Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find Matilda hard to watch?

246 replies

susiesuelou · 27/12/2022 09:59

I know it's just a work of fiction for kids and that it all comes good in the end for Matilda, but I've been watching it this morning whilst toddler DD naps and it's struck me just how horrible it is (the start especially). Particularly the part where she begs to be allowed books to read and the Dad holds her head and forces her to watch TV instead. Not being acknowledged by her mum when she comes in from school and wants to tell her about her day. 🥹

And don't get me started on the abusive practices of Miss Trunchbull! Particularly force feeding chocolate cake to that boy! I actually skipped through that part.

I've watched it before but never really watched it, if that makes sense. And it's just left an uncomfortable feeling.

AIBU? Am I too sensitive? I know the answer is probably yes, as it's just a film after all. But has anyone else had similar discomfort watching it?

OP posts:
Eatentoomanyroses · 27/12/2022 20:33

@Sometimeswinning sorry bit slow today. What do you mean that’s not the reason?

Sometimeswinning · 27/12/2022 20:30

Eatentoomanyroses · 27/12/2022 20:22

Don’t watch the new one. I found it very uncomfortable. The old one I could just about deal with because well it’s Danny Devito so hard to take his meanness seriously. Went to see the musical version in the cinema. I could hardly look. I do work in a safeguarding role though so might be a bit more sensitive

I also work in safeguarding. That's not the reason you could not look. People who know Matilda are aware of what goes on. Matilda grows despite her parents.

Eatentoomanyroses · 27/12/2022 20:24

keeprunning55 · 27/12/2022 19:12

The new film version is brilliant but incredibly scary and sad in parts.
I’m still haunted by the part in The Witches where children are trapped inside paintings forever. Roald Dahl certainly had a wild and disturbing imagination.

Not just me then! The girl trapped in the painting getting older... I was terrified

picklemewalnuts · 27/12/2022 20:23

Actually just been to se it and loved it, despite everything I said earlier!!
Far better than the books, from a sensitivity to nastiness perspective!

Eatentoomanyroses · 27/12/2022 20:22

Don’t watch the new one. I found it very uncomfortable. The old one I could just about deal with because well it’s Danny Devito so hard to take his meanness seriously. Went to see the musical version in the cinema. I could hardly look. I do work in a safeguarding role though so might be a bit more sensitive

Crispyturtle · 27/12/2022 20:21

I found Matilda to be uplifting! She’s so feisty and brave and doesn’t take the shit the adults give her lying down. She stands up for her friends and what’s right, and the awful adults get what’s coming to them in the end, and Matilda finds happiness.

HotChoxs · 27/12/2022 20:19

SarahAndQuack · 27/12/2022 18:40

Please show me where universities have been 'cancelling' books from their curriculums, or explain what you think is wrong with a content warning for any book?

I have taught English Lit at one of the universities that is regularly slated in ignorant articles making up nonsense about 'cancel culture'. We've never 'cancelled' anything, but people love to froth. A colleague of mine had packed lecture halls for his lectures on Shakespeare at the exact time some idiot wrote a Torygraph piece claiming students were trying to ban certain authors. Some people seem genuinely unable to understand that Shakespeare would have been only too delighted to think Titus Andronicus would stimulate visceral reactions.

It's the same thing here. Why on earth does anyone think that discussing books is the same thing as banning them?

There's this thing called google.

SarahAndQuack · 27/12/2022 20:16

MaryJean87 · 27/12/2022 19:52

I'm sure she's still alive.

The mother of the actress playing Matilda did die during filming (the film is dedicated to her). I'm pretty sure this is what the poster meant here.

MargaretThursday · 27/12/2022 20:05

MaryJean87 · 27/12/2022 19:52

I'm sure she's still alive.

That was the older Matilda movie and yes Mara Wilson, I think her name was, her mother died from cancer just after she'd finished filming. There's quite a sweet story about someone pinching the film and taking it to show her as she wasn't going to be able to make the premier (I think she died before it was shown)

I don't think from what I've seen she was made to keep working, but more it was a distraction from what was going on at home.

Needmorelego · 27/12/2022 20:04

@MaryJean87 the actress whose mother died while filming was Mara Wilson in the 90s Matilda film - not the actress of this new version.
Mara Wilson has spoken about her filming experiences and her mother many times over the years.

MaryJean87 · 27/12/2022 19:52

Rockmehardplace · 27/12/2022 19:46

i find it hard to watch as the actress playing matilda’s mother was dying during filming and they just kept her working :/

I'm sure she's still alive.

Rockmehardplace · 27/12/2022 19:46

i find it hard to watch as the actress playing matilda’s mother was dying during filming and they just kept her working :/

Whatwhatwhatnow · 27/12/2022 19:43

pyjamaramabanana · 27/12/2022 14:54

This is a fascinating thread which is right up my street, lots of interesting points. Thank you everyone.

I write a blog looking at horror in kids fiction and childhood in horror films, and I hope some of you will enjoy it based on this discussion.
See a clip of Hitchcock (another very nasty man) talking about fear in childhood. 'You see it all starts with a baby. And the mother says 'BOO!' And the baby giggles.'
https://childishthingshorror.wordpress.com/about/

My short view: we need to explore the dark sides of life, to help us grow, learn and cope with the world and become a fully rounded adult. The world itself is full of dark as well as light, and fiction is a healthy and safe way for kids and adults to process it. Kids are not stupid and early on they know that there is darkness in the world, whether from their immediate experience or through observing the world beyond their own family. Kids fiction - in fact any fiction? - with zero darkness in it is a bit insubstantial and anodyne, isn't it?

Maurice Sendak:
“Children are tough, though we tend to think of them as fragile. They have to be tough. Childhood is not easy. We sentimentalize children, but they know what’s real and what’s not. They understand metaphor and symbol. If children are different from us, they are more spontaneous. Grown-up lives have become overlaid with dross.“

I want to do a future blog post about Roald Dahl and that whole thing of whether we can or should separate art from artist. I don't think he was a 'nice man', if I were his relative I could imagine arguments and possible estrangement. But the point is well made in this thread; people are complicated. Life is complicated. There was a lot of trauma in his generation and his life. And traumatised people don't always recover. And trauma isnt an excuse for doing harm. Maybe virulent anti-semitism was pretty common in his day, and it doesn't mean it was or is ok.
I think you can love a piece of art while still knowing sad painful unpleasant things about the person who created it. Its your own personal choice to read it or not.

This is my piece about Where the Wild things are and also In the night kitchen.
Maurice Sendak IMHO actually genuinely was a lovely man, I get quite choked up reading interviews with him.
Unlike RD - and see MS's quote about RD!
“The cruelty in his books is off-putting. Scary guy. I know he’s very popular but what’s nice about this guy? He’s dead, that’s what’s nice about him.”

MS's books are filled with the trauma of the Holocaust and growing up with traumatised parents. The wild things are his Jewish immigrant aunts and uncles.

And another one about why Jemima Puddle Duck reminds me of the Silence of the Lambs. JPD is a rehash of that Little Red riding hood fairy tale archetype.

This stuff is all there if you look.

Interesting - I read Jemima to dc yesterday!

As I mentioned up thread, Matilda, for me, is remarkably similar to Carrie!

FloorWipes · 27/12/2022 19:42

The new film version is brilliant but incredibly scary and sad in parts.

Interesting as I didn’t perceive it as scary. I can hear my 4 year old attempting the songs in the bath just now. She’s watched the new musical film at least 5 times already which is a bit shameful from a screen time perspective but she just loves it. I’m to call her Matilda now apparently. I suppose the worst thing that happens is essentially Miss Trunchbull committing a double murder which I agree sounds really bad, but DD understood that Miss Trunchbull is very bad and gets her comeuppance in the end and also that the whole thing is only a story. Or maybe I’m a terrible parent.

Agree The Witches was scary but I think that’s partly why I loved it as a child and still do. Still gives me a chill down my spine - more the memory of the fear I felt as a child - which I enjoy.

NewNovember · 27/12/2022 19:17

@keeprunning55 I took my 7 year old to see it, there is nothing even vaguely scary.

keeprunning55 · 27/12/2022 19:12

The new film version is brilliant but incredibly scary and sad in parts.
I’m still haunted by the part in The Witches where children are trapped inside paintings forever. Roald Dahl certainly had a wild and disturbing imagination.

SingedToast · 27/12/2022 18:46

SarahAndQuack · 27/12/2022 18:40

Please show me where universities have been 'cancelling' books from their curriculums, or explain what you think is wrong with a content warning for any book?

I have taught English Lit at one of the universities that is regularly slated in ignorant articles making up nonsense about 'cancel culture'. We've never 'cancelled' anything, but people love to froth. A colleague of mine had packed lecture halls for his lectures on Shakespeare at the exact time some idiot wrote a Torygraph piece claiming students were trying to ban certain authors. Some people seem genuinely unable to understand that Shakespeare would have been only too delighted to think Titus Andronicus would stimulate visceral reactions.

It's the same thing here. Why on earth does anyone think that discussing books is the same thing as banning them?

I’m also a university lecturer in a literature department, and no one at any of he institutions I’ve taught at is ‘cancelling books’. I teach a module on banned books.

SarahAndQuack · 27/12/2022 18:40

HotChoxs · 27/12/2022 17:05

Alternatively the poster was right but didn't quite know how to express it. But let me just point out to you, since you've been living under a rock, that various Universities have begun "cancelling" books from their curriculums and giving trigger warnings for books such as Oliver Twist. They are right in that there is a cultural shift in terms of literature sensitivity.

Please show me where universities have been 'cancelling' books from their curriculums, or explain what you think is wrong with a content warning for any book?

I have taught English Lit at one of the universities that is regularly slated in ignorant articles making up nonsense about 'cancel culture'. We've never 'cancelled' anything, but people love to froth. A colleague of mine had packed lecture halls for his lectures on Shakespeare at the exact time some idiot wrote a Torygraph piece claiming students were trying to ban certain authors. Some people seem genuinely unable to understand that Shakespeare would have been only too delighted to think Titus Andronicus would stimulate visceral reactions.

It's the same thing here. Why on earth does anyone think that discussing books is the same thing as banning them?

SockGoddess · 27/12/2022 18:29

Don’t forget Worzel Gummage - his sentence for throwing a potato at the Crownman was to be burned alive.

Worzel Gummidge scared me shitless as a child! Not so much Worzel himself but the Crowman and Aunt Sally. I didn't understand who they were and the whole thing seemed to be about some kind of deep and terrifying magic under everyday life (I didn't think of it in those terms but that's why I was scared of it).

Children's literature is a strange thing – it's meant to be entertaining and fun but the most memorable and successful examples are always dark in some way and deal with fear, abuse, sadness or monsters. You can often sense a lot about the author through the literature, this is very true of Dahl. Also Sendak, Rowling, and the (IMO genius) writer Arnold Lobel.

HotChoxs · 27/12/2022 17:05

SarahAndQuack · 27/12/2022 15:46

Grin

What you mean is, 'oops, I made up a pile of nonsense,' isn't it?

You said something, which I questioned, and now you are pretending it wasn't 'literal'. What you mean is, it wasn't even tangentially related to the truth.

Alternatively the poster was right but didn't quite know how to express it. But let me just point out to you, since you've been living under a rock, that various Universities have begun "cancelling" books from their curriculums and giving trigger warnings for books such as Oliver Twist. They are right in that there is a cultural shift in terms of literature sensitivity.

Oher · 27/12/2022 16:28

Yanbu. So much ‘kids tv’ has very nasty stuff in it, my son is 10 but he gets upset by this kind of thing.

TV/film is made by insensitive types and aimed at insensitive types and if you are highly sensitive (in the sense described here hsperson.com) then there’s a lot to avoid.

Forestfire12345 · 27/12/2022 16:24

God only knows why these god awful books are revered. A vile man who poured a little poison into every child's ear.

beastlyslumber · 27/12/2022 16:08

HotChoxs · 27/12/2022 14:35

The Lion the witch and the wardrobe, child gets kidnapped by old woman using sweets as bait, locked up, tortured and stabbed.

Alice in Wonderland - neglected child falls down a hole, nearly drowns, is forced to look after a pig child and tortured by having pepper thrown in her eyes, goes to a tea party where everyone is high, is told stories of torment and made to participate in a cruel game without knowing the rules. Through the Looking Glass is even worse.

MargaretThursday · 27/12/2022 16:04

I think though that Matilda's treatment is so extreme that it becomes acceptable again. A lot of Dahl is like that. Extreme to make a point, and also it then becomes fiction rather than scary. Even my dd2 who was very easily frightened by books never blinked reading Matilda.
It's a bit like the beginning of Harry Potter. The Dursleys would never have treated Harry like that, because people would have talked. As they were effectively fostering Harry, even though it was family, they would have been social services involvement. They were all about appearances. They'd have paraded Harry as an example of how wonderfully generous they were. He'd have looked fine on the outside however coldly they treated him inside their house.

Personally, I'm not keen on Dahl; there's something about them that makes my skin crawl. I read something written by him where he'd said that children liked his books because in them the adults are the baddies and children think "ah! at last we have an author who understands us. He knows that we look on adults as the enemy. Only children can rescue us."
I was primary school age, so the age he was talking about, at the time and was confused. Because if I fell and hurt my knee etc I went to find a grown up. I didn't look round for some other child. Was I not meant to do this then?
As a parent, I think that was quite a dangerous message for him to think, because at times children need the protection of adults, and need to feel that they can ask for help.

But I do like the Matilda, especially the musical version. It's how a little girl comes through against all odds. It's a story of love-between her and Miss Honey, and how the evil (her parents and Miss Trunchball) doesn't stop them.

SarahAndQuack · 27/12/2022 15:46

Andsoforth · 27/12/2022 15:35

(Sigh) I forget how depressingly literal one has to be on MN, even discussing literature.

Let me rephrase, then: there have been strong opinions expressed on threads over the years about classicism, jingoism, antisemitism, homophobia and racism in a massive swathe of literature, etc.

My point is that it is easier to spot the problems hidden in current cultural trends if you don’t pretend that bad things never existed.

It’s just as important to see the naive romanticism in late 19th c literature that inspired thousands of teens and young adults to sacrifice themselves for war.

Currently I would suggest that we desensitise our children to horror, suffering and trauma from a very young age, and I have no doubt this too will play out in time.

My point is that I don’t advocate shying away from difficult topics but I’m not sure they all deserve an equal place on the nursery shelves.

Grin

What you mean is, 'oops, I made up a pile of nonsense,' isn't it?

You said something, which I questioned, and now you are pretending it wasn't 'literal'. What you mean is, it wasn't even tangentially related to the truth.