Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gift too small and no alternative offered

207 replies

Remaker · 26/12/2022 23:12

DS was given a Christmas gift by my brother’s family that is too small for him. I messaged SIL asking if she had a receipt. She responded no receipt and was bought in cash so no cc statement either. End of message.

They have a younger DS who the gift is the correct size for. In their shoes I would just take the gift back and give DS money/voucher/correct size gift. But they’ve not offered any solution- just said sorry no receipt.

AIBU for thinking this is their mistake and they should sort it, not just dump DS with a gift he can’t use

OP posts:
Blowthemandown · 27/12/2022 10:20

Blowthemandown · 27/12/2022 10:20

@Remaker does it have the tags on? If so call a branch of the shop and explain you din’t have the receipt but it was a gift, or take it in wrapped in another bag and ask to exchange.

Or @Remaker message SIL and askmif she minds exchanging it for you 😂

Blowthemandown · 27/12/2022 10:20

@Remaker does it have the tags on? If so call a branch of the shop and explain you din’t have the receipt but it was a gift, or take it in wrapped in another bag and ask to exchange.

Changechangychange · 27/12/2022 10:19

Yogagrandmum · 27/12/2022 10:10

Agree…

If OP didn’t have another child who was receiving lovely presents from SIL, I would agree. Just make it a private joke that SIL’s presents are always terrible, and send it to the charity shop on Boxing Day.

The contrast between DD, who is deserving of lovely gifts, and DS, who only deserves stuff that their much-younger child was planning to throw out, means that OP needs to do something. Children will notice this - it is their aunt and uncle, not some random distant relative.

Just stopping Christmas and birthday presents is by far the easiest way to go. I have no idea what your SIL’s issue is with your DS, and I wouldn’t really care. Just stop the gifts.

amiold · 27/12/2022 10:19

WombatChocolate · 27/12/2022 10:03

It’s a sign of the times - people aren’t just pleased to get a gift, but feel entitled to have an item they love and to have anything they don’t swapped until they get something they do.

No right approach, but we tend to offer a receipt for a large item bought for close family - only clothes. Otherwise, no receipt and we hope people like their gift, but aren’t really interested in arranging exchanges etc.

It’s fairly frequent to get something you don’t like/doesn’t fit etc, especially for children. We just smile and say thank you and either re-gift or give to charity shop or a food bank type clothing service.

The issue is when parents are overly invested in how many presents their child gets and feel a deep sense that their child has been short-changed in terms of quantity of presents. Some parents seem to keep a close tally and decide their child will be deeply disappointed not to have had something from Cousin X, when in fact child will not even notice unless it’s pointed out to them. Sadly some parents do make a big thing if it, and then this can fuel a genuine or manufactured disappointment in child. It can also make them more grabby later in life. Totally unnecessary.

The other thing is people calculating the price of gifts and feeling disgruntled about the amount spent by other person in relation to what they spent. If it bothers you, spend less on them next time. If it feels like a big deal, you’re probably over-spending yourself on either that present or presents generally.

I know it’s easy to say if you’ve got plenty, but people really do get obsessed with stuff. Is it a sign of people who are struggling and therefore having a big pile of presents helps them feel better? I assume this is what’s going on when people feel excessively upset about one present given by a friend not being suitable??

A sign of the times? The gift was never going to fit said child and has been recycled because they don't want it/don't want to buy ... it's thoughtless and pointless.

BusyMum47 · 27/12/2022 10:18

@Remaker For what it's worth, I don't think you're being unreasonable at all - especially if there's a history of shit presents for your DS yet nice ones for your DD!! It's just really unkind & unnecessary. Surely, at some point, the kids will notice?

As for your brother - what a twat! Sidestepping anything with a direction to his wife? He's your brother - I'd ask him quite bluntly what's going on & why are they so biased.

ShesFlirtyTurnedThirty · 27/12/2022 10:15

That's pretty shit OP, 4 sizes to small is ridiculous when they see him regularly. I could estimate any kids size I didn’t know well at all better than that! And it sounds like it’s happened a lot before, an extension pack for a game he doesn’t have! Bloody hell. It’s weird when you say that the kids have lists and they just seem to ignore them for your son. After it happening so many times, I would think it’s purposely done by your SIL as she buys the presents. It’s not ungrateful to not be over the moon with presents that seem consistently unusable, especially when it’s the same one of your children every time.

And you say your brother is selfish. Maybe just cool things with them. It sounds like there’s a lot going with your mum being ill. You could also just suggest no presents next year and spend the money you would spend on their kids on your own so that your son isn’t the only one to miss out.

Yogagrandmum · 27/12/2022 10:10

Judgyjudgy · 26/12/2022 23:20

Just be gracious and give to someone else with a smaller child, why make this such an issue. Is it really worth it??!

Agree…

Tiani4 · 27/12/2022 10:07

Oh a few more pages have downloaded and I can see you've decided what to do

That it's a pretty deliberate to regift from their far younger son to yours & that you'll donate it to younger brother of one of DS's friends.

I think in your case you should say we're no longer buying for each other's DCs - so no more birthday or Xmas presents.

Thepeopleversuswork · 27/12/2022 10:05

SalmonEile · 27/12/2022 00:23

Exactly, people always say “it’s the thought that counts”
but if there’s no thought and just passing on random stuff that didn’t suit their own kid then what’s the point?

”oh just put it on eBay!”
yeah that’s fine but OP still has to photograph it, list it, deal with shitty buyers , pack it up, post it, deal with any disputes - that’s not a gift that’s a whole experience
hey OP this year I’m gifting you a “selling on eBay experience! Enjoy!”

I don’t disagree that buying a woefully inadequate present is thoughtless. I used to get masses of shit like this as a child from relatives who just couldn’t be arsed and it pissed me off.

But the problem is the idea that this child has some entitlement to the gift. The entire point about a gift is that it’s given on the terms of the giver.

The recipient doesn’t have to like it but there is no obligation on the part of the giver to buy a gift which the recipient likes.

It’s an important life lesson for children that they don’t always get the gifts they want and they don’t get to stamp their feet and cry and demand it get sorted.

The OP would be far better making peace with the fact that these relatives are for whatever reason a bit shit at gift giving rather than winding herself up worrying about whose “job” it is to “fix” this.

It isn’t a job and there isn’t a fix and fixating on “solutions” is just going to make her look grabby, teach her kids a bad lesson about gifts and generally create a lot of inter-family resentment.

WombatChocolate · 27/12/2022 10:03

It’s a sign of the times - people aren’t just pleased to get a gift, but feel entitled to have an item they love and to have anything they don’t swapped until they get something they do.

No right approach, but we tend to offer a receipt for a large item bought for close family - only clothes. Otherwise, no receipt and we hope people like their gift, but aren’t really interested in arranging exchanges etc.

It’s fairly frequent to get something you don’t like/doesn’t fit etc, especially for children. We just smile and say thank you and either re-gift or give to charity shop or a food bank type clothing service.

The issue is when parents are overly invested in how many presents their child gets and feel a deep sense that their child has been short-changed in terms of quantity of presents. Some parents seem to keep a close tally and decide their child will be deeply disappointed not to have had something from Cousin X, when in fact child will not even notice unless it’s pointed out to them. Sadly some parents do make a big thing if it, and then this can fuel a genuine or manufactured disappointment in child. It can also make them more grabby later in life. Totally unnecessary.

The other thing is people calculating the price of gifts and feeling disgruntled about the amount spent by other person in relation to what they spent. If it bothers you, spend less on them next time. If it feels like a big deal, you’re probably over-spending yourself on either that present or presents generally.

I know it’s easy to say if you’ve got plenty, but people really do get obsessed with stuff. Is it a sign of people who are struggling and therefore having a big pile of presents helps them feel better? I assume this is what’s going on when people feel excessively upset about one present given by a friend not being suitable??

PollyPut · 27/12/2022 10:01

@Remaker a gift is a gift. Clothes are often too small. Just kindly give it back to them in next time you see them for their DS. No point making a fuss

Tiani4 · 27/12/2022 10:00

Crazycrazylady · 26/12/2022 23:47

You're not being unreasonable to be annoyed by the gift and the blasé response but I think you'd be unreasonably to keep pushing the issue and demanded a 'solution'
I would passively aggressively return it to them for their own son however saying someone should get some wear out of it .

This ^^

As you can't do anything with the gift, give your DS money in exchange that you would have spent on their son for his birthday and regift it to their son who it does fit for his birthday . (Meh if it's a bit small by time his birthday comes round, that's a they / SIL problem)

Whatdayisitalexa · 27/12/2022 09:59

Changechangychange · 27/12/2022 09:46

SIL is clearly regifting things her own DS doesn’t want - she isn’t spending a penny, or putting in any thought whatsoever.

Her DS is one she (let’s say 7).
OP’s DS is four years older.
OP’s DS is receiving age 7 clothes for Christmas when he is 11.

That is not SIL mistakenly thinking an 11 year old might wear age 7 clothing, and buying the wrong size. That is SIL passing on her DS’s cast-off clothes as Christmas presents knowing they can’t possibly fit. She might as well have sent him a babygrow, or a tin of peas.

OP of course you are upset, it is an incredibly hurtful thing to do when your DD is getting lovely thoughtful presents from them. I’d stop the gifts from next year, and I’d be quite clear why.

Yes I agree it's a distinct possibility If it was something she has form for I would be suggesting that we bought for our own in the future, that way no child or parent will need to be upset. Some people are better at choosing gifts than others though and what someone thinks is a thoughtful gift may be construed as inappropriate by another. People are strange

amiold · 27/12/2022 09:56

Next year stop gifts. Don't buy each others families. If they ask why just say it's a waste as ds gets something that's no use and unfair his sister gets something lovely. It will save us all the extra hassle too, there's enough to do this time of year.

Changechangychange · 27/12/2022 09:46

RampantIvy · 27/12/2022 08:48

I think it's rude to buy people clothes as presents and not give them a receipt or at least check with the shop that they can exchange without

Or check what size is required. It's just a complete waste of money otherwise.

SIL is clearly regifting things her own DS doesn’t want - she isn’t spending a penny, or putting in any thought whatsoever.

Her DS is one she (let’s say 7).
OP’s DS is four years older.
OP’s DS is receiving age 7 clothes for Christmas when he is 11.

That is not SIL mistakenly thinking an 11 year old might wear age 7 clothing, and buying the wrong size. That is SIL passing on her DS’s cast-off clothes as Christmas presents knowing they can’t possibly fit. She might as well have sent him a babygrow, or a tin of peas.

OP of course you are upset, it is an incredibly hurtful thing to do when your DD is getting lovely thoughtful presents from them. I’d stop the gifts from next year, and I’d be quite clear why.

Treaclan · 27/12/2022 09:36

YANBU, your DS has been getting useless gifts from them while DD gets the good gifts. DS is getting their son's unwanted gifts obviously. I get completely wrong sized clothing from a sister every year. I give her them back. Never a receipt included. Its an insult. She doesn't replace it, So basically each year she gives me her unwanted gifts from her daughter.

ThreeblackCats · 27/12/2022 09:26

My husband got the same book from two different people. It’s well known that my DH is a fan and the author has just released a new book in time for Christmas. We didn’t embarrass anyone by asking if they’d exchange it, instead we plan to regift it to someone that we know is also a fan.
I agree with @Blinki , huge non issue. Yabvu.

But your son replacement pyjamas or sweatshirt and regift the one you’re so ungrateful for.

quinceh · 27/12/2022 09:25

I think it’s odd to give clothes as a gift without checking the size or keeping the receipt. I think you were right to mention it, but doesn’t sound as if there’s much you can do except give it away and maybe next year do a bit of a check on what they’re planning to get, if you’re still doing presents then.

astralpiano · 27/12/2022 09:22

Bit shit of them but maybe they bought it off ebay or something or cheap off Facebook. No worries just do the same to them next year.

AlwaysGoingBackwards · 27/12/2022 09:19

It’s so aggravating when this happens. We spent a lot of time on our DNs’ gifts and rarely get anything of equal value or thought back in return. It’s annoying but it’s not really in the spirit of Christmas to get so wound up about one gift.

Heartsofstone · 27/12/2022 09:16

Maybe she paid a dollar in a thrift shop thinking it was perfect and it isn’t. Just give it to someone else.

Prescottdanni123 · 27/12/2022 09:13

How did you ask for the receipt? Did you say something along the lines of "Thanks for the lovely present, we love it. Sadly it doesn't fit though so do you have the receipt so I can buy him.one in the correct size?"

Or did you just say "Do you have the receipt?"

The first one is fine, the latter comes across as rude.

Willmafrockfit · 27/12/2022 08:50

does it matter if she gave second hand goods?

if there is a label from a shop, try and exchange it at the shop
otherwise just buy him a present yourself.
no need fto further inovlve them

RampantIvy · 27/12/2022 08:49

That should have said or not to check the size.

RampantIvy · 27/12/2022 08:48

I think it's rude to buy people clothes as presents and not give them a receipt or at least check with the shop that they can exchange without

Or check what size is required. It's just a complete waste of money otherwise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread