Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset over Christmas present?

212 replies

CrazyCatLady00 · 26/12/2022 17:28

I know they say it’s the thought that counts, but I seriously felt there was no thought or much effort into my Christmas present from my bf.

I gave him a list of things to choose from that I would like and he got one item from the list which was a pair of earrings that he ordered last minute from Amazon 😒 and I also know they didn’t cost more then £40.

I got him loads for Christmas and put so much effort into it. Am I wrong to feel disappointed?

OP posts:
HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 23:25

@RJnomore1
Just to put this into perspective this is like me saying that my husband can sing and women all deserve to have someone that can sing because it's amazing to have someone so emotionally in tune with themselves and others.

Some people aren't great at singing, some people aren't great at buying gifts. I honestly don't know how anyone can treat a partner as a performer and not a person. And I honestly don't know how anyone can come on here and make a tenuous link with someone being a bad partner because of it.

RJnomore1 · 26/12/2022 23:23

Well that would be one methodology depending on many many factors. I wouldn’t have to do any of that to produce a robust and competent study that would withstand peer review.

i would just like people to be happy and I’m able to observe that many aren’t… and that most of the unhappiness I see comes from perceived unfairness and resentment. Not necessarily just in relationships either that last sentence.

AlwaysGoingBackwards · 26/12/2022 23:19

I think that’s a fair amount and a lovely gift. Why does it matter when it was ordered provided you got it on the day?
I hate the way some people make gift giving so transactional; knowing the trade value.

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 23:16

RJnomore1 · 26/12/2022 22:56

Ok let’s take it to basics.

How many people talking about bad partner gifts are happy?

What is the point of being in a relationship if not to make you happy?

That doesn’t need to be an expensive gift. It can be as simple as making you breakfast, or as another poster beautifully described bringing you things you need.

Can you explain what logic makes you think someone putting no effort in, or deciding to change the goal posts without discussion, makes them a good partner?

Before we even go there you have to justify why this is a bad partner gift.

Is the OP just unhappy because it wasn't £200?
Is the OP jumping to conclusions that the bf put no effort into it?

After that you would have to breakdown the statistics on how many people don't really care that much about what gifts they get because they don't think it's important compared to those that come onto MN to complain about them.

After that you would have to look at whether people focused too much on gifts are bad partners.

Before you even get to a point where you conclude that your marriage is the special sort of marriage that everyone in the world wants (despite the fact it's enabling you to jump to conclusions about everything and everyone)

RJnomore1 · 26/12/2022 23:15

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 23:01

@RJnomore1
You do realise mumsnet despite the name is for parents btw don’t you?

You do realise according to the stats about 80% of users are female btw. Did you really just suggest there's an equal spread of men and women here?

Lets take it back to basics then, what is it exactly your point other than bad gift giver = bad partner, which you can't actually objectively justify and attack other posters when questioned.

Your core argument is that you have an amazing marriage and anyone disagreeing with you on this thread is clearly unhappy and in a bad relationship.

Somehow I find this line of reasoning a bit off.

Oh I’ve just looked at your other posts. Silly me.

Amyway you misrepresent my point which is that lots of women are in bad relationships and openly post on here about them and knowing the early signs could be useful. And that fairness and communication is really important.

id still like to see that venn diagram though.

MickeyMouseShithouse · 26/12/2022 23:14

DP come from a family that gives one gift per occasion, be it Christmas or birthday. Even Santa would bring 1 gift.

I come from a family where is wake up to a overflowing sack of presents.

We set a budget, it’s £50 each; we mostly always end up going over budget. I tend to buy multiple items, I.e a jumper, a body set, a game/novelty gift, some socks ect.

He buys me my favourite perfume most years unless I’ve asked for suggested something specific if he’s stuck for ideas.

One thing I e never done is look at what he brought me and felt disappointed, or felt like he should have brought me more/spent more to make our gifting equal.

The thought really does count here, he brought me something. He went out of his way to search for something, wrap it and give it to me. That in itself is appreciated.

Stop looking at quantity when it comes to gifts, you’ll learnt to appreciate the experience a lot more.

Workinghardeveryday · 26/12/2022 23:06

Well it’s £40 more than I got.

I am pt, he is ft, good wage.

I bought all kids, my family and HIS. Got fuck all.

AnnieSnap · 26/12/2022 23:03

pocketvenuss · 26/12/2022 20:25

Seriously? My 15 year old and her boyfriend spent around £150 on each other.

I think teenagers do this. They are still in the ‘sack of stuff’ mindset, but we’re talking about adults here. Sometimes a present might be expensive because that is the right gift at that time. Sometimes, it won’t be so expensive.

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 23:01

@RJnomore1
You do realise mumsnet despite the name is for parents btw don’t you?

You do realise according to the stats about 80% of users are female btw. Did you really just suggest there's an equal spread of men and women here?

Lets take it back to basics then, what is it exactly your point other than bad gift giver = bad partner, which you can't actually objectively justify and attack other posters when questioned.

Your core argument is that you have an amazing marriage and anyone disagreeing with you on this thread is clearly unhappy and in a bad relationship.

Somehow I find this line of reasoning a bit off.

piedbeauty · 26/12/2022 23:00

Bestcatmum · 26/12/2022 17:39

I didn't even get that in 20 years of marriage.

This is not a competition to see who has the worst man... Why did you put up with that for 20 years if you weren't happy?!

CrazyCatLady00 · 26/12/2022 22:59

Yes I like my earrings, my point being however is that we previously spent a lot more on each other last Christmas and there was no mention of spending less, so this year I probably spend £150 more on him and out so much effort into his presents and unfortunately it didn’t seem reciprocated.

I really wish some would read my replies first before calling me greedy, needy and whatever else I’ve been called….!!

OP posts:
Cherryblossoms85 · 26/12/2022 22:57

You'll have to let this sort of stuff go eventually. Men do make an effort. Just...not very successfully 😀

Livelovebehappy · 26/12/2022 22:56

Seriously? Pineappleskies’ post deleted? Just for telling OP she was moaning and behaving like a self entitled brat? Ansolutely bonkers. The response she received back from OP was so much more offensive….

RJnomore1 · 26/12/2022 22:56

Ok let’s take it to basics.

How many people talking about bad partner gifts are happy?

What is the point of being in a relationship if not to make you happy?

That doesn’t need to be an expensive gift. It can be as simple as making you breakfast, or as another poster beautifully described bringing you things you need.

Can you explain what logic makes you think someone putting no effort in, or deciding to change the goal posts without discussion, makes them a good partner?

AnnieSnap · 26/12/2022 22:56

twinmum2022 · 26/12/2022 19:53

OP literally gave him a list of stuff she wants... so I don't understand why she's now dissatisfied with the level of thought??? Because she didn't expect any?? Hence the list no?

Is the issue you didn't get enough off your list OP?

Apparently, that is indeed the issue 🤷‍♀️

Athenen0ctua · 26/12/2022 22:50

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 22:41

Anyway @RJnomore1 there is a study at CMU which suggests people who are bad at gift giving usually focus on the cost of the gift.

I've noted in this case the OP said nothing about whether she actually liked the earrings or not.

I'm not sure what standards you are trying to hold women to but you may want to to understand that your own standards are not universal before going on about how women should expect more.

Yes, odd that it's the cost that is focused on. He could have bought £100 earrings despite thinking the OP would like the £40 ones better. Would the OP have been happier in that case I wonder?

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 22:44

RJnomore1 · 26/12/2022 22:42

I have, I dated a tight lazy guy in my late teens. Got shot and would not tolerate it now. Have a great, decades long marriage with a bloke who puts effort in on all fronts, and gets effort back from me in return. I’d like to see all women with the same. Set your bar high (that doesn’t mean money - it means thought and knowing and understanding you).

(I should have been clear for the pedantic that I was continuing to refer to intimate relationships and not to wider gift giving, in line with the entire thread. )

You do realise mumsnet despite the name is for parents btw don’t you?

I hope you find happiness anyway, perhaps you’re the lazy one in relationships if you think consideration about something your partner you might enjoy is needy and whatever else you called it, I’m not insisting it’s entirely the domain of men.

I see so we've gone from asking you to justify why people who are bad gift givers are bad partners to attacking me personally and suggesting I'm not happy.

And I'm the snippy emotional one 😂

RJnomore1 · 26/12/2022 22:42

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 22:20

Nah it's not snippy to ask you to back it up when you say Bad gift giver = bad partner. People need to be responsible when making such claims.

You seem kinda snippy though, no doubt experienced it yourself.

I have, I dated a tight lazy guy in my late teens. Got shot and would not tolerate it now. Have a great, decades long marriage with a bloke who puts effort in on all fronts, and gets effort back from me in return. I’d like to see all women with the same. Set your bar high (that doesn’t mean money - it means thought and knowing and understanding you).

(I should have been clear for the pedantic that I was continuing to refer to intimate relationships and not to wider gift giving, in line with the entire thread. )

You do realise mumsnet despite the name is for parents btw don’t you?

I hope you find happiness anyway, perhaps you’re the lazy one in relationships if you think consideration about something your partner you might enjoy is needy and whatever else you called it, I’m not insisting it’s entirely the domain of men.

Blinki · 26/12/2022 22:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 22:41

Anyway @RJnomore1 there is a study at CMU which suggests people who are bad at gift giving usually focus on the cost of the gift.

I've noted in this case the OP said nothing about whether she actually liked the earrings or not.

I'm not sure what standards you are trying to hold women to but you may want to to understand that your own standards are not universal before going on about how women should expect more.

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 22:27

TheLittlestLightOnTheXmasTree · 26/12/2022 22:01

Mumsnet is also full of snippy threads about unsuitable presents from mil's,mothers,Sils and sisters

Not just men. At all

Absolutely. Not sure how this thread jumped to men are bad gift givers. The clue that they're not on here complaining about their partners gifts is in the forum name "mumsnet".

Abcdefgh1234 · 26/12/2022 22:21

Me and dh not doing any gifting anymore. I just choose whatever i want and wrap it myself. Ask dh to pay it. I wrap it myself hust because my kids like to open my presents aswell. This christmas i want celine bag so i bought in myself snd ask dh to pay. I wouldnt dare to ask dh to choose it by himself. He will choose either wrong colour or wrong model.

same aswell as dh. He wants air jordan so he choose himself and ask me to wrap it. The elements of surprise is gone but i’m still happy with celine bag.

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 22:20

RJnomore1 · 26/12/2022 21:58

Well as a completely untested evidence body I present you with mn on Christmas, Mother’s Day, at birthdays…

and while some will undoubtedly be same sex couples the majority are about useless men. There’s plenty on this thread.

i don’t for a second believe these men are useless in other spheres of life. I do believe bad gift giving (which is not linked to cost) is often a sign of lack of consideration and this bad partners. This us based on my observational evidence in real life and on here.

Youre quite snippy and defensive are you not? You do realise I have no obligation to produce peer researched evidence just to satisfy you? Have I hit a nerve somehow? It wasn’t my intention ; I am thoroughly scunnered with women underselling themselves on every front though. And other women jumping in to shut them down from expecting to be treated better.

Nah it's not snippy to ask you to back it up when you say Bad gift giver = bad partner. People need to be responsible when making such claims.

You seem kinda snippy though, no doubt experienced it yourself.

TheLittlestLightOnTheXmasTree · 26/12/2022 22:01

Mumsnet is also full of snippy threads about unsuitable presents from mil's,mothers,Sils and sisters

Not just men. At all

RJnomore1 · 26/12/2022 21:58

HotChoxs · 26/12/2022 20:54

Is it? You're asserting that bad gift giving = bad partner. And bad gift giving = mostly men.

Up to you to back this up with something tangible isn't it?

Well as a completely untested evidence body I present you with mn on Christmas, Mother’s Day, at birthdays…

and while some will undoubtedly be same sex couples the majority are about useless men. There’s plenty on this thread.

i don’t for a second believe these men are useless in other spheres of life. I do believe bad gift giving (which is not linked to cost) is often a sign of lack of consideration and this bad partners. This us based on my observational evidence in real life and on here.

Youre quite snippy and defensive are you not? You do realise I have no obligation to produce peer researched evidence just to satisfy you? Have I hit a nerve somehow? It wasn’t my intention ; I am thoroughly scunnered with women underselling themselves on every front though. And other women jumping in to shut them down from expecting to be treated better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread