Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried for the woman living in the flat above me

80 replies

refuge123 · 28/12/2022 02:22

I live in a flat. About an hour ago, in the early hours of morning I could hear a man aggresively yelling at a woman in a foreign language, and the woman crying and screaming in response in terror, with banging. They have a baby, who rarely cries. I phoned 999 who attended, but because the tenants didnt answer the door, there was nothing they could do. Ive been told to phone back if it starts again and that ive done the right thing. They took my details and left.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cinecitta · 29/12/2022 13:58

refuge123 · 28/12/2022 19:05

I spoke to the woman, she was going out. I asked if she heard anything and she said no, but also said theres shouting all the time in the the building and just to ignore it. Which doesnt make any sense. I asked again if they heard anything anf they said no. So I just left it at that and rung 101 to update who are coming to my flat ive explained I dont need that but they said they have to as its a domestic situation.

I am sorry but you went around it the wrong way. You don’t go up to someone you suspect have been abused and ask them if they heard something like shouting. What do you think she will answer to that?
Your question seems intrusive and she will think you are only asking it because you are irritated by the shouting noises and not because you are concerned about someone’s safety and want to help.
You have to approach it in a totally different manner that will put her at ease. If you are not skilled at that, ask someone else who will know how to do that.

NewBootsAndRanty · 28/12/2022 19:57

I think you've done just about everything you can then. If you speak to her again, maybe ask if she's ok, rather than whether she heard anything.

Hopefully the police will have better advice when they come back.

refuge123 · 28/12/2022 19:18

NewBootsAndRanty · 28/12/2022 19:12

Do you mean you spoke to the woman who you're worried about?

Yes

OP posts:
NewBootsAndRanty · 28/12/2022 19:12

Do you mean you spoke to the woman who you're worried about?

refuge123 · 28/12/2022 19:05

I spoke to the woman, she was going out. I asked if she heard anything and she said no, but also said theres shouting all the time in the the building and just to ignore it. Which doesnt make any sense. I asked again if they heard anything anf they said no. So I just left it at that and rung 101 to update who are coming to my flat ive explained I dont need that but they said they have to as its a domestic situation.

OP posts:
HotChoxs · 28/12/2022 16:47

Redglitter · 28/12/2022 10:36

Oh apologies yeah you're right I made that up. I've only been dealing with calls like that for over 20 years

Situations are assessed on the basis of the information given. Your neighbour lied & made the situation sound worse than it was but there was clearly something wrong in your flat because there was water leaking from it. For all they knew the shouting & banging could have been someone falling & shouting for help.

They wouldn't have come out for the water alone, if they'd come out purely for the shouting & banging & got no reply they'd have left like they did in the OPs situation. Add in both factors in your neighbours call & it increases the possibility of something having happened
& they'd err on the side of caution incase someone was now lying unconscious beside the bath etc

In the OP they had one single report of a disturbance. No sign of it when they got there. Can you imagine the outcry if someone posted on here that Police had smashed their door in at 3am terrifying them & their children because a neighbour whos a known fantasist & busybody had called to report a disturbance in your house when in actual fact you'd all been asleep for hours.

Its all about looking at what you know & assessing it accordingly

Bloody hell that was longer than I meant it to be

That's interesting. I think if I ever hear anything like this (and hopefully I won't) my first thought will be to try to record it while calling the police.

ThinWomansBrain · 28/12/2022 16:41

Have you heard any normal moving about/conversation noises from above through the day OP?
I once had similar with a neighbouring flat, and it is unsettling - the police came, but there was little they could do.

Assuming that she is OK, make a point of speaking to the woman when you next see her, in case she is feeling isolated.
Good luck, I hope it was a one off.

anyolddinosaur · 28/12/2022 16:28

Police probably checking if anyone else heard a disturbance and if anyone has seen them today.

refuge123 · 28/12/2022 16:26

They came back out but the people living in the flat still didnt answer. I could see they spoke to neighbouring flats who did answer. Not sure what the details of the conversation was though.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/12/2022 12:16

I lived in a block of flats once, and was horrified when the nosy old biddy in the flat below called the police when my husband and I were having a row. It was just shouting, and throwing things around. She was being malicious and totally ridiculous. We are a middle class, respectable professional couple having an old fashioned argument about what colour to paint the walls. We were both more livid with the biddy than each other afterwards

Christ Almighty, you'd have fitted in perfectly in the block of flats I used to live in when I was 19. As the scummy couple who needed the police calling because they were fucking fighting again.

SirVixofVixHall · 28/12/2022 11:58

I agree OP you did the right thing.
I hope that the woman and baby are ok.

CatherineNotSoMuch · 28/12/2022 11:58

Do you know if she has family locally OP? Is she on Facebook? If you genuinely feel you heard her screaming in terror and the police are politely knocking on her door I'd be trying to find someone else.

This comes from someone who has close knowledge of police politely knocking on a door and returning multiple times, while she lay dead and covered in blood.

Passmethecrisps · 28/12/2022 11:55

You did absolutely the right thing OP. I have done it myself when living in a flat. 2am on new year and there was the most hideous noise from the flat above. He was shouting, she was screaming in absolute terror and it sounded like furniture was being tipped over. He was an objectionable man in any circumstances but there was no way I could listen to that. The police were there in minutes (hand break turn in the carpark) and frankly the knock at the door brooked no argument.

I have no idea what the outcome was but it all went terribly quiet after. I hope that the woman was able to relax a tiny amount knowing that someone in the block was looking out for her.

I hope you are ok now, OP. It’s a horrible thing to have to deal with.

been and done it. · 28/12/2022 11:51

mamabear715 · 28/12/2022 04:47

Is there only me horrified that the police basically did nothing?
He could have had her in a choke hold or anything.. :-0

I thought the same.

Tinner01 · 28/12/2022 11:51

yadaya · 28/12/2022 08:47

I wish my sister's neighbours had called the police when they heard a professional, middle class couple arguing loudly and throwing things around ...... then maybe she'd still be alive.

They didn't and instead my nephew found her body the morning after.

Loud shouty arguments are not normal
Throwing things around when arguing is not normal
Domestic violence happens to professional, middle class people too.

This. Arguments are healthy, one person (especially a man) screaming abuse at another is not. You did the right thing OP. I’m very sorry about your sister 💐😢

Toddlerteaplease · 28/12/2022 11:49

AgathaX · 28/12/2022 07:01

Bloody hell, shouting and throwing things because of a paint colour disagreement?

Was about to say the same. That is not normal!

Toddlerteaplease · 28/12/2022 11:48

@NewBootsAndRanty babies that rarely cry can be a sign of neglect/ abuse. As they learn that if they cry, no one comes or have been hurt if they do cry. Obviously not in all cases, some babies just are quiet babies with no other issues.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/12/2022 11:44

Swimmingistoocold · Today 06:57
Don’t you think you’re wasting police time though? Every couple has raised voice arguments. It’s healthy.“

No they don’t and no it isn’t. It’s quite possible for adults to disagree and resolve without resorting to screaming and shouting.

ButterBastardBeans · 28/12/2022 11:41

I'm shocked to find that middle class professional people don't have heated arguments. I had no idea.

TossieFleacake · 28/12/2022 11:41

@Swimmingistoocold

Are you a counsellor?
Please stop speaking on behalf of the whole profession and speaking utter bullshit while you're at it.
Counsellors look at each client as an individual, there are very few sweeping judgements or assumptions made so your previous comments about 'all counsellors' are untrue.

monsteramunch · 28/12/2022 11:30

@Swimmingistoocold

You can't really think that shouting and throwing stuff around is a healthy way of interacting with a partner?

It's almost worse if you've been together for so many years as having that level of blazing row over some paint, despite sharing a life for nearly three decades, really doesn't make it sound like a healthy relationship in any way.

No decent counsellor would say that screaming and shouting and throwing stuff is a healthy way to disagree.

Surprised you don't seem to believe that.

Alaimo · 28/12/2022 11:16

Years ago I heard lots of shouting and banging from the flat above mine. I could only hear a woman's voice, but I still called the police. Similar situation, the woman didn't open the door.

Police knocked on my door after and said they wouldn't do any further checks, but to call if it happened again. I moved soon after so don't know if it did ever occur again.

In your situation, I'd not hesitate if it happens again though. I prefer to let the police responders decide whether it's worth a visit or not.

FeltCarrot · 28/12/2022 11:10

Redglitter · 28/12/2022 03:59

They'll possibly come back in the morning & try again. I know if we had a call like that there's no way it'd get written off as no reply to the door. We'd reattend & keep reattending until we spoke to the residents

The Police do have the power to open the door but not in the circumstances you've outlined. If there was no noise & no reply they've got no grounds to. You could be a neighbour or an ex with a grudge & making it up. If the Police arrived while they were shouting & got no reply they'd most certainly put the door in

The police battered my dd’s flat door down when someone reported violent shouting coming from their flat. No one was home and it was the middle of the day.

twanmever · 28/12/2022 11:07

@refuge123 you definitely did the right thing. I hope they come back today and manage to speak to her. Well done for being brave enough to get involved.

twanmever · 28/12/2022 11:03

Swimmingistoocold · 28/12/2022 07:18

Never had a blazing row? Never? I think you’ll find most counsellors will tell you the occasional blazing row is a sign of a healthy relationship. We’ve been married for 27 years now.

If we're playing longevity upmanship, we've been together since 1980 and still haven't had a single blazing row. Healthy conflict isn't necessarily shouting and throwing things you know.