Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH insult on Christmas morning

87 replies

ChristmasInsult · 26/12/2022 18:42

DH wished me a happy Christmas and gave me a peck on the cheek first thing Christmas morning and asked if I wanted breakfast. I said something about still feeling full from all the food we had eaten the night before.

I had tight PJ bottoms and a t shirt on and granted, my belly looked huge. He looked me up and down and said “yeah, you’re turning into a wee fat thing again”. Granted my weight has been fluctuating and I am currently about 2.5 stone overweight whereas at the end of the summer, I was “only” about a stone overweight. I’m only 5”1 so it really shows.

I was devastated but didn’t say anything as didn’t want an argument on Christmas Day. I spoke to him today and he apologised and admitted he shouldn’t have said it. I am beyond upset.

AIBU that I am not talking to him on Boxing Day and not sure when I will feel like talking to him again?

or should I accept I am very overweight and accept his apology and get over it?

OP posts:
PeaceJoySleep · 26/12/2022 21:25

He's rude. You said you were full. You weren't asking him if he thought you looked fat or not.

I would go on whatever eating regime suits you and tell him he's making his own dinner from now on.

I'm 5'1'' and want to lose 20lbs but if somebody said to me ''yeh you're a wee fat thing'' I'd wonder why they were setting out to make me feel bad about myself.

DarkKarmaIlama · 26/12/2022 21:18

I am sorry but he sounds like a total spiteful dick. My husband would never say anything like this to me and I’ve been fat, thin and everything inbetween. Honestly he just loves me for who I am. Personally I would have insulted him back as I’m sure he’s no oil painting himself. Unless you’re going out with someone who’s drop dead gorgeous?

I think a comment like that can really sting for a long time irrespective of a half arsed apology.

Lexi868 · 26/12/2022 21:02

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 26/12/2022 19:55

How is giving him the silent treatment going to help you lose weight?

Do you want to?

Work out a plan going forwards and ask for his support.

Both myself and my DP are about a stone over where we want to be. So our plan is A) Forget about it over Christmas (haha!) and B) Start doing more exercise in the New Year. Together and separately.

You've missed the point. She knows she is overweight and wants to lose weight but doesn't need an unsolicited insult directed at her from her DP. That's hardly encouraging of him.

PrincessScarlett · 26/12/2022 21:01

OP, you have said yourself you are not happy with your weight gain. Perhaps use this as a kick start to get into shape, start going to the gym again and regain a bit of body confidence. DH was an insensitive prick but he has apologised (only you can judge if his apology is sincere or not). I think your continued sulking is just as much your unhappiness with your weight as much as what DH said.

Cas112 · 26/12/2022 21:00

What else would you like him to do other than apologise?

Lexi868 · 26/12/2022 20:59

Theydoyaknow · 26/12/2022 19:26

Ughhhhh grow up! He said sorry, hate that silent treatment crap. I remember my husband commenting on how thin I had gotten once, I didn’t look healthy. It hurt but spurred me on to be more healthy. he worded it poorly but might be worried about you. He kissed you good morning and asked what you wanted for breakfast, he can’t be all bad.

I think most women would be flattered by being called too thin. It's socially more acceptable. Being called fat isn't the same.

Lexi868 · 26/12/2022 20:57

ChristmasInsult · 26/12/2022 18:42

DH wished me a happy Christmas and gave me a peck on the cheek first thing Christmas morning and asked if I wanted breakfast. I said something about still feeling full from all the food we had eaten the night before.

I had tight PJ bottoms and a t shirt on and granted, my belly looked huge. He looked me up and down and said “yeah, you’re turning into a wee fat thing again”. Granted my weight has been fluctuating and I am currently about 2.5 stone overweight whereas at the end of the summer, I was “only” about a stone overweight. I’m only 5”1 so it really shows.

I was devastated but didn’t say anything as didn’t want an argument on Christmas Day. I spoke to him today and he apologised and admitted he shouldn’t have said it. I am beyond upset.

AIBU that I am not talking to him on Boxing Day and not sure when I will feel like talking to him again?

or should I accept I am very overweight and accept his apology and get over it?

That's mean and not funny. He has hurt your feelings and you should make it clear that if he ever calls you fat again, you will lose a bunch of weight overnight by throwing him out the house

Bemyclementine · 26/12/2022 20:56

I think sometimes things hit harder when they are true. You've acknowledged that you've gained weight because you can't be bothered to eat healthily and exercise. (So have I, and I feel stupid about it. I list 2.5st last year and gave regained at least 1.5).

You've discussed, he's apologised. Move on.

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 26/12/2022 20:53

Poundofflesh · 26/12/2022 20:09

Wow, the fat shamers are out in full force! That was a horrible thing to say OP and, in my opinion, designed to wound you and make you feel shit about yourself! The fact that he isn’t genuinely remorseful shows that it wasn’t just a thoughtless gaffe. Nobody should have to listen to comments like this from their partner and I would be seriously rethinking the relationship if my DH said something like that to me.

It's Mumsnet. Fat shaming and insults related to weight are absolutely fine on here. Look how they've even managed to make OP the 'abusive' one.

WunWun · 26/12/2022 20:51

Of course he didn't fat shame her... FFS!

Stravaig · 26/12/2022 20:46

Obviously we can't really gauge the tone and the looks and the subtext from here. If he regularly belittles you then yes, this is a bigger thing than the words themselves. However if he is generally loving, and his apology is sincere, then most likely the words come from an underlying concern about your weight and its effect on your health, and on the relationship. So I would try to let it go and instead open up the bigger conversation.

With hurtful words, I try to factor in accuracy, and whether the thing said is something that needs to be addressed. Some people seem to find accurate things more hurtful and have a worse reaction. I think accuracy only seems more hurtful when we agree with what is said, and so really it is also us giving feedback to ourselves. It is a time to bravely lift the chin and face the thing that needs to be faced, and perhaps enlist the help of the person who has echoed our own thoughts. Of course, if someone is just being nasty this doesn't apply!

As you yourself say you are unhappy with your weight, and assuming his apology is genuine, could you not agree with the truth of what he said, and ask for whatever support you need from him in tackling your weight?

Giving him the silent treatment is not on.

simplefree · 26/12/2022 20:40

1- watch the movie Starfish - preferably together - nothing to do with weight but everything to do with real love - I have been single for ages / divorced twice from two toxic marriages and now I accept nothin less then real love (not saying your relationship is toxic or lacks love but maybe needs some perspective)

2- for weight loss, learning how to eat and mantain weight and exercise tips plus tons of motivation - follow Granite Coaching - coach Deasy on FB - see if you like

3- for better navigating the world as a non skinny person check the podcast Maintanance Phase

BlueTick · 26/12/2022 20:39

What's changed OP? Why did you fall away from the gym?

I do think when we get together with someone there's an unspoken agreement that we'll do our best to maintain that version of ourselves.

He was mean to say this to you. Very mean and it's hurt your pride and self-esteem. I would be gutted too. But you say you hate yourself this way. So instead of dwelling on his comments - which have only voiced how you feel about yourself - what can you do?

I'm sorry he delivered his thoughts the way he did but he may be concerned about why you've lost interest in your health and body? Men can be very crass.

But in the end its on you to decide what you want? If he put on a lot of weight - would you be worried about him? If he lost interest in taking care of himself - what would you do?

What can he do to support you to feel better? What can do you do to support yourself to feel better? It doesn't necessarily mean losing weight, right now - but perhaps look deeper and think about what's really going on?

AllOfThemWitches · 26/12/2022 20:32

Observing that somebody is overweight isn't 'fat shaming!?'

AllOfThemWitches · 26/12/2022 20:30

Hmm I don't think weight should be a taboo subject between couples really. It's true that you're overweight? So not a nasty shock to be told. I don't really get not fancying your partner just for gaining a bit of weight though.

GatoradeMeBitch · 26/12/2022 20:24

That's a horrible thing for him to say but he has apologised so you either accept his apology and move forward or you don't.

What happens if she doesn't accept it and move forward - divorce? Her husband just fatshamed her. "He said sorry so get over it" is very simplistic. Feelings don't shut off that easily.

However giving someone the silent treatment isn't productive either. She needs to speak to him about having some basic respect for his partner. And she also needs to think about why it hurt her so much and what that tells her.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 26/12/2022 20:24

I like how some posters are going straight into how the OP could be a better weight rather than how her husband could be a better person. So if someone is not at an acceptable weight, its OK to be rude? Well, of course it is, we all know that.

Particularly like the poster that said as he'd given her a kiss and asked about breakfast (even though he then said she was fat and should skip the meal!) that he must be a great guy. Set the bar high there love ...!

BCBird · 26/12/2022 20:23

I would be hurt yoo but silent treatment is a definite no no.

LuluBlakey1 · 26/12/2022 20:21

Is he a Greek God? I think probably not but you are kind enough to not point out his areas of 'possibly needing a bit of work'. He's mean and unkind.

PenanceAdair · 26/12/2022 20:20

If it bothered me, I'd have said something then and there like "Wow that's not very nice!", hopefully that would have gotten him to apologise immediately too. Then we get on with it.

Or I'd say "You don't look so good yourself" and we'd laugh at ourselves. Depends on the mood and the sort of relationship I have with the person.

nancydroo · 26/12/2022 20:16

Glamourgal1989 · 26/12/2022 20:10

What a cunt ! Does he look like a model ?

Perfect

NeedToChangeName · 26/12/2022 20:15

Hos comment was horrible. Only you know if his apology was genuine or just to shut you up

Sulking / silent treatment isn't a helpful response

PenanceAdair · 26/12/2022 20:11

Sounded like he meant it in jest but came out as a zinger. If it bothered me, I'd have said something then and there like "Wow that's not very nice!", hopefully that would have gotten him to apologise immediately too. Then we get on with it.

Unless he has form for insulting you (in which case, it's a problem), it doesn't sound like a big deal but it seems you feeling a bit unhappy with yourself right now has caused it to be much more than what it should be.

He's apologised; Don't worry and enjoy the holidays.

AnneLovesGilbert · 26/12/2022 20:11

Do you talk about disliking being bigger a lot? If you do and he’s hearing it a lot he might be annoyed that you’re not annoyed he said it.

Your friends are irrelevant too. Maybe that man does find his wife attractive at 8 stone overweight. Maybe he’s lying but trying to make her feel better. Maybe he prefers her that size. It’s not unreasonable for yours to be honest that while he’d love your personality if you gained a lot of weight he wouldn’t fancy you. If DH gained the weight of a whole other person I doubt I’d fancy him. I wouldn’t expect him to fancy me if I looked substantially different. It’s got nothing to do with love. Though barring a major health issue I doubt he’d be the same type of person he is now if he was that much bigger, there’d be loads of things we enjoy doing that he wouldn’t be able to do.

You’re not 8 stone bigger but at your height you’ve gained a lot and you’re not happy about it. I expect you mention it more than you think you do so he wasn’t necessarily trying to make you feel shit.

Glamourgal1989 · 26/12/2022 20:10

What a cunt ! Does he look like a model ?