Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GP’s are meant to be lenient with prescribing antibiotics?

166 replies

Gem123J · 26/12/2022 23:41

My DD (4 years old) woke up this morning with a headache, checked her temp and it was 38.6 so gave her calpol at 8am. Couple of hours later she was still complaining of a headache and said her forehead was hot so checked her and she was 39.3 so gave her ibuprofen at around 11am. Checked her temp again before we left the house to go for a walk and she was 38.6 and was happy in herself so we carried on with the walk. While on the walk she was totally fine, happy and running around playing “monsters”! We went for a drive and around 3pm she was very pale, lethargic and just wanted to cuddle and wasn’t herself at all, checked her temp and it was back up and was now 40.1 so gave her calpol and decided to call 111 because she was also complaining of sore throat, headache seemed to be bothering her more because she was wincing and she was also complaining of belly ache, her tonsils look inflamed too. We stripped her down and had a call back off the triage nurse, then the GP and was told to come in for an out of hours GP appointment later in the evening. While waiting for the call back her temp went up to 40.2 and we gave her ibuprofen at 5.30pm.

She didn’t want anything to eat but she did manage to drink and had 2 of the baby cucumbers but didn’t want anything else. Her temp went down with the ibuprofen like it had done earlier. She perked up a bit before the appointment and her temp went down to 38.6 and the GP checked her lungs, checked her ears and her mouth but didn’t seem to be concerned about her tonsils and just said it’s most likely viral.

I am obviously a bit concerned because her temp had got so high even with alternating calpol/ibuprofen every 2-3 hours (we were told to alternate off her GP last time she had a high temp that was still rising last year). And there have been local cases of strep a and I thought that GP’s were told to have a low threshold for prescribing antibiotics because viral and bacterial infection symptoms are indistinguishable in the very beginning.

Obviously I’m going to keep a close eye on her tonight but it is a bit scary when you read stories of children who were told they had a viral infection and were seriously ill a few hours later. My friend took her son to their GP last week and was told he had a viral infection, she wasn’t happy with the response and had husband to take him the following day and they swabbed him and prescribed antibiotics and it came back as strep a. I know not all cases are fatal but should I have pushed for the GP to take a swab? All he said was keep an eye out and if she still has a high temp in 5 days to take her back. Has anyone experienced the same thing lately?

Obviously if I thought my daughter was seriously unwell then I wouldn’t be waiting around, it’s just crazy how one minute she looks absolutely awful, but perks up and looks like a different child the next and is just up and down like that!

OP posts:
Jasmino1o · 27/12/2022 14:00

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave

then what is Mumsnet for? It’s a forum, you and @Quincythequince seem to take this a bit too negatively and too seriously. What is wrong in asking the opinion of other Mums without being judges so harshly? It seems some come on this forum purely to bash other people who think differently to them or have reacted differently to how they would react. The word ‘trolls’ come to mind!

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 27/12/2022 13:56

Jasmino1o · 27/12/2022 13:51

@Quincythequince
I never said you were any, just a bit of sarcasm!

I do think you are very narrow minded though. From what I’ve read OP never told any GP what to do because of what they had googled nor did they mention anything about arguing, or even disagreeing with them.

I totally understand why OP would be concerned. They didn’t want antibiotics just because it was their opinion that they should have and that others have had, just that they thought they had read that Doctors are being more cautious and are prescribing antibiotics for less severe cases as before. And because many are being told that their child’s illness is viral when a few days later it turns out it was in fact bacterial.

It is a dangerous game telling someone they were wrong in seeking medical attention just because that is what you believe. OP is right in following guidelines rather than what some ‘maybe’ Doctor, because who really knows on Mumsnet, is having a go at them for.

Bit rich of you to lecture Quincy for that when the OP has seen a real life doctor then came on Mumsnet to ask for layman opinions.

Lots of Dunning Kruger in this thread.

Jasmino1o · 27/12/2022 13:51

@Quincythequince
I never said you were any, just a bit of sarcasm!

I do think you are very narrow minded though. From what I’ve read OP never told any GP what to do because of what they had googled nor did they mention anything about arguing, or even disagreeing with them.

I totally understand why OP would be concerned. They didn’t want antibiotics just because it was their opinion that they should have and that others have had, just that they thought they had read that Doctors are being more cautious and are prescribing antibiotics for less severe cases as before. And because many are being told that their child’s illness is viral when a few days later it turns out it was in fact bacterial.

It is a dangerous game telling someone they were wrong in seeking medical attention just because that is what you believe. OP is right in following guidelines rather than what some ‘maybe’ Doctor, because who really knows on Mumsnet, is having a go at them for.

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 13:24

And anyway, how does telling someone that they are ring to assume GPs should be lenient with anything, give any indication of specialty.

It doesn’t of course, unless you think you can tell a GP what to do because you googled it and then argue with them, when is not what you want.

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 13:20

Jasmino1o · 27/12/2022 13:11

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave is she a Doctor though? I could also claim to be a Doctor on Mumsnet if I wish! If she is, she definitely isn’t a MH doctor or Paediatrician 😂

No, I am neither of those.
Who said I was.

nonevernotever · 27/12/2022 13:16

Actually my guess is that Quincy is a paediatric consultant 😀

NameChangedAsOutraged · 27/12/2022 13:16

YABU.

GPs being “told” (more like ‘advised’) to be more lenient with antibiotics does not override our decision not to prescribe after our clinical assessments.

Jasmino1o · 27/12/2022 13:11

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave is she a Doctor though? I could also claim to be a Doctor on Mumsnet if I wish! If she is, she definitely isn’t a MH doctor or Paediatrician 😂

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 27/12/2022 13:01

FunnyBauble Don't take out your inferiority complex and problem with authority on Quincythequince. She's a doctor, she knows more than you. Get over it.

memorial · 27/12/2022 12:47

FunnyBauble · 27/12/2022 12:23

Oh dear, maybe your are not the skilled doctor you think you are, longing for the good old days when patients did as they were told 😂. As you have noticed, times have moved on and to be an efficient doctor, you move with the times so that you skilfully treat actual 21st century patients, not some imaginary victorian patients who defers to your imagined 'authority'. Interestingly, I have seen GPs google conditions and give advice based on what they find on nhs.uk. Google usually takes you to nhs.uk when you search for symptoms in the UK. It's sad that lots of doctors have rubbish communication skills and a superior attitude but luckily some medical schools focus on this as an integral part of a doctors education. After all, what use is all your knowledge and expertise, if your patients don't follow doctors 'orders'? NICE have specific guidelines on shared decision making and enabling patients to actively participate in their care. Most medics expect that patients have googled their condition and don't bumble into the surgery without having a clue about their symptoms. Funnily enough, the NHS actively promotes the use of digital resources such a 111 online (which could be much improved) so clearly digital information and decision making is part of NHS strategy. A good contemporary doctor can manage a google informed (or uninformed) patient without being all tired out and irritated by it.

What a nasty post. If you can do such an amazing job and never be tired or irritated. Am well and truly sick and tired of people on the Internet thinking they know better than a doctor while at the same time thinking it's so easy and well paid. Then why didn't/don't you do it? There's a shortage of doctors (and all HCP) for a very good reason.
And yes of course most times "doctor does know best" that's what all the training and experience is for. I dont question my mechanic, electrician, plumber etc etc for very good reason.

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 12:34

FunnyBauble · 27/12/2022 12:23

Oh dear, maybe your are not the skilled doctor you think you are, longing for the good old days when patients did as they were told 😂. As you have noticed, times have moved on and to be an efficient doctor, you move with the times so that you skilfully treat actual 21st century patients, not some imaginary victorian patients who defers to your imagined 'authority'. Interestingly, I have seen GPs google conditions and give advice based on what they find on nhs.uk. Google usually takes you to nhs.uk when you search for symptoms in the UK. It's sad that lots of doctors have rubbish communication skills and a superior attitude but luckily some medical schools focus on this as an integral part of a doctors education. After all, what use is all your knowledge and expertise, if your patients don't follow doctors 'orders'? NICE have specific guidelines on shared decision making and enabling patients to actively participate in their care. Most medics expect that patients have googled their condition and don't bumble into the surgery without having a clue about their symptoms. Funnily enough, the NHS actively promotes the use of digital resources such a 111 online (which could be much improved) so clearly digital information and decision making is part of NHS strategy. A good contemporary doctor can manage a google informed (or uninformed) patient without being all tired out and irritated by it.

🤦🏼‍♀️ I despair.

Of course patient choice matters. Who said it didn’t?!

However, Patient diagnosis and questioning of GP treatment suggestion, when the patient has not even followed basic advice on how to treat a (likely) virus and who simply wants AB’s because ‘my friend’s son got some’ is really not up for consideration.

hcnirg · 27/12/2022 12:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FunnyBauble · 27/12/2022 12:23

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 11:03

I am not being unpleasant and there is no bullying about it.
People just don’t like being told they’re wrong.

My area of expertise was mentioned in response to your comment to me.
A Perfectly reasonable retort under the circumstances (although you’ll note I am not upset by this and don’t feel bullied)

Food for thought perhaps!

Anyway, what are you…the OPs minder?

My point remains; GPs are there for a reason and are indeed skilled individuals who have to now fend of Dr ‘educated by Google’ constantly.

Tiresome and irritating at best.

Oh dear, maybe your are not the skilled doctor you think you are, longing for the good old days when patients did as they were told 😂. As you have noticed, times have moved on and to be an efficient doctor, you move with the times so that you skilfully treat actual 21st century patients, not some imaginary victorian patients who defers to your imagined 'authority'. Interestingly, I have seen GPs google conditions and give advice based on what they find on nhs.uk. Google usually takes you to nhs.uk when you search for symptoms in the UK. It's sad that lots of doctors have rubbish communication skills and a superior attitude but luckily some medical schools focus on this as an integral part of a doctors education. After all, what use is all your knowledge and expertise, if your patients don't follow doctors 'orders'? NICE have specific guidelines on shared decision making and enabling patients to actively participate in their care. Most medics expect that patients have googled their condition and don't bumble into the surgery without having a clue about their symptoms. Funnily enough, the NHS actively promotes the use of digital resources such a 111 online (which could be much improved) so clearly digital information and decision making is part of NHS strategy. A good contemporary doctor can manage a google informed (or uninformed) patient without being all tired out and irritated by it.

Teder · 27/12/2022 11:56

You obviously don’t think you’re BU, so why ask? It’s tough when your kids are ill. Viral infections can be serious and horrible - has covid taught us nothing?!

Namenic · 27/12/2022 11:33

@Gem123J - I understand you are anxious and I think you did the right thing in seeing the GP.

It’s a lot easier for clinicians to just prescribe antibiotics. It reduces their worry and stress too. But it’s not necessarily in the long term best interest of the patient or population to do that (thrush, diarrhoea post antibiotics, resistance etc). It’s harder to examine carefully and use clinical judgement to come to a reasoned, evidenced decision. Clinical judgement is mentioned in most guidelines (strep an included) - which is why it’s not a tick box exercise that anyone/computers can follow a flowchart to do. GPs have gone through a 3 year specialism on top of junior doctor years (and many will have additional experience too). And you should be reassured that when the gp saw your child, they did not show worrying features (enough to reach the threshold for antibiotics - maybe there wasn’t pus on the tonsils or skin didn’t seem pale/mottled).

It’s impossible to pick out ALL the rare severe cases early (sometimes only time will show which ones get better/worse) - which is why you need advice to continue monitoring - and seek further medical advice if patient doesn’t improve as expected or deteriorates further. But this is a far better system overall than to either give everyone with a sore throat and temperature antibiotics or refer them to the hospital paediatricians. I hope your child improves and feels better soon.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 27/12/2022 11:05

Why ask if you're being unreasonable when you won't entertain any suggestion you were? So tedious.

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 11:03

UmbilicusProfundus · 27/12/2022 10:28

An ad hominem argument is valid when the point is to highlight how a person is being so unpleasant. Someone has come here for support and understanding. You have adopted an unnecessary bullying and unkind tone. Which I found surprising for a doctor. Especially for someone who claims to be in such high demand. Though perhaps not that surprising for someone who feels the need to make such a claim.

I am not being unpleasant and there is no bullying about it.
People just don’t like being told they’re wrong.

My area of expertise was mentioned in response to your comment to me.
A Perfectly reasonable retort under the circumstances (although you’ll note I am not upset by this and don’t feel bullied)

Food for thought perhaps!

Anyway, what are you…the OPs minder?

My point remains; GPs are there for a reason and are indeed skilled individuals who have to now fend of Dr ‘educated by Google’ constantly.

Tiresome and irritating at best.

memorial · 27/12/2022 10:54

girlmom21 · 27/12/2022 10:49

2nd lot of abiotics certainly shouts viral. If it was bacterial the abiotics would have worked.

That's not always true. Lots of people need a 2nd course, especially those with more severe infections or, you know, people who've built up resistance from being prescribed antibiotics they don't need!

Sorry not really in my almost 30 years as a doctor.
Not unless it a very serious infection when you are almost certainly in hospital.
Those who come back repeatedly "because antibiotics aren't working", IME almost always have lingering viral symptoms.
The demand for antibiotics us causing untold harm and I feel actual dread for my children's futures.
Another sign of the instant gratification and selfishness of the current population.

girlmom21 · 27/12/2022 10:49

2nd lot of abiotics certainly shouts viral. If it was bacterial the abiotics would have worked.

That's not always true. Lots of people need a 2nd course, especially those with more severe infections or, you know, people who've built up resistance from being prescribed antibiotics they don't need!

memorial · 27/12/2022 10:42

People wouldn't demand any other types of medicine with no evidence they had the relevant condition and they wouldn't get them without tests.

sorry posted to soon.
Oh trust me they most definitely do. Dr Google has not been good for patients or doctors. I'm all for shared decision making. But equally I have 10 years of training and 20 years of experience. I dont make decisions for fun or to cause harm or inconvenience. I make them because they are what I feel is correct at the time in the best interests of the patient (and sometimes the community/society). I remain baffled why people feel doctors do things to cause harm.

memorial · 27/12/2022 10:39

People wouldn't demand any other types of medicine with no evidence they had the relevant condition and they wouldn't get them without tests.

UmbilicusProfundus · 27/12/2022 10:28

Quincythequince · 27/12/2022 09:47

Dearie me!
Are you able to read and assimilate my post by way of response to specific information.

You’d probably faint when I tell you who the main body of my patient group is, and I am pretty sought after too.

Any more childish ad hominems from you? Am at the vet( thought it best to let an expert treat my dog rather than read up about it and make my own diagnosis), so have plenty of time.

It’s amazing how many people do actually want the skills and knowledge of a trained clinician - doesn’t surprise me of course.

An ad hominem argument is valid when the point is to highlight how a person is being so unpleasant. Someone has come here for support and understanding. You have adopted an unnecessary bullying and unkind tone. Which I found surprising for a doctor. Especially for someone who claims to be in such high demand. Though perhaps not that surprising for someone who feels the need to make such a claim.

Vallmo47 · 27/12/2022 10:19

I hope your daughter feels better soon OP. It’s horrible when your kids are ill, you feel so helpless and there are so many worrying bugs doing the rounds. Hang in there. Please ignore any harsh comments on here and focus on your child instead. A high temperature is so worrying but her body is working hard to fight this thing and I hope she will very soon be on the mend. ♥️

JoyBeorge · 27/12/2022 10:17

A lot of people don't understand that antibiotics are for bacterial conditions, not viral conditions. I wouldn't expect them to be prescribed unless there is evidence the condition is bacterial, obviously a swab will be the only way to confirm that but if it turns out not to be bacterial and they prescribed them on the off chance then they aren't going to work anyway and will have been wasted. People wouldn't demand any other types of medicine with no evidence they had the relevant condition and they wouldn't get them without tests.

FuntCase · 27/12/2022 10:12

Why do you keep saying you’re following NHS WALES guidance but keep showing English websites? Lots of inconsistencies hmm.

Swipe left for the next trending thread