Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In laws cleaned our house while away....

465 replies

ohnnoclean · 28/12/2022 08:22

We were away for Christmas. In laws have our key for emergencies. The night before we left, in laws came round. I was in the middle of packing and a lot of things were everywhere ( but the house wasn't actually dirty ).

MIL kept saying, ' don't worry about cleaning the house before you leave, you won't have time '.. ( she's been asking me whether I was packed to go for about a week before I left. I don't pack a week early. I tend to pack the day before and I always manage fine. I travel a lot and always have and have traveled with my kids a lot too, so I do know what I'm doing..

Anyhow, the house wasn't dirty, there was just clothes everywhere as I was packing. MIL kept repeating I should not worry about cleaning.. kind of annoyed me, as it wasn't dirty. But OK.. I ignored it. She then said she'd come and clean while we were away. I said no don't worry at all, it's not dirty..

Of course, we got back and it's clearly been cleaned a bit ( fridge has been cleaned, for example ). Of course I'm grateful and I've said thanks. But I'm really uncomfortable with it. I assume she thinks I'm a dirty cow of course. Just the way she kept saying I shouldn't worry about cleaning - when it wasn't really dirty. The fact she was here when we were not here and the fact I had declined the offer of her cleaning my house.. it's annoyed me. I won't start a fight over it, but next time we go away, this can't happen.

OP posts:
Cocolapew · 28/12/2022 11:05

From the update it definitely is a control thing, my mil was the screaming, crying typ too.

Notimeforaname · 28/12/2022 11:04

I cleaned it more for me, than the mum. Perhaps your MIL was doing the same. Is she a particularly tidy and neat person in her own home ?

Notimeforaname · 28/12/2022 11:03

Ugh,I did this once and embarrassed the hell out of the lady. I was babysitting for a child I worked with in a school(the parents worked a lot) when I got there the place was in bits. Breakfast still in the pan from the morning, clothes ,books and toys piled up everywhere.
Child fell asleep very quickly and I didn't want to be sitting around nothing so I cleaned. When the mum came home she looked absolutely mortified and mumbled a thank you.

I'll never do it again. I realised how invadey of personal space it was.

toomuchlaundry · 28/12/2022 10:56

@Stunningscreamer doesn't the MIL sound lovely from the OP’s latest update. A kind caring thoughtful MIL. A cupboard rearranger in someone else’s house is very rarely doing it to be kind and caring.

@ohnnoclean I would be changing the locks and giving a responsible neighbour a key for emergency purposes only

JenniferBarkley · 28/12/2022 10:54

If she'd wiped down the counters and run the hoover around that would be one thing. But rearranging someone else's cupboards is really really weird.

Would you do hers next time you're round? Grin

ohnnoclean · 28/12/2022 10:53

OneMomentPlease · 28/12/2022 10:48

OP why do you keep saying you’re grateful for something that has clearly upset you? You don’t have to accept this behavior (whatever the intention behind it) and if you don’t say anything to MIL it will happen again and escalate.

FWIW this would drive me insane and I was very clear with MIL the one time she ignored me over something like this. It’s intrusive and infantalising, I’m guessing she wouldn’t do this to a friend or neighbour’s house?

Your children are young and I would urge you to set your boundaries now. If you’re ‘nice’ and let things go it’s much harder to redress as the patterns of behavior are set.

Because I don't want to start an argument with MIL. I want to keep the peace, we've had many horrible arguments in the past about stuff like this.

It won't help. It will just make her lash out.

Next time, we will subtly be more clear about her not coming her whilst we are gone. Or we will subtly take the key away with some other excuse and then forget to return it. MIL is pretty aggressive and will cry and scram and shout about how ungrateful and sensitive I am, if I say anything about this. I don't want to play into her hands.

OP posts:
Stunningscreamer · 28/12/2022 10:52

toomuchlaundry · 28/12/2022 10:48

@Stunningscreamer but where does it stop? Rearranging cupboards is not necessary in someone else’s home. Also when tidying and sorting through cupboards in my own home inevitability there will be probably something that I will get rid of. You don’t normally just shuffle stuff round

Well that's you when you're doing things. It's not what happened here and is just aimed to be inflammatory.

maeveiscurious · 28/12/2022 10:50

This is a hard no from me. I had a MIL a who started this as soon as I married my DH. We asked her to stop, but the level of interference got out of hand.

The "help" she provided was random and sometimes destructive unintentionally.

Over the years it's led to bad feelings on both sides. Better you start as you mean to go on.

RichardsGear · 28/12/2022 10:49

Mirabai · 28/12/2022 10:35

Cleaning a property you’ve stayed is just basic good manners.

The MIL hasn't stayed there though?

OneMomentPlease · 28/12/2022 10:48

OP why do you keep saying you’re grateful for something that has clearly upset you? You don’t have to accept this behavior (whatever the intention behind it) and if you don’t say anything to MIL it will happen again and escalate.

FWIW this would drive me insane and I was very clear with MIL the one time she ignored me over something like this. It’s intrusive and infantalising, I’m guessing she wouldn’t do this to a friend or neighbour’s house?

Your children are young and I would urge you to set your boundaries now. If you’re ‘nice’ and let things go it’s much harder to redress as the patterns of behavior are set.

toomuchlaundry · 28/12/2022 10:48

@Stunningscreamer but where does it stop? Rearranging cupboards is not necessary in someone else’s home. Also when tidying and sorting through cupboards in my own home inevitability there will be probably something that I will get rid of. You don’t normally just shuffle stuff round

ohnnoclean · 28/12/2022 10:47

Sceptre86 · 28/12/2022 10:45

You are different people. Clothes everywhere equals messy in my book. She did a nice thing from her point of view and it's the kind of thing my mum would do but I wouldn't like it either. Tell her the truth, that it felt like she was judging your standards and you'd prefer if she did not do it again.

Have you never had to repack a suitcase before ? Therefore taking clothes out and so temporarily having them out ?

She's definitely not cleaner than I am.

OP posts:
DecayedStrumpet · 28/12/2022 10:46

Mirabai · 28/12/2022 10:35

Cleaning a property you’ve stayed is just basic good manners.

Uh huh... and what is it when you clean a property which you've been given an emergency-only key to and specifically been told not to clean?

Sceptre86 · 28/12/2022 10:45

You are different people. Clothes everywhere equals messy in my book. She did a nice thing from her point of view and it's the kind of thing my mum would do but I wouldn't like it either. Tell her the truth, that it felt like she was judging your standards and you'd prefer if she did not do it again.

Walkaround · 28/12/2022 10:45

Mil wants to feel relevant and useful - perfectly valid feelings and sensitivities. Ds and dil want to feel respected as competent and capable - also perfectly valid feelings and sensitivities. Sometimes people get things a bit wrong, because they are only seeing things from their own perspective, rather than making an effort to understand the other person’s point of view. To interpret an action as being judgemental is a pretty self-centred response, as it focuses exclusively on how it has made the recipient feel (due to their own feelings and sensitivities), and doesn’t express any real interest in whether that was the real motivation for the action. I’m sure there are deeply damaged people out there who deliberately do things simply in order to demonstrate how judgemental they feel about other human beings, but most people are muddling along, trying to feel relevant in relatively innocuous ways, not deliberately sending unpleasant, loaded messages about how superior they feel to others.

Stunningscreamer · 28/12/2022 10:44

What about if she had thrown some things away or taken to a charity as she didn’t think they were necessary anymore, in the guise of being helpful, would that be okay?

Why invent things that didn't happen? Almost as if you're trying to wind up the OP.

Dahliasrule · 28/12/2022 10:43

My DMIL when she came to stay was always cleaning and tidying. I mean, she would always re clean the bath! Obviously, I would have given it a good clean before MIL came to stay. I realised over the years this was her way of showing love. She wasn’t a cuddler, didn’t play with the grandkids etc. but if anything needed doing she was there. I loved her for it. Try to see it this way.

toomuchlaundry · 28/12/2022 10:39

And if your cupboards had been rearranged @PlinkPlonkFizz? Is that helpful? What about if she had thrown some things away or taken to a charity as she didn’t think they were necessary anymore, in the guise of being helpful, would that be okay?

Do you go and rearrange cupboards at other people’s houses without them asking you?

Why is deemed okay for MILs to come in and rearrange their son’s house and DILs should just be grateful

FancyFelix · 28/12/2022 10:39

It’s amazing the people twisting themselves in knots to say that because they like it, OP needs to like it also.

This

Stunningscreamer · 28/12/2022 10:36

ohnnoclean · 28/12/2022 09:42

I always like to leave my house clean and tidy when I go away. I always do it. There's nothing worse than coming back to a dirty / messy house. So I made sure I left it that way, no matter what she said. That's my preference.

In terms of being judged. I'm not the only one who thinks we may have been judged. My husband is also a bit Confused about it and would have preferred if it hadn't happened. Those are our feelings and they're perfectly valid I think. Will I show that to MIL ? No. Just letting it go. It was a nice gesture, but probably there's some judgement there too.

That's true but there are also a lot of people who think it was just a kind gesture. And of those who agree with you, many seem to have an agenda of nightmare in laws/parents.

Without a backstory of controlling and interfering behaviour then I don't really get why you leap to the idea that someone is being judgmental by offering a kind gesture. You could then say that anyone who ever offers to help is only doing so because they think you're incompetent in some way. Which is a really sad way to think in my view.

For what it's worth, I never had anyone help me with the children or cleaning when I had young children and I might think it was a nice gesture to help as a surprise (definitely not rummuging in drawers or wash baskets though). I think it's part of trying to be family minded. But you don't seem to want to see it in any other way but negatively, which is a shame in my view.

Mirabai · 28/12/2022 10:35

RichardsGear · 28/12/2022 10:16

Or MIL stop being overbearing and ignoring boundaries?

Cleaning a property you’ve stayed is just basic good manners.

PlinkPlonkFizz · 28/12/2022 10:31

What a wonderfully kind gesture from your MIL. If I returned from holidays to a clean house I'd be very grateful TBH.

harrassedmumto3 · 28/12/2022 10:31

She was obviously planning it as a little surprise while you were away. She meant well I think.

Cocolapew · 28/12/2022 10:29

How the fuck is someone coming into your house and rearranging a cupboard "helpful"?
The op had already said no, she's also said it wasn't dirty or messy.
Mil didn't need to come in, her 'help' wasn't wanted, and she knew that but carried on regardless.

Fizbosshoes · 28/12/2022 10:29

I always felt judged by MIL whether she meant it or not.
She probably was trying to be helpful. She never asked "what can I do to help " she decided what she thought needed doing or would give her the most satisfaction (she enjoyed housework!)
When Dc were very little, weeding the garden, rearranging kitchen utensils or tidying but creating a pile of toys that needed sorting/putting away later were actually not high on my agenda, I'd have preferred a half an hour break from my kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread