Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't like Welsh people

213 replies

snowstone · 27/12/2022 14:40

Said to me, a Welsh person born in Wales, married to a Welsh man, with two welsh children.

By my own father?!

He and my mum are looking at moving houses, I was asking about where and he mentioned they were a looking more at a specific county further away from me. I asked if they'd consider my county as we see them quite a bit. My dad said that my county is too Welsh, and the main draw of the other county is that it's much more English and he fits in better with English people, Welsh people are a bit odd and he doesn't like them and wants to be surrounded by English people.

Told him to move to fucking England then! My mum said I overreacted but it was just quite a grim thing to say to be honest, made me look at him a bit different. They were visiting for Christmas Day and the whole atmosphere turned a bit after that and they left earlier than planned. AIBU to be pissed off?!

OP posts:
Strangeways19 · 27/12/2022 18:09

He doesn't like all Welsh people?! Like, all of them?
What does that even mean?

IaltagDhubh · 27/12/2022 18:07

StreamingCervix · 27/12/2022 16:41

I don’t want to cause a fight, but how would you honestly feel if you replaced the unwelcome in his community from wales to Brixton, and decided that he was holding animosity to a black community for making him feel like an outsider? Would you be sympathetic to his sense of disliking and othering another group?

Good question. Yes and no?

I’m not familiar with Brixton, or with the specific counties in wales that have been mentioned, so I don’t know if it’s an equivalent comparison. I feel like Brixton is much smaller in terms of area, so opportunities to find a likeminded community would be easier - ie taking a bus 5 miles to see friends rather than driving across several counties. So less opportunity for resentment to build up?

If a white person was living in a majority black community, socialising mainly with black people, and constantly being made to feel as if he was an outsider, then I guess those same feelings of resentment could be expected. Obviously, it’s completely unacceptable to express that as “I hate black people” though.

MsGrumpytrousers · 27/12/2022 17:49

It's racism, isn't it? You wouldn't accept that kind of nasty blanket criticism of any other race, so why is it okay to say it about the Welsh?

I think you're right to be furious, and good for you for speaking out.

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 17:36

You start a thread about this

but not about fact he and your mother refused to attend your child’s nativity play because it was in Welsh?

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 17:35

snowstone · 27/12/2022 17:22

@Ursuladevine He did snarl, I saw his face, he looked disgusted! What a strange assumption to make that I despise my father because I said that he snarled.. he did snarl. And no I don't despise him generally, I didn't like the comment he made.

Oh no

The love you have for him and the positive relationship just oozes through this thread 😂

MinnieMountain · 27/12/2022 17:31

Does he have any Welsh friends or are they all English people who moved to Wales?

I’m from Pembs. DH’s aunt and uncle moved to my village from
England. They don’t like Welsh people because the locals weren’t friendly to them (because the aunt and uncle are knobheads).

returningbrit · 27/12/2022 17:25

He has his opinion. Was blunt and i wouldn't be happy about it myself but it is up to you to decide if his values are not acceptable in your life.

snowstone · 27/12/2022 17:22

@Ursuladevine He did snarl, I saw his face, he looked disgusted! What a strange assumption to make that I despise my father because I said that he snarled.. he did snarl. And no I don't despise him generally, I didn't like the comment he made.

OP posts:
Exibstudent · 27/12/2022 17:16

I hate your dads attitude. I'm from pembs and I'm a native English speaker. I'm not less Welsh than any other Welsh person- English main language speaking Welsh people are the majority of the Welsh population.

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 17:13

snowstone · 27/12/2022 15:52

@mysterybelle Ha, he definitely does not class himself as welsh despite living here for so long. He was referring to himself as a proud Englishman during this very conversation. He wasn't making jokes at the expense of his 'own kind' he was snarling his mouth up at the thought of being surrounded by welsh people and saying he wants to be surrounded by fellow English people as welsh people are odd and he doesn't like them. I know him and was present for the conversation, there was nothing lighthearted about it

He was “snarling his mouth up”

op you obviously despise him 🤷‍♀️

20RegalPlease · 27/12/2022 17:12

I think you’ve proven your dad’s point OP

curleyismyname · 27/12/2022 17:07

Did you have a sign on your forehead with "I am English" on it????

fancyacuppatea · 27/12/2022 17:01

Born n bred in England - some Welsh via both GMs, although my M & D didn't give a fig. Technically 1/6 of me is Welsh. Daffodil

I've learned some Welsh (from S4C) so can understand a few phrases.

And unlike other posters, I really have had the "Oh shit, let's change from English to Welsh" when I've visited a shop or a pub. 🥱

The difference between southern welsh and northern ("gog") are fascinating to me.

@snowstone Start talking to him in Welsh only. He won't know what to do, say or think. 😵😉

Mooshamoo · 27/12/2022 17:00

My mum does this all the time! It's bizarre. My mum is Irish, she moved to England 40 years ago. Her two children were born in England. She moved back to Ireland where we live now.

She will constantly say to me that she doesn't like English people and that English people are awful. I have pointed out to her on many occasions that her own two children are English, but she doesn't stop!

I can't understand it. If I moved to Germany and my two children were born in Germany, I don't think I would say to my own children that I hate German people. It's nasty

BigglyBee · 27/12/2022 16:53

hiraethheart · 27/12/2022 16:45

Pendine ❤️ I grew up there too, and went to Tremoilet primary school. Did you?!

It does make me a little sad to visit these days, Pendine is a ghost town in the winter and has been thoroughly taken over by Parkdean Resorts - and Tremoilet is closed down!

I went to Llanmiloe! Tremoilet was much nicer- we went there for a cookery lesson or something once. I'm really sad to hear that your old school has closed.

lieselotte · 27/12/2022 16:47

One of my best friends went to Bangor University and I remember being quite disappointed that I didn't hear anyone speaking Welsh there (I went to Cardiff and probably heard more there).

However a few years ago I visited Denbigh and people did speak Welsh there (and English with a distinct Merseyside accent!)

Ursuladevine · 27/12/2022 16:47

i will take a punt that this issue aside… you and your father aren’t exactly close

lieselotte · 27/12/2022 16:45

I'm very sceptical about many of the 'speaking English then switching to Welsh when they saw me' anecdotes

Me too. It belongs in the Did Not Happen box.

I also don't understand the inter-UK xenophobia - the UK is too small for people to be stupid about what accent you have (which is effectively what it boils down to, as you don't know that someone is English/Welsh/Irish/Scottish until they speak, and even then they might live in one country and have that accent but be born in another, and have parents from yet another).

hiraethheart · 27/12/2022 16:45

BigglyBee · 27/12/2022 16:33

I lived in Wales as a child (in Pendine). Back then there was far less effort made to promote Welsh as a language, but it was still taught at school. I always found that people were always pleased when I at least tried to speak Welsh, even though I was pretty bad at it! I never noticed anyone switching to Welsh when I arrived anywhere, but I wasn't looking for it, and I was a visitor to their country, so it never occurred to me to be offended by them speaking the language of that country.
I miss Wales. I was really, properly happy there.
OP, your dad sounds like he was completely in the wrong. I have experienced something slightly similar from my (Scottish) children, who were very anti-English for a while. I pointed out two things to them; that they are half-English, and also that if you want "purity" then you end up in real trouble- not in the Nazi sense, necessarily, but in the "this is what happens when too many cousins marry" sense.

Pendine ❤️ I grew up there too, and went to Tremoilet primary school. Did you?!

It does make me a little sad to visit these days, Pendine is a ghost town in the winter and has been thoroughly taken over by Parkdean Resorts - and Tremoilet is closed down!

StreamingCervix · 27/12/2022 16:41

IaltagDhubh · 27/12/2022 16:26

If he’s spent years feeling unwelcome in the community that he’s been living in, I can kind of understand that that that might turn to resentment and a bit of an English vs Welsh view. Presumably he wasn’t including you or your family in his “I hate welsh people” comments, because you don’t exclude him. You are not “Welsh people” you are simply his daughter and grandchildren, just the same as he isn’t “English people” to you, he’s just your dad? Unless you do have a tendency to put down England and English culture, plaster welsh flags around etc. In which case, perhaps you have inadvertently been making him feel the same as he made you feel. You could try buying him a few welsh phrase books, or encouraging him to try Duolingo or some Welsh beginner classes, and getting your DC to try to teach him a few words of Welsh.

I don’t want to cause a fight, but how would you honestly feel if you replaced the unwelcome in his community from wales to Brixton, and decided that he was holding animosity to a black community for making him feel like an outsider? Would you be sympathetic to his sense of disliking and othering another group?

Salome61 · 27/12/2022 16:39

My Mum's family are Welsh and friends and I went to stay with my great aunt in Cardiff in the late 70's. My Mum was born in Caerphilly. We didn't stay long, it seemed quite hostile to tourists then.

SirVixofVixHall · 27/12/2022 16:39

Little England Beyond Wales refers to below the Landsker line, not Pembrokeshire as a whole.

CoffeeBoy · 27/12/2022 16:37

“Little England beyond Wales” is how my (very Welsh) ex boss described Pembrokeshire to me.

her husband once took me to the Presili hills to pick a horse up and warned me “they’re all a bit odd out there, they all speak Welsh”. 😁

gogohmm · 27/12/2022 16:34

How odd an attitude. Pembrokeshire is lovely but too touristy for me, poor man's Cornwall (or not so poor it isn't cheap!) please don't send him over the bridge to England though, we how enough little Englanders in Somerset!

I'd happily live in wales and dd (who lives there) has passable Welsh after 2.5 years

BigglyBee · 27/12/2022 16:33

I lived in Wales as a child (in Pendine). Back then there was far less effort made to promote Welsh as a language, but it was still taught at school. I always found that people were always pleased when I at least tried to speak Welsh, even though I was pretty bad at it! I never noticed anyone switching to Welsh when I arrived anywhere, but I wasn't looking for it, and I was a visitor to their country, so it never occurred to me to be offended by them speaking the language of that country.
I miss Wales. I was really, properly happy there.
OP, your dad sounds like he was completely in the wrong. I have experienced something slightly similar from my (Scottish) children, who were very anti-English for a while. I pointed out two things to them; that they are half-English, and also that if you want "purity" then you end up in real trouble- not in the Nazi sense, necessarily, but in the "this is what happens when too many cousins marry" sense.

Swipe left for the next trending thread