Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH insult on Christmas morning

87 replies

ChristmasInsult · 26/12/2022 18:42

DH wished me a happy Christmas and gave me a peck on the cheek first thing Christmas morning and asked if I wanted breakfast. I said something about still feeling full from all the food we had eaten the night before.

I had tight PJ bottoms and a t shirt on and granted, my belly looked huge. He looked me up and down and said “yeah, you’re turning into a wee fat thing again”. Granted my weight has been fluctuating and I am currently about 2.5 stone overweight whereas at the end of the summer, I was “only” about a stone overweight. I’m only 5”1 so it really shows.

I was devastated but didn’t say anything as didn’t want an argument on Christmas Day. I spoke to him today and he apologised and admitted he shouldn’t have said it. I am beyond upset.

AIBU that I am not talking to him on Boxing Day and not sure when I will feel like talking to him again?

or should I accept I am very overweight and accept his apology and get over it?

OP posts:
Poundofflesh · 26/12/2022 20:09

Wow, the fat shamers are out in full force! That was a horrible thing to say OP and, in my opinion, designed to wound you and make you feel shit about yourself! The fact that he isn’t genuinely remorseful shows that it wasn’t just a thoughtless gaffe. Nobody should have to listen to comments like this from their partner and I would be seriously rethinking the relationship if my DH said something like that to me.

Zanatdy · 26/12/2022 20:02

It wasn’t nice, he shouldn’t have said it. He’s apologised, I hate it when people punish people with the silent treatment. Been there with my ex and it’s actually abusive in my opinion

TedMullins · 26/12/2022 20:00

You know you’re overweight so he isn’t lying is he? Insensitive yes but you said yourself you don’t like your current weight. Many people don’t find overweight people attractive. I told my boyfriend the same, that if he got fatter I wouldn’t fancy him (he was bigger before we met, I’ve seen photos and I don’t find him attractive in them). I wouldn’t expect him to fancy me if I piled on the pounds either. I don’t believe anyone is obliged to fancy their partner all the time no matter how they look - some people hate beards and tattoos for example, and probably wouldn’t fancy their partners if they got either of them.

roarfeckingroarr · 26/12/2022 20:00

Well... it wasn't very nice but it sounds like he said it in jest and he's apologised. Silent treatment isn't healthy. Don't ruin Christmas/

Zippy1510 · 26/12/2022 19:59

Wrong to say it but clearly honest.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 26/12/2022 19:55

How is giving him the silent treatment going to help you lose weight?

Do you want to?

Work out a plan going forwards and ask for his support.

Both myself and my DP are about a stone over where we want to be. So our plan is A) Forget about it over Christmas (haha!) and B) Start doing more exercise in the New Year. Together and separately.

FayCarew · 26/12/2022 19:53

2.5 stone overweight at 5'1" is a lot, but he was insensitive.

bippit · 26/12/2022 19:49

What a horrible contemptuous comment. I would struggle to get past this too and would not find a cursory apology sufficient. It seems like there must be some real aggression or other underlying issue on his side for him to come out with something so obviously derogatory.

I disagree that the silent treatment is always “abusive” - it is very common to be upset and hurt and not know how to proceed, not want to go on the attack but not have been given enough to move on. The silent treatment can be a way of retreating or an unavoidable spinning of your wheels. I fail to see how it is worse than outright abuse. The comments saying that your response is worse than his weird spiteful comment are facile imho.

I hope you’re able to sort your head out and work out how you want to proceed. 💐

Scabetty · 26/12/2022 19:33

Not sure what you want. You want to be lighter, you aren’t happy with current weight. He agrees you are heavier than you should be. He apologised and you are offended. 2.5 stone is not a slight fluctuation. What weight do you want to be for you? Decide on that first - what is realistic for you to achieve without being unhappy in lifestyle changes.

Theydoyaknow · 26/12/2022 19:26

Ughhhhh grow up! He said sorry, hate that silent treatment crap. I remember my husband commenting on how thin I had gotten once, I didn’t look healthy. It hurt but spurred me on to be more healthy. he worded it poorly but might be worried about you. He kissed you good morning and asked what you wanted for breakfast, he can’t be all bad.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/12/2022 19:23

Giving someone the silent treatment is really not on. He has apologised, you need to either accept his apology or go back and discuss it more with him

MissingMoominMamma · 26/12/2022 19:22

It sounds as though it was said with affection, but only you really know that.

Sulking though…

fancyacuppatea · 26/12/2022 19:21

You could easily lose quite a lot of weight, about 10, maybe 12stones - Him.

Luredbyapomegranate · 26/12/2022 19:18

It was hurtful, especially at Christmas.

However, sulking is never a healthy way to deal with anything, so don’t do it, tackle whatever you need to tackle.

Tinner01 · 26/12/2022 19:16

What @Teddeh said.

WunWun · 26/12/2022 19:15

His comment was obviously horrible, but sulking and giving him the silent treatment is so fucking unbelievably childish and unhelpful. I'm not surprised he's annoyed. Do you want him to beg for your forgiveness? Urgh.

Teddeh · 26/12/2022 19:12

I think it depends on what you want that hasn't been satisfied by his apology.

Do you want him not to care if you've gained weight? He either does or doesn't care; beyond basic politeness, there's no point in his saying one thing and thinking another. But if you're not sure and need more info, then I'd raise it again and talk it through. You're better off knowing where he stands, but you have to let him say it does bother him if it does.

Do you not mind if he minds that you've gained weight, but don't want him to comment on it? That's the easiest one; if he hasn't specifically said he won't comment again, or he's said he won't and you don't believe him, ask for additional reassurances.

Do you not mind his commenting, but take issue with specifically WHAT he said? That requires further discussion, and may have wider range than that single comment. (This would be my view, I think - "yes, you've gained some weight this winter" is fine, "wee fat thing" is rude as fuck. But tone and relationship won't come across here, and everyone's different.)

Do you want to lose weight but need/want his support, or more understanding of how difficult it is for you? That's another conversation, but you'd be better to know exactly what you want to ask from him before raising the subject again.

If you feel this is a last straw in the relationship, that's your right - but silent treatment doesn't seem productive. If you don't know what he can do to make things right, how can he know? If you feel like you'll get over it but need a little time for it to feel less raw, can you tell him that and ask him for a little space/peace, rather than saying nothing?

midsomermurderess · 26/12/2022 19:12

Raise it with him, tell him you’re hurt. You’re sulking, it’s not helpful.

PritiPatelsMaker · 26/12/2022 19:12

At 5'1" 2.5 stone is likely to have significant health implications for you OP.

I'd accept his apology, he's admitted that he's made a mistake and use that negative energy you're feeling, turn it into positive energy and use it get get yourself fitter.

ChristmasInsult · 26/12/2022 19:11

Betwixlass · 26/12/2022 19:08

@wee” is used affectionately. He’s also apologised. I would let it go. I also need to lose a little and don’t feel great about it but if a man said so I would let it go. It’s true after all and men tend to be more factual than women.

Yeah I’m Scottish so get the “wee” bit - but his tone /the way he looked me up and down were not affectionate

OP posts:
ChristmasInsult · 26/12/2022 19:09

Thanks for the comments. I guess I’m not convinced he is genuine in his apology. He seems to be annoyed that I’m annoyed, if that makes sense?

I am unhappy being this size. I’ve fallen away from going to the gym and eating more healthily - no reasons for this other than “can’t be bothered “.

we have a friendship group with 4 other couples and I just cannot imagine any of the other husbands saying this. One of the female friends was obese years ago, lost about 8 stone but has put about another 3 back on. Her husband is always saying she looks great, he still fancies her etc. my DH told me years ago if I ever got really fat, he’d still love me but not fancy me. So it’s always stuck in my mind - he has a real aversion to overweight people.

but I do accept that my response needs to be more adult. I just can’t seem to strike up a “normal” conversation when I’m still reeling. Think I’ll take a glass of wine to bed and get an early night - move on tomorrow

OP posts:
Betwixlass · 26/12/2022 19:08

@wee” is used affectionately. He’s also apologised. I would let it go. I also need to lose a little and don’t feel great about it but if a man said so I would let it go. It’s true after all and men tend to be more factual than women.

KilmordenCastle · 26/12/2022 19:07

What are you hoping to achieve by giving him the silent treatment?

WandaWonder · 26/12/2022 19:06

Sure not a nice thing, it was dealt with but not speaking to him till the next time he says something that upsets you could see you never speaking to him again

Deal with it and move on or wallow in it if it actually makes you feel better your choice

Sunnytwobridges · 26/12/2022 19:05

Words hurt. And I'm one of those people that even after an apology it's hard for me to forget what was said.