Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GP’s are meant to be lenient with prescribing antibiotics?

166 replies

Gem123J · 26/12/2022 23:41

My DD (4 years old) woke up this morning with a headache, checked her temp and it was 38.6 so gave her calpol at 8am. Couple of hours later she was still complaining of a headache and said her forehead was hot so checked her and she was 39.3 so gave her ibuprofen at around 11am. Checked her temp again before we left the house to go for a walk and she was 38.6 and was happy in herself so we carried on with the walk. While on the walk she was totally fine, happy and running around playing “monsters”! We went for a drive and around 3pm she was very pale, lethargic and just wanted to cuddle and wasn’t herself at all, checked her temp and it was back up and was now 40.1 so gave her calpol and decided to call 111 because she was also complaining of sore throat, headache seemed to be bothering her more because she was wincing and she was also complaining of belly ache, her tonsils look inflamed too. We stripped her down and had a call back off the triage nurse, then the GP and was told to come in for an out of hours GP appointment later in the evening. While waiting for the call back her temp went up to 40.2 and we gave her ibuprofen at 5.30pm.

She didn’t want anything to eat but she did manage to drink and had 2 of the baby cucumbers but didn’t want anything else. Her temp went down with the ibuprofen like it had done earlier. She perked up a bit before the appointment and her temp went down to 38.6 and the GP checked her lungs, checked her ears and her mouth but didn’t seem to be concerned about her tonsils and just said it’s most likely viral.

I am obviously a bit concerned because her temp had got so high even with alternating calpol/ibuprofen every 2-3 hours (we were told to alternate off her GP last time she had a high temp that was still rising last year). And there have been local cases of strep a and I thought that GP’s were told to have a low threshold for prescribing antibiotics because viral and bacterial infection symptoms are indistinguishable in the very beginning.

Obviously I’m going to keep a close eye on her tonight but it is a bit scary when you read stories of children who were told they had a viral infection and were seriously ill a few hours later. My friend took her son to their GP last week and was told he had a viral infection, she wasn’t happy with the response and had husband to take him the following day and they swabbed him and prescribed antibiotics and it came back as strep a. I know not all cases are fatal but should I have pushed for the GP to take a swab? All he said was keep an eye out and if she still has a high temp in 5 days to take her back. Has anyone experienced the same thing lately?

Obviously if I thought my daughter was seriously unwell then I wouldn’t be waiting around, it’s just crazy how one minute she looks absolutely awful, but perks up and looks like a different child the next and is just up and down like that!

OP posts:
Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:55

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:53

Fair enough OP. I am not going to dispute that. But your thread title doesn’t represent what you’re saying to wanted to achieve here, and many people, myself included, have answered accordingly.

Answered to the title only, by making assumptions and berating someone without even considering what they actually meant.

OP posts:
Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:54

Sirzy · 27/12/2022 08:46

I don’t judge you for making a judgment call to go out for some fresh air. But the fact that she was well enough to (even if tired afterwards) is a positive sign that she is coping ok with fighting whatever bug it is off.

hopefully a couple of days of rest and she will bounce back

Unfortunately she wasn’t just tired after, her temp had shot up to 40.2 even with regular calpol and ibuprofen, that’s when I decided to call 111 as per advice sent out via NHS Wales. But she does seem to be better today, thank you. I’ll keep an eye out and try and keep her temp down as much as possible.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:53

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:48

@Quincythequince

oh and following the above, I then followed the advice of 111 Wales (as was advised to call from the above), and then followed the advice of the Triage Nurse who called me back, then followed the advice of the on call GP over the phone who made an appointment because he thought it was necessary to see DD face to face. And then I did actually follow the advice of that GP, I just simply created this post to share my concerns given the information I had read elsewhere, and wanted to know if anyone else had experienced something similar and what they did about it.

Fair enough OP. I am not going to dispute that. But your thread title doesn’t represent what you’re saying to wanted to achieve here, and many people, myself included, have answered accordingly.

TroysMammy · 27/12/2022 08:52

Last week I took numerous calls about cough and cold symptoms. Most of these people had been prescribed antibiotics which were nearly finished or had just only finished and they had the same symptoms.

Perhaps they didn't need antibiotics in the first place as they wouldn't have helped.

We live in an "Amazon Prime" world where we want it now and we get it straight away. In other words antibiotics are not magic and coughs and colds, no matter how rotten they make you feel sometimes we need to ride them out.

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:51

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:48

OP you should be concerned about your child’s care and shouldn’t ever feel
guilty. Nobody has said that.

But your thread title said this

‘To think GP’s are meant to be lenient with prescribing antibiotics?’

This isn’t the same thing tbh.

Just keep dosing regularly with paracetamol/brufen for now and keep an eye on her. Obviously go back if any major concerns, but from the sound of it, she sounds like she’s doing ok.

Yes that was the title, not because I personally thought they should be more lenient, because that is what I had read. Maybe I should have titled it differently, but if other pp’s gave me the chance to explain that it’s not MY opinion, it’s what has been said on the news, instead of throwing me into the lions den and making so many assumptions about me then maybe they would have seen my intentions in the post.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:51

UmbilicusProfundus · 27/12/2022 08:45

I wouldn’t like you as my doctor @Quincythequince !

OP I also saw plenty of coverage about having a low threshold to treat with ABx and it’s a bit surprising that (supposedly) a doctor has no idea of this, irrespective of their speciality.

I also think you question is reasonable in the circumstances, and you are getting a hard time. As a worried mum, it’s fine to ask questions, and I don’t think you have “demanded antibiotics”, but just querying the situation.

Having said this, I also think if your child has been examined and felt no meds required I would be reassured by this. The fact they are happy and playing when the temp goes down is a good sign.

I know exactly what a low threshold is.
What I asked is where the OP saw this information. What is communicated to (and understood by) healthcare professionals is a very different thing to what the average layperson may read and rely on.

Any doctor if a patient comes in saying they read something about something, would ask where they read it, if it had a grain of truth in it.

As has been pointed out by a completely different poster, a key part of that text was left out by the OP (in terms of specific symptoms which warranted prescribing).

Milkand2sugarsplease · 27/12/2022 08:50

With the shortage of antibiotics at the moment, there is no way I'd want my 2 boys prescribed antibiotics on a low threshold "just in case" that then meant a child who needed those antibiotics couldn't get them.
Deal with the symptoms as they present and make a judgement as to whether things have changed and need reassessing.
Keep her warm, not out walking, let her rest and allow her body to fight it off.

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:48

@Quincythequince

oh and following the above, I then followed the advice of 111 Wales (as was advised to call from the above), and then followed the advice of the Triage Nurse who called me back, then followed the advice of the on call GP over the phone who made an appointment because he thought it was necessary to see DD face to face. And then I did actually follow the advice of that GP, I just simply created this post to share my concerns given the information I had read elsewhere, and wanted to know if anyone else had experienced something similar and what they did about it.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:48

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:44

@possomcandle

thank you. As a parent and seeing all the fatal cases you do worry don’t you. Thankfully she is fine in herself this morning, as she was yesterday but obviously took a funny turn. I will keep a close eye on her and if she is still unwell tomorrow I might take her to see our GP but hopefully she’ll be fine and won’t need to go in.

I don’t think it’s fair for parents to be made to feel guilty about being concerned of their children, I’m sure there are some parents of the 25 who have passed away recently who might feel like they should have done more, I know I would, even if I did try my best. But I also understand the media like to scare us so I’ll just be playing it by ear and hoping for the best.

OP you should be concerned about your child’s care and shouldn’t ever feel
guilty. Nobody has said that.

But your thread title said this

‘To think GP’s are meant to be lenient with prescribing antibiotics?’

This isn’t the same thing tbh.

Just keep dosing regularly with paracetamol/brufen for now and keep an eye on her. Obviously go back if any major concerns, but from the sound of it, she sounds like she’s doing ok.

Brunilde · 27/12/2022 08:47

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:40

@ItsNotReallyChaos

You go by how they are at the time don’t you. Not all children are the same, some want to be outside. I obviously would never take her out if she appeared very ill. But at the time she had heaps of energy, her temp had gone down, she had been playing in the house all morning anyway so not bed bound, and she was eating at the time. A little later she was sick, very high temp, not eating, very pale and lethargic, happy to lie on the sofa then so that’s what we did.

You don't have to explain yourself OP. This is a prime example of one person initially picking up on an inconsequencial detail to be a smart arse and then others following suit like a little gang of sheep as they think it makes them seem clever. Typical mumsnet behaviour.

It's not clever to berate and try to pick apart a concerned mum who is worried about their child. If I were you I'd leave this thread and you're bound to just get more of the same.

Sirzy · 27/12/2022 08:46

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:40

@ItsNotReallyChaos

You go by how they are at the time don’t you. Not all children are the same, some want to be outside. I obviously would never take her out if she appeared very ill. But at the time she had heaps of energy, her temp had gone down, she had been playing in the house all morning anyway so not bed bound, and she was eating at the time. A little later she was sick, very high temp, not eating, very pale and lethargic, happy to lie on the sofa then so that’s what we did.

I don’t judge you for making a judgment call to go out for some fresh air. But the fact that she was well enough to (even if tired afterwards) is a positive sign that she is coping ok with fighting whatever bug it is off.

hopefully a couple of days of rest and she will bounce back

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:46

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:43

I questioned it yes.
As a GP would also have, had the OP had the initial conversation with them about this.

OP hasn’t followed at home instructions for treating these kinds of bugs. I am going to hazard a guess she has read what she wants to read rather than following what would have been the suggested standard treatment plan by her GP under these circumstances.

I followed this which was sent to me by the headteacher of DD’s school several weeks ago. What advice should I follow since you seem to know better?

To think GP’s are meant to be lenient with prescribing antibiotics?
OP posts:
UmbilicusProfundus · 27/12/2022 08:45

I wouldn’t like you as my doctor @Quincythequince !

OP I also saw plenty of coverage about having a low threshold to treat with ABx and it’s a bit surprising that (supposedly) a doctor has no idea of this, irrespective of their speciality.

I also think you question is reasonable in the circumstances, and you are getting a hard time. As a worried mum, it’s fine to ask questions, and I don’t think you have “demanded antibiotics”, but just querying the situation.

Having said this, I also think if your child has been examined and felt no meds required I would be reassured by this. The fact they are happy and playing when the temp goes down is a good sign.

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:44

possomcandle · 27/12/2022 08:36

I totally understand you OP and have read the same about the threshold for ABs being lowered at the moment.

I would think of it this way. Your daughter saw a doctor who at that point in time given her symptoms and the wider context of the Strep A outbreak, still decided that she doesn't need antibiotics.

However as your daughters advocate and again given the wider context of the Strep A outbreak you should not hessitate to take her back for a new look if things don't seem right.

Sometimes parents just can't win. If we stay informed and get what knowledge we can of current dangerous illnesses then we are berated for playing Dr Google when we have concerns. But then at the same time we are told by doctors to "keep an eye out for anything" and expected to know if itsa problem or not. Its really tough and feels like a huge responsibility to get the balance right.

@possomcandle

thank you. As a parent and seeing all the fatal cases you do worry don’t you. Thankfully she is fine in herself this morning, as she was yesterday but obviously took a funny turn. I will keep a close eye on her and if she is still unwell tomorrow I might take her to see our GP but hopefully she’ll be fine and won’t need to go in.

I don’t think it’s fair for parents to be made to feel guilty about being concerned of their children, I’m sure there are some parents of the 25 who have passed away recently who might feel like they should have done more, I know I would, even if I did try my best. But I also understand the media like to scare us so I’ll just be playing it by ear and hoping for the best.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:43

EarringsandLipstick · 27/12/2022 08:40

I have not been rude at all.

I disagree. It's possible to take a different opinion to OP's (I have) without denigrating her care for her DD (which you did).

I questioned it yes.
As a GP would also have, had the OP had the initial conversation with them about this.

OP hasn’t followed at home instructions for treating these kinds of bugs. I am going to hazard a guess she has read what she wants to read rather than following what would have been the suggested standard treatment plan by her GP under these circumstances.

Reallybadidea · 27/12/2022 08:41

Completely and utterly OT and I hope your dd gets better soon, but do people still 'go for a drive'?! I thought it was something people did 50+ years ago before we knew about global warming or for very elderly people who can't otherwise get out. I honestly don't think I've ever gone for a drive just for the sake of it. Or have I misunderstood?

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:40

ItsNotReallyChaos · 27/12/2022 08:31

Oh and just to add that I’d absolutely take my DD out for a walk if she was unwell, just as I’d go out for fresh air myself even if unwell. I don’t understand people’s horror at taking a mildly unwell child out for a walk.

@ItsNotReallyChaos

You go by how they are at the time don’t you. Not all children are the same, some want to be outside. I obviously would never take her out if she appeared very ill. But at the time she had heaps of energy, her temp had gone down, she had been playing in the house all morning anyway so not bed bound, and she was eating at the time. A little later she was sick, very high temp, not eating, very pale and lethargic, happy to lie on the sofa then so that’s what we did.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 27/12/2022 08:40

I have not been rude at all.

I disagree. It's possible to take a different opinion to OP's (I have) without denigrating her care for her DD (which you did).

TerraNostra · 27/12/2022 08:39

I know what you mean about the guidance OP and understand what you are asking, and why.

Unfortunately, however, I think that the only way to resolve this would have been to have politely asked the GP at the time why their recommendation didn’t seem to fit with what you had read. He or she could then have explained their thinking to you with reference to your daughter’s specific symptoms, and hopefully given some reassurance.

I hope your DD feels better soon.

Beepbopadooda · 27/12/2022 08:38

Do you suffer from health anxiety OP?

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:37

doctor refusals

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 08:36

EarringsandLipstick · 27/12/2022 08:29

@Quincythequince

Leave OP alone - she doesn't need to be berated by you 'for not looking after' her DD.

She's a caring, concerned mother.

I don't agree with her re the antibiotics but she doesn't need your rude posts.

I have not been rude at all.
But OP demanding antibiotics and suggesting her DD meets the threshold for them, when not even administering basic at home treatment properly, despite focussing on apparent GP advice from central government sources, is a bit rich.

My friend had someone threaten to kill him last week of his sick note wasn’t renewed - irrational patient behaviour because of Doctor is slowly on the increase; thank god I don’t have to deal with it.

possomcandle · 27/12/2022 08:36

I totally understand you OP and have read the same about the threshold for ABs being lowered at the moment.

I would think of it this way. Your daughter saw a doctor who at that point in time given her symptoms and the wider context of the Strep A outbreak, still decided that she doesn't need antibiotics.

However as your daughters advocate and again given the wider context of the Strep A outbreak you should not hessitate to take her back for a new look if things don't seem right.

Sometimes parents just can't win. If we stay informed and get what knowledge we can of current dangerous illnesses then we are berated for playing Dr Google when we have concerns. But then at the same time we are told by doctors to "keep an eye out for anything" and expected to know if itsa problem or not. Its really tough and feels like a huge responsibility to get the balance right.

Hobbitfeet32 · 27/12/2022 08:35

What @RosesAndHellebores said.
Very unfair to GP bash.

Gem123J · 27/12/2022 08:34

SavoirFlair · 27/12/2022 08:28

Argh @Gem123J why do you have to yell at another poster on here?

Also you fail to understand that guidelines are not direct mandates instructions to all GPs to take the same action in every little instance. They are guidelines. Though to be honest I can see from how you write that this whole paragraph and its inference is wasted on you.

Anyways - if you have read so much about it, and you know the “guidelines”, could you tell us what the GP said when you challenged them on their “failure” to apply the recommendation in the guidelines?

I didn’t challenge him on his “failure”, because contrary to what you think, I do trust what he said, I just simply said I was concerned because of what I have read and was just asking for advice if someone has had the same experience.

Capital letters did seem rude, but don’t you think sarcasm and what he/she said was rude also? I’m having to constantly repeat the same information and having assumptions made about me that are totally false.

OP posts: