Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In laws cleaned our house while away....

465 replies

ohnnoclean · 28/12/2022 08:22

We were away for Christmas. In laws have our key for emergencies. The night before we left, in laws came round. I was in the middle of packing and a lot of things were everywhere ( but the house wasn't actually dirty ).

MIL kept saying, ' don't worry about cleaning the house before you leave, you won't have time '.. ( she's been asking me whether I was packed to go for about a week before I left. I don't pack a week early. I tend to pack the day before and I always manage fine. I travel a lot and always have and have traveled with my kids a lot too, so I do know what I'm doing..

Anyhow, the house wasn't dirty, there was just clothes everywhere as I was packing. MIL kept repeating I should not worry about cleaning.. kind of annoyed me, as it wasn't dirty. But OK.. I ignored it. She then said she'd come and clean while we were away. I said no don't worry at all, it's not dirty..

Of course, we got back and it's clearly been cleaned a bit ( fridge has been cleaned, for example ). Of course I'm grateful and I've said thanks. But I'm really uncomfortable with it. I assume she thinks I'm a dirty cow of course. Just the way she kept saying I shouldn't worry about cleaning - when it wasn't really dirty. The fact she was here when we were not here and the fact I had declined the offer of her cleaning my house.. it's annoyed me. I won't start a fight over it, but next time we go away, this can't happen.

OP posts:
Christerbell · 31/12/2022 09:33

I’m a mil to 2. I’m walking on egg shells not to upset the dils.
I have a dragon of a mil myself which I don’t want my dils to ever think I am the same.
I think mum of sons get a rough deal. I love my dils but their mums always come first. Invited to every sports day/class assembly etc. and one mother is absolutely horrible to my dil (toxic mother daughter relationship)won’t help in any way.. yet the red carpet comes out if she visits . It’s very hurtful. My husband and I do all the babysitting and childcare so all the work. The mother gets all the rewards.
don’t be hard on the mil. Maybe she’s being kind and wants to be your friend (that’s my take on it)

sue20 · 31/12/2022 06:10

toomuchlaundry · 30/12/2022 17:55

@Sainte because it’s my home and my cupboards are arranged how I like them. OP’s house was clean. OP told MIL not to go into the house. Why should OP be pleased that MIL did something she didn’t want her to do?

Why should a MIL (or DM) have a right to go into someone’s else house and start rearranging/tidying it to the way they want it with no regard to the actual people who live in the house?

I’ve also asked this before why is it only women who do this? Are their lives so empty or have they been brain washed/conditioned to think that cleaning is their role in life. Will the next generation of DMs and MILs do this? Fine to help if asked but if you do something that someone doesn’t want you to do, it isn’t helping

Last paragraph - yes.

But a story I have from long ago - friends PILs staying at their absent friend’s house decided to sand and re wax an old table without discussion as a “lovely thank you “ surprise. The owners were furious, the original patina on table wrecked ( possible devaluation).

not dissimilar, stop interfering with other people’s stuff and their way of living. Especially if you know nothing about their home,

sue20 · 31/12/2022 05:54

Justellingthetruth · 30/12/2022 08:11

@ohnnoclean

thought about this a lot.

I think they were trying to be nice.
Not saying you are dirty atall.
I would be greatful.
I find all people clean differently so it's good to have different people do the same room over time as they clean different places ( after the obvious is done).
so anyone would see different things the ones before didn't.
so be happy and don't get hung up.

end of the situation.

Except it’s not. Unless the boundary is laid down it can be breached again.

I don’t think the point is about whether this is a kind favour. Some people seem to be happy with the concept of a friend or relative “helping “ in this way which is fine (and not the point).

point being that our home is the place we live our most basic and private times and habits. The place where most of us form our identity.

To have unsought and unwanted invasion of this privacy is insensitive and crass behaviour by the perpetrator regardless of who they are.

KatherineJaneway · 31/12/2022 01:36

OP’s house was clean.

Then surely it could have not been cleaned further.

Catkin51 · 30/12/2022 22:12

I would be delighted if my MIL cleaned my house for me! Don’t you think she was just trying to be helpful? Don’t worry about it - I wouldn’t!

JustPoppinBy · 30/12/2022 20:56

I completely get why this would bother you op, it would rile me too. Not even just the worry about being judged, but the fact that she’d been all through your house in your absence would really bother me, especially after asking her not to. My MIL has a spare key for a ‘incase of emergencies’ situation and last time we were on holiday she was supposed to let herself in through the back gate to grab something from the garden but I saw on the doorbell that she was actually in the house and it bothered me. Not only that she’d been in our house without us being there, but also that she didn’t mention to us before or after that she had let herself in or why. It is absolutely ok to have boundaries for your own home, maybe even more so with people who think they’re entitled to be there regardless of your wishes.

Sennelier1 · 30/12/2022 19:15

My inlaws have always made passive-agressive remarks about my cleaning (not frequent enough, not thorough enough). They lived in a small house with her parents (so 4 adults) and one child (my husband. They cleaned every nook and cranny every week - or so they claimed. I clean whenever something needs cleaning. My house is tidy, clean and healthy. Also, we (me, DH and 2 DC) shower and put on clean clothes daily. My inlaws not so, once a week at the best. My DH always supported me, spoke up for me and our family. But they always claimed they were so much tidier than me because they went through the whole house weekly. Then they died, and I had to empty the house. Those oh-so-clean people were not clean at all. I found very old and grimy stuff in every drawer and every cupboard. Nothing was really clean, you know the feeling when a greasy plate has only been rinsed in cold water, not washed with hot water and Fairy? That! And in grandma's old room there were rolls of fabric, old papers, old clothes, all moth eaten and mouldy. Drawers were filled with everything from hundreds of old playingcards, old keys, hundreds of elastic bands, buttons, shoelaces, old greasy combs to discarded glasses and used batteries. Everything fitted in like 3D jigsaw puzzles. I had to wear rubber gloves I was so disgusted by the grime. When my husband saw all this he was in shock, he really never knew. So I'm telling you, those the loudest in claiming how clean everything is at their place could véry well have something to hide.

Sainte · 30/12/2022 18:05

Dear Toomuch - sorry you are feeling it’s only a female situation. Just not my lived experience as I had a house proud Father who would often hoover and tidy if he thought it needed.
Don't think we’ll ever agree on this.
(Think OP needs her husband to be a go between, perhaps that’s where the harmony lies)
I wish you a Happy New Year ( if that’s ok? )

Pitpatwaddlepat · 30/12/2022 18:03

I once watched my ( judgemental, emotional) mother in law clean my sister in law's already clean house for her. Anyway, after MIL cleaned, she said "when SIL gets home, she will think she has the best mother in law. No one would ever do this for me". So it was nothing to do with SIL being dirty or anything.

toomuchlaundry · 30/12/2022 17:55

@Sainte because it’s my home and my cupboards are arranged how I like them. OP’s house was clean. OP told MIL not to go into the house. Why should OP be pleased that MIL did something she didn’t want her to do?

Why should a MIL (or DM) have a right to go into someone’s else house and start rearranging/tidying it to the way they want it with no regard to the actual people who live in the house?

I’ve also asked this before why is it only women who do this? Are their lives so empty or have they been brain washed/conditioned to think that cleaning is their role in life. Will the next generation of DMs and MILs do this? Fine to help if asked but if you do something that someone doesn’t want you to do, it isn’t helping

Sainte · 30/12/2022 17:45

Providing she doesn’t ‘swear’ I can cope with almost anything but never ‘potty mouth’
Im still confused as to why you would be upset with In-laws cleaning, tidying etc for you.

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 30/12/2022 17:36

Palaver1 · 30/12/2022 17:33

I'm dreading being a mother in law.

Just try not to be a cunt and you'll be fine.

Palaver1 · 30/12/2022 17:33

I'm dreading being a mother in law.

Janecat23 · 30/12/2022 17:13

😱😱😱

aloris · 30/12/2022 16:46

"My DH's grandma once bought me and his cousins matching thongs! 🙈"

This is no big deal. It was probably just a 'buy 3, get 1 free' sale. She simply has an eye for a great deal.

Just kidding.

MrsRonaldWeasley · 30/12/2022 16:43

@SamosaChaat you win! 🙈🤣🤣🤣

SamosaChaat · 30/12/2022 16:41

Janecat23 · 29/12/2022 18:14

My MIL tidied my underwear draw after we gave them our bedroom when they came to stay. I throw it all in the draw anyhow and opened it to find all my bras and knickers carefully folded…. It felt like a scene from a horror film!! Beat that!!!

My DH's grandma once bought me and his cousins matching thongs! 🙈

toomuchlaundry · 30/12/2022 16:27

I don't think it is particularly British to not want people (family or not) rearranging cupboards in you own home. There are some cultures where daughters/DILs have no say in their own home but I don't think we should be aspiring towards that attitude

threatmatrix · 30/12/2022 16:16

mathanxiety · 30/12/2022 15:27

@threatmatrix

If it's fine and dandy to pick up and put away other people's clothes, open their drawers and closets, and clean out their fridges, would you be happy if the person who holds your spare key took it upon herself to let herself into your home and do this favour for you whenever you were away? Is there any difference between a random neighbour and a family member?

This is why I said typically British, we are a strange lot so protective of our cupboards and drawers. To answer your question if someone has a key to my home then they are 100% trusted. I couldn’t give to fecks as long as my house was cleaned.

toomuchlaundry · 30/12/2022 16:09

But friends don’t come and clean my house and rearrange cupboards so why should my MIL (or DM)

aloris · 30/12/2022 16:05

"I think it’s a lovely thing to do. I’m a mum of 2 adult sons. And think mum of sons get the short straw too often. She’s only being kind and helpful. Don’t take it the wrong way by reading into it. She probably just wants to be your friend. "

That's what I thought too, until she went in my and my husband's dressers and made it clear that she had seen the very private things in there, and showed absolutely no awareness that it was inappropriate and an invasion of my privacy. Bonkers.

mathanxiety · 30/12/2022 15:29

@isthewashingdryyet

Absolutely agree with your comments.

mathanxiety · 30/12/2022 15:27

@threatmatrix

If it's fine and dandy to pick up and put away other people's clothes, open their drawers and closets, and clean out their fridges, would you be happy if the person who holds your spare key took it upon herself to let herself into your home and do this favour for you whenever you were away? Is there any difference between a random neighbour and a family member?

toomuchlaundry · 30/12/2022 14:46

@Sainte have you missed the bit where MIL can be aggressive, not sure her family door of kindness is open!

threatmatrix · 30/12/2022 14:35

orchid220 · 30/12/2022 14:24

If you have a cleaner why would you be "over the moon"?

Because then I wouldn’t have to pay a cleaner. Mil didn’t charge 🤦🏼‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread