Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL reaction to our proposal to begin fostering children. AIBU to find this upsetting?

562 replies

Happypomegranate · 27/12/2022 22:41

We FaceTimed our in-laws on Xmas day and mentioned our intention to apply to become foster carers. This is something we have both wanted to do for years, but have been previously unable due to work commitments and living in a small flat. We’ve been very fortunate and we now live in a big house and we are financially secure enough that I don’t have to work. I still do a little bit of part time care work but can give this up to focus on fostering. MIL initially said she thought our DD was too young which is a fair point to make. We have a toddler and will not be having anymore biological children. I said we would discuss with the LA but we could wait until DD was in school if necessary but that we just wanted to get the ball rolling as we know how long these things can take. But it later became apparent that she was very against the idea of us fostering at any point in the future and I don’t believe my DD’s age has anything to do with it. She used language such as ‘it will be someone you don’t know’, ‘there could be problems’, and ‘troubled children’. We have done our research and we are aware that the children may have additional needs, mental health and/or behavioural problems, but every child in need of a foster placement is different and I feel it’s not right to stereotype. As for children that may come with challenges, I feel it would be our job as the foster parents to try and work through the challenges with the children. I don’t understand why she doesn’t want us to support vulnerable children, it’s just bizarre to me. It hurts because I had an extremely abusive childhood, struggled with mental health in my early adulthood and I’ve worked really hard to get to a place where I am happy, stable and resilient. I feel I could have a lot to give as a foster carer. My DH is lovely and a great dad, and I believe he’d be a fantastic foster carer but he had a drastically different upbringing from me. Think well to-do, independent school, etc. We are an unlikely but very happy pair. I thought she would be supportive but she’s actively against it and I’m not sure why it bothers me so much because it’s ultimately my and my husbands decision to apply, not hers. AIBU to be upset?

OP posts:
Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 20:45

I also agree that anyone who thinks homosexuality is wrong shouldn't be a foster carer and I would worry for their biological children. Many Christians would share that view. Not to derail the thread but a foster carer shouldn't be anything other than accepting of trans issues also - not pushing one way or the other.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 20:42

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 20:28

If you watch the documentaries on him it's very clear he thought his charity work would ofset the evil and allow him a ticket into heaven.

He was given a free pass, partly based on his so called religion.

Religion quite frankly doesn't make you a good person. And anyone using it as a way to express homophobic, misogynistic views is obviously not fit to guide children's mortalities and I'd be worried about how they treated children of differing opinions in their care. Sadly, there's a very thick vein of bigotry and bullishness running through the church to as with the posters who turn a blind eye because they think God will do their safeguarding. It's thick and careless. I'm not saying all Christians are thick and careless, but trusting God to do your parental role is thick and reckless.

He would be one of many who used the church to prey on vulnerable people. He was clearly a manipulative liar and I personally think it would be naive to believe anything he says in his documentaries. People like that are practised in covering up their true thoughts and feelings. I doubt he thought there was a heaven or cared. I doubt he had the capacity to understand other people as truly human or the concept of a world outside his own gratification.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 20:36

Hoppinggreen · 29/12/2022 19:37

Why do you need to believe in God to be nice?
I donate both my time and money to charity and try to help the community and generally be a good person. However, I do it because it’s the right thing to do rather than because I am afraid of a mythical being

He doesn't need to believe in God to be nice. He is clearly nice! But it's clear from the statistics that faith (not fear, nasty jump from you there) does motivate a great proportion of people to go the extra mile and actually bring a child into their home. That could be because many Christians are encouraged to consider how they can make a difference in the world regardless of what it might cost them (aka Christ). I agree with you that they don't have the right to make that decision on behalf of their children. And of course many Christians listen and don't act at all. Many people do the same thing without that motivation and good for them. Chances are they will also be doing in the context of a value system which is based on deeply held beliefs about the world and themselves. We're all a product of our cultures.

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 20:28

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 20:22

I do not believe JS was motivated by his faith for one second.

If you watch the documentaries on him it's very clear he thought his charity work would ofset the evil and allow him a ticket into heaven.

He was given a free pass, partly based on his so called religion.

Religion quite frankly doesn't make you a good person. And anyone using it as a way to express homophobic, misogynistic views is obviously not fit to guide children's mortalities and I'd be worried about how they treated children of differing opinions in their care. Sadly, there's a very thick vein of bigotry and bullishness running through the church to as with the posters who turn a blind eye because they think God will do their safeguarding. It's thick and careless. I'm not saying all Christians are thick and careless, but trusting God to do your parental role is thick and reckless.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 20:22

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 19:04

A lot of them wouldn't do that work without their faith.

Well they're not very nice people then are they?

I just don't believe in sacred castes. Jimmy Saville did a lot of good work for.children didn't he? Motivated by his faith. If only safeguarding had been applied to that case a lot of trauma could have been avoided.

I do not believe JS was motivated by his faith for one second.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 20:17

Ramsbottom · 29/12/2022 18:16

I think you’ve misunderstood what you’ve read. People don’t think a parent to a single toddler should foster, as they lack parenting experience. particularly one where there has been very recent trauma therapy required.

and quite frankly neither do the local authorities, which is why most will rule the op out. This doesn’t mean no one should foster.

I would take issue with that. You don't need parenting experience to foster. You need experience with children, good training and commitment. Fostering is completely unlike having your own children.

Reindeersnooker · 29/12/2022 20:11

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 18:02

I hope it doesn't make sense to most christians. Surely christians understand the need for safeguarding over wishy thinking?

Otherwise I would actually have to back up the hyperbole of no christians should foster. But I don't think they can all be that naive/stupid...

Mind you the record of the church and safeguarding isn't exactly watertight.

You're right, safeguarding and the church is an appalling black hole. That could be because it's an organisation that deals with vulnerable people, especially children (always vulnerable) so predators are drawn to it. They've had free rein. And the church hasn't always acted to protect the vulnerable, quite the opposite. It's quite rightly turned many people away from the church. The church deserves that criticism. Many churches are now completely up to speed on safeguarding but it will still be vulnerable to abuse because anyone can misrepresent themselves.

There's nothing to stop a Christian from exercising rigorous safeguarding while also exercising their faith.

My kids don't do sleepovers with anyone but my brothers children because I only trust my brothers. I don't believe I can know the truth about any other men and I've thought carefully about them too. If I was a Christian, I might exercise my faith but it wouldn't stop me being fully aware that there is evil in the world in the most unlikely places. If anyone thinks that's paranoid, I can only say that I've known two people convicted of child abuse/sexual assault who were looked upon as shining lights in the community while I was a child, both supposedly Christian leaders. Abuse ruins lives. Sleepovers are a small sacrifice and it's easier to have a blanket rule.

Fostering is like a long sleepover. I wouldn't personally trust God to keep a ring of angels around my child's bed, not because I have a problem with God but because of what I know about the world.

theparkisrising · 29/12/2022 19:56

I'd say the lack of foster carers is an even bigger reason to think very hard before going into it. When we started to look into it about 20 years ago now I had the idea of looking after lovely little children whose parents were maybe sick in hospital. I had no idea about the attachment issues or abuse. The long (over six months) process to become a foster carer opened our eyes to what it really was going to be like, and it was drummed into us that the children who were going to be placed with us were very unlikely to be grateful or happy to be placed with us. They invariably want to be with their birth parents.

We had a long term placement who settled well but was very vulnerable and easily led. Social services placed two other children with us and one of them targeted the existing child who had to barricade themselves in their room at night to avoid the 'unwelcome advances' of one of the new children. Social services were told, said they would find a new placement for the siblings, but due to lack of carers it took 6 weeks for them to find anyone who would take them. For those 6 weeks we had to patrol the hallway at night to keep the other child safe.

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 19:56

I'm fundamentally a flawed person, definitely not better than anyone else. But our faith is what pointed us towards fostering, where we achieved some good things, that's all.

Stripedbag101 · 29/12/2022 19:43

Hoppinggreen · 29/12/2022 19:37

Why do you need to believe in God to be nice?
I donate both my time and money to charity and try to help the community and generally be a good person. However, I do it because it’s the right thing to do rather than because I am afraid of a mythical being

I grew up in a community where the church had a lot of influence.

some people to genuinely believe that people who follow religion are in some way better. Of course they aren’t - some of the best and some of the worst people I know are religious.

min my community child abuse was swept under the carpet for a long time because the perpetrator was a Christian with a calling to teach. Even when it was eventually reported to the police the church prayed for this man. Not for his victims who were branded misguided.

while I appreciate some fabulous, generous, kind people are Christians - being a Christian. Does not make you a good person. It doesn’t work that way.

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 19:40

Hoppinggreen · 29/12/2022 19:37

Why do you need to believe in God to be nice?
I donate both my time and money to charity and try to help the community and generally be a good person. However, I do it because it’s the right thing to do rather than because I am afraid of a mythical being

My point exactly.

Plenty of nice people around who don't believe in god.
I would hope my christian friends would try to be nice without invisible law enforcement, as do their non religious friends.

The fact that you seem to think being christian is some kind of requirement for being a good person is evidence you are not suitable to foster children who will have a range of beliefs and cultures. It's quite bigoted.

BrownEyedGhoul · 29/12/2022 19:40

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 19:35

You're right. I'd be a lot less nice if I wasn't a Christian.

Then you're not actually a nice person at all.

Hoppinggreen · 29/12/2022 19:37

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 19:35

You're right. I'd be a lot less nice if I wasn't a Christian.

Why do you need to believe in God to be nice?
I donate both my time and money to charity and try to help the community and generally be a good person. However, I do it because it’s the right thing to do rather than because I am afraid of a mythical being

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 19:35

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 19:04

A lot of them wouldn't do that work without their faith.

Well they're not very nice people then are they?

I just don't believe in sacred castes. Jimmy Saville did a lot of good work for.children didn't he? Motivated by his faith. If only safeguarding had been applied to that case a lot of trauma could have been avoided.

You're right. I'd be a lot less nice if I wasn't a Christian.

RandomSunday · 29/12/2022 19:29

theparkisrising · 29/12/2022 18:35

Fostering can be brillliant we enjoyed doing it for years because our own children had grown up, so they weren't at risk of harm from the children we looked after. Wouldn't have ever exposed my children to the behaviours we've seen over the years when they were young. The thing is that social workers often have no idea what has happened to the children they place with you. There's often a honeymoon period of a few weeks and then it all comes out. You need a strong stomach to deal with a lot of it

I couldn’t agree more.

From this thread all I’ve taken is those who have no idea of what foster care entails cannot see the the different challenges each placement poses. I loved working with children and their families and know I made a difference. Each child came with their own problems and each child left me with the best outcome, according to their individual needs. Except two. They stayed (that’s another story, or two).

My only grievance, during my time as a FC, is the, sometimes, unrealistic expectations, and downright condemnation from SS - towards the Foster carers and their birth children, the foster child and their birth families.

I’ve worked with amazing Social Workers, who go above and beyond for the children they are responsible for. I’ve also experienced SW’s who don’t have the brains they were born with and their poor practice has had devastating effects on the children within their case load. There are SW’s who see children as a case - rather than a vulnerable human being who need support. The system pains me.

I can’t keep up with the FC who is religious. I’ve no idea what is happening there tbh. There are many FC’s who are religious. I can’t see that FC applications would be rejected because of “religion”. That makes no sense. Unless the religion was - and I’m only making a suggestion here - Their religion would cause LA to be reluctant to use them because they couldn’t place a child with someone who couldn’t provide the experiences the child’s birth parents would wish for them. Eg Christmas/birthday celebrations. That would cause all sorts of problems. If parents are not happy with the child’s placement, based on their cultural/religious beliefs then it means another move for the child.

Just a scenario guys!

I’ve worked, closely, with FC’s who are Christian (I’ve had a child placed and another FC had the sibling placed with them, so lots of contact) and LA were happy for them to include the foster child in their church services, festivals and celebrations.

Anyway, apart from saying, one more time, that OP is free to pursue her application as a FC. The outcome depends on the info contained within her very lengthy assessment. I’m out now.

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 19:04

A lot of them wouldn't do that work without their faith.

Well they're not very nice people then are they?

I just don't believe in sacred castes. Jimmy Saville did a lot of good work for.children didn't he? Motivated by his faith. If only safeguarding had been applied to that case a lot of trauma could have been avoided.

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 18:58

I can see you're not a big fan of basing decisions on faith, perhaps not a fan of Christianity or religion in general. You also alluded to the church's safeguarding record, I assume in connection with scandals in church institutions etc. But Christians (and people of other faiths) also do a lot of good work in areas like fostering, making a big impact on those who need help. A lot of them wouldn't do that work without their faith.

FleasNavidad · 29/12/2022 18:55

"I simply don't agree that it was dishonest. Your hectoring tone suggested that you were against foster parents having a spiritual dimension to their decision (which they always will as everything has a spiritual element for them). But anyway, I'm willing to bet there are children who knew a loving home and stable, trusted adults because of that poster's actions and I'm glad you weren't able to rain on that parade, other than belatedly sniping on the internet."

Hectoring tone? Fuck me 🤣. Have you even read his AMA where he clearly says the people assessing didn't like the motivation he had being a religious calling so he omitted that part on the next application despite it being the truth!? If that's not dishonest to you then fine but I'm not "sniping on the internet" and my discussion with @Petros9 was simply pointing out that he couldn't possibly know how his biological children have been affected since one is only 14 years old.

Not sure why you've taken such issue with that @Reindeersnooker since Petros himself took the point on board and agreed with it.

I stand by my argument that the OP is not suitable to foster since she has a toddler and personal trauma to deal with. I also think you should be completely open when applying and hiding the degree of impact a calling from God has had on your decision making is dishonest.

Stripedbag101 · 29/12/2022 18:54

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 18:38

Thanks. I suppose foster carers shouldn't impose a secular world view on the children either? It's hard not to have an influence on children that you help to raise. Social services were happy enough with our faith to let us take the children to church on Sundays, say grace at meals etc. They always checked that this was OK with the birth parents too.

I am not sure what you mean by a secular world view? Are you conflating secular and atheist? I am atheist and would never tell a child there is no god. I would tell them that some believe in God, some people believe the Bible is true and and that should be respected and protected. But everyone must form their own view.

Explaining what you believe in a of course fine - but children should have freedom of and from religion.

This story for example shows the challenges that can come up:

amp.theguardian.com/society/2011/feb/28/christian-couple-lose-care-case

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 18:50

I'd be wary of people making safeguarding decisions through the lens of 'spirituality'.

My grandparents incidentally once took in a homeless man because of their Christian beliefs, despite being advised against it because of the risk.

He was a drug adult and subsequently robbed them.
They'd have been better off making decisions based on reality.

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 18:46

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 18:38

I'd hope that christians are able.to make rational decisions without relying on spiritual intervention. It's a bit worrying that you think christians can't seem to uncouple that.

Yes there's a lack of places. That doesn't mean safeguarding standards should be lowered. Perhaps more support and motivation for single couples who are actually suitable. Perhaps early intervention, funding and support for families before children have to be taken away. Family planning support. Many services need to be considered before we can assume that we have the best system to avoid and support sad situations.

As a pp said, Christians tend to see all decisions through a spiritual lens. With the figures I just quoted in mind, it's clear that their faith is a major factor in Christians choosing to foster (they're also twice as likely to adopt). Where we live, Social services work closely with some of the churches to recruit a lot of foster carers. There are also a few Christian fostering agencies.

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 18:38

Stripedbag101 · 29/12/2022 18:31

On the religious motivation - I think people should be open and honest about their motivations and explore why the system might consider this a red flag.

There is nothing wrong with religious people Forster I g of course - as long as they don’t try to influence the children in their care or impose their own belief system on them. Your recognised your views on homosexuality for example would be problematic. I hope you were open about this during the assessment stages.

Thanks. I suppose foster carers shouldn't impose a secular world view on the children either? It's hard not to have an influence on children that you help to raise. Social services were happy enough with our faith to let us take the children to church on Sundays, say grace at meals etc. They always checked that this was OK with the birth parents too.

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 18:38

I'd hope that christians are able.to make rational decisions without relying on spiritual intervention. It's a bit worrying that you think christians can't seem to uncouple that.

Yes there's a lack of places. That doesn't mean safeguarding standards should be lowered. Perhaps more support and motivation for single couples who are actually suitable. Perhaps early intervention, funding and support for families before children have to be taken away. Family planning support. Many services need to be considered before we can assume that we have the best system to avoid and support sad situations.

theparkisrising · 29/12/2022 18:35

Fostering can be brillliant we enjoyed doing it for years because our own children had grown up, so they weren't at risk of harm from the children we looked after. Wouldn't have ever exposed my children to the behaviours we've seen over the years when they were young. The thing is that social workers often have no idea what has happened to the children they place with you. There's often a honeymoon period of a few weeks and then it all comes out. You need a strong stomach to deal with a lot of it

Petros9 · 29/12/2022 18:34

MarysGirlChildWasLate4ChristmasDay · 29/12/2022 18:24

I don't think you can take the risk down to adequately protect children to am acceptable risk with children in the house, no.

Fair enough, less risk if there's no other children in the home, though the risk from babies is limited, surely? But how do you cater for the need, when more and more children come into care? I'm estimating that about a quarter of fostering households have their own children at home, and there still aren't enough places available. And I just read that Christians are three times more likely to foster than the population in general, so how do we make do without the wishy thinkers?