Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have told Dad truth about not being invited?

216 replies

freckles20 · 27/12/2022 15:01

My BIL has a big birthday coming up. He is celebrating with a family meal this Sunday which is New Year's Day.

DH and I will be going along with DS (16). My dad is in his late 70s and I usually have him over every Sunday for a roast. As such, he would normally expect to be coming to us unless I let him know otherwise. He lives alone and feels lonely so I do what I can around work (only child).

We all get on well (well as far as I can tell anyway). We hosted everyone including inlaws and my Dad here on Christmas Day and everyone seemed to get on and have a nice day.

My BIL and SIL know I usually have Dad over on a Sunday and they have sometimes included him in their birthday celebrations before. They hadn't invited him specifically- but I wasn't sure whether they had assumed he would join us.

After much puzzling with DH over what to do I decided to take the bull by the horns and just ask my SIL outright. I sent a bright and breezy message which I hope made it clear that there was no expectation but I wasn't sure if my Dad was invited.

The reply came back with an apology but saying that they didn't have room for him.

So when I called Dad today for a chat I let him know that I wouldn't be able to have him over for dinner on Sunday. I said we will do something on a different day instead, and that I'll drive over in the morning on NYD and we can have a cuppa together.

Dad asked me outright why Sunday was off and I told him the truth that we were going to BIL's birthday lunch. Dad suggested that I asked them if he could come and again I told Dad the truth- that there wasn't room.

Here's the point of my AIBU- DH thinks I was wrong to tell Dad the truth. He thinks I've created an awkward situation, and I should have made something else up. He is usually really reasonable but he's really annoyed with me.

I am baffled. I have been working hard to be less of a people pleaser and to get some sensible boundaries in place- so I gave this situation plenty of thought and decided that the truth was the best way forward.

The way I see it:
I asked SIL as gently as I could if dad was able to come.

She had every right to say no. She didn't need to give a reason- but her reason was that there isn't enough room.

I let Dad know as soon as I could so as to manage his expectations wrt Sunday. I'll do what I can to make sure he's not alone on NYD.

When Dad asked me why he wasn't invited I told him the truth.

Maybe Dad will be quietly upset, or picking holes in SIL's reason but I have just passed on the truth. It is an unfortunate and awkward situation but I'm not sure what else I should have done differently.

I'd love some mumsnet wisdom in this one please!

OP posts:
sianiboo · 27/12/2022 17:07

You did the right thing.

30 odd years ago my mother invited herself along to my brother in laws birthday BBQ, on a Sunday afternoon - it wasn't a 'big' birthday but it turned out they were announcing their first pregnancy to the family that day. Myself and husband had only been married about 6 months at this point....and it was also 6 months since my father had left my mother for another woman. My mother was staying with us temporarily while her new flat was being got ready for her to move into. My in laws were giving us (myself and husband) a lift to the BBQ and I could tell they were a bit taken aback when my mother piped up with 'I'm coming along too, if that's ok'...as a side note, myself and my mother are Australian, husband and in-laws British...so basically the in-laws were too polite to say 'no, you aren't invited'.

The party was so awkward. My mother of course knew nobody there, she hadn't known my in-laws before we got married and hadn't met a good 99% of the people there. She'd only met my brother and sister in law once, at our wedding! Add in that my mother is a narcissist who can't stand not being the centre of attention...we ended up having to leave early.

My mother then complained bitterly to me how unfriendly Brits are, and my husband had his parents complain bitterly to him about how rude my mother was to invite herself along, and ruin the announcement of their first grandchild by trying to make it all about her and my father leaving her. Myself and husband divorced less than 3 years later and my mother never saw any of husband's family ever again.

A capable grown adult can cope with the fact that they aren't going to be invited to everything.

Pascor · 27/12/2022 17:06

cantba · 27/12/2022 15:20

Your sil is a bitch.

She isn't. Sounds like you probably are though.

Gandalflight · 27/12/2022 17:06

I don't think YABU for telling the truth, but definitely for dumping your father for your BIL. You shouldn't have accepted an invite on a day where you had plans, simple as that. You're his only child, he's an old man. An adult, yes, but old people are sensitive to change. But that's your priorities, not mine. Thankfully.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 27/12/2022 17:04

Inkpotlover · 27/12/2022 15:58

He's part of OP's family, not the BIL's!

Honestly, I am struggling to see why people are so insistent they squeeze him in.

Completely agree. As a child we used to
have yearly family reunions with my GP, their children ( my mum and brothers) and GC ( me, my siblings and cousins).
One of my uncle’s wife dad was always there as he was living with them and it definitely changed the dynamic.
I mean, fine sometimes of course, but not necessarily every single time. If you were next to him you weren’t really able to catch up with family members but would have to make mundane chit chat otherwise he would have been excluded.
So I really see why they might not have wanted to include him especially if they already spent Christmas with him last weekend!

saraclara · 27/12/2022 16:57

Since when has New Years Day been a big occasion that no-one should be on their own for?

I'm alone for it every year. I fully expect and hope that my own adult kids are either sleeping off a fun NYE or remembering the days when they could, but now the toddler and baby will have woken them up!

I'm not far off the dad's age in this situation, and I pray that I don't turn needy in the next two or three years.

WhereYouLeftIt · 27/12/2022 16:55

"I did ask DH what I should have done and he suggested I made up a different reason. Or said we were doing something else. He wasn't more specific even when I pushed him but he's clearly annoyed with me."

Sounds to me as if your people-pleasing husband wanted you to take the 'blame' for your dad's non-invite rather than his sister, the actual non-inviter. I would not take kindly to the implication that he cares more how your dad regards his sister than how your dad regards you. And I would be telling him to get a fucking grip.

YANBU

GrasstrackGirl · 27/12/2022 16:52

I don't think that BIL and SIL have done anything wrong by not inviting OP's father, SIL certainly is not a bitch, it's up to them who they invite.

I'm also surprised that some posters are suggesting that OP doesn't go to the party just so her father can see her, it's BIL's birthday and OP sees her father every Sunday, so OP can never do anything else, she MUST see her father and any other invites can fuck off?

Sorry but that's nuts.

diddl · 27/12/2022 16:48

I think it is her husband’s sister’s husband’s birthday.

Thank you.

I think that a pp might be right about her husband's sister being "blamed".

"Sorry, we're busy" should have done.

Instead it's "I asked & she said no".

It (to me) seems very entitled that Op/her Dad asked,

Seems such a big fuss about a Sunday/NYE lunch alone.
Rather be thankful for all the times he was included!

Ladybug14 · 27/12/2022 16:46

I think it's reasonable not to invite him. I think making up an excuse might have been kinder, although not having enough room at the table is an OK and truthful reason

UsingChangeofName · 27/12/2022 16:39

NumberTheory · 27/12/2022 16:34

He’s a grown up whose daughter is missing their weekly Sunday lunch on one week (and promising to go along some other time instead). Most people don’t make a big deal out of New Year’s Day.

I suppose it might be different if he’d always made a big deal over New Years Day and maybe invited the BiL, SiL any of DH’s other siblings’ families and others over in the past. So I guess there’s some wiggle room but it seems super unlikely.

Exactly.

The OP is kind enough to often have him over for a roast on a Sunday. It is nice. But it doesn't - or shouldn't - prevent her from ever being able to accept any invitation to be elsewhere on a Sunday ever again, and I can't believe people are seriously suggesting the OP doesn't go to the party. What an odd way of thinking.

Clymene · 27/12/2022 16:37

HowVeryLikeSibella · 27/12/2022 15:27

So BIL is expected to ask his wife's brother's wife's father to his birthday meal? Have I got that right?

Apparently so! Some people seem to live on Albert Square.

NumberTheory · 27/12/2022 16:34

MyNameisMathilda · 27/12/2022 16:11

No - it is the situation! He is alone. It is New Year's Day and she usually has him on a Sunday.

He’s a grown up whose daughter is missing their weekly Sunday lunch on one week (and promising to go along some other time instead). Most people don’t make a big deal out of New Year’s Day.

I suppose it might be different if he’d always made a big deal over New Years Day and maybe invited the BiL, SiL any of DH’s other siblings’ families and others over in the past. So I guess there’s some wiggle room but it seems super unlikely.

DoNotGetADog · 27/12/2022 16:32

Boomboom22 · 27/12/2022 16:07

OK so by your logic they should invite:
Ops husbands parents
The bil parents
The parents of any other siblings he or the sister have spouses parents

To the meal because they are all family now?

Well the first three of your categories are actually much more closely related to the birthday boy than OP’s dad!

C8H10N4O2 · 27/12/2022 16:31

Here's the point of my AIBU- DH thinks I was wrong to tell Dad the truth. He thinks I've created an awkward situation, and I should have made something else up. He is usually really reasonable but he's really annoyed with me

In general truth is better or simply tell him to take it up with his sister and BiL.

However if I read you right, this is your DF and your husband's BiL, ie no actual relationship between them? Unless they are good friends outside of the indirect family connection why would he expect to be invited?

Aprilx · 27/12/2022 16:30

HowVeryLikeSibella · 27/12/2022 15:27

So BIL is expected to ask his wife's brother's wife's father to his birthday meal? Have I got that right?

I was just trying to work that out too! I think it was really cheeky of OP to even ask if her dad was invited in the first place. If OP didn’t want her dad to be alone then she needed to decline the birthday meal, not ask to bring her dad!

BellePeppa · 27/12/2022 16:29

diddl · 27/12/2022 15:41

It's your husband's brother's bday?

I think that your Dad was cheeky to ask for an invitation tbh.

It's a "big" bday so your Dad is rarely on his own on NYD?

You saw him Christmas Day?

You can see him before or after lunch?

I think a lot of people don't expect to be hosted on NYD if they have been on CD.

Not sure that being on your on NYD is that bad is it?

I think it is her husband’s sister’s husband’s birthday.

diddl · 27/12/2022 16:25

Why is the SIL being called names/accused of being mean-it's not her party, she may not have decided who does/doesn't go!

BadNomad · 27/12/2022 16:24

A lack of space is a perfectly fine reason to not invite non-family and non-friends. There is nothing to be upset about or needing covered up. Tbh I think your dad is a bit cheeky to ask for an invitation!

ChicCroissant · 27/12/2022 16:21

I suspect that your DH was just annoyed at his sister having to take the blame/fault for having just one day off from giving your father a roast dinner, OP. If you do it every week, then it shouldn't be a big thing to miss one or two occasions. You should definitely go to the party, and they are under no obligation to invite your father.

I agree with the PP who have suggested switching the days of the meal up a bit, does your father have any friends or go out on his own? It can be easy to fall into a bit of a rut of depending solely on family and it does narrow down your father's world if he does this.

Puppers · 27/12/2022 16:20

I dont think anyone has done anything wrong. She isn't mean for not inviting him. Yes she obviously could have squeezed one more person in, but it's likely that if the party is at home space is an issue and they've likely been unable to invite whole families or groups of people who would have liked to come. They are probably trying to avoid explaining to aunt and uncle X why all the cousins and their kids weren't invited but their SIL's dad was.

I also think you were right to tell the truth. It would be very easy to lie about where you were going and then DS (or one of you!) slip up and mention it. Or another person who went to the party since you say that you do all socialise from time to time.

Tiltedandwilted · 27/12/2022 16:17

This thread is bonkers, for a site where most don’t like the idea of inviting their own MIL to theirs for Christmas there are lines of posters saying the SIL here is unreasonable for not inviting her brothers, wife’s father to her husbands birthday party?!

He is essentially an acquaintance, they see each other a handful of times a year, hardly ‘family’ or even friends.

Its incredibly unreasonable that the OP even asked if her dad was invited, that was ultimate cheeky fuckery, and the fact the dad also asked makes me wonder whether there are good reasons outside of the obvious (he isn’t their family) for him not to be invited.

DoNotGetADog · 27/12/2022 16:15

Viviennemary · 27/12/2022 15:18

It was mean to exclude him. And thats it. doesnt matter how he was told it was mean.

How is it mean to not have your wife’s brother’s wife’s father at your birthday party???!!!

He is no relation whatsoever and if OP’s Dad had been invited to things in the past then that’s a bonus and shouldn’t be expected.

Most people with that relationship between them would have met once at a wedding and that’s it.

The SIL is not being mean at all.

And yes, OP was right to just say the truth - it’s fine and normal and not something hurtful.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 27/12/2022 16:14

Overthebow · 27/12/2022 15:28

I think you should have your dad round as usual and not go to SIL to be honest. You have a long standing invite that he comes to yours each Sunday. Fair enough the occasional plan that clashes on a normal weekend, but this is New Year’s Day so a bit mean really and kind of like he comes to yours unless you get a better invite.

And BIL on his birthday? Should he anticipate others refusing all invitations because something that happens every other week of the year clashes once a year?

Be careful before you answer as that applies to every other day of the year too.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 27/12/2022 16:14

Is it just me who thinks NYD is a bit of a nothing day? Never felt under any obligation to see people then. Christmas Day yes, NYE maybe but not NYD You are going for a coffee in the morning, seeing him another day, I think that sounds fine and why make up a different reason when that one is fine.

PicturesOfDogs · 27/12/2022 16:13

You were right to be honest, what spontaneous lie did your DH expect you to invent?

Swipe left for the next trending thread