Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In laws cleaned our house while away....

465 replies

ohnnoclean · 28/12/2022 08:22

We were away for Christmas. In laws have our key for emergencies. The night before we left, in laws came round. I was in the middle of packing and a lot of things were everywhere ( but the house wasn't actually dirty ).

MIL kept saying, ' don't worry about cleaning the house before you leave, you won't have time '.. ( she's been asking me whether I was packed to go for about a week before I left. I don't pack a week early. I tend to pack the day before and I always manage fine. I travel a lot and always have and have traveled with my kids a lot too, so I do know what I'm doing..

Anyhow, the house wasn't dirty, there was just clothes everywhere as I was packing. MIL kept repeating I should not worry about cleaning.. kind of annoyed me, as it wasn't dirty. But OK.. I ignored it. She then said she'd come and clean while we were away. I said no don't worry at all, it's not dirty..

Of course, we got back and it's clearly been cleaned a bit ( fridge has been cleaned, for example ). Of course I'm grateful and I've said thanks. But I'm really uncomfortable with it. I assume she thinks I'm a dirty cow of course. Just the way she kept saying I shouldn't worry about cleaning - when it wasn't really dirty. The fact she was here when we were not here and the fact I had declined the offer of her cleaning my house.. it's annoyed me. I won't start a fight over it, but next time we go away, this can't happen.

OP posts:
DesolationRow · 28/12/2022 15:05

@LookItsMeAgain yes you're right, it's different because I've checked they are happy for me to do it but because the OP says 'its a nice gesture but there's probably some judgement in it' I suppose I'm trying to say that she's right, there is, unavoidably, a little bit of judgement in it - but really so what?! Any judging I do is my problem, it reflects on me, not on my DD and SIL. And it's honestly only a tiny (unavoidably human, I hope) part of why I've just tugged a lump of hair out the shower plughole🤢😂!

I used to find it excruciating to accept help of any kind because I've felt people might be judging me weak, hopeless, lazy or whatever. Now I reckon people help others for a whole, complicated mixture of reasons - but the overriding reason is almost always because we care about each other. Of course the OP has the right to tell her MIL to not do it again, but I think not worrying about being judged is a good solution too.

been and done it. · 28/12/2022 14:59

My DS and DIL regularly go off for days/1 week holidays sometimes 2. I pop in at their request just to check all is okay. I often find their used breakfast bowls and half full juice glasses in the kitchen. I rinse them out and leave them on the side..I don't clean them properly as I know my DIL would be mortified

On the other hand if I go to my DDs house I do the mountain of washing up hang out the washing on the line if it's fine and sort out the cat litter if nec.

She thanks me, says I didn't need to I say I know..she loves me for it.

Know your relatives is my motto.

Gemmy96 · 28/12/2022 14:59

People use the words "clean" and "tidy" interchangeably. They almost certainly saw that you were stressed and wanted to help.

diddl · 28/12/2022 14:58

Speakingmymind · 28/12/2022 14:54

The op has already said her house wasn't dirty or even messy.

One person's dirty and messy might not be the same definition as someone else's

That's for the people who live there to decide isn't it?

Not MIL who has been told no!

Alittlelost0 · 28/12/2022 14:57

I think due to how much she mentioned it before hand, she was planning it as something nice to do and it has no reflection really at all on how clean or tidy it was. She was going to clean and tidy while you were away because she wanted to, to be nice. It could have been a show home and she would have cleaned it!
But I do understand how you feel judged as most of us would. I think a kind, honest chat is best.

Speakingmymind · 28/12/2022 14:54

The op has already said her house wasn't dirty or even messy.

One person's dirty and messy might not be the same definition as someone else's

THEDEACON · 28/12/2022 14:54

Redraw your boundaries with a heavier pencil If you don't she will keep overstepping I've had to do this with my own mother!

toomuchlaundry · 28/12/2022 14:49

@FusionChefGeoff you haven’t read all of the OP’s posts have you?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 28/12/2022 14:49

diddl · 28/12/2022 14:43

The op has already said her house wasn't dirty or even messy.

Even if it was it doesn't constitute an emergency does it?

Exactly.

And you know she was snooping.

The woman would never have another unsupervised moment in my home.

FusionChefGeoff · 28/12/2022 14:43

If you feel judged, that's on you I'm afraid - nothing in the post suggests that's where it came from.

Very few houses have literally NOTHING that needs cleaning at any one moment - you said yourself you could tell she'd been. Plus an empty house is so much easier to clean.

I would switch your perspective - she's a kind woman who remembers what it was like trying to get a family ready to go on holiday and thought of one thing she could do to lighten your load.

What a kind gesture.

diddl · 28/12/2022 14:43

The op has already said her house wasn't dirty or even messy.

Even if it was it doesn't constitute an emergency does it?

ReformedWaywardTeen · 28/12/2022 14:42

You need to tell her firmly that although you've thanked her, on reflection you don't feel comfortable with her doing this.

I had my SIL do this once. I wasn't on holiday, I was preparing for DHs surprise birthday party, I had two children under 2 and she had come over to sit with them. The idea was that DH and I went out to the pub, found no mates there on his birthday and then back home.

On the way out she had said about there being toys everywhere (there was a toy box, with a lid. That was it) and she said the place looked "cluttered".

In the just over an hour we were out, she had fucked about with my cupboards and moved loads of stuff around. I could barely find anything for weeks. She is very minimalist though, we aren't. She looks uncomfortable every time she visits which is thankfully not often.

I told her after that to never ever do it again. That if my house is cluttered, I like it that way and I don't go into her home and fiddle with stuff.

She has never done it since.

Kennykenkencat · 28/12/2022 14:39

My mother got the landlord to open up my flat to her and another relative whilst I was out at work.
she and my relative cleaned the whole place then rang me at work to berate me about how dirty my flat was.

I actually flat shared and the other person who was not happy some stranger had been messing with her stuff.

Ended up having to move out as my mother couldn’t be trusted to not gain entry again.

annlee3817 · 28/12/2022 14:38

I wouldn't ike this either, my MIl and FIl stayed at our place once when visiting and we stayed with my parents, as not enough room for us all and she reorganised our drawers including bedroom drawers, I was less than happy!

ButterflyOil · 28/12/2022 14:37

Id hate that too. I think getting the key off her is the best bet.

Hollaatme3022 · 28/12/2022 14:32

I would see it as her just trying to help. The fact that you didn't want the help, is why you feel the way you do. And that's fair enough.

However, I don't think it was her insinuating that you were unclean. If she usually ignores your pleas, then this is a problem. But I, personally, think it was coming from a place of kindness, mixed in a little, with nosiness.

Kennykenkencat · 28/12/2022 14:32

Mirabai · 28/12/2022 13:03

You said there there “a lot of things were everywhere” and there were “clothes everywhere” as you were packing. That’s all I meant by “mess.”

And if you read op says everything was left tidy as the clothes were either packed or put away.

Nat6999 · 28/12/2022 14:29

After coming back off holiday & finding exmil had gone through all our post I claimed the spare keys back & never returned them to her.

zzzexhaustedzzz · 28/12/2022 14:18

My mum can’t help but clean, and she does it in my kitchen whenever she’s round. She likes to be ‘useful’. I don’t complain at all. She does judge as I have heard on the (poison) grapevine over the years…. But I don’t care what she thinks of me generally, she has totally different values etc.
My ex’s mum on the other hand over-stepped boundaries many times and thankfully I no longer have to see her. She also judged me for everything I did, and it was poisonous. Thankfully my DD/S are too old for that to matter anymore. I should have sensed this about her and laid boundaries early and firmly.
A good/ non confrontational way to deal with this could be: you have a friend coming to stay and need the key for them to use. You need it ASAP so they can’t offer to copy it. You forget to return it to them. You get a key safe.

LookItsMeAgain · 28/12/2022 14:16

DesolationRow · 28/12/2022 12:59

I am a mum/MIL currently cleaning my daughter/SIL's house. They invited me up for Christmas and we had a lovely three days, now they've gone to my SIL's family for a few days and I'm staying on here for a couple of days. The house was in post-Christmas chaos when they left, also neither of them give housework much priority at any time. They know I'm doing this and say they are delighted that they'll be coming home to a sparkling kitchen, bathroom and tidy sitting room (I never go into their, or my teenage grandson's, bedrooms).

I don't feel like it's an act of judgementalness from me. I don't usually enjoy housework but this feels like a way to look after them and make their busy lives a bit easier. There's not much I can do for my competent, happy and financially secure daughter/SIL these days (except be a good grandma, but that's a huge benefit to me anyway) but this I can do.

I do (secretly I hope) feel a teeny bit of judgement at how messy/mucky their house can get at times - but judging is human nature. My overwhelming judgement about my daughter, her family and her home is that they are bloody brilliant people, I'm forever impressed by how they manage their jobs, parenting and relationships and feel very fortunate that they share their time and affection with me. That's why I'm cleaning their house today.

This is so far removed from being in the wheel house of the OP's MiL though. You sound really lovely @DesolationRow and I'd say your daughter/SiL appreciate what you are doing for them. They are aware of what you're doing too. Makes a huge difference.

LookItsMeAgain · 28/12/2022 14:14

UWhatNow · 28/12/2022 10:01

Classic. MIL does something nice, trying to help and DIL is raging.

Why so dramatic? So you feel ‘judged’ - what’s she going to do - announce your slattern ways in the local paper? Get over yourself. It’s not about you. Most things aren’t. It’s about her and probably wanting to be feel needed and useful. You should thank her and move on.

I don't 100% agree with this.

This wasn't a case of running a mop over a kitchen floor or vacuuming the carpet in the living room and arranging the cushions so that they would be nice for the OP and her family to return to.

The MiL here decided to clean the OP's fridge. Something that isn't visible to anyone except the OP and her family.
It wasn't just wiping down surfaces in the kitchen or cleaning the bathroom either, it was rearranging the items that the OP has in her kitchen cupboards (again something that only the OP and her family would see).

I see this as overstepping.

Fine if the MiL wanted to vacuum the carpets, wipe down surfaces or mop the kitchen floor if the urge took her. Buying a bunch of flowers and having them waiting in a vase on the kitchen table for the OP to return home to is nice and thoughtful. However, this was going next level, in my eyes.

For this, I wouldn't be 'raging' but I'd be making very certain that the next time that I'd be going away, no one, absolutely no one would be able to enter the property, so I probably would be looking for the key back or being very subtle and just changing the locks but overlooking giving her a key.

If the MiL here wants to feel and be useful, she should ASK what the OP and her son want her to do, not assume that what she has done is what they wanted/needed doing.

RosesAndHellebores · 28/12/2022 14:09

If my MIL had put a duster round and hoovered that would be fine (not going to happen). Cleaning the fridge and sorting out cupboards is beyond the pale

Having said that, it would have to be agreed in advance because neither sets of parents have ever had our keys in their possession. They live too far away.

toomuchlaundry · 28/12/2022 14:04

@Beachloveramy you have obviously missed the bit where OP says the MIL is aggressive

Cocolapew · 28/12/2022 14:02

The op has already said her house wasn't dirty or even messy.
That's why cupboards and fridges get rearranged, so we know they've been there, my house was clean and tidy there was nothing to do so mil moved things. The minute I walked in I knew someone had been in.
Mil's like this are a different breed to normal ones 🤷

Seeingadistance · 28/12/2022 14:00

Aquasulis · 28/12/2022 08:28

Ask your partner to ask for the key back easy and put it in a key safe instead. That way you can have anyone trustworthy in - neighbour etc and she doesn’t need the code at all.

This.

Key safes are a great solution to the need for emergency access.