Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't like Welsh people

213 replies

snowstone · 27/12/2022 14:40

Said to me, a Welsh person born in Wales, married to a Welsh man, with two welsh children.

By my own father?!

He and my mum are looking at moving houses, I was asking about where and he mentioned they were a looking more at a specific county further away from me. I asked if they'd consider my county as we see them quite a bit. My dad said that my county is too Welsh, and the main draw of the other county is that it's much more English and he fits in better with English people, Welsh people are a bit odd and he doesn't like them and wants to be surrounded by English people.

Told him to move to fucking England then! My mum said I overreacted but it was just quite a grim thing to say to be honest, made me look at him a bit different. They were visiting for Christmas Day and the whole atmosphere turned a bit after that and they left earlier than planned. AIBU to be pissed off?!

OP posts:
Ericaequites · 27/12/2022 16:04

As for the Welsh woman who didn’t want give birth in an English hospital, just because the jenny cat has kittens in the oven of the old wood stove doesn’t make the kittens biscuits

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/12/2022 16:00

They tend to get really annoyed when native Welsh speakers don't doff their hats to their betters by switching to English....even if that English person is a total stranger, is not part of their conversation. The entitlement of that is unbelievable, but there are plenty of people here with that attitude.

I know somebody upthread has given their experience here, but I'm very sceptical about many of the 'speaking English then switching to Welsh when they saw me' anecdotes. Aside from the likelihood that somebody there previously didn't speak Welsh and needed them to use English, but now that person has left and so it's back to their default first language; in general, your average Welsh and average English person don't actually really look any different!

I realise that some people will deliberately use their own language (any language) for nefarious/exclusionary purposes when they know/assume people nearby won't understand it; but it's hardly the default - and you get unpleasant speakers of ALL languages.

I do think there are a lot of people who believe the Welsh language to be a conspiracy that was developed just to annoy and exclude non-Welsh speakers. It absolutely isn't a snarky hobby that some enjoy, just to be difficult: it's their first language!

MysteryBelle · 27/12/2022 15:57

Meant to add, my dh’s family is Welsh 😀and so my last name (took my dh’s) is actually a Welsh name.

Papergirl1968 · 27/12/2022 15:56

Derail not detail...

AdoraBell · 27/12/2022 15:55

I would have said something like - So, you don’t like me then? Or, I feel much the same about non Welsh people.

CAJIE · 27/12/2022 15:55

Bit ageist to assume your mid to late 60s parents have dementia.think u need to educate yourself on the stats ....it might just be their personalities.or are you one of those folk that like to put people in pigeonholes.

Papergirl1968 · 27/12/2022 15:55

Don't want to detail the thread but was the woman who said she didn't want to give birth in England the mother of April Jones? She was interviewed on a recent documentary about April's tragic murder and said she refused to be transferred to Liverpool during April's difficult birth, which shocked me somewhat.
I'm English, by the way, but love Wales, would like to live there one day, and am (slowly) learning Welsh on Duo Lingo.

MysteryBelle · 27/12/2022 15:55

snowstone · 27/12/2022 15:52

@mysterybelle Ha, he definitely does not class himself as welsh despite living here for so long. He was referring to himself as a proud Englishman during this very conversation. He wasn't making jokes at the expense of his 'own kind' he was snarling his mouth up at the thought of being surrounded by welsh people and saying he wants to be surrounded by fellow English people as welsh people are odd and he doesn't like them. I know him and was present for the conversation, there was nothing lighthearted about it

Ah, well you are the best judge of him as he is your father. I’d try to get at the root of his hostility. He is Welsh, is he not? Whether he classes himself as such or not 😂

snowstone · 27/12/2022 15:52

@mysterybelle Ha, he definitely does not class himself as welsh despite living here for so long. He was referring to himself as a proud Englishman during this very conversation. He wasn't making jokes at the expense of his 'own kind' he was snarling his mouth up at the thought of being surrounded by welsh people and saying he wants to be surrounded by fellow English people as welsh people are odd and he doesn't like them. I know him and was present for the conversation, there was nothing lighthearted about it

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 27/12/2022 15:50

Are there counties in England that folks wouldn't want to live in preferring others . I've Yorkshire family and there's areas they wouldn't consider

Loads but hopefully in the vast majority of cases people are just joking based on historic rivalries and stereotypes.

Verbena17 · 27/12/2022 15:50

Cuppasoupmonster · 27/12/2022 14:45

I saw an article the other day about a Welsh woman who had a very high risk pregnancy and had to consider giving birth at an English hospital which was better equipped for her issues. She said she refused as she definitely didn’t want her child to be born English Hmm I don’t understand inter-U.K. xenophobia, it’s bizarre.

You’d be surprised! Even more so with inter-England xenophobia.
When I was pregnant with DS, we were stationed in Wiltshire…..a few miles from Swindon. Numerous other military wives chose to have their babies at the John Radcliffe….so they could put Oxford on the birth certificate, instead of Swindon!! 😩

We opted for Swindon because we didn’t care and aren’t snobby.

donquixotedelamancha · 27/12/2022 15:48

Is Welsh a race?

Nobody is 'a race', humans don't have Scientific races (dogs do, cabbages do). Racism is the belief that human have sub groups which determine characteristics; any time someone thinks that about a group, it's racism.

There aren't some groups that it's valid to have prejudices about- all racism is equally silly.

MysteryBelle · 27/12/2022 15:48

AkoraEdelherb · 27/12/2022 15:00

When a region / language has been historically suppressed and its people have had to fight hard to conserve the tradition and culture, it’s not xenophobia wanting your child to be born there.

I’m not Welsh but I come from a similar country with 5 national identities and 4 different languages, with clear geographical separations. My children will probably not be raised there like I was, and there is literally no other chance for them to become native in the minority language (only local speakers keep it alive, and we will already be a trilingual family before any extra are introduced). Yes I do feel sad about it because it’s part of my identity and the culture is dying out. Through suppression from the national government - thankfully not currently, but through history more often than not.

You not understanding this feeling doesn’t make the woman xenophobic.

Well said. Op, I think you overreacted. He’s Welsh himself and oftentimes we refer to our “own kind” as quirky or whatever, that may be his meaning. I make jokes or observations sometimes about where I’m from, it’s with affection or frustration, not from bigotry. And he doesn’t mean every single Welsh person, he’s probably just thinking of several individuals he doesn’t fit in with, and understandably you took him to mean the entire group because of how he said it. I don’t think he is a bigot or phobic or racist or anything else. You took it personally but you don’t have to.

We’ve lost sight of the difference between real and malicious racism, and other stuff that is not that, because political groups use that tactic, calling this racism or that, to divide us and pit people against each other to suit their agenda. For an example I’ll give you Canada’s Trudeau. He belongs to the political left who use that tactic yet he himself has worn blackface so many times he admitted he couldn’t count how many times. A real racist yet he’s in good standing because he is on the side that accuses others of it as it gets and keeps them in power.

PurpleFlower1983 · 27/12/2022 15:48

Why did they move there in the first place OP?

Jumbojade · 27/12/2022 15:47

Alwaysworryingoversomething · 27/12/2022 14:46

I have heard so many negative comments about Welsh people over the years and I do not understand (i) what exactly people mean - I can't see a common thread through 'Welsh people' and (ii) why people think it's acceptable to say things like that.

Sorry you experienced that OP. I'm afraid in this instance, your dad sounds like an idiot - but I'm sure he's lovely the rest of the time!

I love Wales and regularly holiday there. However I understand one reason why some people don’t like it, depending on the area.

One holiday we stayed near Porthmadog, and I definitely wouldn’t go back to that area as we were sometimes made to feel it was anti-tourism. In one shop we entered the shopkeeper was talking to someone at the counter in English. They then changed and started speaking in Welsh when they noticed us, which I felt was pretty rude, so we left without buying anything (shop lost out on my buying a lovely painting they had). Unfortunately this wasn’t an isolated instance and similar happened several other times too!

Now, when we holiday in Wales, it is in the Rhyl / Colwyn Bay areas and we don’t go much further afield than Llandudno/ Conway. We have always felt much more welcome in these areas, than we did further West or South.

Weepachu · 27/12/2022 15:46

Welsh people (well, the ones I’ve met) are absolutely wonderful.
Your dad is bonkers.

Tanith · 27/12/2022 15:46

Ah, my Welsh husband wanted me to drive up the M4 and over the Severn Bridge into Wales on my due date for our first child so he'd have a Welsh birth certificate.
I set the midwife on him Grin

Op, just shove your father up to Llandudno Smile

snowstone · 27/12/2022 15:45

justasking111 · 27/12/2022 15:42

Are there counties in England that folks wouldn't want to live in preferring others . I've Yorkshire family and there's areas they wouldn't consider

There's nothing wrong with having a preference about where you want to live, of course, I wouldn't want to live in England as I am very happy in Wales. I wouldn't dream of saying I don't like English people?! That's clearly what the issue is here.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 27/12/2022 15:42

Are there counties in England that folks wouldn't want to live in preferring others . I've Yorkshire family and there's areas they wouldn't consider

Whatineed · 27/12/2022 15:41

Cuppasoupmonster · 27/12/2022 14:53

I mean what are the odds of them becoming an international rugby player…

My godfather, my geography teacher, my Uncles FIL, my school friend, 3 of his brothers and his dad, and my dad's best friend all played international rugby. 🤣🤣🤣

The odds in Wales can be pretty good.

The cultural identity is very important to a lot of Welsh people though.

Climbles · 27/12/2022 15:40

It’s a ridiculous and prejudiced thing to say. The older people in my family seem to be getting less and less tolerant as they get older and I try to mostly ignore them otherwise we’d have unnecessary arguments all the time.

DanFmDorking · 27/12/2022 15:39

Simon Evans

EarthSight · 27/12/2022 15:39

OP - can't you push your Dad to live in Gloucestershire or Herefordshire. Both rural counties with plenty of beautiful places, and it sounds like he'd be happier there.

EarthSight · 27/12/2022 15:35

@bigbluebus As someone from Gwynedd, I'm not surprised by this attitude.

OK, she didn't like some Welsh people who "deliberately " spoke their native language in front of her

🙄

Unfortunately there are some xenophobic types who move here because they want a piece of Little England as it was in the 1950s.....except it's not the 1950s.....and it's Wales. They tend to get really annoyed when native Welsh speakers don't doff their hats to their betters by switching to English....even if that English person is a total stranger, is not part of their conversation. The entitlement of that is unbelievable, but there are plenty of people here with that attitude.

Coooosd · 27/12/2022 15:32

What a stupid comment

I'm sure there are loads off annoying welsh people and equally loads of annoying English, Scottish and Irish people.

Also depends what you class as annoying, I find small minded people like your dad annoying

Swipe left for the next trending thread