Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH family not treating kids evenly

183 replies

Sickofpeople18 · 27/12/2022 16:32

AIBU?
My husband has 2 kids from his first marriage and 2 with me.
We normally give money to all the family kids at Christmas but couldn't manage this year, I didn't expect anyone to give any to my boys as we didn't give to their's so that's only fair but now I found out all the family gave to the 2 oldest girls and nothing to our 2 boys, because as I over hear them say on Christmas day "they gave ours nothing so I'm not bothering with their's are you?" But then to give to 2 just didn't seem fair the little ones don't understand why the bigger ones got something and they didn't. I'm upset about it, I don't know ow if I should say something or just distance from them as I know it was done out of spite.

OP posts:
Boulshired · 28/12/2022 07:14

I don’t treat my adult children equally to DS2 whilst I do treat them fairly. The adult children both at university receive cash whereas DS2 presents are in line with what the adult DCs received when they were his age (less financially). Both sides of the family stop present giving at the age of 18. They may all be my children but there is clear separation as two of my children are now adults with different needs and have formed bonds with the extended family outside of the relationship of being my children. My adult children are often slipped money by family members, that is between them and the family member. They also know this will likely stop once the have finished university.

Untitledsquatboulder · 28/12/2022 06:43

Create10 · 28/12/2022 01:16

OP has not said she asked for no presents for her sons.

What sort of people buy Christmas presents for their adult nieces but not their toddler nephews?

Ordinary people. Young adults tend to be far more "in need" than toddlers.

I think that, as they grow older, your relationship with nieces and nephews tends to be directly with them, not via their parents. I don't think its up to my bil/sil whether I buy for their adult children, although I would respect their wishes /follow their lead regarding younger ones.

notsorich · 28/12/2022 06:15

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 19:28

And you keep repeating about the choice between buying them presents versus rent and food.

Fair enough. You couldn’t afford to buy presents. So you said… no kids presents this year.

They took you at your word and didn’t buy for your kids and you didn’t buy for them.

but you seem put out they they didn’t get your kids something.

They got their adult SC a present though. Two adults that they have known many many years longer than you.

OP, it's worth considering as well that DH's relatives have had a relationship with the stepchildren for longer than you have had, and they've created their own customs around gift giving based on how well they know them. For whatever reason, based on that longstanding relationship, they felt it would have been inappropriate to not give them a present this year.

I'm not sure how long you and your DH have been together, but the above is even more true if you came into the stepchildren's lives when they were teens rather than tiny children.

It doesn't mean that DH's family loves his older two more than his younger two, just that they probably know things about his older two that you don't. Which is not a bad thing, just a fact of creating a blended family.

notsorich · 28/12/2022 06:07

I can see why you were upset, but at the same time, if you wanted the older two children to be excluded too, you needed their consent as well as that of their mother. You and your DH didn't seek that consent, so your ruling was ignored, and only applied to the children who were 1) solely under your care and 2) young enough to have their decisions made by you.

I think it's one of those things where you didn't quite think it through, and it's had unintended consequences.

Your step children's mother didn't get anything for these people either - well, maybe she was also financially stretched, but instead took the view that gift giving doesn't have to be reciprocal. Some people like you feel funny about accepting a present when you aren't in a position to give one - others are OK with it on the basis that they would be OK if the tables were turned. Neither approach is wrong.

Next time, if you want something to be applied to all of DH's children, you'll need to have a conversation with at least another three people.

Aprilx · 28/12/2022 02:49

Create10 · 28/12/2022 01:16

OP has not said she asked for no presents for her sons.

What sort of people buy Christmas presents for their adult nieces but not their toddler nephews?

OP has not said she asked for no presents for her sons

She said she wasn’t buying presents, I would certainly hope she accompanied it with a “so please don’t buy for us either”. Damn rude if she didn’t!

I once (when I was a student) had to tell my family that I couldn’t afford presents and I definitely told them not to get me anything too. They all got my presents anyway as they definitely knew how hard up I was at the time. Perhaps the wider family think OP simply doesn’t want to partake in present swapping any more and have taken her at face value. I think to exclude the two adult daughters who I gather live in another household would have been unkind.

user1492757084 · 28/12/2022 02:37

Maybe you, once you saw the family had reciprocated your non gift giving, could have given your own boys a gift to help shield them. Or could you have given others a chocolate Santa? Then the family might know that you did your best or that you do appreciate gift giving. The family could have been trying to not offend your practise of no gift giving.

Create10 · 28/12/2022 01:16

Lenald · 27/12/2022 19:36

I’m not going round in circles with you, it’s pointless. OP ASKED for this so she got it. She has no right to ask for things to change for the families adult nieces who have been part of that family for years before she even came along.

she got what she asked for, the girls got what they asked for.

OP has not said she asked for no presents for her sons.

What sort of people buy Christmas presents for their adult nieces but not their toddler nephews?

Create10 · 28/12/2022 01:13

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 19:28

And you keep repeating about the choice between buying them presents versus rent and food.

Fair enough. You couldn’t afford to buy presents. So you said… no kids presents this year.

They took you at your word and didn’t buy for your kids and you didn’t buy for them.

but you seem put out they they didn’t get your kids something.

They got their adult SC a present though. Two adults that they have known many many years longer than you.

Eh? They're all their father's children and we're talking about their father's family. You are obviously hurting and/or insane.

JudyGemston · 27/12/2022 22:00

EllesB · 27/12/2022 19:52

Rather glad you mentioned it as I was wondering if I was the only one a bit weirded out by it! Dissecting all of the posts and interrogating the OP… bizarre. 😂

You must be new to MN. This is pretty much how threads go around here. Who cares? It’s good escapism. At least half of what you read on here is bullshit anyway.

Shopgirl1 · 27/12/2022 21:27

I’m sure they also have kids wondering why you got them nothing this year, but that’s the decision you made.

Ravenrobin309 · 27/12/2022 21:13

My god since when do you give to recieve.
@lookoutkid thank you for saying it!. Op asked for opinions and people are entitled to disagree but @Ursuladevine seems to have taken it very personal. I feel he/she will be sitting at home thinking non stop about this thread.

DashboardConfessional · 27/12/2022 20:21

They see the older girls as a different family and may indirectly blame you and your kids as the reason there's not enough money any more

This is why I asked ages ago if the DH told his family the plan, or OP did. Even if it was the DH there is indirect disapproval of something here - financial decisions, second family, choice of second partner. I'd be amazed if the OP didn't know, deep down, if she really looked at her relationship with them, which it was.

hattie43 · 27/12/2022 20:11

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 18:40

Presumably they have a relationship with your SC aged 21 and 17 that far far exceeds your presence in their lives by… well many many years. They would have seen them grow from babies, children, teens to women. It’s a totally different relationship and when you say “No kids presents” I don’t blame them for a minute not lumping their adult nieces in with your “no kids” statement

I kinda agree with this . It feels like 2 different families give the age differences in your OH children .
Did your OP buy gifts for his children , I hope he did but if he didn't it might be another reason why his family didn't want his older girls missing out . FEIW I don't think their reasoning for giving the older girls is anything more than tit for tat , you're not buying so you're kids aren't getting . They see the older girls as a different family and may indirectly blame you and your kids as the reason there's not enough money any more

MelchiorsMistress · 27/12/2022 19:57

I just don't see why the younger ones were forgotten they are my husbands kids too,

But your younger ones were no more forgotten than any of the other young children were. Of course it’s fine for you not to give gifts to the other children when you can’t afford it or for any other reason, but you don’t get to complain when your children get nothing in return.

You don’t seem to understand that although you and your husband chose to opt out of gift giving for the children, you don’t have the right to dictate that for young adults who have their own established relationship with these relatives.

At 3 and 4 years old, your children will be able to understand that they aren’t old enough to do many of the things that their older siblings can do. Your children will only be offended if you teach them that that’s the correct response in this situation. If you brush it off as one of those things that’s just for grown up children the little ones would think nothing of it.

chopc · 27/12/2022 19:56

This is an issue when people have multiple kids with multiple people. Shows families have no standards and no sense of right or wrong

If OP is in a situation where she can't afford to "do" Christmas she should have done something at home and explained to everyone her situation.

Or if DH family are kind, people would know not to gift some kids and not others in front of everyone.

This just shows the lack of emotional maturity amongst some communities

Yes go ahead and call me names and that's absolutely fine

EllesB · 27/12/2022 19:52

lookoutkid · 27/12/2022 19:29

@Ursuladevine you absolute weirdo, how many comments?!!! Must be 20 plus! You are either obsessed with this situation.... or a troll looking for threads to attack an OP at every opportunity. Either way how sad in the season of goodwill!

Rather glad you mentioned it as I was wondering if I was the only one a bit weirded out by it! Dissecting all of the posts and interrogating the OP… bizarre. 😂

Boulshired · 27/12/2022 19:51

I’ve always treated my nieces and nephews equally when they were children, but as adults it’s been on the relationship we share and irrespective of their parents and that does make it complicated with your scenario. I’m more disgusted with the comments than the actions

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 27/12/2022 19:48

Sickofpeople18 · 27/12/2022 17:53

I see that but 100 euro each when the small ones did get so much as an animal bar is not fair when done I front of them, I qa she one that overheard, what was said but my 4 yr old saw them getting something and him getting nothing that's what was so bad when he then asked us why he didn't get anything,

There's no way I'd leave any DC out if I was giving, especially if I can afford 200 euro on gifts, I'd at least give the little ones something. Mine would be stoked with 5 euro each. It's not kind of the adults involved. I wouldn't expect very young children to feel that's fair.

Fizzadora · 27/12/2022 19:48

OP I don't blame you for taking a step back from this whole charade of Christmas presents. Passing cash around to children is just bloody ridiculous especially when you really can't afford it.
Fortunately we don't have a very big extended family on either side, but after one Christmas when the gifts we bought for DH's nephews and nieces and for MIL & PIL were unappreciated and we were asked for cash or vouchers in future, I told them I didn't see the point and no more Christmas gifts would be given or expected.
It all went a bit low contact after that.
I can think of no reason why your DH's siblings would treat his children unfairly like they did. It sounds really mean and nasty to me.

Lenald · 27/12/2022 19:37

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 19:28

And you keep repeating about the choice between buying them presents versus rent and food.

Fair enough. You couldn’t afford to buy presents. So you said… no kids presents this year.

They took you at your word and didn’t buy for your kids and you didn’t buy for them.

but you seem put out they they didn’t get your kids something.

They got their adult SC a present though. Two adults that they have known many many years longer than you.

This!! Honestly it’s not a hard concept!

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 19:37

Lenald · 27/12/2022 19:36

I’m not going round in circles with you, it’s pointless. OP ASKED for this so she got it. She has no right to ask for things to change for the families adult nieces who have been part of that family for years before she even came along.

she got what she asked for, the girls got what they asked for.

This. With bells on

42….

Lenald · 27/12/2022 19:36

SleepingStandingUp · 27/12/2022 19:27

But said you couldn't NOT buy for the girls because you love them so much after seeing them grow up, indicating its OK to see the boys go without because you don't...?

Why should their children see their family hand over a chocolate Santa to your children when you couldn’t do the same for them? I mean God forbid someone teaches their kids you don't give to receive. Imagine how screwed up they'd be being told "Uncle Steve can't afford it this year, we can so we still buy your cousins, it's called kindness"

I’m not going round in circles with you, it’s pointless. OP ASKED for this so she got it. She has no right to ask for things to change for the families adult nieces who have been part of that family for years before she even came along.

she got what she asked for, the girls got what they asked for.

Sickofpeople18 · 27/12/2022 19:35

@lookoutkid thanks I was starting to wonder why this weirdo kept appearing all the time god must have nothing else to do. I have no interest in bothering with them, they must have a very sad life if this is what they do for entertainment. The last post they put to you with the laughing face explained their whole messed up mentally. Some people need to find a hobby

OP posts:
Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 19:34

But perhaps it would be a good idea to get myself moving and find something in the fridge to eat!

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 19:33

lookoutkid · 27/12/2022 19:32

I take it back @Ursuladevine, no less than 40 posts from you, definitely a troll, OP please don't rise to any more of the tragic goading!

Have you just counted? I’m honoured! 41 and counting…. As i say, it’s a quiet night here! 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread