Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you lend this money if you were receiving this back?

112 replies

Boxingdaytoday · 26/12/2022 13:59

Would you lend someone around a thousand, if they were able to pay it back in 3 months at just over £300 per month?

OP posts:
00100001 · 26/12/2022 16:28

ChristmasChair · 26/12/2022 16:22

Sorry everyone is kicking you while you are down OP xx

No one is "kicking her down" just wondering why she can all of a sudden find £300 a month when she hasn't been able to atm and claims she didn't spend the £1000 on Christmas.

It doesn't make sense that she could pay £300 a month more now. Her bills will be as expensive. And,yes, she won't have Christmas,but she claims that the £1000 wasn't spent on Christmas. So I think her maths is wrong and it might be more like £200 pm she could afford.

00100001 · 26/12/2022 16:26

Why would you have a spare £300 pm now? Despite claiming you s ore on bills.

Your energy bills won't magically go down in the next 3. Months. So if the bills aren't a problem because you seem to think you can pay £300 a month on top of bills no problem

It can only mean you've spent £1000 on Christmas ??

ChristmasChair · 26/12/2022 16:22

Sorry everyone is kicking you while you are down OP xx

diamondpony80 · 26/12/2022 16:20

Someone short £1000 is unlikely to have £333 to spare every month for the next 3 months.

Getoff · 26/12/2022 16:19

Boxingdaytoday · 26/12/2022 15:20

I didn’t spend 1000 on Christmas 😫

Okay thanks for the advice everyone

If you didn't spend £1000 on christmas, and your income exceeds your outgoings by £333 a month, even after allowing for the increase in outgoings, then it's not clear why you are short of money now.

You can't make the case for being a good risk if you can't explain why there's a problem now, when apparently you have more than enough income overall. The facts are not adding up.

Survey99 · 26/12/2022 16:15

I wouldnt lend money to anyone if it was the result of poor financial management, living beyond their means or spending money they couldnt afford on Christmas when their mortgage payments were at risk. If it was my child it would be different, but I wouldnt lend them money without know exactly how they got there as I wouldnt want to throw (my) good money after bad if there were a better solution to their difficulties.

I wouldnt ask to borrow money if I had for myself into that position.

If you can afford to easily pay back £300/month you shouldnt be in debt now and you need to be more honest with yourself how you got here. The cost of living crisis isnt ending anytime soon.

BreadInCaptivity · 26/12/2022 16:12

You're getting a hard time here OP because what you've described doesn't make any sense.

The rate at which you can pay back the money (which is on top of the elevated standard outgoings you have described such as utilities and mortgage payments) is at odds as to why you would need it in the first place.

You say you got "behind" because of those items being increasingly expensive plus Christmas.

It simply doesn't add up that you can throw £1k at those issues now and then pay £300 per month to repay the loan without falling behind again.

So something doesn't add up.

If your circumstances where that you'd had an unexpected bill of £1000 that needs to be paid now, that would make sense in so far you can afford to pay it, just not in one go- but in that case your first port of call is to see if you could pay that bill in instalments rather than asking your parents for a loan.

However, you specifically mention your mortgage which is NOT an unexpected bill.

The only other thing I can think of is if your wage is variable such as you own your own business and have had a minor cash flow issue but expect a number of payments will come good in the next 3 months (though again I'd question how you are managing your finances as most self employed people keep cash reserves for such a scenario and smooth their earnings over the year).

However when all is said and done, as a parent and if I could afford it, I'd give you the money (never mind lend it) as long I was confident that the circumstances that led to this issue was a one off and beyond your control rather than a result of being financially feckless.

Proudofitbabe · 26/12/2022 16:05

Yes, loans are no biggie between my parents/siblings.

Fishwifer · 26/12/2022 15:56

Er, Ask your parents to gift it and deduct it from your future inheritance. ...?

You're assuming they will give an inheritance and also have ready money in a form to be able to cash it in?! Bizarre - this isn't real life for many, many working class folk up and down the country.

RememberNancyDrew · 26/12/2022 15:55

Ask your parents to gift it and deduct it from your future inheritance.
Borrowing for routine daily living expenses like this is the hardest to pay back because it will always be something over the 3 month pay-back period. If they can gift it to you it will be way more helpful in the long run to your budget.

Nevermind31 · 26/12/2022 15:53

I just don’t understand how you have a spare £300 a month, but got behind on mortgage and bills. They are not going back down.
children “don’t go without” if they don’t have a present pile. They go without if your house is repossessed.
my grandparents have helped out my parents, my parents help me and my siblings out, and I will help out my children.

C1N1C · 26/12/2022 15:49

I would. The friendship is worth more to me than £1000 and I have good enough friends that if they wouldn't ask unless they actually needed it.

I guess it all depends on what you as a person can afford to lose and whether that is offset by the friendship.

HornyHandedSonOfTroll · 26/12/2022 15:44

I wouldn't, in the situation you describe. If any of my adult children prioritised Christmas presents over bills, I would not be very pleased and I'd think they should sort it out for themselves. I also don't see how you can think you can pay an additional £300 per month to your parents if you're struggling as it is.

Fishwifer · 26/12/2022 15:44

P.s . Op your scenario is why I have a blanket rule.

Long term a loan won't help you.

You need to get a grip of essential Vs discretion spending, a real budget based on actual spend, ensure you're on the best utility tariffs - basics of financial management. Throwing £1k is not helping long term.

antelopevalley · 26/12/2022 15:43

Yes I would.

Fishwifer · 26/12/2022 15:41

Nope.

When you mix money with friends and family, it leads nowhere good.

I am more than willing to invest time and effort into support In other forms (I'm the one who helps people navigate official forms, complaints and benefits stuff for friends, family, neighbours). I've helped many people sort budgets and claim entitlements and my financial background means I can do that fairly quickly without much effort on my part Vs what people can do alone.

I won't lend people money though. Full stop.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 26/12/2022 15:41

No.

BertieBotts · 26/12/2022 15:38

It doesn't hurt to ask them if they will lend it interest free and it won't damage your relationship. But I would look at this as a bit of a kick to start some more proactive financial planning. MoneySavingExpert has some brilliant resources on budgeting and cutting down costs. Have a look at their money makeover. It's all stuff you can do for free at home and you don't need to be a maths whiz.

I know costs have gone up for a lot of people, but being able to pay back 333 per month means you probably have quite a bit of wiggle room in your budget - you could use this to your advantage to prevent being in the same situation in future.

lostinthejungle22 · 26/12/2022 15:31

Depends who it is. I lent a very good friend money under a similar agreement, and never seen it back. To be fair, I knew I'll never get it back, and lent it anyway, as I wanted to help her, and if agreeing to the repayment plan made her feel better, then be it. I only lent an amount I could afford to lose. She said recently she's still planning to pay it back, it's been 10 years, so I doubt it..

Eilan50 · 26/12/2022 15:30

They're your parents OP. Just explain your situation and ask for the money. If they can't afford it they'll soon tell you. Most parents would want to try to help their adult children in this situation

Redebs · 26/12/2022 15:29

If one of my children needed £1000 and I had it, I would give, not lend.

But why are you asking us, OP? Have you asked your parents?
Our perceptions are going to be varied and not relevant to your situation. Some people won't want to lend, while others will hand it over with no expectation of getting it back.

I don't think it's ok to spend money you haven't got, on Christmas presents for your daughter, by the way. But it's done now so can't be helped. Maybe get a more realistic grip on your finances for the future, to save you from a lot of pain and stress. Things are going to get tougher for most of us.

NoSquirrels · 26/12/2022 15:25

This amount will basically get us back to square one and I’m able to pay them back

The trouble is, you can’t get ahead so that this won’t happen again if you have no safety net (an emergency fund) and you don’t prioritise properly - which is, essential bills first, non-essentials after.

Do your budget (properly, including saving up for next December - take what you spent this year and divide by 12), go through absolutely everything this way (dividing irregular bills like car MOT etc by 12) and only then offer a repayment plan if you absolutely must ask for £1,000.

Or call your mortgage provider and utilities provider and sort out the same repayment plan with them.

But start with the budget - a proper one.

HRTQueen · 26/12/2022 15:22

If I had the money and depends who it was

my friends and I often lend each other money to help get by

ACynicalDad · 26/12/2022 15:21

Only lend what you can afford not to get back. Suggest an interest free credit card or similar, if they really can pay that it won’t be a problem.

bestchristmasever · 26/12/2022 15:21

Yeah sorry but I if I couldn't get an understanding of how much you spent on non essentials I wouldn't lend you anything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread