023 22:53

Wasn't Ted Humphries going to work in Russia and he didn't want to take Robin? What he would have been doing there I have no idea.

Debtknell · 29/01/2023 22:45

HagridTheGiant · 29/01/2023 22:00

Roald Dahl was sent at around the 7-9 age as well, I believe? I remember reading his auto biography and being a bit shocked, although of course it happens still- some boarding schools take children as young as 8- for military families especially.

Someone remind me why exactly the Robin is sent to board at the CS so young? I get that her mother died, but even by the ‘solo men can’t make homes for their children’ standards of the day, surely it wasn’t outside the bounds of possibility for Ted Humphries to get a job that would allow him to have his motherless six year old living with him, even if he had to hire in childcare?

HagridTheGiant · 29/01/2023 22:00

Roald Dahl was sent at around the 7-9 age as well, I believe? I remember reading his auto biography and being a bit shocked, although of course it happens still- some boarding schools take children as young as 8- for military families especially.

110APiccadilly · 29/01/2023 21:01

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 29/01/2023 19:49

EBD does seem to have a lot of girls who live with their aunts for whatever reason.

I wonder why it never occurred to Dick & Mollie Bettany to move somewhere that Peggy and Rix could live with them?

I think it did happen a lot more (for all sorts of reasons). And the ones who lived with their aunts might have been the lucky ones - there's a heartbreaking short story by Kipling about a boy and girl who are sent from India to stay with a woman who's being paid to have them as lodgers. Admittedly that would have been set pre WW1, but the first Chalet School books aren't that far from WW1.

Outside of the boarding school level of society, it also happened. My great grandmother (I think, I'm not totally clear on which relative this was) lived with her grandparents simply because she was one of a large poor family and her grandparents could house and feed her. That would have been in the 1910s/1920s. Add in high levels of maternal mortality, and a fair few children would have ended up with no mother, and a father who would need to work to support them.

Society definitely saw the parent-child relationship very differently as well (did high levels of maternal and infant mortality factor in to this? Probably.) I remember in Noel Streetfeild's auto-biography she talks about her brother being sent to boarding school at a young age and I'm sure she said everyone was upset about it, but it (in those days) had to be done, no one would have considered not sending him.

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 29/01/2023 19:49

EBD does seem to have a lot of girls who live with their aunts for whatever reason.

I wonder why it never occurred to Dick & Mollie Bettany to move somewhere that Peggy and Rix could live with them?

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 29/01/2023 19:46

I was very struck by the similarities with Monica in particular. It's interesting that in this one it's the younger girl who is difficult, whereas in both of those it's a superior older one who challenges the girl on home ground.

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 29/01/2023 19:43

I agree with you about the domesticities, and the descriptions of the rooms and furnishings. Poor Marigold has just been removed to hospital - I suppose she'll be reformed.

TinselAngel · 29/01/2023 19:42

Lorna's Mother's behaviour that is.

Heather Leaves School, Monica Turns up Trumps and Lorna at Wynyards all have a similar these of a girl being taken out of a school for unsatisfactory behaviour. I like to read them like a trilogy but then I'm sad 😬

TinselAngel · 29/01/2023 19:38

The Lorna's are my favourites. EBD does explain her behaviour but doesn't excuse it.

I like the domesticity of the Lorna books.

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 29/01/2023 18:30

Prompted by this thread I'm reading the Lorna books, that I bought years ago when GGB issued them. I thought I'd tried tham and not 'got on' but have no memories of them at all. Definite Mrs Cochrane vibes from Lorna's mother - sends her daughter to live with her sister, siezes the opportunity to refuse to have her home for half term, is thoroughtly nasty to her when the two do meet, and as soon as L's father is dead, goes to Madeira, marries a rich widower and sends his children back to England to live with the same sister.

Very odd stuff, and does make me wonder who EMBD based it on? Boarding schools nowadays do get a disproportionate number of children from dysfunctional and marginally neglectful families, so maybe even way back then she'd heard stuff from friends.

Elle54321 · 29/01/2023 18:08

It seems unlikely and I wonder how well it would translate to the screen. Robin Stevens mentioned on her website that a tv or film version of the Murder Most Unladylike books would cost millions to produce and they have relatively few characters, I think that would work well on TV.

EmpressaurusOfWitchesBackFromTheDead · 29/01/2023 17:46

The Malory Towers TV series was narrowed down to half a dozen girls, Miss Grayling and Miss Potts.

I suppose if they stuck to the first few books they'd get away with a small cast - Jo, Madge, Grizel, Robin, Jem, Simone, one other teacher and two Tyrolean girls?

SockQueen · 29/01/2023 11:41

HagridTheGiant · 29/01/2023 11:13

Can you imagine? A solo Ode to the Robin, a solid lump of comfort number...
Actually if anyone made it, I'd watch!

Add some yodelling, a few golden/silvery voiced solos, some obscure Czech carols and quaint English folk dances.

Finishing with a big group number of "She's a real Chalet girl now!"

TheShellBeach · 29/01/2023 11:17

HagridTheGiant · 29/01/2023 11:13

Can you imagine? A solo Ode to the Robin, a solid lump of comfort number...
Actually if anyone made it, I'd watch!

So would I.
Malory Towers has been made into a TV series.
Why not the CS?
Someone would have to learn The Red Sarafan, for verisimilitude.

OP posts:
HagridTheGiant · 29/01/2023 11:13

TheShellBeach · 29/01/2023 11:06

I am now visualizing Chalet School - The Musical!
Coming to a cinema near you!

Can you imagine? A solo Ode to the Robin, a solid lump of comfort number...
Actually if anyone made it, I'd watch!

TheShellBeach · 29/01/2023 11:06

I am now visualizing Chalet School - The Musical!
Coming to a cinema near you!

OP posts: