Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GP’s are meant to be lenient with prescribing antibiotics?

166 replies

Gem123J · 26/12/2022 23:41

My DD (4 years old) woke up this morning with a headache, checked her temp and it was 38.6 so gave her calpol at 8am. Couple of hours later she was still complaining of a headache and said her forehead was hot so checked her and she was 39.3 so gave her ibuprofen at around 11am. Checked her temp again before we left the house to go for a walk and she was 38.6 and was happy in herself so we carried on with the walk. While on the walk she was totally fine, happy and running around playing “monsters”! We went for a drive and around 3pm she was very pale, lethargic and just wanted to cuddle and wasn’t herself at all, checked her temp and it was back up and was now 40.1 so gave her calpol and decided to call 111 because she was also complaining of sore throat, headache seemed to be bothering her more because she was wincing and she was also complaining of belly ache, her tonsils look inflamed too. We stripped her down and had a call back off the triage nurse, then the GP and was told to come in for an out of hours GP appointment later in the evening. While waiting for the call back her temp went up to 40.2 and we gave her ibuprofen at 5.30pm.

She didn’t want anything to eat but she did manage to drink and had 2 of the baby cucumbers but didn’t want anything else. Her temp went down with the ibuprofen like it had done earlier. She perked up a bit before the appointment and her temp went down to 38.6 and the GP checked her lungs, checked her ears and her mouth but didn’t seem to be concerned about her tonsils and just said it’s most likely viral.

I am obviously a bit concerned because her temp had got so high even with alternating calpol/ibuprofen every 2-3 hours (we were told to alternate off her GP last time she had a high temp that was still rising last year). And there have been local cases of strep a and I thought that GP’s were told to have a low threshold for prescribing antibiotics because viral and bacterial infection symptoms are indistinguishable in the very beginning.

Obviously I’m going to keep a close eye on her tonight but it is a bit scary when you read stories of children who were told they had a viral infection and were seriously ill a few hours later. My friend took her son to their GP last week and was told he had a viral infection, she wasn’t happy with the response and had husband to take him the following day and they swabbed him and prescribed antibiotics and it came back as strep a. I know not all cases are fatal but should I have pushed for the GP to take a swab? All he said was keep an eye out and if she still has a high temp in 5 days to take her back. Has anyone experienced the same thing lately?

Obviously if I thought my daughter was seriously unwell then I wouldn’t be waiting around, it’s just crazy how one minute she looks absolutely awful, but perks up and looks like a different child the next and is just up and down like that!

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:15

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:11

@Hobbitfeet32

she’s fine in herself, has had a little something to eat, has drank a lot, happily playing but does still have a high temp.

Good god OP.
Find something else to main about.
Your daughter feels fine, but you think she should have been given antibiotics on your say so yesterday.

No wonder GPs are leaving in droves. Clearly your articles and google are a better resource than a trained, skilled HCP.

WandaWonder · 27/12/2022 08:15

So you want something so you can think it works rather it actually working?

Gawdknows · 27/12/2022 08:14

My daughter had the same symptoms as yours. I took her to the Doctors ( she had a temp and a sore throat) I would never ever normally bother the doctors & just assume viral but due to Strep A concerns I called & they wanted to see her. She was then given ABs because the GP wanted to err on the side of caution. Like you say maybe certain GPs do things differently.

OP posts:
Brunilde · 27/12/2022 08:13

Is anyone commenting here actually a GP/practise manager or someone who is aware of the guidance sent to GPS about the strep A outbreak? Or are you all just commenting about how antibiotics are usually prescribed?

dammit88 · 27/12/2022 08:12

I agree that it sounds like there is no issue with her care at the moment and its not unreasonable that she hasn't been given antibiotics but given the stories of young people dying I understand your worry. People here are right about the antibiotics though which was your question. They are also right that a Boxing Day walk was probably not ideal - she does need to rest. But again it think you are maybe getting a bit of hard time - sometimes we think a bit of fresh air will do them good but she does probably need rest so her body can fight what she has and get better. I hope she is better soon.

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:12

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:09

This statement just doesn’t apply here. DD obviously has more than a cold. I was also following NHS Wales guidelines regarding strep a. And I’m not desperate for antibiotics, I’ve just read many, many articles about GP’s being urged to give antibiotics (to children) in the light of the strep a crisis because it was safer than not to prescribe given that viral and bacterial infections are indistinguishable in the early stages.

Where are all these articles OP?
In what capacity in healthcare do you work?

For transparency, I am a doctor. I would not say antibiotics were needed by your daughter at this stage.

I would also question why she wasn’t at home, keeping warm, fluids, regular pain relief etc

SavoirFlair · 27/12/2022 08:11

You have basically been lying in wait for a doctor to fail you @Gem123J because you want to be treated with the same attention as your friend was.

You wrote:

My friend took her son to their GP last week and was told he had a viral infection, she wasn’t happy with the response

This is the problem with the current situation - some parents will not be happy with any doctor who uses their diagnostic skill to say they child is just experiencing viral. In your friend’s case, I can see why they persisted. That may not be the same for your child.

“she wasn’t happy with the response” - is this TripAdvisor??

…and had husband to take him the following day and they swabbed him and prescribed antibiotics and it came back as strep a.

Good on your friend for persisting, but this was the outcome for them, and their child.

You have basically taken their example as the gold standard for all children who fall ill, and therefore you expected to be swabbed and given antibiotics at the first sign of trouble for your child.

YABU, it isn’t a menu that should be offered on a “standard booking”.

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:11

Hobbitfeet32 · 27/12/2022 08:06

Is she still unwell this morning?

@Hobbitfeet32

she’s fine in herself, has had a little something to eat, has drank a lot, happily playing but does still have a high temp.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:10

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:05

@Jimboscott0115

I completely understand that but from what I had read, GP’s were urged to have a low threshold for prescribing given the strep a business, as I’ve already answered twice.

Where did you read this?

gamerchick · 27/12/2022 08:09

Am I the only one who does rush their kids to the GP with every little thing?

You're not listening OP. Antibiotics are in shortage and antibiotics have their own risks and overuse of antibiotics is making superbugs.

You should have skipped your boxing day walk, keep her comfortable and hydrated. Get some lollies or icepops in and let it works itself out. If something else develops then deal with it then.

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:09

fishonabicycle · 27/12/2022 08:07

It's no wonder that antibiotics are becoming less and less effective. People are just desperate for them - Friday morning at work (GP receptionist) I must had had at least 15 patients call in saying they needed antibiotics. I had 2 colleagues booking in the same. It seems a general trend that if you have a cold, you phone the GP ....

This statement just doesn’t apply here. DD obviously has more than a cold. I was also following NHS Wales guidelines regarding strep a. And I’m not desperate for antibiotics, I’ve just read many, many articles about GP’s being urged to give antibiotics (to children) in the light of the strep a crisis because it was safer than not to prescribe given that viral and bacterial infections are indistinguishable in the early stages.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:09

WonkasBooboofixer · 27/12/2022 07:42

Ffs your kid is sick so you drag her out for a walk in cold weather then wonder why she isn't getting better. Paracetamol, rest, fluids, she's pale and lethargic because she is unwell and needs to rest. Her body cannot be active and using energy for walking around etc AND fight off a virus she's too small and her immune system is immature.

Yep, this.

OP, as a first port of call given your description, I wouldn’t have said Antibiotics were needed.

Regular alternating paracetamol/ibuprofen for a start would have helped. And not getting her out for a walk when she’s clearly unwell would have also been better.

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:07

gogohmm · 27/12/2022 07:54

Those are the exact symptoms DD's boyfriend has now, he has covid!

I work in healthcare so routinely test myself for covid and have tests at home so I did test her just in case, she was negative, but agreed, they were the symptoms I had last time I had covid, although had an awful blocked nose too! No cough strangely enough!

OP posts:
fishonabicycle · 27/12/2022 08:07

It's no wonder that antibiotics are becoming less and less effective. People are just desperate for them - Friday morning at work (GP receptionist) I must had had at least 15 patients call in saying they needed antibiotics. I had 2 colleagues booking in the same. It seems a general trend that if you have a cold, you phone the GP ....

Hobbitfeet32 · 27/12/2022 08:06

Is she still unwell this morning?

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:05

Jimboscott0115 · 27/12/2022 08:02

There's a couple of things at play here OP, firstly it's that there is absolutely nothing in your description that would warrant me and many others even asking for antibiotics. Most of the types of infections you're discussing are viral rather than bacterial so antibiotics aren't really going to help. There are a certain generation orlf people who have this impression that antibiotics are the be all and end all of treating children yet most of us wouldn't have had them as a matter of course when we were younger soni find this a little odd and it's likely due to the proliferation of using online diagnosis etc rather than common sense when a child is Ill.

The first issue above directly leads to the second. We simply cannot give antibiotics out willy nilly because we're becoming immune to some of them (or bacteria is) and given most of the ones we used have been around a long time, there's a real danger that most bacterial infections will be resistant to antibiotics. Clearly this is evolution at work but overuse is one of the reasons this has happened so I see antibiotics as something you take when seriously ill now rather than a day to day treatment option like it once was and I think that's sensible.

@Jimboscott0115

I completely understand that but from what I had read, GP’s were urged to have a low threshold for prescribing given the strep a business, as I’ve already answered twice.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:04

You didn’t properly alternate every two hours though did you.
It’s right there in your post…

Morph22010 · 27/12/2022 08:03

There is a shortage of antibiotics at the minute, especially in medicine ie. Liquid form, if they set the threshold too low there won’t be any left for the people who are much worse for longer

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:03

InfluenzalA · 27/12/2022 07:43

It was serious enough to be seen f2f - by a skilled, trained professional. That's why you went, to benefit from a trained HCP examining your dc. It's not a vending machine for abs.

By your logic, you could argue everyone should be given antibiotics all the time.

They are a prescription only medicine, with side effects and issues, not only for the patient but wider society if over used. GPs have the very difficult responsibility of trying to manage their appropriate use in the face of relentless uneducated demand.

It's horrible when DC are poorly, but you've had her seen v quickly, you're managing the temp, you have advice. Hopefully she will get well v soon.

It wasn’t my logic that everyone should be given antibiotics all the time. I just read the news and saw many articles about strep a and how GP’s were being told to be lenient in prescribing antibiotics because viral and bacterial infections were indistinguishable in the beginning.

www.gponline.com/gps-told-low-threshold-prescribing-antibiotics-possible-strep-cases/article/1807142#:~:text=GP%20Locums-,GPs%20told%20to%20have%20'low%20threshold'%20for%20prescribing%20antibiotics,in%20possible%20strep%20A%20cases&text=GPs%20have%20been%20urged%20to,about%20rising%20levels%20of%20cases.

www.express.co.uk/life-style/health/1705936/strep-a-cases-increase-uk-health-antibiotics-gps/amp

www.publichealth.hscni.net/news/public-urged-be-alert-signs-group-strep

and there are many, many, many more. So it’s not my logic, as I’ve previously mentioned my DD has had many sinus infections that I’ve treated at home, no antibiotics. She’s only ever had antibiotics for severe uti’s.

OP posts:
Jimboscott0115 · 27/12/2022 08:02

There's a couple of things at play here OP, firstly it's that there is absolutely nothing in your description that would warrant me and many others even asking for antibiotics. Most of the types of infections you're discussing are viral rather than bacterial so antibiotics aren't really going to help. There are a certain generation orlf people who have this impression that antibiotics are the be all and end all of treating children yet most of us wouldn't have had them as a matter of course when we were younger soni find this a little odd and it's likely due to the proliferation of using online diagnosis etc rather than common sense when a child is Ill.

The first issue above directly leads to the second. We simply cannot give antibiotics out willy nilly because we're becoming immune to some of them (or bacteria is) and given most of the ones we used have been around a long time, there's a real danger that most bacterial infections will be resistant to antibiotics. Clearly this is evolution at work but overuse is one of the reasons this has happened so I see antibiotics as something you take when seriously ill now rather than a day to day treatment option like it once was and I think that's sensible.

Brunilde · 27/12/2022 08:01

Actually based on my experience I'd agree with you. Not going to argue over whether they should or not as I'm not medical but I took my DS in as I couldn't get his temp under control even after alternating ibuprofen and Calpol. I was certain it was viral so wasn't really pushing for antibiotics but the GP told me they have been told to have a very low threshold for prescribing antibiotics because of the situation. So although most likely viral he was given them. Maybe it differs by area?

Oysterbabe · 27/12/2022 07:56

A doctor who has actually seen your child thinks she doesn't need them. They are better placed than us.

gogohmm · 27/12/2022 07:54

Those are the exact symptoms DD's boyfriend has now, he has covid!

Hobbitfeet32 · 27/12/2022 07:53

I’m surprised you would take her out for a walk when she had a temperature and that you also called the doctor after she was ill for a few hours only.

Swipe left for the next trending thread