Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL reaction to our proposal to begin fostering children. AIBU to find this upsetting?

562 replies

Happypomegranate · 27/12/2022 22:41

We FaceTimed our in-laws on Xmas day and mentioned our intention to apply to become foster carers. This is something we have both wanted to do for years, but have been previously unable due to work commitments and living in a small flat. We’ve been very fortunate and we now live in a big house and we are financially secure enough that I don’t have to work. I still do a little bit of part time care work but can give this up to focus on fostering. MIL initially said she thought our DD was too young which is a fair point to make. We have a toddler and will not be having anymore biological children. I said we would discuss with the LA but we could wait until DD was in school if necessary but that we just wanted to get the ball rolling as we know how long these things can take. But it later became apparent that she was very against the idea of us fostering at any point in the future and I don’t believe my DD’s age has anything to do with it. She used language such as ‘it will be someone you don’t know’, ‘there could be problems’, and ‘troubled children’. We have done our research and we are aware that the children may have additional needs, mental health and/or behavioural problems, but every child in need of a foster placement is different and I feel it’s not right to stereotype. As for children that may come with challenges, I feel it would be our job as the foster parents to try and work through the challenges with the children. I don’t understand why she doesn’t want us to support vulnerable children, it’s just bizarre to me. It hurts because I had an extremely abusive childhood, struggled with mental health in my early adulthood and I’ve worked really hard to get to a place where I am happy, stable and resilient. I feel I could have a lot to give as a foster carer. My DH is lovely and a great dad, and I believe he’d be a fantastic foster carer but he had a drastically different upbringing from me. Think well to-do, independent school, etc. We are an unlikely but very happy pair. I thought she would be supportive but she’s actively against it and I’m not sure why it bothers me so much because it’s ultimately my and my husbands decision to apply, not hers. AIBU to be upset?

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 29/12/2022 16:15

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 08:25

This is the other side of the coin perhaps and we have not seen any positive voices on this thread from the birth children of foster carers.

On the subject of research, I had a look at a couple of pieces, one at www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=scholarworks.smith.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi%3Farticle%3D1892%26context%3Dtheses&ved=2ahUKEwirhNrsrZ78AhWjQUEAHZYSBxkQFnoECBMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0soXB-7VFHZuQW1PaBD2Xu and another at www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=repository.canterbury.ac.uk/download/afae3df1404f870cb70dcb56bb3b04677d18f93340ab87aeb10b8165e4984743/1064026/Presentation%2520for%2520Biological%2520Children%2520in%2520Foster%2520Families%2520final%2520version1.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwirhNrsrZ78AhWjQUEAHZYSBxkQFnoECBoQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1YOw9b_qVOJtoQjOwDp5YM.

Sorry for long links. One theme that resonated with me was to do with foster children's families building stronger relationships within their family group- they pull together in the face of challenges. Maybe a case of adversity making you stronger.

Lots to consider on this thread and a range of views, often well-informed, and mostly negative about the idea of fostering when your own children are young. Even as one if the positive voices, I accept that there are perils and drawbacks. I'm glad we did it, my children reflect on it in a generally positive way (though I accept that may change over time, or that the things they say to me are not the full story)- but ultimately it was a Christian calling that we chose to accept.

Fucking hell. You’ve given the required ‘sorry’ then got straight on to countering what the poster has said in regards to the traumatic impact her parents fostering had on her, instead of actually listening to and acknowledging something that doesn’t suit your own narrative.

whether your children’s experience was ‘worth it’ for them isn’t for you to decide. It’s for them.

Gemmanorthdevon · 29/12/2022 15:36

Happypomegranate · 27/12/2022 22:49

@Keyansier If not now then when? Having my DD did bring up some underlying trauma but I’ve have since had trauma focused therapy. I’m stable, happy, confident and resilient.

Don't you dare be put off by some of these replies. You are perfect, and you know very well the impact a positive or negative foster placement can have on a child in the middle of a shed ton of trauma.

I just wish to god some of the placements I was chucked in had an iota of personal experience, instead i got middle class SAHM'S who thought it was an easy way to earn! And 1 was downright cruel, because she just couldnt put herself in my shies.

You won't be perfect, but you seem receptive to knowing that and eager to fill the gaps in your knowledge.

Ignore the doubters, go make a difference. Good luck. 🙂

FleasNavidad · 29/12/2022 15:28

You're making a lot of assumptions there @Reindeersnooker 😅

They changed the wording because their first application was rejected on the basis that their motivation was inappropriate. That's dishonest.

"If you don't think anyone with children should foster that's up to you but you shouldn't condemn one family for doing so."

Huh 🤔 I've not condemned them and I've never said anyone with children shouldn't foster. How random.

"If you don't think Christians should foster"

Why on earth would I think that?!

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 15:20

xoxrebelxox · 29/12/2022 14:27

As a parent of children who are adopted yes it will be hard for you if you chose to do it but be honest with said children from day dot... You aren't their parent but you are their responsible adult. The woman who has adopted my children has lied to them and they call her mum but when they are older then she has an obligation and duty to tell them of their adoption and I'm waiting for the day they come find me. Good luck op, LA are crying out for decent reliable Foster carers... Not all FC'S do it for the children but the money they receive for being a FC. FC'S are meant to be highly vetted which isn't always the case as there are FC'S who abuse their Foster Child.

You don't think the woman who has adopted your children is a parent to them? That's interesting. You might want to think about that because when your children come looking for you, they may well find it easier to have a relationship with you if you can accept that they will have a loyalty to this person and perceive them as a parent. The woman hasn't done anything wrong. An adoptive parent is supposed to teach adopted children to call them Mum or Dad, and to feel everything for them that a parent would.

Stripedbag101 · 29/12/2022 15:19

xoxrebelxox · 29/12/2022 14:27

As a parent of children who are adopted yes it will be hard for you if you chose to do it but be honest with said children from day dot... You aren't their parent but you are their responsible adult. The woman who has adopted my children has lied to them and they call her mum but when they are older then she has an obligation and duty to tell them of their adoption and I'm waiting for the day they come find me. Good luck op, LA are crying out for decent reliable Foster carers... Not all FC'S do it for the children but the money they receive for being a FC. FC'S are meant to be highly vetted which isn't always the case as there are FC'S who abuse their Foster Child.

It sounds like you are in a lot of pain about this adoption - therefore I assume it was done against your wishes?

adoptive parents are legally parents though and entirely appropriate to be called mum and dad.

you must have contact with your children to know their adoptive mother has lied to them? But as she is legally their parent there isn’t much you can do. It is also up to her to decide when and how to tell them the full truth about their biological parents. I agree though she has a moral obligation to be open and truthful.

i Hope you are able to reconnect with your children once they are adults.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 15:16

FleasNavidad · 29/12/2022 14:55

"I find that histrionic. I'm sure the social workers were aware that there was a religious faith within the home and this altruistic work was being done within the context of that."

@Reindeersnooker they were turned down on the first application because they admitted to wanting to foster based on a calling from God. They did not believe it to be in the best interests of their own children and family but the calling from God trumped that.

They then submitted a second application leaving out the religious stuff and putting what they thought the social workers wanted to hear. That application succeeded.

I don't think they misrepresented themselves the second time but I can see we're not going to agree. I'm sure they didn't pretend they had no faith and they were free to explain their altruistic motivations in other terms which would still have been valid for them. It doesn't sound like they were trying to create an underground caliphate.

They were right to recognise there would be elements of hardship for their biological children. If they hadn't, you'd think it naivete and you'd be right. If you don't think anyone with children should foster that's up to you but you shouldn't condemn one family for doing so.

If you don't think Christians should foster (and any Christian who does feel a desire to do this will probably contextualise it as a calling but it doesn't mean they're raging fundamentalists, it's just how they perceive a desire to help), that's a different issue. But we all foster from a desire to help at some level. I certainly did. I do have a stronger sense of responsibility to my own children now I have them which is why I now don't.

Barbie222 · 29/12/2022 14:59

xoxrebelxox · 29/12/2022 14:27

As a parent of children who are adopted yes it will be hard for you if you chose to do it but be honest with said children from day dot... You aren't their parent but you are their responsible adult. The woman who has adopted my children has lied to them and they call her mum but when they are older then she has an obligation and duty to tell them of their adoption and I'm waiting for the day they come find me. Good luck op, LA are crying out for decent reliable Foster carers... Not all FC'S do it for the children but the money they receive for being a FC. FC'S are meant to be highly vetted which isn't always the case as there are FC'S who abuse their Foster Child.

Have your children been adopted or are they in foster care? If they are adopted that's a different legal arrangement and appropriate to call adoptive parents mum and dad. Not heard any adoptive children / parents use another term. Agree that honesty about origins is important but there are often restrictions around how much you can discuss birth family or possible future contact once adopted.

FleasNavidad · 29/12/2022 14:55

"I find that histrionic. I'm sure the social workers were aware that there was a religious faith within the home and this altruistic work was being done within the context of that."

@Reindeersnooker they were turned down on the first application because they admitted to wanting to foster based on a calling from God. They did not believe it to be in the best interests of their own children and family but the calling from God trumped that.

They then submitted a second application leaving out the religious stuff and putting what they thought the social workers wanted to hear. That application succeeded.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 29/12/2022 14:35

@Happypomegranate - have you talked to your therapist about whether they think foster caring would be a good idea for you? They will know where you are, with your mental health, and will be able to provide an informed, unbiased opinion.

I don’t have any experience or knowledge in this area, but I do think that people who have been through trauma/bad life experiences/mental health struggles, and who have come through these and healed from them, may well have a lot to offer people who are going through the same things. It may be that foster caring is not the best way for you to offer this help, but there are other avenues - becoming a therapist yourself, or a support worker, or finding ways to work with vulnerable and disadvantaged children and young people.

Testina · 29/12/2022 14:34

“I’m stable, happy, confident and resilient.”

Until your MIL gives a perfectly valid and realistic opinion, then you’re hurt, not resilient at all.

I have several friends who have adopted (I don’t know any foster careers) and all 3 were told by their social worker - every child we might place with you has a troubled start.

I hope you do investigate it further, and hope that at the right time for you, you’re able to do this. But in the meantime, go easy on your MIL’s opinion.

xoxrebelxox · 29/12/2022 14:27

As a parent of children who are adopted yes it will be hard for you if you chose to do it but be honest with said children from day dot... You aren't their parent but you are their responsible adult. The woman who has adopted my children has lied to them and they call her mum but when they are older then she has an obligation and duty to tell them of their adoption and I'm waiting for the day they come find me. Good luck op, LA are crying out for decent reliable Foster carers... Not all FC'S do it for the children but the money they receive for being a FC. FC'S are meant to be highly vetted which isn't always the case as there are FC'S who abuse their Foster Child.

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 14:26

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 14:20

I find that histrionic. I'm sure the social workers were aware that there was a religious faith within the home and this altruistic work was being done within the context of that. Everyone has a belief system they're acting within. It won't be the first time they've encountered Christian foster carers. They would look at the carers ability to look after the children etc in the same way.

In which case why lie about it?

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 14:20

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 10:34

Not to me. For me lying to get access to vulnerable kids because it’s ‘your calling’ and satisfies a religious interest for you is not actually placing the needs of the children (including your own) at the highest point.

I find that histrionic. I'm sure the social workers were aware that there was a religious faith within the home and this altruistic work was being done within the context of that. Everyone has a belief system they're acting within. It won't be the first time they've encountered Christian foster carers. They would look at the carers ability to look after the children etc in the same way.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 14:16

Nordix · 29/12/2022 10:59

If you don’t want them in your house for another night because you aren’t equipped to manage the situation safety, and you have another sleepless night, it’s hard. And isn’t it sad that it comes to carers dropping kids at the contact centre and leaving? Social services shouldn’t be so incompetent that it has to be handled in such an unpleasant way. But they push it and push it.

My impression of OP was she’s already being very defensive of foster children because she was one herself, so might be too soft to take action to protect her existing child. But of course we can’t know. SS will make an assessment of whether she can foster, but no one can force her to consider the wellbeing of her existing child.

Yes, it's heartbreaking. Really, really sad. Agreed.

zingally · 29/12/2022 13:01

Speaking as someone with a social work background, you won't get approved. Or not imminently at least.

You say your DD is a toddler, and you had to have therapy when she was born because of trauma it bought up. In the social work arena, this is considered VERY RECENT, and the fact it was trauma-related would be a fairly big red flag. You would also have to disclose your own childhood abuse, which would also be a big red flag.

Not your fault of course, but adults with childhood trauma are usually turned down as foster carers. Especially when it comes out that it was still an issue for you as recently as 2-3 years ago.

OhFFS! · 29/12/2022 12:50

Hi. I'm an adoptive parent and not qualified to talk about fostering. I did however have similar issues with my mother. The first time we adopted, she was very anti and we had some difficult conversations. 2nd time around, she was anti again, although this time she was anti because of the impact on our AD who she loved a lot.

She drove us nuts on both occasions but I know deep down it was because she was worried about the impact of adopting these children would have on us. One has FASD and the other ASD and ADHD, so she had a point. Didn't make it easy though

MiddleOfTheNightAgain · 29/12/2022 12:36

I agree with your MIL. You are not making your DD’s needs your priority. And that’s not ok.

Stripedbag101 · 29/12/2022 12:33

It’s a debate we often have with children - is omitting to tell the truth lying? it is certainly dishonest/

you knew that your belief that your God called you to do this would cause difficulties so you chose just to say you loved children.

the reality was you didn’t think it was the right time for your young family but your religious beliefs were the deciding factor.

you chose not to disclose this brocade you knew it would raise questions about your motivations and suitability. Is that lying? There may be a ‘kinder and more polite’ way to put it. But the facts are quite clear.

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 12:32

Although Ito me it would have ‘been kind’ to consider why you were rejected rather than simply deciding to lie next time. I would ‘be kind’ to actually consider your kids rather than reiterate that it’s your calling and your kids don’t have a choice. It would ‘be kind’ not to try to silence people giving their opinion by implying they’re rude/unkind.

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 12:30

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 12:28

'lying to get access to vulnerable kids' could be phrased more kindly, don't you think?

Sorry, ‘telling untruths about your motivation after being denied access to vulnerable children to satisfy your religious urges as you believe you had a religious calling.’

Both honest and ‘kind.’

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 12:29

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 12:03

Again, that is unfair. The calling we had was one that gave us compassion for children that needed looking after, and it sustained us for a decade. It wasn't about us, but about the children we looked after. You can (and have) question the impact on our children and I have accepted the balance of positive and negative in that respect; also that what they say and think about it now may change or be adapted to what I want to hear. But it is definitely unfair to question our actual motivation for fostering in this way. And we didn't lie to get approved, we said that we wanted to support children who need help, which was absolutely the case- we simply downplayed the religious motivation because it doesn't sit well with social services, who are very secular.

Please be kind and polite.

Be kind and polite? I am polite. I don’t need to ‘be kind’ when it comes to shutting up about things I disagree with. Please don’t be patronising and try to silence other people’s opinions.

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 12:28

'lying to get access to vulnerable kids' could be phrased more kindly, don't you think?

Stripedbag101 · 29/12/2022 12:20

Ah yes the be kind argument. Usually used to women and girls to teach them to not to disagree or express contrary views.

there was nothing impolite in the post - just a different opinion.

People‘s motivations to work with vulnerable children should absolutely be probed. Downplaying your belief that you had a religious calling rather than exploring why it is considered a potential red flag suggests to me you felt you knew better than social services.

i am not being unkind or impolite by saying this 1 merely expressing an opinion that I know you won’t agree with.

FleasNavidad · 29/12/2022 12:15

"Please be kind and polite."

What was impolite? @Kanaloa just reiterated what you said in your AMA thread. You changed your second application to what you knew they wanted to hear and downplayed the truth.

Also, "be kind" = "shut up woman"

I'm not seeing any unkindness here. I agree you have taken on board what's been said about your kids in the future and how they may feel.

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 12:03

Kanaloa · 29/12/2022 10:34

Not to me. For me lying to get access to vulnerable kids because it’s ‘your calling’ and satisfies a religious interest for you is not actually placing the needs of the children (including your own) at the highest point.

Again, that is unfair. The calling we had was one that gave us compassion for children that needed looking after, and it sustained us for a decade. It wasn't about us, but about the children we looked after. You can (and have) question the impact on our children and I have accepted the balance of positive and negative in that respect; also that what they say and think about it now may change or be adapted to what I want to hear. But it is definitely unfair to question our actual motivation for fostering in this way. And we didn't lie to get approved, we said that we wanted to support children who need help, which was absolutely the case- we simply downplayed the religious motivation because it doesn't sit well with social services, who are very secular.

Please be kind and polite.