Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that if it wasn’t for DILs…

107 replies

Iwanttoslowdown · 26/12/2022 23:34

Most MILs darling sons would not:

Receive Birthday cards / presents
Receive Christmas cards / present
Invitations for Christmas or any other family event
Have much of a relationship with their Grandchildren

And in return, MIL have generally given us their sons that

Think there is a towel fairy
And a diary that orders Christmas presents and send cards
And a fairy that responds to endless messages from school
And a patience fairy for said MIL who expects all of the as above

The End.

OP posts:
Ohnotheydidnt · 27/12/2022 10:12

MIL and FIL did an amazing job raising my DH

Georgeandzippyzoo · 27/12/2022 10:10

Beamur · 26/12/2022 23:43

I have never bought my PIL birthday presents or organised their cards. That's their son's responsibility.
I do buy them gifts from myself 😁 Christmas is a bit of a joint effort.

So you and your partner each buy 'separate' presents for his parents?? Why?? I find that strange. I have an amazing relationship with my PiL, especially MiL (way better than with my DM) but all presents are from us as a couple.

scooobie · 27/12/2022 10:09

I won’t do it. DH fucks it up every year but that’s his issue.

Women need to stop mollycoddling their husbands if they want these progressive gender roles that they claim they do.

noworklifebalance · 27/12/2022 10:04

Iwanttoslowdown · 27/12/2022 09:53

Interesting range of responses. There is no FIL in our lives so hence why only MIL focus.

For years and years I did all of that MiL stuff and then I stopped with it all. But it wasn’t just the Christmas and birthday cards it was all of it - arranging the visits, sending the pictures, having the long conversations about the kids with MIL - all of that. And with me withdrawing from this role, I do think impacted on my children's relationship with their GM (my OHs mum) because there was so much less contact.

And I think that as soon as we had kids thats where I noticed that I was with someone that just didn’t see what it took to run a household. It wasn’t even intentional but he just didn’t see it, didn’t know that things like this needed to be done. And there was a summit point where this stuff became completely overwhelming and I had to literally spell out all these micro tasks because they were all landing on my shoulders - doctors and dentist appointments, cutting fingernails, changing sheets/towels/tea towels/scourers, endless nursery and school admin (they would always always call me), arranging play dates, after school activities, goodness it was endless.

For all those that are saying I picked badly or DILs turn into MILs, and that their lives with your OH is perfectly and completely equal I’m really glad that you don’t have this burden and that somehow you escaped this. But I didn’t. And I still think a lot of women just step into this role unthinking and manage these tricky relationships and do all the stuff that goes with it and the cycle just continues.

Whilst I don’t agree with you that it’s necessarily the MIL’s fault, I do agree with your above post. I think, in more recent times, a lot of this starts during maternity leave where the father may return to work after 2 weeks but the mother stays at home for a year.
The pattern of behaviour is then set and it maybe only a few years down the line - perhaps when a second child arrives and that period of mat leave is over - that you suddenly realise the division of labour and mental load is not proportionate.

Iwanttoslowdown · 27/12/2022 09:53

Interesting range of responses. There is no FIL in our lives so hence why only MIL focus.

For years and years I did all of that MiL stuff and then I stopped with it all. But it wasn’t just the Christmas and birthday cards it was all of it - arranging the visits, sending the pictures, having the long conversations about the kids with MIL - all of that. And with me withdrawing from this role, I do think impacted on my children's relationship with their GM (my OHs mum) because there was so much less contact.

And I think that as soon as we had kids thats where I noticed that I was with someone that just didn’t see what it took to run a household. It wasn’t even intentional but he just didn’t see it, didn’t know that things like this needed to be done. And there was a summit point where this stuff became completely overwhelming and I had to literally spell out all these micro tasks because they were all landing on my shoulders - doctors and dentist appointments, cutting fingernails, changing sheets/towels/tea towels/scourers, endless nursery and school admin (they would always always call me), arranging play dates, after school activities, goodness it was endless.

For all those that are saying I picked badly or DILs turn into MILs, and that their lives with your OH is perfectly and completely equal I’m really glad that you don’t have this burden and that somehow you escaped this. But I didn’t. And I still think a lot of women just step into this role unthinking and manage these tricky relationships and do all the stuff that goes with it and the cycle just continues.

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 27/12/2022 09:43

Sorry, but if you chose a man who can’t function as an independent adult within a relationship, that’s your problem, and has nothing to do with his mother. Grow up.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 27/12/2022 09:19

My dh gets his own but always last minute

But at least he does.

He is actually getting a bit better with age in that respect

He has other failings tho 😂

theremustonlybeone · 27/12/2022 09:16

Sadly outdated attitudes like that still exist. My DH was always late with sending cards to his family but was good with presents. However I didn’t get a birthday card from the outlaws one year - a bit random but it turns out the outlaws were angry that fil didn’t get a birthday card 4 weeks earlier. Turns out that was my fault as in their family it’s woman that is responsible!

after that they got shit presents from there son as he was pissed off and that was my fault too ….

astralpiano · 27/12/2022 09:10

Iwanttoslowdown · 26/12/2022 23:34

Most MILs darling sons would not:

Receive Birthday cards / presents
Receive Christmas cards / present
Invitations for Christmas or any other family event
Have much of a relationship with their Grandchildren

And in return, MIL have generally given us their sons that

Think there is a towel fairy
And a diary that orders Christmas presents and send cards
And a fairy that responds to endless messages from school
And a patience fairy for said MIL who expects all of the as above

The End.

Nah you married the wrong bloke.

ColinRobinsonsfamiliar · 27/12/2022 09:09

Due to having a crappy dad growing up and a doormat mother, my dh has thankfully carved out his own path. He knows how NOT to do stuff in other words.

So it’s me that’s shit at present buying, Christmas organising, childcare and diary planning. Dh does all of that stuff.

No one would get anything or get fed in our house if it were left to me.
Im genuinely grateful to have such a great person looking after us all. This with no thanks to the Pil.

swedex · 27/12/2022 09:05

Teach your son to do his fair share and it wouldn't happen..make sure your dh models the behaviour

Alexandernevermind · 27/12/2022 09:02

I think some of you need to set the bar higher. You realise that behind the "incapable" man is a woman enabling the incapable / lazy behaviour? Too many woman have martyr syndrome and run around thinking if they don't do x, y or z it won't get done, whereas they just need to learn the art of delegation.

noworklifebalance · 27/12/2022 08:57

Awrite · 26/12/2022 23:40

Nice that women are to blame for the failings of men.

Yes to this. Where is the mention of the the FILs’ roles in raising sons?

Ledkr · 27/12/2022 08:56

This oes exist in some families yes. But as long as women accept and go along with this there will.always be a load of daughters who think this is the norm so the cycle continues.
As long as we continue to inantise men we will have men who expect women to do all this shit.
Seriously so depressing.
If you didn't buy all the family presents he'd have to face them with none so would probably buy them yhe following year.

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 27/12/2022 08:52

After 20 years together, I couldn't tell you any of my in-laws birthdays. I've never needed to know them, because DH has always remembered them and send cards and presents. MIL visited yesterday, and he did all in the cleaning in advance, and all the cooking, glass filling etc, on the day.

He's never expected anything from me WRT his family except that I treat them with respect and kindness.

Cornettoninja · 27/12/2022 08:50

Er no, I’m not managing another adults family relationships. I’m also not bypassing their responsibility to function as an adult to someone who raised them. You’re a child for a short time, any gaps in upbringing have more than adequate time to be realised and sorted out by a competent person.

If this is how you’re living your life you’re a mug.

bellinisurge · 27/12/2022 08:44

We organise separately for our respective families. I would simply refuse to if he didn't do his. As for grandkids. That continues to be a joint operation

Heronwatcher · 27/12/2022 08:44

I genuinely don’t know the dates of my other half’s family’s birthdays. And have never bought a single Christmas present for any of them (and to be clear I like them). It simply would not occur to me that it is my job to deal with that. Equally I don’t think he knows my side of the family’s birthdays and I don’t think it would occur to him to be responsible for presents for them. So not in all cases.

Barnowl25 · 27/12/2022 08:40

DH sorts presents/cards for his family. If he doesn't they get nothing. DS organises for us and his sister.

Remmy123 · 27/12/2022 08:40

My husband goes to town with his mum and dads present -I have no input

TheYummyPatler · 27/12/2022 08:39

My MIL has to take her chances with her son, because I’m certainly not buying her anything. I don’t even see or talk to the woman. That’s because she’s a truly awful person though. Since I met her son, she’s chosen to treat me with open contempt and behaved dreadfully. So screw her.

It’s not an I don’t like MILs thing. My first MIL was (is) a lovely woman. I will count her as a good friend for the rest of my life.

ShandaLear · 27/12/2022 08:37

You just have a shitty DH. My DP and I just go out together a few weeks before and buy all the gifts in a day. He also does all the organising for visits etc to his family as I do for mine. I do keep separate contact with my two SILs but that’s just because we get along very well and sometimes do separate stuff together. My DP also does his fair share of the cooking and cleaning - though I do more of the cooking and he does more of the bins.

MrsSkylerWhite · 27/12/2022 08:32

DuplicateUserName · Today 00:23

“What a pile of sexist old shite.”

👏👏👏

Peasepuddingbloodycold · 27/12/2022 08:30

Contentious first post, OP doesn’t return.

Purplechicken207 · 27/12/2022 08:28

I do a fair chunk of this, but personally I'm OK with it because he does a load of things I can't/won't. We each play to our strengths and find that works well for us.

He would remember his family birthdays etc, a day or two late (because he remembers but then gets caught up in other things), and would then send gifts etc. I just prod him a week or two before (they live hours away so usually posted) and if relevant drop some gift ideas (because his mum likes some of the same things as me). I'm clueless with his other family gift ideas though. And he always, without fail, gets and wraps gifts etc for me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread