Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Suicide because of Benefits Being Stopped

235 replies

StridTheKiller · 26/12/2022 13:58

Another casualty of our brutal benefits system. RIP.

www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/dad-who-took-life-days-28813953

OP posts:
YouOKHun · 26/12/2022 18:04

PurpleButterflyWings · 26/12/2022 15:08

Biscuit

Try being someone FIGHTING tooth and nail and having your disability and health condition questioned, and have a bunch of witless fuckers who have NO medical experience 'assessing' you and deciding if your disability is worthy enough of receiving state benefits.

OR having your jobseekers benefit STOPPED because you were 30 seconds late for your appointment, and are then expected to live on fresh air.

The TORY benefits system IS cruel and unjust, and you're fucking deluded if you claim otherwise. And don't bother responding to this post. I won't be talking to again on this thread. CBA with you.

@Dotjones Are you fucking serious?! Hmm

what @PurpleButterflyWings says.

When I was working in NHS primary care MH so many people had a constant battle to survive. Their mental health problems so often created by poverty and a system that viewed them as worthless.

just one example: I remember one young woman who had found her sister dead in bed one morning and in the ensuing horror missed an assessment appointment with the DWP. She moved temporarily to stay in her sister’s flat to help care for the sister’s young children and so missed a letter to her home; only responding to it a few hours later than the 24 hours they gave her. Her money was cut off and it took her around SIX MONTHS to reinstate her disability benefits. By the time I saw her she was desperate; grieving, depressed, undernourished and actively suicidal. It was shockingly callous and just one of many many examples I could give of people being sent into utter despair by a system’s poor administration, by unqualified assessors, by callous assumptions that people in their positions had put themselves in that position and deserved no mercy.

Unless you’ve seen first hand what people are put through you are not in a position to look up from the pages of the Daily Mail and announce our system isn’t brutal.

C4tastrophe · 26/12/2022 18:02

NewBootsAndRanty · 26/12/2022 17:35

How recently was that?
The benefits system 25 years ago was a bit different to say the least.

Being on disability benefits doesn't mean that you get a furnished apartment or a carer by any stretch.

Both died this year, so claimants from the ‘90s. I have no idea what benefits they were receiving, but they seemed, with regards to financial adequacy, to be doing ok.
They never mentioned financial hardship, though they obviously had ‘no money’.

Florenz · 26/12/2022 18:02

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 17:58

I do think that someone who is unable to work should have a lifestyle that is average. Right now, it is below the lowest paid worker. And this is literally punishing people with poverty for not being able to work. It’s disgusting imho.

When you save "average" what do you mean? Above the lowest paid 50% of workers but below the highest paid 50% of workers?

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 17:58

Florenz · 26/12/2022 17:55

I don't know how high people would want benefits to be. Should people who don't work (regardless of whether they are unable to work or not) expect to have the same lifestyle of someone who works? I would say not, but I know some will say otherwise, that we are a wealthy, civilised country etc etc.

I do think that someone who is unable to work should have a lifestyle that is average. Right now, it is below the lowest paid worker. And this is literally punishing people with poverty for not being able to work. It’s disgusting imho.

danceyourselfdizzy1 · 26/12/2022 17:57

Should people who don't work (regardless of whether they are unable to work or not) expect to have the same lifestyle of someone who works?

@FlorenzThe majority aren't expecting the same lifestyle, they just want to be able to survive!

Florenz · 26/12/2022 17:55

I don't know how high people would want benefits to be. Should people who don't work (regardless of whether they are unable to work or not) expect to have the same lifestyle of someone who works? I would say not, but I know some will say otherwise, that we are a wealthy, civilised country etc etc.

Sadless · 26/12/2022 17:54

I don't think you keep the money while in appeal and appeals take ages. The benefit system suits families with children because they get money for the child but as a single person on the £70 a week it's not possible to even live a normal life. I have two neighbours live separate but one doesn't speak to the other used to be good friends due to one getting full pip with mobility car and the other mustn't get the same. She said shes had to fight to get the money she gets while the other with the car didn't and hasn't got mobility issues to be walking her dogs around all the time and she tells everyone how she went to the assessment in a wheelchair but never seen her in one.

Sal

IndieK1d · 26/12/2022 17:49

Addicted2Kale · 26/12/2022 17:47

Disabled claiments, widowed single mothers and those made redundant to the side, the benefits system is not "brutal". It is generous. Far too much so. I'm sick of reading about people complaining their handouts are too low or "brutal". Try existing in the myriad of countries with no welfare state, then come back and complain about the system here.

And before the "most people on benefits are in low paid work" comments come in, and? I started off in low paid work and never claimed a penny. I made life decisions that ensured I always lived comfortably within my means. Now I'm very comfortable.

It's good there's a welfare state. But there needs to be perspective.

Try living on £77 a week and out of that you're paying 20% council tax.

£11 a day really isn't "generous". It's nearer £60 if you're under 25

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 17:48

Cheeseandlobster · 26/12/2022 17:46

Probably funded by Continuing Healthcare rather than benefits

Yes, and I hate saying this but pre-2010 disability benefits & social care was a different world compared to recent past & today.

Addicted2Kale · 26/12/2022 17:47

Disabled claiments, widowed single mothers and those made redundant to the side, the benefits system is not "brutal". It is generous. Far too much so. I'm sick of reading about people complaining their handouts are too low or "brutal". Try existing in the myriad of countries with no welfare state, then come back and complain about the system here.

And before the "most people on benefits are in low paid work" comments come in, and? I started off in low paid work and never claimed a penny. I made life decisions that ensured I always lived comfortably within my means. Now I'm very comfortable.

It's good there's a welfare state. But there needs to be perspective.

Cheeseandlobster · 26/12/2022 17:46

C4tastrophe · 26/12/2022 17:29

Probably over sharing, but both my younger brothers had illnesses that prevented them working, both after about the age of 25. Both lived off full benefits for over 25 years each, had carers, furnished apartments etc.
The benefits system is more than adequate in the UK.

Probably funded by Continuing Healthcare rather than benefits

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 17:46

Miss03852 · 26/12/2022 17:41

It definitely isn’t generous to disabled people with the Tory’s forcing people who can’t work to sign on. They’ve been criticised by the UN for the treatment of disabled people and them being denied benefits they need. It’s a disgrace. We are a first world country and compared to other wealthy countries we do not have a generous system.

Non goady but what do you mean forcing the disabled to sign on? As in, look for work?

Weepachu · 26/12/2022 17:45

Miss03852 · 26/12/2022 17:41

It definitely isn’t generous to disabled people with the Tory’s forcing people who can’t work to sign on. They’ve been criticised by the UN for the treatment of disabled people and them being denied benefits they need. It’s a disgrace. We are a first world country and compared to other wealthy countries we do not have a generous system.

But are we really a first world country after the demographic change of the last 25 years? So many more needy people claiming now. The ONS figures referenced by a pp are grim.

Miss03852 · 26/12/2022 17:41

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 14:14

Our benefits system is very generous compared to other countries. I’m not sure of the ins and outs of this sad case but the system isn’t ‘brutal’.

It definitely isn’t generous to disabled people with the Tory’s forcing people who can’t work to sign on. They’ve been criticised by the UN for the treatment of disabled people and them being denied benefits they need. It’s a disgrace. We are a first world country and compared to other wealthy countries we do not have a generous system.

danceyourselfdizzy1 · 26/12/2022 17:35

C4tastrophe · 26/12/2022 17:29

Probably over sharing, but both my younger brothers had illnesses that prevented them working, both after about the age of 25. Both lived off full benefits for over 25 years each, had carers, furnished apartments etc.
The benefits system is more than adequate in the UK.

Sorry but this is nothing more than anecdotal and not representative of the lives of so many living in dire poverty who are not able to cope on the present system.

NewBootsAndRanty · 26/12/2022 17:35

C4tastrophe · 26/12/2022 17:29

Probably over sharing, but both my younger brothers had illnesses that prevented them working, both after about the age of 25. Both lived off full benefits for over 25 years each, had carers, furnished apartments etc.
The benefits system is more than adequate in the UK.

How recently was that?
The benefits system 25 years ago was a bit different to say the least.

Being on disability benefits doesn't mean that you get a furnished apartment or a carer by any stretch.

urbansecond · 26/12/2022 17:34

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 14:14

Our benefits system is very generous compared to other countries. I’m not sure of the ins and outs of this sad case but the system isn’t ‘brutal’.

I've read enough to know that posters are correct about it being brutal. I would not like to be in a position to have to rely on benefits for any length of time. I can only imagine how difficult it must be.

FedUpWithEverything123 · 26/12/2022 17:33

@Dotjones & @Onnabugeisha for fuck's sake, disgraceful

urbansecond · 26/12/2022 17:30

Been watching The Duke on Christmas Day TV? @Dotjones A character there made exactly the same observation about the word hanging that you did.

Not appropriate on a thread like this.

Biscuit
C4tastrophe · 26/12/2022 17:29

Probably over sharing, but both my younger brothers had illnesses that prevented them working, both after about the age of 25. Both lived off full benefits for over 25 years each, had carers, furnished apartments etc.
The benefits system is more than adequate in the UK.

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 17:29

@Wenttoohighwantdown
Sorry for your loss 💐

Wenttoohighwantdown · 26/12/2022 17:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

My dad died in the same way the man in the article did, and I have a deeply unpleasant visceral reaction when someone says "hung" rather than "hanged" when talking about suicide. I can't explain it - other than "hung" feels inhumane and callous. (I don't even like typing it). So I agree with you, albeit maybe for different reasons.

And language around suicide is always important. I'm still getting over the idiotic term of "completed suicide". Thankfully few people use that now.

Getoff · 26/12/2022 17:23

What someone actually gets out of Universal Credit will also depend on the family they have to support.

Getoff · 26/12/2022 17:21

helford · 26/12/2022 15:56

France based on earning 20k euros over the previous 12 months, you will get 55 euros per day.
Germany 60% of previous salary up to 7k euros per month.

These are the two most similar economies in Europe to compare the UK too.

UK unemployment benefit is £78 per Week, it is ridiculous that the contribution element of benefits has been taken away in the UK (You get nothing if you have some savings)
The rent payments have been frozen for years and because we have a small council house sector, rent payments go straight to a private landlord.

My question would be "what have we done with the money we have not paid out"

Do France and Germany have the equivalent of housing benefit that is added on top of unemployment benefit? If not, then you're using facts in a very misleading way.

Echobelly · 26/12/2022 17:21

The system is definitely brutal. A mentally unwell friend was being investigated because for a very brief period she had more in savings than you're 'allowed' to have and receive benefits. She was totally terrified she'd have to pay back money and/or lose her benefits; she had no updates on the investigation and was in a state of appalling anxiety for nearly a year. Only when she was on a call with a rare helpful and supportive DWP person about something else, was he kind enough to look into it, and told her the files said it was closed months ago with no further action. They never bothered to tell her, someone on record as being mentally unwell. She absolutelyvcould have killed herself just from the lack of that information.

Swipe left for the next trending thread