Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to get a puppy?

84 replies

TodayIsFridayHooray · 27/12/2022 08:00

Been looking for the last year for a rescue pup. Finally the perfect pup has come up and we can collect today. Now the time has finally come round, I'm freaking out!!!

Will we cope?

It will be DH, 2 X DC, me and the pup! I work mainly from home most of the week but in the office sometimes. DH works full time (not from home). The dog will be mainly my responsibility to walk etc..

We had dogs all though my childhood so I know what I'm doing I think. But it's such a big responsibility! Feel like I'm getting last minute cold feet!

If you have a doggy, was it worth it? Do you have any regrets? Or is it the best thing you've ever done?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
GreenDanglyearrings · 27/12/2022 10:02

I researched what type of dog breed I wanted. We visited rescues for ages but couldn't find the breed. We found a rescue puppy so immediately went to visit her and were lucky to have her.

I felt sad taking her away from her mum and the first couple of weeks I slept on the sofa with her as she just wanted to nuzzle into my neck. She cried terribly If we put her in a crate or left her. Her toilet training took quite a few weeks.

We don't regret it at all. She's 6 years old now and probably the best dog in the world. She is loved by everyone. We will all need therapy if something happened to her! We are a happy home but she brings an extra bit of happiness into it.

She's a whippet, so doesn't moult, bark or be hyper. When I work from home - she just sleeps upstairs on my daughters bed.

Think about the breed traits carefully or chose an older rescue where youll know their personality. I don't think we would have had such a positive experience if she was a hyper boxer/visler/husky!

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 27/12/2022 10:02

My huge red flag here is a rescue releasing not just a dog but a puppy so close to Christmas.

Yes people could give far better advise if the age and breed was known - a working line Mal is going to be far harder work than a cavalier as an example, a lab is going to be very mouthy compared to several other breeds, terrier types are likely to be very stubborn… etc

Polkadotties · 27/12/2022 10:00

A poster up thread said they thought they had PND after getting a puppy. I completely understand. I got a lab puppy back in the summer. After a couple of weeks of getting up multiple times during the night, having to look after a bitey land shark during the day I thought I was going mad.
My dog is nearly 7 months old and is more like a little dog rather than a puppy but it’s been bloody hard work.

KimmySchmitt · 27/12/2022 09:52

Depending on the dog, are you aware you might not be able to work from home effectively? I have a spaniel who goes to daycare when we're both in work. She's almost 2 and a half. It's only in the last 9 months or so that I could feasibly have her at home with me while I WFH. Before that it was just impossible, on the few occasions I had to have her at home (daycare closed due to covid or she was sick) I just didn't get anything done.

I had horrendous puppy blues. After a few months everything fell into place and she's now the best thing ever, but I put a hell of a lot of work (and time and money) into training her. She's my first dog and I'm glad I got her as a puppy; as much as I'd have liked to rescue for ethical reasons, I feel that for my first dog I needed a clean slate.

My in laws got a puppy earlier in the year. He's a very different character to mine, much more chilled. However because of this they just haven't bothered to train him. He now can't be left alone, refuses to wear a harness or a coat, won't be bathed... etc. So even an 'easy' puppy can set you up for real issues.

You've failed to answer questions about age, breed, or the circumstances of the rescue, which is your prerogative I guess but does give me some concerns.

FarFlungFlamingo · 27/12/2022 09:49

I probably wouldn't do it again, mainly because we have no back up. I realised far too late that my friends with dogs all had family members with dogs and had reciprocal arrangements for ad hoc care. Whilst we can board our dog to go away, it's something that needs to be arranged months in advance. In an emergency we'd be screwed.

JamNittyGritty · 27/12/2022 09:40

Growing up we always had dogs, I absolutely loved them and am still a dog person. I have 2 dc now but would never have a dog. They tie you down too much- what happens if you want to go out for the day as a family to a non dog friendly place? Go away for a night at a weekend? It cannot be left home alone for more than 5 hours as an adult dog and hardly at all as a puppy / young dog. It completely changes what you can & can’t do. My friend got one a couple of years ago, she loves it dearly but really regrets it as it’s limited their lifestyle in so many ways. Another friend uses doggy daycare but it’s horribly expensive.
I would do a serious reality check about the impact on your life (yes I know many positives too)

Hoppinggreen · 27/12/2022 09:38

Theduchy · 27/12/2022 08:10

We did two years ago. Years of thought went into it. We aren't new dog owners. It was the worst mistake we ever made.

I had a certain breed from childhood and always wanted one as an adult. We Waited until the youngest child was 7, planned and researched carefully, had looked after friends dogs etc etc etc. We love him to bits and when he was ill last year and we nearly lost him I was distraught.
BUT if I could turn back the clock I probably wouldn’t have got him. It’s such a huge tie and while we have had some great times with him it’s been difficult at times too

losingit31 · 27/12/2022 09:36

Reading this, I'm so glad we didn't get a puppy! Mine was 2 weeks short of his first birthday according to the records we received and he's a rescue maltipoo. We have been incredibly lucky with him, he has such a sweet nature and is a fast learner. I'm pleased we missed his puppy stage!

yaflouloci · 27/12/2022 09:32

They're absolutely brilliant.

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 27/12/2022 09:32

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

BootifulLoser · 27/12/2022 09:31

bitfit · 27/12/2022 09:17

Depends massively on the dog as well. We had a lab puppy and he was really difficult. I felt really depressed for ages. He needed tons of attention (obviously) but he seemed impossible to train. We now have a 9 week old border collie pup and she is a dream. Smart so has already got a grip of sit stay and lie down and she has a crate that she sleeps in and goes to whenever she's ready for a rest. Brace yourself. The puppy days are hard and tiring, but so worth it

Interesting! One of our dogs was a lab/collie cross. She was an adorable puppy, easy to train and very rapidly became a calm, gentle, loving dog. She was our sweetheart. I cried for three days straight when she died at the ripe old age of 16.

BootifulLoser · 27/12/2022 09:28

Just do it! Puppies are the most adorable creatures alive! You know what you're doing. You won't regret it for a second.

dnaconundrum · 27/12/2022 09:28

Worst thing I’ve ever done - two rescue pups

they give unconditional love, snuggle me when I’m sad - ew
make my heart hurt with love
I would die for them

the pain that will come when they pass - not sure I’ll be able to take it

Suzi888 · 27/12/2022 09:27

What breed are you getting?
No regrets here, there were times I thought “OMFG you have to be fooking kidding me” but they were brief. Usually because DDog had destroyed something, chewed something or been really been a bloody nuisance. 🤣But it doesn’t last long and so loving. They are a tie though.

Days out can be awkward, kennels can’t be booked short notice, trips need to be planned.

ChessieDarling · 27/12/2022 09:26

Of course you’re going to cope, you’ll be absolutely fine.. with the occasional WTF did I do this for
moment I’m sure 😂 it sounds like just last minute nerves, you’ve obviously thought this through and done your research to have got to this point with a rescue puppy.
I’ve got two dogs, both are fast asleep with me now, one on my legs and one by my side. I got one when I was 19 and with my ex, he’s now 9 and definitely starting to slow down but he’s been with me, my little hairy best bud, through a break up with my ex, living back at my mums for a while, meeting, moving in with then marrying my husband (DDog was at our wedding) and he was there when I brought DS home from hospital, my little shadow through everything. We got 3 month old DDog2 when DS was 7 months and while it’s not all been completely plain sailing and I did question my decision a bit prior to getting her and certainly a bit since, she’s an angel and we all adore her.
Just always remember that you get out what you put in. The more time, love, effort and consistent training you can give to the puppy, the better (and happier!) dog you’ll end up with.

Tumbleweed101 · 27/12/2022 09:25

It’s worth it but first two years can be hard work. Initially it’s the back and forth to do toilet training which can feel relentless (especially when you catch flu the day after bringing home a new puppy 🙄). Then it’s the chewing everything and later, if you get a boy, marking behaviours.

I’d had a couple of puppies in the past through the years so was prepared for the work, but it would be a shock if you weren’t expecting it. My most recent puppy is nearly four now and fully trained and a good boy in the house for the most part. I’m at the stage where I can just enjoy him.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 27/12/2022 09:20

Make sure you do puppy classes (for you to learn).

i love dpup - guess 2.5 years and I adore him but I’ve concluded I’m a dog person and not a puppy person. Puppies are dicks. Cute but dicks. It’s like having a toddler.

bitfit · 27/12/2022 09:17

Depends massively on the dog as well. We had a lab puppy and he was really difficult. I felt really depressed for ages. He needed tons of attention (obviously) but he seemed impossible to train. We now have a 9 week old border collie pup and she is a dream. Smart so has already got a grip of sit stay and lie down and she has a crate that she sleeps in and goes to whenever she's ready for a rest. Brace yourself. The puppy days are hard and tiring, but so worth it

TodayIsFridayHooray · 27/12/2022 09:17

Thanks all :) A healthy dose of reality for me, but also really lovely to see how most people are overall happy with their furry friend :) wish me luck!!!

OP posts:
TodayIsFridayHooray · 27/12/2022 09:16

SamPoodle123 · 27/12/2022 08:54

My dh was so against us getting a dog. He always said he wanted one in the future. But a VERY tough year for me with my father dying plus two close friends dying all within a couple months of each other meant, I decided to take things into my own hands. I wanted a change, some happiness and I was not willing to wait for my husband to be ready. We had been talking about getting a dog for years. I had done loads of research. So I went ahead and put a deposit down to get the dog I researched would be the best fit for our family. Six months later the dog was ready (I wanted a certain bread, female, fur). Anyway, I told my husband that we need to drive 3 hours to view the dog. He was like "WHAT!?!?!!?!" I told him we are just going to look, but bring your card in case we want to buy. I was completely ready to walk away if we both felt the dog was not the right one or that the breeder was shady when viewing it. And btw at the time our kids were 4 and 5.

It was love at first sight. My dh could not resist (I knew he would not). It has now been 4 years and we have added a third dc since. My dh will be the first to tell everyone to get a dog, he will talk your ear off about how wonderful our dog is. And I would do the same :) It was the BEST decision for us. Our dog is the easiest and most kind dog ever. Super smart. Even as a 8 week old puppy. She was easy. A dream dog. HOWEVER, this is not the case with all dogs. I did a lot of research and I knew the right way to train her. I have seen some friends get dogs and struggle because they chose a dog for looks and it was too hyper or annoying. But everyone who say my dog and fell in love....that decided to get the same breed have had no regrets. They also had it easy and fell in love. We have an australian labradoodle btw. It is the best family dog and a great first hand dog bc they are so smart and easy to train. My only complaint is the paws attract so much mud and my dog love mud, puddles etc :) But it is well worth it. She brings so much joy, love and happiness to us all. And for us, she was super easy and we decided to have a third child two years after getting our dog bc she was so easy.

That's nice to read :) thanks! :)

OP posts:
Sunnysidegold · 27/12/2022 09:14

We had been thinking about a dog for years but had been advised by the shelter to go for a pup as we had kids, and they always went so quickly. A situation arose where a friend's brother had a litter of pups and we decided to go for it.

The first two months were hard. Really hard! Toilet training, as mentioned upthread, out after every play time, every meal, every sleep and then every hour in between. We were determined to crate train and the crate was in our bedroom at night so we could take her out. It was like going back to baby sleepless nights!

But then we turned a corner, and she now sleeps in her crate in the kitchen all night through. She is a lovely temperament and I love snuggling her.

There is a lot of expense as mentioned, and we are fortunate due to working from home that we don't need walkers or doggy day care. We have family who will look after her if we are to be out for long periods.

The only downside is the chewing. I know it's not all dogs, but this one chews everything despite the plethora of chew toys provided.

Now that she is here we wouldn't be without her. The kids often comment on how much they love her and how it was the best decision we made.

TodayIsFridayHooray · 27/12/2022 09:14

Beginningless · 27/12/2022 08:45

Our pup is now 20wks and it’s been some of the worst couple of months of my life to be frank! And I am sahm. Perhaps that’s why it’s been so bad, I haven’t had work or any way to get away from him. Sometimes I adore him but tbh I have advised all my friends who are keen not to do it. I think the age of your kids is important tbh, they have to be able to reliably follow the puppy rules and at 4 and 7, they can’t. The elder is better and getting there but they just want to cuddle him when they want to, cant or won’t read the signs.

I think it’s like your first child. You’ve done the research, you think you know what it’ll be like, but the actual raw emotion of having your life completely controlled by this thing, the constant cleaning of piss/shit/vom, the time it takes to get to know them and understand what they are trying to say… BUT at least all that part passes more quickly than with kids. Well I hope. He is now toilet trained but dribbles when excited so there is still a fuckload of piss in my life and I could do without it tbh. My couch is ruined. Basically how patient are you?!

Oh no!!! I'm bracing myself!!! I'm hearing how hard it is, but I don't think it will hit me til.hes here! :(

OP posts:
GetThatHelmetOn · 27/12/2022 09:10

Mine is worth every penny. I’d like having your personal therapy dog always making you aware that she knows you are there, happy to interact as soon as you want, always there when you feel down or stressed and guests adore her. It has been wonderful for my son and his friends and has been great for me since he moved out.

Downsides? It is more difficult to go away without a lot of planing or extra expense (the kennel alone this week is costing more than my flights abroad), food is not expensive as she is small, insurance is not either as she is a rescue that we have chosen to describe as a mongrel no matter how designer mix she looks/is, but last year she had to have a “dental” and that was over £700 as the insurance won’t cover. I am saving for the one she will need next year already…

Alarchbach · 27/12/2022 09:08

By far the best thing I have done, she is the light of my life. My husband has always hated dogs, never wanted one but caved to my pressure and he adores her and can’t imagine life without her.
the first few months were hard, toilet training and stuff but once she turned 6 months, it was plain sailing.
Ive been really poorly over Christmas with flu and she hasn’t left my side.
I did lots of research into the best breed for us beforehand and it all worked out x

Notanotherusername4321 · 27/12/2022 09:02

And finally, what rescue is releasing a puppy the day after Boxing Day? Maybe they do but it's not ideal so worth a check that it's a decent rescue

this