Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS accused of hitting when no one saw

114 replies

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 15:43

First time poster here. My brother is back from the states with his wife and 2 DC (DS 3yrs & DD 2yrs) Haven’t seen them in over 3 years so was excited to catch up. Very close to my brother and get on well enough with SIL.

So they called over this morning for a play date with our 2 DC - similar ages, I have a DS 2 & DD 1. It just didn’t go well at all. My brother and his wife always refer to how smart their older son is.. can write his own name, so good with jigsaws, gives impromptu concerts etc. My mum is always going on about how bright he is and leaves my fella for dust (her words). I had some trepidation about the visit if I’m honest as my DS does not have many words yet and we’ve been relaxed about it but I was nervous of any comparisons.

Anyway to the incident itself. We have a playroom. They were all playing while we sat separately in the kitchen having coffee. I popped my head in frequently to check on them. Cue some loud crying from my brothers boy. We all go in. He’s crying uncontrollably. My brother asks what happened and after a few minutes he says that my DS would not give him the monster truck. My husband directs our DS to a second truck and asks him to give it to his cousin which he does in a kind gentle way that made me proud ( we’re focusing on sharing with our 2 atm). Throughout the course of an hour there were 2 more incidents of crying from same boy. Each time DS was the cause according to his cousin. The second time it was over a toy but not quite sure what happened. They were close to us but not clear. My nephews leg appeared to be stuck in something so my brother went over. I heard him mumbling something about well if he tries to hit you say no! I remember thinking I was looking in that direction and didn’t see anything of that nature happen but let it go. Tbh I just though my brother was getting overly involved and just let kids be kids!

Anyway third crying incident happened. Just my nephew and DS in playroom. I went in, my brother looked at me and said can you handle? I was like of course (handle what!?).. so I lean down gently to nephew and ask is he ok, can he tell me what happened. Can’t talk with cries. Brother comes in and picks him up. Clearly annoyed says he only cries like this when he’s been hit (same cry as not getting the truck, honestly). Wife follows and says the same. Then say we can’t police your children just so our kids can play without getting hurt. Not a mark on him btw. Listen, no one saw the incident I said. We don’t know what happened. If my DS did anything wrong I would step in (I already had with things such as sharing and grabbing and flailing arms near DN - he did hit her. I saw it. He had to apologize).

DS is learning, can be physical, we always step in for what we witness. He’s very good with his own little sister, goes to childcare, not one mention of hitting.

Things got slightly heated with brother and wife and I. I said they’re not perfect parents as we’re all just doing our best. My DS is younger etc. but I’d never let him bully anyone. It just got uncomfortable, I said best to leave the play date, it might be more enjoyable for them and us if they did their own thing (we had originally planned to go for lunch). It definitely escalated quickly but there were already underlying tensions with our different parenting styles. We hugged and admitted we’re all tired, young kids, working though Christmas with no childcare (us) and traveling with small ones (them).

But it’s left a bad taste in my mouth as we don’t see them much at all - AIBU?

OP posts:
Reugny · 28/12/2022 16:09

@SomethingOriginal2 very easy.

After asking you why on the same exact small subject a few times, they then blurt out in the appropriate setting the answer to their "why' question.

Other adults then think they are clever when they are just repeating what they have learnt in the correct context.

My DD does this, and I have looked after nephews and nieces who did this as small children.

TheYummyPatler · 28/12/2022 16:08

Your brother is going to ensure his son is really whiny about everything. He’s going to regret that at some point. 🤣

Peashoots · 28/12/2022 16:08

@WakeAwake less you though, honestly. Your brothers “my kid is perfect” act will wear very thin very quickly on most people!
your kid is a normal toddler, please don’t stress over this. X

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:06

@Peashoots 😂😂😂 yes agree! I think we were probably the same emotional age as the toddlers with that!

OP posts:
Peashoots · 28/12/2022 16:06

If your brother carries on like this, you won’t be the only one backing away from play dates, I promise you. 💐

Pascor · 28/12/2022 16:06

We have other cousins similar ages and they can be left alone for long periods of time without supervision but know each other well

No, they can't. They are babies. stop putting them in a different room and then having ridiculous fights about what they do when you aren't bothering to mind them at all.

ClaretBarret · 28/12/2022 16:05

This would have all been avoided if you had all actually parented your children and not left them unattended for so long.

They're incredibly young, you’re lucky it was only a few tears and an accusation of hitting

CaptainBarbosa · 28/12/2022 16:05

Look, toddlers fight regardless of their perceived IQ by adults.

I think you all need to chalk this up to a parenting experience.

At least you all know moving forwards to not leave them unattended together all be it for 2 minutes or 20minutes.

It's done now, Brother will return to the US you probably won't see them for another year by which point it's old history and the cousins will be a year older 🤷🏻‍♀️

UsingChangeofName · 28/12/2022 16:05

They were all playing while we sat separately in the kitchen having coffee.

You lost me at this.
Y were ALL BU thinking you can leave a 3 yr old, 2x 2yr olds and a 1 yr old playing alone while adults sit in a different room with their coffee.

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:05

Thanks @Hugasauras ! Yes that’s it exactly, I think it’s normal to have tears and struggles over sharing! I’ve learned some lessons with this one definitely.

OP posts:
saraclara · 28/12/2022 16:04

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:00

Oh no we were definitely watching them, they were in front of us for the majority of that hour but once or twice went into the playroom to get more toys. Only a few minutes unsupervised (which in my opinion is ok). Yes there is some competitive parenting going on - I think that’s the root cause here and I have to take some accountability there.

Make your mind up, OP

We have a playroom. They were all playing while we sat separately in the kitchen having coffee. I popped my head in frequently to check on them

RealBecca · 28/12/2022 16:04

After the first incident you should all have been supervising more closely. And when he said can you deal with it he meant to talk to your kids and not his. Just let kids be kids smacks of lax parenting to me because your kid wasnt the child crying. Next time just all go out or actually watch the kids. Or go for lunch with your brother and then do family play with the kids all together.

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:03

And the 3 year old said he’d been hit AFTER his dad said it. I don’t doubt it may have happened - it was the quick conclusion of it. Tbh hearing the responses I’m thinking that we needed to be in the same room at all times because of the ages and gaps etc. and to help them with the playing together. Don’t get me wrong we were doing that for the majority of the time but there were a few minutes where it didn’t happen and that’s when the ‘incident’ happened.
I think my brother and wife were saying my DS was the cause of it not going well. And look that hurt. I got defensive. We haven’t had issues like this with any other play dates. I’m sure they’ll come up again!

OP posts:
Hugasauras · 28/12/2022 16:03

Your mum sounds awful. Your brother sounds totally OTT. Some kids just don't play that well together, but that doesn't sound unusual for kids that age anyway. Play dates at that age often involve tears for someone cos sharing is hard and toddlers aren't known for their balanced negotiating skills. That's just part of having young kids really.

Stressedmum2017 · 28/12/2022 16:03

Yanbu your brother and sil sound like they are so desperate to look like perfect parents with their perfect child they will do anything to make that apparent include set up non situations making your toddler look bad. They seem pretty pathetic to be honest. All the kids are toddlers at the end of the day they are gonna fall out. Advise them they should work on their ds not being a whingebag.

SomethingOriginal2 · 28/12/2022 16:03

Why on earth were they unsupervised?! They're so young, and you're "he's getting too involved, let kids be kids" shit does make me think that your one of those parents that just leaves your kids to run riot and "be kids"/"sort it themselves" .

But I also think it sounds like they're a bit precious and he's a bit of a Prince. Our nephew is the same, he's a bloody genius apparently, amazing at everything, can do no wrong, if we're having a conversation as adults he'll just butt in and chat some shit and his dad is amazed for him like "well he's right. How does he know that?!" It's exhausting.

But you really should have been supervising your 2 year old, obviously.

Reugny · 28/12/2022 16:03

He probably did hit but he's two and that's what two year olds do.

If the three year old knew him better instead of crying he would have whacked him back as that's what kids do.

So like PP said you need to supervise your kids.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/12/2022 16:02

We have a playroom. They were all playing while we sat separately in the kitchen having coffee. I popped my head in frequently to check on them.

This sounds like they were unsupervised most of the time

MichelleScarn · 28/12/2022 16:00

Is your dB used to being the one in charge and wonderful? From the whole post your mums shitty favouritism stuck out to me! If a relative of mine stated the 'leaves them for dust' comment I wouldn't have them around my child!

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:00

Oh no we were definitely watching them, they were in front of us for the majority of that hour but once or twice went into the playroom to get more toys. Only a few minutes unsupervised (which in my opinion is ok). Yes there is some competitive parenting going on - I think that’s the root cause here and I have to take some accountability there.

OP posts:
Schoolchoicesucks · 28/12/2022 15:58

I wouldn't have left them playing in a separate room at those ages. But that's not a criticism of you - there were at least 3 adults there and it seems your dbro and sil were also fine with leaving them alone.

Perhaps stick with outdoor walks/visit to playground/muddy puddle splashing in wellies for the rest of the trip? There's more space and fewer possessions to worry over.

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 15:57

Thanks both. Very true. We were all very tired! They had only been playing for an hour and just not getting on well at all. We have other cousins similar ages and they can be left alone for long periods of time without supervision but know each other well.

OP posts:
PriOn1 · 28/12/2022 15:57

Two and three year olds, unsupervised over three periods of crying and none of the parents thought that perhaps someone should be in there watching them? Pretty sure at that age, I wouldn’t have let mine out of my sight for any length of time in case they ate something or pulled something over on them.

Sounds like there’s some competitive parenting going on, egged on by a pain-in-the-arse grandparent as well.

MelchiorsMistress · 28/12/2022 15:55

Even if the children were fairly close in age it sounds like emotionally and developmentally there is a big difference between them. That’s difficult when they’re so little because they both expect the other to play and communicate the same way they do. It just means they need more support to play together or alongside each other if they’re going to be expected to spend time with each other.

Kindly, I would also listen if the older child is saying they’re being hit. It wouldn’t be unusual for a child with good understanding but few words to use a hit to communicate something. That is not going to be nice for that child or their parents, so I do think you that you need to be on top of it more next time.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/12/2022 15:55

I agree with everyone else that the adults should have been in the same room as them rather than leaving four absolutely tiny kids/ toddlers to play alone.

As for the hitting, sounds like the 3 yo didn’t even accuse your 2 yo of hitting him, never mind it being witnessed. Your brother just jumped to that conclusion. Surely if his ds is so “smart” he would have the words to say so?