Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH family not treating kids evenly

183 replies

Sickofpeople18 · 27/12/2022 16:32

AIBU?
My husband has 2 kids from his first marriage and 2 with me.
We normally give money to all the family kids at Christmas but couldn't manage this year, I didn't expect anyone to give any to my boys as we didn't give to their's so that's only fair but now I found out all the family gave to the 2 oldest girls and nothing to our 2 boys, because as I over hear them say on Christmas day "they gave ours nothing so I'm not bothering with their's are you?" But then to give to 2 just didn't seem fair the little ones don't understand why the bigger ones got something and they didn't. I'm upset about it, I don't know ow if I should say something or just distance from them as I know it was done out of spite.

OP posts:
Ansumpasty · 27/12/2022 18:14

Sorry OP, but I’m kind of in the YABU camp.

It seems to me that the gifts to the girls were given more discreetly (so you didn’t see) and that they didn’t buy for your boys so as not to make you feel uncomfortable about the fact you couldn’t afford to give gifts this year. The agreement was with you, not with adult children. I agree with a PP that your children won’t see them as equals, as they’re ‘grown ups’ to them. What if the girls (as adults) had turned up with gifts for the others?
The family may have been hoping that the girls would keep their presents to themselves, again, so as not to make you feel bad. They shouldn’t miss out because you were’t buying this year, IMO.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/12/2022 18:11

Honestly OP I think this is on your DP to sort. For you, I'd probsy take a step back. Because they're punishing YOUR children not his children (as the girls got £100 each). They easily could have given them £80 and brought the boys a toy even if they didn't want to make it even. But they're decided this is YOUR fault so your kids should suffer.

Sickofpeople18 · 27/12/2022 18:11

Tandora · 27/12/2022 17:53

Why didn’t you gift them a chocolate Santa? Gifts don’t have to cost money, it’s the thought and effort that counts. You made it clear you weren’t participating in the ritual reciprocity-
that probably caused some offence.

Because the year I tried presents over money I was told is that it where's the money by 4 of the 6, so with them it's money or nothing an we don't have it

OP posts:
blubberyboo · 27/12/2022 18:10

they only see them rarely and the oldest maybe 3 times a year, the boys go to visit regularly

and this is relevant too.
when family don’t see kids as much as the others they often like to give them money or gifts as they don’t see them during the year.

my mother often gives more to 2 of my nieces at Xmas as she doesn’t see them as often as the rest of the grandchildren who regularly get little treats from her throughout the year such as pocket money for the shop, chocolate bars , take away treats , trips to town etc

yabvu to make an issue of this. It’s really not your business why they did this. people can give gifts to who they want Just understand that they have their reasons and they most likely are perfectly valid

SleepingStandingUp · 27/12/2022 18:09

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 18:01

Did your two have to sit there whilst their siblings and cousins opened piles of present

the op has said no other child was given presents

No, she said no one gave her boys anything

they saw the extended family all getting something so I imagine it's like 3+ siblings. A and B brought for each others kids. C (ops dp) brought for no one but his older kids for something.
So A kids for from B, B kids for from A, preferred C kids got from A and B.

Bananarama21 · 27/12/2022 18:09

You have not right to dicate their relationship with their neices they aren't your kids. They respected your wishes and didn't exchange gifts. What's the problem. You wanted your dsds to go without.

Ponderingwindow · 27/12/2022 18:08

What is the age range of the other children that you would have normally bought for in past years? Are they closer in age to your younger 2 or are they closer to adulthood? These would have been kids seeing relatives, mostly cousins I am guessing, getting a gift when they did not receive one in return. Yet the givers of these gifts didn’t think it inappropriate to do to their own children. That makes me wonder if there is some significant age difference or other dynamic at play here that makes this particular gifting different.

Sickofpeople18 · 27/12/2022 18:07

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 17:53

So they saw

But you only found out by having “overheard”?

Seriously if you could read as good as you could comment something might go in, let's get this cos I am not answering you again, you are just a troll from all I can see.
Right we are broke presents or food. I over heard my DH sibling saying they weren't getting anything for the boys cos we were getting theirs anything, then they gave the 2 older ones who gave them nothing 100 each infant of the 2 small kids then the 4 ye old asked us why he got nothing. I have always given them something every year I never said there was no one but them 2 getting present I sais we gave nothing ans no one gave to us, I yet on great or so I thought with his family, he is really upset by it all too, anything else? Don't bother me again

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 27/12/2022 18:03

blubberyboo · 27/12/2022 17:58

Yabu

the older kids would be regarded as being from another household and probably go a byball as the family would have accepted the ex didn’t know about this “new arrangement”

you and Dh made the decision not to do gifts so they left out your household

i don’t know why u are making it such an issue anyway when you didn’t buy gifts for anyone!! Are you going to stew all year on the grounds that you didn’t buy gifts but someone had the audacity to buy gifts for your dsc??

But why would the ex buy presents for thee ex husbands siblings kids?? Surely it's been on the kids Dad and his CURRENT partner, not the ex's who'll have virtually nothing to do with their ex family, esp given the ages of the girls.

What did dp say @Sickofpeople18 . If my sister brought eldest DS a present but not the babies I'd be asking why she's not just not brought for all

In future years, perhaps DP could put a couple of pound away a month and at least get them a selection box / chocolate reindeer etc. It doesn't have to be £50 cash

Bananarama21 · 27/12/2022 18:03

You can't have it all you can't say no presents and then be annoyed when your dsds are adults get a gift they always got off their dhs family their relationship is completely seperate to you. That relationship has been long standing before you were even with your dh. You then can't argue they could have got them a chocolate santa because you could have gotten a selection box. Yabu

blubberyboo · 27/12/2022 18:03

@Sickofpeople18

but my 4 yr old saw them getting something and him getting nothing that's what was so bad when he then asked us why he didn't get anything

and your answer to him simply should have been an immediate

”we chose not to buy gifts for your cousins this year so they didn’t buy us… see that’s fair”

not leave him to watch open mouthed and thinking it was to do with him. You should have accepted responsibility to your own child.

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 18:02

I wouldnt see my nieces go without who I love and adore for years bc my sis and her new husband decided not to exchange presents with the kids

ok, that’s great. But what if you also were struggling to afford to buy all the kids toys and thought this was a good idea, especially knowing at these ages how much plastic etc they tend to get!

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/12/2022 18:02

Yanbu. I buy for my neices every year, as a result I buy for the older sibling of my niece. I have only met her once but even before we met I have always treated her the same.

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 18:01

Or adult

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 18:01

Did your two have to sit there whilst their siblings and cousins opened piles of present

the op has said no other child was given presents

SleepingStandingUp · 27/12/2022 18:00

So did you tell them in advance you couldn't afford to give?

Did your two have to sit there whilst their siblings and cousins opened piles of presents?

I do agree it's odd to give to half the siblings and not the others, esp given the oens who got presents are an adult and virtually an adult.

As for unfair that the older girls were affected by your choice...
I wouldnt see my nieces go without who I love and adore for years bc my sis and her new husband decided not to exchange presents with the kids

So you couldn't see your nieces go without @Lenald but you're OK with seeing your nephews go without, despite the girls being adults / nearly adults and the just little kids who have zero capacity to gift themselves. Because you love your nieces lots, but you're only mildly ambivalent about the nephews cos they've only been alive a few years. Do you love your older kids more than your younger ones? Your older siblings more than younger ones?? I couldn't imagine ranking how much I love my niblings based on how long they're been around 😐😐

Holly60 · 27/12/2022 17:59

Is it that really you wanted them to ignore your request and buy your children a gift anyway?

Or did you want your step daughters to miss out?

These are your options in the situation.

Theydoyaknow · 27/12/2022 17:59

YABVU

blubberyboo · 27/12/2022 17:58

Yabu

the older kids would be regarded as being from another household and probably go a byball as the family would have accepted the ex didn’t know about this “new arrangement”

you and Dh made the decision not to do gifts so they left out your household

i don’t know why u are making it such an issue anyway when you didn’t buy gifts for anyone!! Are you going to stew all year on the grounds that you didn’t buy gifts but someone had the audacity to buy gifts for your dsc??

Lenald · 27/12/2022 17:57

@Sickofpeople18 i do see why you’re upset but this is the way it has been for two decades. I don’t feel like the girls should suffer because you and DH want things to change now, I’m sorry but I really don’t.

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 17:56

So not like he was surrounded by a load of cousins unwrapping toys!!

all other kids there got squat all too

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 17:56

When he asked why he didn’t get anything??

he would have seen all his cousins also getting nothing…from you.

Holly60 · 27/12/2022 17:56

The thing is if you asked for your children not to get gifts, then that is what was respected.

You don't get to decide what happens with regards to the girls- they aren't your children.

They chose to give gifts to the girls they were allowed to, and respected your wishes regarding your own children.

You might have been angry if they'd ignored you and got your children presents against your wishes

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 17:55

Sickofpeople18 · 27/12/2022 17:53

I see that but 100 euro each when the small ones did get so much as an animal bar is not fair when done I front of them, I qa she one that overheard, what was said but my 4 yr old saw them getting something and him getting nothing that's what was so bad when he then asked us why he didn't get anything,

I doubt you’r 4 year old regards his 21 year old half sister as his peer. In his eyes well and truly an adult (in mine too actually!).

if your niece was 5… I’d be with you.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 27/12/2022 17:54

It's your DH's family so get his to ask them about it.