Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL reaction to our proposal to begin fostering children. AIBU to find this upsetting?

562 replies

Happypomegranate · 27/12/2022 22:41

We FaceTimed our in-laws on Xmas day and mentioned our intention to apply to become foster carers. This is something we have both wanted to do for years, but have been previously unable due to work commitments and living in a small flat. We’ve been very fortunate and we now live in a big house and we are financially secure enough that I don’t have to work. I still do a little bit of part time care work but can give this up to focus on fostering. MIL initially said she thought our DD was too young which is a fair point to make. We have a toddler and will not be having anymore biological children. I said we would discuss with the LA but we could wait until DD was in school if necessary but that we just wanted to get the ball rolling as we know how long these things can take. But it later became apparent that she was very against the idea of us fostering at any point in the future and I don’t believe my DD’s age has anything to do with it. She used language such as ‘it will be someone you don’t know’, ‘there could be problems’, and ‘troubled children’. We have done our research and we are aware that the children may have additional needs, mental health and/or behavioural problems, but every child in need of a foster placement is different and I feel it’s not right to stereotype. As for children that may come with challenges, I feel it would be our job as the foster parents to try and work through the challenges with the children. I don’t understand why she doesn’t want us to support vulnerable children, it’s just bizarre to me. It hurts because I had an extremely abusive childhood, struggled with mental health in my early adulthood and I’ve worked really hard to get to a place where I am happy, stable and resilient. I feel I could have a lot to give as a foster carer. My DH is lovely and a great dad, and I believe he’d be a fantastic foster carer but he had a drastically different upbringing from me. Think well to-do, independent school, etc. We are an unlikely but very happy pair. I thought she would be supportive but she’s actively against it and I’m not sure why it bothers me so much because it’s ultimately my and my husbands decision to apply, not hers. AIBU to be upset?

OP posts:
nettie434 · 28/12/2022 00:50

I'm surprised you've had such negative replies because your own abusive childhood and the age of your daughter will be among the many factors that will be considered when you apply to be a foster carer. It will be for the local authority or fostering agency to decide your suitability, not your MIL.

There is a shortage of foster carers but there is also a shortage of home based respite care for children and adults so the suggestion that you could consider respite care is a good one. Shared Lives plus supports adults sharedlivesplus.org.uk/get-to-know-our-members/shared-lives-and-shared-lives-plus/

There are various voluntary organisations that help children, such as Action for Children who provide breaks for children with disabilities and fostering. Your experience in care work could help here if children need help with personal care or taking medication.

www.actionforchildren.org.uk/how-we-can-help/foster-with-us/find-a-fostering-service/

I hope you find a solution that works for you.

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:50

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 00:48

I am speaking from my own experience. We found babies that came straight from hospital to be straightforward to care for. I expect you are right that they may show signs of trauma later, perhaps as they come to terms with issues around why their birth parents couldn't look after them. But it was nothing like looking after some of the older children we cared for, they were troubled and challenging. And you may be right that OP's toddler wouldn't find much benefit from living in a foster family, as my daughter didn't when we started. But now, aged 14 and having grown up in a fostering family, she could tell you at length about the benefits and the pride. She'd also tell you about the challenges and pain.

And there’s absolutely no reason for op to introduce the ‘challenges and pain’ to her toddler.

And yes, those babies would have been traumatised. While their behaviours may not have been as challenging as those of an 11 year old, any baby who is removed at birth will have experienced traumas, and will in turn cause difficulties for a mother who needed therapy to deal with caring for her own infant child.

Pascor · 28/12/2022 00:49

Happypomegranate · 27/12/2022 23:03

Hi. Thanks for chipping in. I understand where you are coming from but surely every child is different? Some children needing fostering may be ‘troubled’, whereas others may not fit that label at all. Do you look at the family and their ability in terms of their circumstances, experience, etc before placing a child with them? If so then surely we wouldn’t be asked to care for a child that needed more support than we could give? We all have to start somewhere and maybe in years to come when our DD is much older and we have more experience we could foster children with higher needs. Also what about children younger than our DD, isn’t there a need for foster carers for babies, etc.

Wow, you are so naive. No wonder your MIL is concerned

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 00:48

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:35

Every child in care is traumatised! Honestly I find it hard to believe you were ever a foster carer if you honestly think it isn’t a huge trauma for a child to be removed from their birth family. And there are very few benefits of their parent fostering for a toddler that wouldn’t be instantly outweighed by the huge negatives.

I am speaking from my own experience. We found babies that came straight from hospital to be straightforward to care for. I expect you are right that they may show signs of trauma later, perhaps as they come to terms with issues around why their birth parents couldn't look after them. But it was nothing like looking after some of the older children we cared for, they were troubled and challenging. And you may be right that OP's toddler wouldn't find much benefit from living in a foster family, as my daughter didn't when we started. But now, aged 14 and having grown up in a fostering family, she could tell you at length about the benefits and the pride. She'd also tell you about the challenges and pain.

MintJulia · 28/12/2022 00:38

RelentlessForwardProgress · 27/12/2022 23:48

There really is no upside for your child to you doing this.

None.

They will get less attention / emotional security and even if it is a perfect placement they will get attached to a child/children who then leave. That's if you get placements with no trauma or difficulty, which is extremely unlikely.

I think all this was obvious to your mother in law and she had the courage to voice it.

This. Your dd has a secure stable home environment. Don't jeopardise that for her. Wait until she has left home.

saraclara · 28/12/2022 00:37

I really don't want to put off people who are interested in fostering. I saw first hand how important they are, and what a great job most are doing. I did consider it myself at one time, but when I thought it through and asked myself the questions that is be asked if I applied, I realised that it wouldn't work.

If you're annoyed at your MIL asking these questions, how are you going to react when you're asked the same ones when you apply? You need to be reflective, you need to be objective and you need to be realistic.

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 00:37

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:25

Although I think it’s interesting that you’re so confident it’s super beneficial for all birth kids and there’s so many supposed benefits when you’re - surprise surprise - not one of the kids involved at all and can’t actually name any real benefits (other than being super proud of the amazing parents) that would come to the toddler child of op.

Not quite what I said. Just adding some balance. I have seen both sides of the impact on my own children. They are proud of themselves, not of me.

RandomSunday · 28/12/2022 00:36

MediocreMummy · 28/12/2022 00:31

Have you considered reading any of the books by "Cathy Glass " ? They are all true accounts of her life as a foster carer and give a really good insight into the challenges and rewards of fostering.

I disagree - strongly! The “stories” of fostered children by Cathy Glass are “stories”. There is no way anyone would be able to tell a factual account of a child in the care of a LA.

How naive can you be? You, obviously, have no experience of fostering children! Your post has angered me! Just stop giving misinformed “advice”

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:35

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 00:33

Social services have good processes for assessing suitability. No one's perfect. You do have to be robust and capable. Possibly OP might not be suitable right now, I don't know. I am just trying to add some balance from my own experience. To refute blanket statements to the effect that no one with young kids should foster. That every child in care is traumatised. That there are no benefits to birth kids in fostering families. These are not true.

Every child in care is traumatised! Honestly I find it hard to believe you were ever a foster carer if you honestly think it isn’t a huge trauma for a child to be removed from their birth family. And there are very few benefits of their parent fostering for a toddler that wouldn’t be instantly outweighed by the huge negatives.

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 00:33

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:21

Right, so did you find your own children at that age so difficult it triggered a need for therapy? Because that’s where op is coming from - a short time ago when her toddler was a baby this triggered a need for therapy to examine her own traumatic childhood.

So yeah, someone needs to look after them. Someone who is trying to heal their own issues while also struggling to care for their own toddler and taking any lack of agreement personally? Not that someone.

Social services have good processes for assessing suitability. No one's perfect. You do have to be robust and capable. Possibly OP might not be suitable right now, I don't know. I am just trying to add some balance from my own experience. To refute blanket statements to the effect that no one with young kids should foster. That every child in care is traumatised. That there are no benefits to birth kids in fostering families. These are not true.

Cw112 · 28/12/2022 00:32

Hi op, I work within the care system and to be fair- the points your mil has raised are all correct and could be challenges you and your family will face if you move forwards with this. She could have worded it more tactfully but her concerns are valid and its important that you take them into consideration because you will need your extended family to be on board and to be prepared to support your family, do some training themselves and be ready to work through things with any children that come into your household. Your decision to Foster does have impact on the wider family unit and that will be explored in the recruitment process so it's best you're prepared for that. I would agree with other pps who recommend that you wait until your dd is older and has a good understanding of herself and what's safe/unsafe before progressing and it's good that you can recognise that. You actually might want to consider waiting until she's old enough to understand fostering and the behaviour she might see in her home and agree to you doing it. It would also be important that she's old enough that she can tell you if it becomes too much for her and you need to be prepared for that. There's a serious lack of Foster carers so it's great you're thinking about it but it's important not to go into it blindly as it's a long term choice even if a child stays with you for a short period.

MediocreMummy · 28/12/2022 00:31

Have you considered reading any of the books by "Cathy Glass " ? They are all true accounts of her life as a foster carer and give a really good insight into the challenges and rewards of fostering.

Geppili · 28/12/2022 00:31

Have you done any volunteering with vulnerable children? Have you volunteered to go in to hear kids read at your local state primary?

bloodywhitecat · 28/12/2022 00:30

Having fostered babies who were removed at or shortly after birth I can tell you that they do suffer varying degrees of trauma.

My children were adults before I started fostering and even they struggle every time a child leaves us. I cannot tell you how hard the goodbyes are for everyone who has grown to love that child. I am fortunate enough to still have regular meet ups/ updates from all of my little ones and I cherish the relationships with the children and their families but the goodbyes still bloody hurt.

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 00:27

saraclara · 28/12/2022 00:20

Babies fostered from a very young age are not traumatised (excepting foetal alcohol syndrome or similar). And that is what the OP would likely be dealing with at first.

Why do you think OP would be dealing with babies first @Petros9 ? I think that's very unlikely. Baby fosterers tend to be the most experienced. It's a big deal to foster a baby and involves a lot of contact with the birth mother and significant extra training to deal with the relationship involved and the trauma to the birth mother.

Just because that was our own experience. Our youngest was 3 and Social services said a foster child had to be at least a couple of years younger than our youngest. I don't think they would place a dangerous teenager in a family with a small child of their own. And no one sensible would accept that even if they tried.

Riu · 28/12/2022 00:26

Your responsibility is towards your own child. Based on my experience of working with children in care, fostering isn’t something I would consider doing until my own child was grown up. I think that your MIL is right, but I also agree that it is up to you and your dh.

Oher · 28/12/2022 00:25

It’s a lovely idea OP but I’m with your MIL. You don’t bring a troubled and angry stranger into the home of a young child, especially a female young child. My neighbour fosters and all of the kids have had major psychological issues. I don’t know the stats on fostering but I do recall that 70% of adopted children are violent towards their new family. Your MIL, is, quite rightly, protective of her toddler granddaughter.

Your daughter deserves to have her home be a place of safety and security. Bring up your child, THEN be a wonderful foster carer.

Literally any other time of your life would be better for this. Not when you have a toddler.

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:25

Although I think it’s interesting that you’re so confident it’s super beneficial for all birth kids and there’s so many supposed benefits when you’re - surprise surprise - not one of the kids involved at all and can’t actually name any real benefits (other than being super proud of the amazing parents) that would come to the toddler child of op.

saraclara · 28/12/2022 00:23

Ah, was typing when you posted abbot your experience @Petros9 . The baby fosterer that I know has a far more complex role than just caring for the babies she fosters, and has had a lot of counseling and safeguarding training because she's working with the mothers too

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:23

And you’ve only got to search on here for the foster carer lady who made a thread about caring for traumatised tiny babies. It’s not exactly something that slots easily in between caring for your toddler and examining your traumatic childhood with nobody every criticising or upsetting you and the baby not causing any issues.

NestingSparrow · 28/12/2022 00:22

Her concerns are valid YABU

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:21

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 00:20

We fostered for ten years. We started with babies and looked after a number who were under six months old. Our experience is that they were no more difficult to look after than our own children at that age. We moved on to older children as our own kids grew up and the issues became more problematic; I agree that the older ones were all traumatised in various ways. But someone needs to look after them!

Right, so did you find your own children at that age so difficult it triggered a need for therapy? Because that’s where op is coming from - a short time ago when her toddler was a baby this triggered a need for therapy to examine her own traumatic childhood.

So yeah, someone needs to look after them. Someone who is trying to heal their own issues while also struggling to care for their own toddler and taking any lack of agreement personally? Not that someone.

Tempyname · 28/12/2022 00:21

Have you even spoken to the social workers at a fostering agency about your concerns and reasons for fostering and whether this is the right time?

saraclara · 28/12/2022 00:20

Babies fostered from a very young age are not traumatised (excepting foetal alcohol syndrome or similar). And that is what the OP would likely be dealing with at first.

Why do you think OP would be dealing with babies first @Petros9 ? I think that's very unlikely. Baby fosterers tend to be the most experienced. It's a big deal to foster a baby and involves a lot of contact with the birth mother and significant extra training to deal with the relationship involved and the trauma to the birth mother.

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 00:20

Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 00:11

All babies removed from their parents will be traumatised. So you’re wrong from the get go.

How does a toddler gain perspective and pride from mum (who has just finished therapy to help her deal with the toddler) suddenly being taken over by a small traumatised baby?

I’m glad you’re ‘evangelical’ about fostering, may I ask what experience of it you actually have? Do you foster, were you fostered etc? And no, it isn’t easy on birth kids, or foster kids. Only the most robust and realistic of people are fit to be foster parents really.

We fostered for ten years. We started with babies and looked after a number who were under six months old. Our experience is that they were no more difficult to look after than our own children at that age. We moved on to older children as our own kids grew up and the issues became more problematic; I agree that the older ones were all traumatised in various ways. But someone needs to look after them!