Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL reaction to our proposal to begin fostering children. AIBU to find this upsetting?

562 replies

Happypomegranate · 27/12/2022 22:41

We FaceTimed our in-laws on Xmas day and mentioned our intention to apply to become foster carers. This is something we have both wanted to do for years, but have been previously unable due to work commitments and living in a small flat. We’ve been very fortunate and we now live in a big house and we are financially secure enough that I don’t have to work. I still do a little bit of part time care work but can give this up to focus on fostering. MIL initially said she thought our DD was too young which is a fair point to make. We have a toddler and will not be having anymore biological children. I said we would discuss with the LA but we could wait until DD was in school if necessary but that we just wanted to get the ball rolling as we know how long these things can take. But it later became apparent that she was very against the idea of us fostering at any point in the future and I don’t believe my DD’s age has anything to do with it. She used language such as ‘it will be someone you don’t know’, ‘there could be problems’, and ‘troubled children’. We have done our research and we are aware that the children may have additional needs, mental health and/or behavioural problems, but every child in need of a foster placement is different and I feel it’s not right to stereotype. As for children that may come with challenges, I feel it would be our job as the foster parents to try and work through the challenges with the children. I don’t understand why she doesn’t want us to support vulnerable children, it’s just bizarre to me. It hurts because I had an extremely abusive childhood, struggled with mental health in my early adulthood and I’ve worked really hard to get to a place where I am happy, stable and resilient. I feel I could have a lot to give as a foster carer. My DH is lovely and a great dad, and I believe he’d be a fantastic foster carer but he had a drastically different upbringing from me. Think well to-do, independent school, etc. We are an unlikely but very happy pair. I thought she would be supportive but she’s actively against it and I’m not sure why it bothers me so much because it’s ultimately my and my husbands decision to apply, not hers. AIBU to be upset?

OP posts:
Ch3wylemon · 29/12/2022 11:53

I can imagine it's hard for a foster child to read that biological children have been negatively impacted by foster children.

OP you didn't make the decisions when you were a child. The adults did. And if any biological children were affected that's on their parents and not you. You weren't responsible and can't repair it. Nor should you.

What you can do is to protect your own child by giving her a safe and secure home to grow up in.

Nordix · 29/12/2022 10:59

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 10:33

You don't know if the op would have resilience or not, she's a stranger behind a screen.

Having a kid until the afternoon when you've said you won't keep them past the morning is not hard. It's easy to say you're leaving them at the contact centre at 10am and going away for the weekend straight afterwards, if it came to it. There's no law against it. I've seen it done.

If you don’t want them in your house for another night because you aren’t equipped to manage the situation safety, and you have another sleepless night, it’s hard. And isn’t it sad that it comes to carers dropping kids at the contact centre and leaving? Social services shouldn’t be so incompetent that it has to be handled in such an unpleasant way. But they push it and push it.

My impression of OP was she’s already being very defensive of foster children because she was one herself, so might be too soft to take action to protect her existing child. But of course we can’t know. SS will make an assessment of whether she can foster, but no one can force her to consider the wellbeing of her existing child.

Mouk · 29/12/2022 10:51

I work with fostering link social workers and I'd tend to agree with your MIL. Chances are with your childhood, you may not be approved as carers. The assessments and studies before you are even approved are very very detailed and probing.

I admire you for considering to become carers, I really do. They are crying out for carers where I live. But in saying that, the social workers themselves would say "don't do it". Unless a newborn or baby are placed in your care, it's a hard hard job to do.

Also, it wouldn't be your job as the foster parents to try and work through the challenges with the children. Leave that to the trained professionals.

LlynTegid · 29/12/2022 10:41

YANBU in my opinion to be upset. If your MIL had said you should do your research and be aware, very different from her opposition.

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 10:36

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 10:30

Maybe when she’s 34 you’ll hear a different story about how your calling affected your children.

I doubt it. My grandparents both died without being told the truth. They may have wondered by the various clues, son more distant with them, became an atheist, grandchildren kept a bit of a distance. But they were never actually confronted. (On earth anyway)

Well, I suppose that’s possible too. I guess that’s why it’s not a great idea to listen to the parents about how much foster kids benefit the kids in the house and how the calling is great for the biological family kids - because they simply don’t know.

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 10:34

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 10:29

That's unjustified. You can't know that.

Not to me. For me lying to get access to vulnerable kids because it’s ‘your calling’ and satisfies a religious interest for you is not actually placing the needs of the children (including your own) at the highest point.

RandomSunday · 29/12/2022 10:33

@Redcisco

Perfectly said. My youngest DS was 13 when I had my first foster placement. A 5 year old, who was on her 3rd foster placement, that should have been a big red flag. I was as green as grass, at the time and saw no red flags. Within 3 months I was at my wits end and discussed quitting, with my SSW. My teenager didn’t know what had hit him and I felt so guilty. His world was turned upside down. I won’t go into details as to why a 5 year old had severe behavioural problems. Let’s just say her previous home life was not pretty. By the time SS agreed the child needed specialised input, DS had left for university so I continued fostering.

@jamoncrumpets

There are plenty of threads here dedicated to Logan, with posters who knew him. Why would MN remove them? Do you think child murderers live on a planet where nobody knows them?

Do you think CM is a 14 year old you would be happy to bring into your home to live with a 2 year old?

There are plenty of CM’s in the fostering world. They just haven’t gone as far as he did. They cause misery for people around them too. There are also some lovely 14 year olds. My first 14 year old (well 13 at the time of placement) still visits me now. He got his life together, after a tough start, and joined the RAF. Neither his parents, extended family or anyone from SS (His corporate parents) went to watch his passing out parade. So I did. Im so bloody proud of him.

The problem with fostering with small children is you never know what you’re going to get. Ignore the poster who says foster carers don’t have to take them. The fact is the FC doesn’t get the relevant info about a proposed placement. Very often SS don’t have any info because the child was not, previously, known to them. Other times they won’t tell you because they know you won’t take them once you have the facts. And once they’re in it’s extremely difficult to get them back out. SS are not interested in the FC or their DC.

All everyone here is trying to do is give OP the benefit of their experience within their world of Children's Services so she can make the decision whether to apply.

I wouldn’t with a young child - Based on my own real life experiences of fostering. OP can make her own decision.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 10:33

Nordix · 29/12/2022 09:43

@Reindeersnooker SS can pressure you VERY hard, and it takes a very resilient foster carer to stand up for themselves and say “you’re picking the child up now or I’m dropping them at the town hall.” And even then SS will say “okay we’re picking them up in the morning.” And then come the following afternoon. So it’s not true to say it’s ridiculous that you’d have someone in your home that you don’t want - of course it happens. I’m getting the impression OP doesn’t have that kind of resilience and ability to stand up to SS when needed, either.

I think you’re being a bit disingenuous, there are plenty of foster carers who can tell you how very hard it can be to get SS to end a placement. Maybe your LA is better than others.

And fair enough to say “If you say you won't take that child, they don't turn up with the child”, but they can and do completely lie about a child’s background in order to get them housed, and place children in homes which aren’t suitable (outside the approved age range/approved number of kids). SS are very good at pressure tactics.

You don't know if the op would have resilience or not, she's a stranger behind a screen.

Having a kid until the afternoon when you've said you won't keep them past the morning is not hard. It's easy to say you're leaving them at the contact centre at 10am and going away for the weekend straight afterwards, if it came to it. There's no law against it. I've seen it done.

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 10:30

Maybe when she’s 34 you’ll hear a different story about how your calling affected your children.

I doubt it. My grandparents both died without being told the truth. They may have wondered by the various clues, son more distant with them, became an atheist, grandchildren kept a bit of a distance. But they were never actually confronted. (On earth anyway)

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 10:29

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 10:25

It does strike me that @Petros9 is so in favour of op fostering though - because they’re very similar. In both cases it isn’t really about foster children. It’s MY calling. MY trauma. I want, I need. With no thought to the obvious issues.

That's unjustified. You can't know that.

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 10:25

It does strike me that @Petros9 is so in favour of op fostering though - because they’re very similar. In both cases it isn’t really about foster children. It’s MY calling. MY trauma. I want, I need. With no thought to the obvious issues.

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 10:24

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 08:25

This is the other side of the coin perhaps and we have not seen any positive voices on this thread from the birth children of foster carers.

On the subject of research, I had a look at a couple of pieces, one at www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=scholarworks.smith.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi%3Farticle%3D1892%26context%3Dtheses&ved=2ahUKEwirhNrsrZ78AhWjQUEAHZYSBxkQFnoECBMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0soXB-7VFHZuQW1PaBD2Xu and another at www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=repository.canterbury.ac.uk/download/afae3df1404f870cb70dcb56bb3b04677d18f93340ab87aeb10b8165e4984743/1064026/Presentation%2520for%2520Biological%2520Children%2520in%2520Foster%2520Families%2520final%2520version1.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwirhNrsrZ78AhWjQUEAHZYSBxkQFnoECBoQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1YOw9b_qVOJtoQjOwDp5YM.

Sorry for long links. One theme that resonated with me was to do with foster children's families building stronger relationships within their family group- they pull together in the face of challenges. Maybe a case of adversity making you stronger.

Lots to consider on this thread and a range of views, often well-informed, and mostly negative about the idea of fostering when your own children are young. Even as one if the positive voices, I accept that there are perils and drawbacks. I'm glad we did it, my children reflect on it in a generally positive way (though I accept that may change over time, or that the things they say to me are not the full story)- but ultimately it was a Christian calling that we chose to accept.

But your children aren’t likely to be actually honest, are they? They’re not going to say ‘I know this was your religious calling that you were so obsessive about that it didn’t matter whether it benefitted us, and you’d even lie to social workers to fulfil it, but actually we thought it was shit.’

Your child is mid-teens. In the same way she wouldn’t come out and say ‘I hate church’ she won’t fly in the face of your beliefs. Maybe when she’s 34 you’ll hear a different story about how your calling affected your children.

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 10:15

My father lived in a family who fostered since he was around 9 or ten. His siblings were younger.
He's very clear that whilst they felt sorry for the foster children, all his biological siblings and him suffered. He acknowledges a lingering resentment, but if you look at the way he deals with confrontation or danger I'm pretty certain there is deep trauma too. His youngest sibling is an alcoholic and emotionally unstable. His other sibling married a man at sixteen who got prosecuted as a pedophile and went to jail in her mind twenties. I do wonder if there is a link.
My grandma was adopted herself and did it for similar reasons to the op. However, interestingly enough all the siblings agree she was cold and cruel to the kids, and created a weird us Vs them dynamic. She was also deeply religious and would have considered it a calling but her children would not describe her actual behind closed doors behaviour as very Christian or kind.
It's all a bit sad because as my dad is placid and well adjusted he never said anything to his parents so they'd be walking around talking about how their children had no problems and benefited from it. He just got very good at masking his true feelings. A habit he has carried through life and I wish I could rid him of because it's not healthy for him.
The reality of it is you have to be a very special person to withstand the realities of fostering and do a good job. Social services are desperate and people with a good understanding of their own limitations won't do it. It's a perfect storm for.things to go wrong.

Nordix · 29/12/2022 09:43

@Reindeersnooker SS can pressure you VERY hard, and it takes a very resilient foster carer to stand up for themselves and say “you’re picking the child up now or I’m dropping them at the town hall.” And even then SS will say “okay we’re picking them up in the morning.” And then come the following afternoon. So it’s not true to say it’s ridiculous that you’d have someone in your home that you don’t want - of course it happens. I’m getting the impression OP doesn’t have that kind of resilience and ability to stand up to SS when needed, either.

I think you’re being a bit disingenuous, there are plenty of foster carers who can tell you how very hard it can be to get SS to end a placement. Maybe your LA is better than others.

And fair enough to say “If you say you won't take that child, they don't turn up with the child”, but they can and do completely lie about a child’s background in order to get them housed, and place children in homes which aren’t suitable (outside the approved age range/approved number of kids). SS are very good at pressure tactics.

jamoncrumpets · 29/12/2022 09:37

@Redcisco I had a sleepless night too as a direct result of reading this thread. I don't think the people that describing in vivid detail the abuse and suffering of small children realise can be like opening a wound for others. Particularly the details about the Logan Mwangi case. The unsubstantiated details from people supposedly living in the same place are dangerous and I really don't think @MNHQ should allow them to remain on the thread.

Nordix · 29/12/2022 09:33

@Reindeersnooker The OP is well are that victims of abuse can be abusive. But she is sensitive to the presumption that they will be because it isn't true and it's prejudiced. That's fair enough.

The OP and some other posters have latched on to “foster children are abusive” /“not all of them” , which is not what’s even being said. At all!

People aren’t saying these young children will be abusers - that is rarer. But there are a series of behaviours in foster children which negatively impact the other children in the home, to the point of causing them discomfort and trauma in their own home.

A five year old displaying oversexualised behaviour is not an abuser. But it can traumatise another child in the home. Same with false accusations, self harm, making threats, there’s a great long list of behaviour which doesn’t make a foster child an abuser - they are a small traumatised child! - but does spread the trauma to the other children in the home.

This is what OP and others are wilfully ignoring.

OP may think “oh if I foster them as a baby/very young they won’t show signs of trauma”, but you’ll be shocked how that often isn’t the case, and as the child gets older they are still so impacted by their traumatic beginning, especially if contact with the birth family is ongoing (as it almost always is).

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 09:27

I can also tell you it isn't the case that you book a particular type of child, you're right, although many younger children would fit that description and be easy enough to care for, but nor do you take who you're given for as long as it's decided. You're not speaking from personal experience. If you say you won't take that child, they don't turn up with the child. If you say you're going away for the weekend on Friday and child must be collected earlier, that will have to take the child. I've seen them do it. How ridiculous to imagine SS can force you to have someone in your home. They can pressure if you let them. They can't force you.

Nordix · 29/12/2022 09:23

Thank you @Redcisco for sharing. A very thought-provoking post which should be mandatory reading for any parent thinking of fostering while they still have young children in the home.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 09:22

FinnysTail · 29/12/2022 09:08

No I’m certainly not saying Angharad Williamson is innocent. She deserves to rot in the bowels of hell for all eternity, for her part in Logan’s suffering. There is nothing to suggest she delivered the blows that ended Logan’s life though. You believe what you want.

What I think pp is saying is OP has commented that she is pissed off when proffessionals say victims of abuse can and do go on to abuse. Craig Mulligan is proof that some children who have been abused certainly abuse others because abuse is their normal.

It would be interesting to hear the techniques OP would use if she was presented with a 14 year old abuse victim who put her in constant fear for her own and her baby daughters lives and the SW turned a blind eye.

The foster parents in this case were terrified of their foster child yet were very experienced foster parents. How would OP deal with it we’ll never know as she seems to not like the reality of fostering and has flounced.

As pp has said there will be positives to fostering. It must be very rewarding when things work out for the child but we all know there are horrors too. No foster carer is able to book a “Blond haired, blue eyed, sweet 4 year old”. They get what their given and have to live with it for however long it takes. And so do their children.

I'll believe what the courts have decided as there has been a thorough investigation and I doubt anyone but her knows better.

The OP is well are that victims of abuse can be abusive. But she is sensitive to the presumption that they will be because it isn't true and it's prejudiced. That's fair enough. What would be a problem would be if she was more trusting than another foster carer would be as a result of having less prejudice - if it made her more naïve to the detriment of her safe guarding abilities. Just having a problem with the prejudice isn't evidence of that. I wasn't abused, I have fostered and I completely see why she's a bit defensive.

Ch3wylemon · 29/12/2022 09:18

Redcisco · 29/12/2022 07:46

After posting on this thread yesterday, I was plagued by memories of my own childhood through the night - and a deep sadness that these threads come up time and time again with an op who doesn’t want to listen because they’ve got a romantic view of fostering and want to play the hero.

I know the op has flounced but thought I’d write for any other followers of this thread who might have similar ideas.

There is very little focus on the biological kids of foster parents. I’m not very sure if there’s much research into it but clearly not enough. We don’t really have a voice. Threads like these have so many of us that come along and say no don’t do it and give reasons and we barely get a response because it doesn’t fit with the narrative. Foster kids are the traumatized ones. We are the privileged ones with so much to learn and gain from the “experience”.

Time and time again we come along to say that’s not true. But our experience is minimized or ignored because someone’s friend’s cousin’s neighbours fostered and their kids are happy.

The truth is, children are not capable of containing their trauma. It spreads. When you foster, you bring it into every crevice of your home. If you are a resilient adult you may have the mechanisms to handle that, which is why there are many fantastic foster parents (with no small dc of their own at home) who do a brilliant job. They are willing to share their own safe space a vulnerable child and what a gift they give.

But EVERY child has a right to a trauma-free home. Including the biological dc. The only reason foster children are placed with families that already have children is that it solves a problem for them. What the bio dc have to lose is so much greater than what they have to learn. But they don’t have a voice so few people care.

I wrote about the attachment issues that arise as the
minimum that can happen. But it can be so much worse. It just takes one really bad placement to ruin your own dcs life.

Thank you for this thoughtful post. I too have a visceral reaction to romantic notions of fostering and adoption. Most crucially I would say that anyone who denies the issues with either their own DC or any proposed foster DC or thinks they have easy solutions to them is not cut out to foster.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 29/12/2022 09:09

Happypomegranate · 28/12/2022 17:41

Oh no. Imagine taking abuse that happened to someone as a kid and using it against them when they go on to apply to support vulnerable children. I have been through it all to become a success in my own right. I was always open to waiting until DD is older. My problem was MIL’s outright objection to the idea and nothing to do with having to wait. I’ve been breaking barriers and tearing down walls my entire life, and I will continue to do so. Checking out now. Wish me luck.

@Happypomegranate Then you best prepare yourself because the fostering agencies WILL using your past against you, when you apply! So best you get used to it now. If you don't want it used against you, don't apply. Because you will find the scrutiny you are put under to be absolutely unbearable.

FinnysTail · 29/12/2022 09:08

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 00:00

Are you saying Logan's mother is the victim of a miscarriage of justice? Because what you're saying doesn't align.

No I’m certainly not saying Angharad Williamson is innocent. She deserves to rot in the bowels of hell for all eternity, for her part in Logan’s suffering. There is nothing to suggest she delivered the blows that ended Logan’s life though. You believe what you want.

What I think pp is saying is OP has commented that she is pissed off when proffessionals say victims of abuse can and do go on to abuse. Craig Mulligan is proof that some children who have been abused certainly abuse others because abuse is their normal.

It would be interesting to hear the techniques OP would use if she was presented with a 14 year old abuse victim who put her in constant fear for her own and her baby daughters lives and the SW turned a blind eye.

The foster parents in this case were terrified of their foster child yet were very experienced foster parents. How would OP deal with it we’ll never know as she seems to not like the reality of fostering and has flounced.

As pp has said there will be positives to fostering. It must be very rewarding when things work out for the child but we all know there are horrors too. No foster carer is able to book a “Blond haired, blue eyed, sweet 4 year old”. They get what their given and have to live with it for however long it takes. And so do their children.

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 08:25

Redcisco · 29/12/2022 07:46

After posting on this thread yesterday, I was plagued by memories of my own childhood through the night - and a deep sadness that these threads come up time and time again with an op who doesn’t want to listen because they’ve got a romantic view of fostering and want to play the hero.

I know the op has flounced but thought I’d write for any other followers of this thread who might have similar ideas.

There is very little focus on the biological kids of foster parents. I’m not very sure if there’s much research into it but clearly not enough. We don’t really have a voice. Threads like these have so many of us that come along and say no don’t do it and give reasons and we barely get a response because it doesn’t fit with the narrative. Foster kids are the traumatized ones. We are the privileged ones with so much to learn and gain from the “experience”.

Time and time again we come along to say that’s not true. But our experience is minimized or ignored because someone’s friend’s cousin’s neighbours fostered and their kids are happy.

The truth is, children are not capable of containing their trauma. It spreads. When you foster, you bring it into every crevice of your home. If you are a resilient adult you may have the mechanisms to handle that, which is why there are many fantastic foster parents (with no small dc of their own at home) who do a brilliant job. They are willing to share their own safe space a vulnerable child and what a gift they give.

But EVERY child has a right to a trauma-free home. Including the biological dc. The only reason foster children are placed with families that already have children is that it solves a problem for them. What the bio dc have to lose is so much greater than what they have to learn. But they don’t have a voice so few people care.

I wrote about the attachment issues that arise as the
minimum that can happen. But it can be so much worse. It just takes one really bad placement to ruin your own dcs life.

This is the other side of the coin perhaps and we have not seen any positive voices on this thread from the birth children of foster carers.

On the subject of research, I had a look at a couple of pieces, one at www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=scholarworks.smith.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi%3Farticle%3D1892%26context%3Dtheses&ved=2ahUKEwirhNrsrZ78AhWjQUEAHZYSBxkQFnoECBMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0soXB-7VFHZuQW1PaBD2Xu and another at www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=repository.canterbury.ac.uk/download/afae3df1404f870cb70dcb56bb3b04677d18f93340ab87aeb10b8165e4984743/1064026/Presentation%2520for%2520Biological%2520Children%2520in%2520Foster%2520Families%2520final%2520version1.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwirhNrsrZ78AhWjQUEAHZYSBxkQFnoECBoQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1YOw9b_qVOJtoQjOwDp5YM.

Sorry for long links. One theme that resonated with me was to do with foster children's families building stronger relationships within their family group- they pull together in the face of challenges. Maybe a case of adversity making you stronger.

Lots to consider on this thread and a range of views, often well-informed, and mostly negative about the idea of fostering when your own children are young. Even as one if the positive voices, I accept that there are perils and drawbacks. I'm glad we did it, my children reflect on it in a generally positive way (though I accept that may change over time, or that the things they say to me are not the full story)- but ultimately it was a Christian calling that we chose to accept.

londonrach · 29/12/2022 08:13

You not usually allowed to foster a child older than your youngest child. Thinking you not thinking this through. Wait a few years

Redcisco · 29/12/2022 07:49

Them = social services *