Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS accused of hitting when no one saw

114 replies

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 15:43

First time poster here. My brother is back from the states with his wife and 2 DC (DS 3yrs & DD 2yrs) Haven’t seen them in over 3 years so was excited to catch up. Very close to my brother and get on well enough with SIL.

So they called over this morning for a play date with our 2 DC - similar ages, I have a DS 2 & DD 1. It just didn’t go well at all. My brother and his wife always refer to how smart their older son is.. can write his own name, so good with jigsaws, gives impromptu concerts etc. My mum is always going on about how bright he is and leaves my fella for dust (her words). I had some trepidation about the visit if I’m honest as my DS does not have many words yet and we’ve been relaxed about it but I was nervous of any comparisons.

Anyway to the incident itself. We have a playroom. They were all playing while we sat separately in the kitchen having coffee. I popped my head in frequently to check on them. Cue some loud crying from my brothers boy. We all go in. He’s crying uncontrollably. My brother asks what happened and after a few minutes he says that my DS would not give him the monster truck. My husband directs our DS to a second truck and asks him to give it to his cousin which he does in a kind gentle way that made me proud ( we’re focusing on sharing with our 2 atm). Throughout the course of an hour there were 2 more incidents of crying from same boy. Each time DS was the cause according to his cousin. The second time it was over a toy but not quite sure what happened. They were close to us but not clear. My nephews leg appeared to be stuck in something so my brother went over. I heard him mumbling something about well if he tries to hit you say no! I remember thinking I was looking in that direction and didn’t see anything of that nature happen but let it go. Tbh I just though my brother was getting overly involved and just let kids be kids!

Anyway third crying incident happened. Just my nephew and DS in playroom. I went in, my brother looked at me and said can you handle? I was like of course (handle what!?).. so I lean down gently to nephew and ask is he ok, can he tell me what happened. Can’t talk with cries. Brother comes in and picks him up. Clearly annoyed says he only cries like this when he’s been hit (same cry as not getting the truck, honestly). Wife follows and says the same. Then say we can’t police your children just so our kids can play without getting hurt. Not a mark on him btw. Listen, no one saw the incident I said. We don’t know what happened. If my DS did anything wrong I would step in (I already had with things such as sharing and grabbing and flailing arms near DN - he did hit her. I saw it. He had to apologize).

DS is learning, can be physical, we always step in for what we witness. He’s very good with his own little sister, goes to childcare, not one mention of hitting.

Things got slightly heated with brother and wife and I. I said they’re not perfect parents as we’re all just doing our best. My DS is younger etc. but I’d never let him bully anyone. It just got uncomfortable, I said best to leave the play date, it might be more enjoyable for them and us if they did their own thing (we had originally planned to go for lunch). It definitely escalated quickly but there were already underlying tensions with our different parenting styles. We hugged and admitted we’re all tired, young kids, working though Christmas with no childcare (us) and traveling with small ones (them).

But it’s left a bad taste in my mouth as we don’t see them much at all - AIBU?

OP posts:
Reugny · 28/12/2022 16:31

but I do draw a hard line when it comes to my kids. Like all of us right!?

Yes

Each child is an individual.

Your child isn't behind.

TheYummyPatler · 28/12/2022 16:30

Was (is) your brother your mum’s favoured child, by any chance? 🤣

Bbq1 · 28/12/2022 16:29

So a 1 year old, two 2 year olds and a 3 year old were all left playing in a room unsupervised? While you all sat drinking tea in another room? That sounds very unsafe. The entire issue here has arisen because none of you wanted to supervise your own children. What's worse is the children got upset on multiple occasions and not one of you thought to suggest actually staying with them and watching them...

DuplicateUserName · 28/12/2022 16:29

They were all playing while we sat separately in the kitchen having coffee.

'All' two of them then...

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:29

@DuplicateUserName not all left unsupervised together. The younger ones with parents, the older boys in playroom unsupervised on 2 separate occasions for a few mins - should have learned my lesson after first incident.

OP posts:
DuplicateUserName · 28/12/2022 16:27

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:24

1 year old was having a nap most of the time and was with me the rest of the time. 2 year old DN with us all of the time too. She walked into the playroom, i accompanied her. The 2 boys who had played together at Christmas alone for a time were the ones who were unsupervised for no longer than 5 mins. However lesson learned on this… more guidance and parenting needed going forward.

Oh, a complete change in story 🙄

DuplicateUserName · 28/12/2022 16:26

Who in their right minds leaves a 3 year old, two 2 year olds and a 1 year old in a separate room, while they sit chatting and sipping coffee in another one?

Jesus, are you all mad? 😂

Lesson totally learned I hope. That's not fair at all on the kids.

PollyPut · 28/12/2022 16:26

Why on earth weren't any of you actually in the room with the children supervising them?

saraclara · 28/12/2022 16:26

I was far from a helicopter parent, but no way would I not supervise four kids aged 1,2 and 3. Three of them are still of the age of putting things in their mouths for starters. I might have dipped in and out with my own kids at 2 and 3, but I knew them backwards and there was never any friction between them. But even then, for no more three or four minutes while I was in the kitchen cooking or something.

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:24

1 year old was having a nap most of the time and was with me the rest of the time. 2 year old DN with us all of the time too. She walked into the playroom, i accompanied her. The 2 boys who had played together at Christmas alone for a time were the ones who were unsupervised for no longer than 5 mins. However lesson learned on this… more guidance and parenting needed going forward.

OP posts:
WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:22

@SomethingOriginal2 agreed. That’s the takeaway for me on this. Big time.

OP posts:
WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:21

@PeekAtYou right on all counts. Honestly I could have handled this better but I was finding it all a bit exhausting! I will speak to my mum. These are old patterns. She compared all of us growing up. Still does. Her stuff not mine, but I do draw a hard line when it comes to my kids. Like all of us right!?

OP posts:
SomethingOriginal2 · 28/12/2022 16:20

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:12

@Theunamedcat 😂😂 me too! Honestly more supervision is what I’m hearing and taking on board here!

lax parenting - yes, I am slightly lax. No doubt about it. Do parents on here honestly watch their kids on playdates 💯 of the time at that age?! Not even a few mins alone? They had some Christmas Day together with no issues and some minutes alone together like today.

My DS is 19mo, he's a bit ahead though so probably quite a bit like your 2yo. No, I never leave him unattended with another young child. We had a play date with a friend and her 19mo, we both were with them constantly. We had a playdate last week with my 3yo niece, they were supervised constantly by at least one parent and rightly so.

You have to teach kids how to act, they don't just sort things out themselves, you have to teach them to share, or to not snatch, or distract them from toys. Especially with the age gap. The playdate with my niece was much harder than the same aged kid. You really need to be more involved.

TheYummyPatler · 28/12/2022 16:20

I try to avoid leaving my toddler unsupervised anywhere, even on his own in the next room. Obviously I sometimes have to leave the room briefly, but he’s got an incredible capacity for getting himself into silly situations (being 2).

I would expect tears extremely quickly if I left him and another toddler unsupervised, even for a minute.

Social interaction and sharing are not easy for tiny people. Their methods of getting what they want are often not pretty. 🤣

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:19

@Peashoots thankfully my sisters are super laid back. I have lots of play dates, never had anything like this. It was the last thing I wanted. God knows when we’ll see them again! We’ll still be on good terms but my god do we parent differently!

OP posts:
CaptainBarbosa · 28/12/2022 16:19

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:12

@Theunamedcat 😂😂 me too! Honestly more supervision is what I’m hearing and taking on board here!

lax parenting - yes, I am slightly lax. No doubt about it. Do parents on here honestly watch their kids on playdates 💯 of the time at that age?! Not even a few mins alone? They had some Christmas Day together with no issues and some minutes alone together like today.

Mine was like Dracula at that age 🧛🏼, he bit everyone 🤣. So yes I had to helicopter parent 😳

He was and is also a only child, so learning to "share" took a bit longer so I had to be there to guide and teach him how to share with others.

He also has ADHD so yeah more supervision required, especially around "risk taking" he had a phase where jumping off the dining room table, off the top of the staircase, climbing into kitchen surfaces was also "fun". To be honest it still is but now you can add the shed roof, the 6ft fences and playground equipment into the mix.

He's also still to this day a little stubborn, a little bossy and a dash of cocky. Were getting there .....🙄 But yes I'm exhausted from basically being on high alert since he learnt to walk at about 11 months old.

One day I'll relax, but not a for a while yet....

MichelleScarn · 28/12/2022 16:18

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:15

@MichelleScarn this is the real issue tbh. It hurts. And my sister just said to me now you know why we don’t get on. He’s superior about everything. I guess I’m only seeing it now because it got personal 😅

That's really shit, I'm already envisaging his version of this to your mum!

PeekAtYou · 28/12/2022 16:17

After the first incident, the kids should have been separated or more heavily supervised. A group of under 4s were unlikely to play peacefully without supervision. Your kids might be fine playing together but your brother's reaction to the first incident should have round alarm bells at how things might proceed without a change of pace.
Your nephew is going to find himself in difficulty if his dad continues like this. The other kids will keep a wide berth because who wants to get into trouble and the other parents will find toy all too much.
Have you given your mother a piece of your mind ? Her attitude is disgusting and nasty

DowntonCrabby · 28/12/2022 16:17

A 3, 2, 2 and 1 year old, all together need to be 100% supervised.

ClaretBarret · 28/12/2022 16:16

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:12

@Theunamedcat 😂😂 me too! Honestly more supervision is what I’m hearing and taking on board here!

lax parenting - yes, I am slightly lax. No doubt about it. Do parents on here honestly watch their kids on playdates 💯 of the time at that age?! Not even a few mins alone? They had some Christmas Day together with no issues and some minutes alone together like today.

You left them for over an hour

Thats not a few minutes, and yes with a 1 year old most don’t even do that.

Pascor · 28/12/2022 16:16

Yes, honestly. It's not normal at all to leave babies and toddlers in a different room while the adults sit completely away from them having coffee. It's weird and its dangerous. They are one and two years old, you don't put them in a different room!

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:15

@MichelleScarn this is the real issue tbh. It hurts. And my sister just said to me now you know why we don’t get on. He’s superior about everything. I guess I’m only seeing it now because it got personal 😅

OP posts:
TinySaltLick · 28/12/2022 16:15

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:12

@Theunamedcat 😂😂 me too! Honestly more supervision is what I’m hearing and taking on board here!

lax parenting - yes, I am slightly lax. No doubt about it. Do parents on here honestly watch their kids on playdates 💯 of the time at that age?! Not even a few mins alone? They had some Christmas Day together with no issues and some minutes alone together like today.

At that age (eg 2 and 3), yes pretty much the entire time yes. Only takes one minute to choke on something. Entire thing could have been avoided had they not been neglected

The other couple do sound a bit highly strung, I think leaving was a good idea. Try again in 6 months when everyone is a bit older

WakeAwake · 28/12/2022 16:12

@Theunamedcat 😂😂 me too! Honestly more supervision is what I’m hearing and taking on board here!

lax parenting - yes, I am slightly lax. No doubt about it. Do parents on here honestly watch their kids on playdates 💯 of the time at that age?! Not even a few mins alone? They had some Christmas Day together with no issues and some minutes alone together like today.

OP posts:
RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 28/12/2022 16:09

Kids that age probably need an adult in there with them to be honest - especially if the adults are going to be precious about who has what toy, who pushed whom etc.

It all sounds like toddlers behaving like toddlers, just different temperents colliding. It sounds like their child has a go to reaction to cry in order to get help in social situations he can't handle yet (because he's only 3). e.g. he wants a toy, another child has toy and won't give it up, he doesn't have the emotional maturity to negotiate or wait for toy so he cries until an adult comes and solves it for him. Normal behaviour. Your child also sounds like a normal 3 year old. He's playing with his monster truck, another child wants it and he says no. Maybe he pushed his cousin or maybe he didn't but even if he did it doesn't sound out of the realms of normal 3 year old behaviour when there's another child in his space trying to get at all his toys.

I would have had at least one adult sitting with them to handle these situations before they got out of control.