Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Suicide because of Benefits Being Stopped

235 replies

StridTheKiller · 26/12/2022 13:58

Another casualty of our brutal benefits system. RIP.

www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/dad-who-took-life-days-28813953

OP posts:
Nospringchix · 26/12/2022 19:05

IndieK1d · 26/12/2022 17:49

Try living on £77 a week and out of that you're paying 20% council tax.

£11 a day really isn't "generous". It's nearer £60 if you're under 25

This. Plus making a quite significant payment out of said £77 towards rent since housing benefit rates have not anywhere near kept up with private rents. People are therefore relying on food banks as they have no money left after bills , rent and council tax.

OhmygodDont · 26/12/2022 19:05

A lot of disabled people can work. As this man was looking to be declared too just maybe not the job he wanted or originally had. Not that many people are actually so disabled to an extent they cannot work at all.

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 19:02

Katypp · 26/12/2022 18:59

So anyone not on benefits is either cooking ghe books or earning £100k plus. OK.

There’s definitely a school of thought on MN that anyone who is NT and not on benefits has somehow won the lottery of life and has much fewer struggles. Which simply isn’t true, it drives me nuts tbh.

SueVineer · 26/12/2022 19:00

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 14:14

Our benefits system is very generous compared to other countries. I’m not sure of the ins and outs of this sad case but the system isn’t ‘brutal’.

Yes true. The article indicates that the man had severe depression which would have likely been a major cause of suicide. Very sad

Katypp · 26/12/2022 18:59

PurpleButterflyWings · 26/12/2022 15:30

This. ^ It's a myth that benefits are large and generous, and as you say, 100s of 1000s of people who had to apply and live on them for 6 months (or more) had a massive shock.

As did those who had their own business/were self employed and had cooked the books for a number of years (and got £70K a year but only declared £24K a year to the taxman - as the rest was cash in hand/hidden.) They were knocked sideways when they 'only' got 80% of the £2K a month they declared to the government!

Yeah, being on low pay/benefits is a wake up call for those who have been raking in £80K to £95K a year or more net pay. These are the type who cry into their pillow because their DH's job changes and his salary drops from £90K to £65K and they have to give up the cleaner, or cancel the installation of the orangery.

Utterly UTTERLY clueless some people. I remember a woman I met once whose DH was on £135K, and he bought her a Mercedes Benz for her 40th birthday, saying she wouldn't be able to cope if he had bought her a 10 year old Astra like we had, and would be embarrassed to be seen in it. And was knocked sideways when someone else we were talking to said her DH brings home £1200 a month. How do you SURVIVE she said. My DH brings twice that much home a week. Shock

Farcical.

So anyone not on benefits is either cooking ghe books or earning £100k plus. OK.

MarshaBradyo · 26/12/2022 18:56

The U.K. has a big welfare bill (re tax v benefits) so if you up how much is paid or have more relying on it it’s going to become too onerous

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 18:56

I hate it when someone drops a post and never comes back. It's borderline trolling.

Despite the headlines the man suffered anxiety and depression for over 10 years. He had COPD and after 5 yrs of payments they confirmed whilst he couldn't do painting and decorating he previously did, he was fit for other forms of work.

They continued paying him fully up until his death through the appeal.

The headline is a smokescreen for what was actually a fair process. Whether you agree with the amount of benefit being paid or not, it's likely he actually could have worked and got paid equivalent of £70 a week.

MEFibroHell · 26/12/2022 18:53

Dreamsoffreedomjoyandpeace · 26/12/2022 18:19

It’s pretty crap for those of us with a hidden disability. Can’t work (full time or at all) but entitled to nothing because we don’t get enough points.

Dreams is fit for work because she can walk her dog, wash herself, drive etc. whatever it is that you can actually do is used against you. It doesn’t matter how many negatives you give, one positive and you’ve ruined your chances of receiving anything. Go to the assessment looking human and you don’t stand a chance.

Yep. I know what all my medication is for and I didn’t “sound” like I was in pain during my telephone interrogation therefore I do not qualify for help.

The fact that I’m only able to shower around 4 days a week because I often don’t have the energy, and last month didn’t eat an actual meal for 17 days, because I was unable to stand and prepare one, is apparently neither here nor there.

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 18:53

TreadLight · 26/12/2022 18:38

Sorry, should have said £254.20 per week, not per month.

I’m not sure that’s correct, unless it includes some sort of housing benefit which isn’t going to benefit you at all. It’s going to your landlord.

TreadLight · 26/12/2022 18:48

helford · 26/12/2022 18:40

Housing costs?

Apparently includes £155.77 per week for housing costs. Take this out and, for a single person, it remains a generous safety net but a difficult lifestyle choice.

notyourmam · 26/12/2022 18:47

Reugny · 26/12/2022 15:15

Says someone who has never lived on them.

Loads of people got a shock during Covid when they had to apply and live on them.

Me! I had that shock! I was raised in a Conservative household and genuinely believed nearly everyone on benefits was at fault and therefore undeserving of much help. And that, because our welfare spendings are relatively high, that meant we had a generous benefits system for the individual, as @Cuppasoupmonster believes.

Lord no. When I got Long Covid, I suddenly found myself with £95 a week in SSP to live on. That was it. Try going from a healthy salary to just over £400 a month to live on overnight, to cover everything, while your bills remain the same. The state expected me to live on bread and beans while seriously ill and just shrugged their shoulders. Then, after the 28 week SSP allowance ran out, I went onto ESA instead - at £324 a month. Great bloody fun that was. The financial stress absolutely worsened my illness, and has had continued impacts.

Eventually, thank god, I got assessed as having LCWRA (i.e, I'm deemed long term unfit to work), which upped my allowance to £689 a month. But that was on the strength of now being so disabled I can't walk more than 50m with any reliability. The criteria to meet eligibility for the higher rate I'm on are so extraordinarily stringent that few meet them, and it does not catch everyone who is too ill to work, who are suddenly thrown into poverty living a mean little existence on £324 a month, with no ability to improve their circumstances.

PIP is even worse. It's literally designed to deny as many people as possible, and the assessors set out to do so.

I can't begin to describe just how inhumane our benefits system is towards the long term ill. It's been utterly demoralising having to fight DWP for scraps, while already chronically exhausted.

You really do feel like you're thrown on the scrap heap if you lose your ability to work. You go from being a person who is seen worthy actual respect to someone unworthy of any quality of life. Subhuman almost, or certainly a second tier. We're made to feel like we're bludging off other people's taxes. Well, no - those were my taxes. This is what we pay in for. Life throws a curveball sometimes, and it can happen to any of us. It's not my bloody fault a pandemic happened, and someone sneezed in Asda.

Part of me wishes everyone with these beliefs had their own wake up call like this, just for a few months (cruel though it may be). Our society would sure as heck be better for it afterwards.

Thedogscollar · 26/12/2022 18:46

MarshaBradyo · 26/12/2022 16:38

A recent ONS stat stood out to me - more receive benefits than pay tax. It’s welfare heavy

Wells that's as maybe but many on benefits are in work and pay tax!

Bestcatmum · 26/12/2022 18:45

Several of my patients have killed themselves because their benefits were stopped or they had to really fight for disability benefits.
They were just too ill to fight anymore and killed themselves, usually overdose but one went off Beachy Head, I used to live there.
We did our utmost to help writing letters and reports but these were largely ignored.
I won't be voting Tory anytime soon.

DysonSpheres · 26/12/2022 18:43

It is cruel and brutal. It adds further stress to those already disadvantaged in life. Further mental anguish to those already suffering with severely compromised mental health.

I was once sanctioned. I was sanctioned for not turning up due to having an allergy induced asthma attack. I couldn't afford a taxi and couldn't walk up the stairs in my house let alone to the bus stop. I called, and called, and called the job centre to explain and didn't get through to anyone until close of day. Gave my name, NI number, begged for note to be added to the system.

I was still immediately sanctioned. I learned later that I was sanctioned the same day, within hours of me not turning up and no one even bothered to call or send me a letter.

When I finally got into the job centre, I was spoken to like dirt by a girl young enough to be my own daughter who told me in an imperious tone that I had brought it on myself and wasn't going to get any money that day and 'I knew the rules' given a number to call.

I cried all the way home. I have just over 8 quid in my pocket.

I spent 7 days calling department after department and person after person trying to get my benefits reinstated. I finally gave up. I didn't have the mental strength to do anymore and my self-esteem was in the toilet. I felt strong suicide ideation.

I have gone childhood sexual abuse, and rape. Ok, so what. Many have it worse. But now I was getting the message that I was worthless as a human being, again. Worthless as a mother to boot.

I relied on my overdraft which was £200 at the time. Barclays wanted to remove it, as I was in it all the time and I phoned and begged them to keep it installed. They had more compassion than the JC did. They kept it installed. Thankfully my rent was kept going. I looked after my two children on the £200. I was very grateful and remain grateful for every penny. I preferred that to the indignity of dealing with the JC.

Don't get me started on disability Pip. If you think it's reasonable to be asked whether you have ever called an ambulance to prove your mental health is bad, then I honestly don't know what to say. Those are the sorts of questions you get.
There are stories everyday of people getting turned down because they were carrying a cup of tea in a flask (so you can handle money, a kettle, are mentally cognizant enough to ask for a cuppa, you're well!!) walked across the car park too quickly, got up from a chair too fast or because they made eye contact with the assessor when depressed. Some of these people have strokes, parkinsons, multiple-sclerosis, cancer, or chronic fatigue/M.E. (god help you with that as you don't look unwell)

I love this country and we are blessed to have a safety net, yes. Very, very blessed. But it is harsh and I can see why suicides happen. I think it has to be under-reported, actually.

NewBootsAndRanty · 26/12/2022 18:41

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 18:34

You do know the temporary increase of £20/week was not given to those on legacy disability benefits of ESA? Or those disabled already on UC prior to the uplift?

So, literally disabled got less than the unemployed….

The court case appeal for legacy claimants was heard at the beginning of this month - hopefully should get a decision in the next few months

www.disabilitynewsservice.com/court-hears-universal-credit-20-uplift-appeal-as-activists-vow-to-fight-back/

helford · 26/12/2022 18:40

TreadLight · 26/12/2022 18:38

Sorry, should have said £254.20 per week, not per month.

Housing costs?

IndieK1d · 26/12/2022 18:40

TreadLight · 26/12/2022 18:35

I have to get up at 6am and work most of my waking hours to earn money to survive. Filling in forms every few years is more than an acceptable requirement to get thousands of pounds of free money.

It's not just filling in forms though. Most people are "invited" for an assessment to determine whether they can work where most of your evidence is ignored.

You can have my "free" money, blue badge, etc and I'll have your job. In return, you're at the hospital several times a year constantly having tests done because no one can decide on a proper diagnosis. Most of those tests will have to be repeated because it's difficult to get an accurate reading. Some of those tests will be painful. Oh and you can't drive. Sounds fair?

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 18:40

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 18:36

And there’s the nasty steak of ableism.

Why is it ableism? I’m disabled but work (physically, lifelong and quite severely in terms of pain/treatments/management). Although whether I’ll be able to keep doing so for years is doubtful. I would expect to have to prove my disability if I needed out of work benefits.

Florenz · 26/12/2022 18:40

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 18:36

And there’s the nasty steak of ableism.

There's nothing nasty about it, it's the simple truth. Filling in some forms every year is a piece of piss compared to working 40 hours a week in a physically or mentally taxing job in order to earn a living.

helford · 26/12/2022 18:39

Florenz · 26/12/2022 18:31

Lockdown was always going to end. Wars end. The amount paid out in benefits has only ever increased since the start of the welfare payment. Look at all the furore over the temporary increased in benefits being reduced once lockdown ended.

Benefits have had to increase because wages are so low & we have done away with Council Housing so now we pay billions into the private sector instead, with no chance the tenant will be able to save and better themselves. :(

TreadLight · 26/12/2022 18:38

NewBootsAndRanty · 26/12/2022 18:36

Generous as long as you don't need to eat or pay bills.

Sorry, should have said £254.20 per week, not per month.

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 18:36

TreadLight · 26/12/2022 18:35

I have to get up at 6am and work most of my waking hours to earn money to survive. Filling in forms every few years is more than an acceptable requirement to get thousands of pounds of free money.

And there’s the nasty steak of ableism.

NewBootsAndRanty · 26/12/2022 18:36

TreadLight · 26/12/2022 18:31

I know people have talked about "£77 per week" so I have put my details into entitledto.com. Not working, no children, no disabilities, no caring responsibilities. 44 years old living in Buckinghamshire.

Apparently if I can work but don't work I am entitled to £254.20 per month which as a safety net seems very generous. As a lifestyle choice; less so.

Generous as long as you don't need to eat or pay bills.

TreadLight · 26/12/2022 18:35

IndieK1d · 26/12/2022 18:28

Is it reasonable to have to fill out forms every few years? Many of us live with incurable and permanent health conditions. We're not going to suddenly wake up and be cured.

I have to get up at 6am and work most of my waking hours to earn money to survive. Filling in forms every few years is more than an acceptable requirement to get thousands of pounds of free money.

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 18:34

Florenz · 26/12/2022 18:31

Lockdown was always going to end. Wars end. The amount paid out in benefits has only ever increased since the start of the welfare payment. Look at all the furore over the temporary increased in benefits being reduced once lockdown ended.

You do know the temporary increase of £20/week was not given to those on legacy disability benefits of ESA? Or those disabled already on UC prior to the uplift?

So, literally disabled got less than the unemployed….