Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Suicide because of Benefits Being Stopped

235 replies

StridTheKiller · 26/12/2022 13:58

Another casualty of our brutal benefits system. RIP.

www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/dad-who-took-life-days-28813953

OP posts:
Dovahh · 26/12/2022 23:02

Livelovebehappy · 26/12/2022 23:00

Your previous post wasn’t saying you were having to decide whether to heat your home or put food on the table though - you were indicating you were having to tweak your outgoings to afford holidays and birthdays….

Thankfully I don't have to make that choice I do adjust my finances accordingly, but there is people out there who can't make that choice .

Livelovebehappy · 26/12/2022 23:00

Dovahh · 26/12/2022 22:49

He's really not able too however he has no choice , they are both at school thankfully , I work 12 hour shifts in social care and then take over when I'm home & on my days off .
I'm not saying that it should be a bed of roses for people on benefits but it should also never be a choice of whether to heat your house or put food on the table as that is a reality for many people .

Your previous post wasn’t saying you were having to decide whether to heat your home or put food on the table though - you were indicating you were having to tweak your outgoings to afford holidays and birthdays….

Whatwhat123 · 26/12/2022 22:59

These threads always upset me. It may be true that some people on disability benefit could do some form of work, the problem is, is that there are few jobs that will be accommodating.
If you’ve been long-term unemployed due to illness, try finding an entry level job that will be flexible and understanding of your health needs, or give you mental health support. I’ve tried and just been met with people that just don’t get it, I’ve been mocked and shouted at. I’m not confident and I have poor social skills. Feels like there’s no place in society for people like me.

Dovahh · 26/12/2022 22:59

Livelovebehappy · 26/12/2022 22:26

Benefits were never meant to cover holidays and birthday presents. Those are ‘wants’ and not ‘needs’. Sad you can’t afford a holiday, but many people working full time with no access to benefits can’t afford holidays either.

Where in my post did I state benefits were to pay for holidays or birthday presents ?????
I adjust my budget to my best abilities to cover these things so I don't expect benefits to cover this . The access I get is help towards my rent however the full amount isn't paid I still pay towards this from my wage .
I would never begrudge anybody that relies solely on benefits from buying birthday presents , Christmas presents or any kind of holiday if that's what they have chosen to spend their money on , after all MP's sit in parliament daily sleeping , having lunch paid for and have their expenses paid for all by the benefit system of the taxpayer but nobody bats an eyelid about this. People are more outraged about toothless Glenda and her 6 kids that live in a council house and rely on benefits .

Dovahh · 26/12/2022 22:49

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 22:33

@Dovahh I’m just curious/nosy but how is your husband able to care for 2 children, one with SEN, but is too unwell to work? It seems like a lot of pressure on you.

Both DH and I work full time and haven’t had a holiday since 2018 and that was to Scotland. It isn’t a bed of roses for working people so naturally they can’t make benefits ‘better’ than that.

He's really not able too however he has no choice , they are both at school thankfully , I work 12 hour shifts in social care and then take over when I'm home & on my days off .
I'm not saying that it should be a bed of roses for people on benefits but it should also never be a choice of whether to heat your house or put food on the table as that is a reality for many people .

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 22:44

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 22:42

@Onnabugeisha

The rate of Fraud overpayments was 3.0%, which is a slight increase from 2.9% in FYE 2021. The monetary value of Fraud overpayments increased from £6.2bn to £6.5bn.
The rate of Claimant Error overpayments was 0.7%, a small increase from 0.6% in FYE 2021 and the monetary value of Claimant Error overpayments increased from £1.3bn to £1.5bn.
The rate of Official Error overpayments was 0.3%, a small decrease from 0.4% in FYE 2021 and the monetary value of Official Error overpayments decreased from £0.8bn to £0.7bn.

Thank you. That’s a huge increase in fraud. Did covid coincide with the rates going up?

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 22:42

@Onnabugeisha

The rate of Fraud overpayments was 3.0%, which is a slight increase from 2.9% in FYE 2021. The monetary value of Fraud overpayments increased from £6.2bn to £6.5bn.
The rate of Claimant Error overpayments was 0.7%, a small increase from 0.6% in FYE 2021 and the monetary value of Claimant Error overpayments increased from £1.3bn to £1.5bn.
The rate of Official Error overpayments was 0.3%, a small decrease from 0.4% in FYE 2021 and the monetary value of Official Error overpayments decreased from £0.8bn to £0.7bn.

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 22:33

@Dovahh I’m just curious/nosy but how is your husband able to care for 2 children, one with SEN, but is too unwell to work? It seems like a lot of pressure on you.

Both DH and I work full time and haven’t had a holiday since 2018 and that was to Scotland. It isn’t a bed of roses for working people so naturally they can’t make benefits ‘better’ than that.

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 22:32

XenoBitch · 26/12/2022 22:24

Disabled on UC did get the uplift. The uplift was applied to the basic amount that every on UC gets. I am in the LCWRA group and got it.

Sorry, I was misinformed then on the UC angle. I know those on ESA did not get it though.

Spectre8 · 26/12/2022 22:31

Livelovebehappy · 26/12/2022 22:26

Benefits were never meant to cover holidays and birthday presents. Those are ‘wants’ and not ‘needs’. Sad you can’t afford a holiday, but many people working full time with no access to benefits can’t afford holidays either.

I agree, the issue is may people don't agree with that view.

However its what even people working full time have to forgo too if their earnings are not enough to cover anything more than rent/mortgage, basic bills, travel for work and food.

Livelovebehappy · 26/12/2022 22:26

Dovahh · 26/12/2022 19:06

Our benefits system is an absolute disgrace , yes it does assist people but in actual fact it's not the great help that the dwp will have you believe .
The fact that carers allowance is £69.70 per week to care for loved ones with disabilities is completely unacceptable , but to then have this classed as an income to be taxed on tells you everything that is wrong with the benefits system .
Tv shows like benefits Britain are also picking the worst examples of people on benefits it's a great piece of Tory propaganda.

I work full time my husband is unable to work due to illness so stays home taking care of our 2 children one of which has additional needs .
We do get help from universal credit with our rent but not much more on top , money is tight we make it work but it's not easy it's a lot of adjusting the budget each month to accommodate for things like holidays , birthdays etc

Benefits were never meant to cover holidays and birthday presents. Those are ‘wants’ and not ‘needs’. Sad you can’t afford a holiday, but many people working full time with no access to benefits can’t afford holidays either.

XenoBitch · 26/12/2022 22:24

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 18:34

You do know the temporary increase of £20/week was not given to those on legacy disability benefits of ESA? Or those disabled already on UC prior to the uplift?

So, literally disabled got less than the unemployed….

Disabled on UC did get the uplift. The uplift was applied to the basic amount that every on UC gets. I am in the LCWRA group and got it.

Puppamumma · 26/12/2022 22:18

Notallroses · 26/12/2022 18:22

Name change for obvious reasons.

A year ago I made an enormous mistake. I left my job through ill health and went to tribunal and claimed Universal Credit. After claiming benefits I received a payout through employment tribunal, got holiday pay returned and was subsequently awarded backdated PIP. I thought I was fine because I thought you were allowed up to £16,000 and I only had £13,000. What I didn't realise was that you can have up to £16,000 but anything over £6,000 counts as bringing in an income regardless if it does or not, and benefits are reduced accordingly.

I carried on thinking I was within the threshold and used the excess money to pay off debts I had been drowning in since my mother died a decade ago. Paying these debts flagged up on my credit file and the next thing I knew my benefits were stopped and I was being investigated for fraud and had to hand over all of my financial details which I willingly did as I genuinely didn't think I had done anything wrong at that point. The most I ever had was £13,000 but the decision maker decided I had over £20,000, had never been entitled to any benefit and owed them £25,400.

I was terrified. I thought I was going to prison and would get a criminal record. In shock because I knew I had never possessed over £20,000 I'm my life, I insisted on a mandatory reconsideration. The new decision maker found that I had only ever had £13,000, was always entitled to a reduced amount of benefit and because I used the money to repay debts which I had been struggling with for years I was found not to have deprived myself of capital. And the overpayment? £733.00! less than one month's money!

This happened over Christmas 2021 and I didn't get the final outcome until the spring. I went through months of hell, ended up feeling suicidal because I thought I was going to prison and my mental health suffered. The Jobcentre sent the police to my door to do a welfare check because they were concerned I may harm myself as a result. And all along the original decision maker had made a huge mistake. I genuinely didn't realize my own original mistake and believed I was allowed more in savings. The case was found in my favour and I was exonerated. It is a bit of a jump from £733.00 to £25,400. The case was closed and I was told to repay £10 per month. I've never had a formal apology and was too weary and Ill from the experience to complain about the original decision maker. I was just thankful it had been properly sorted out.

The DWP really do make huge mistakes sometimes. My mistake of course was not properly reading and understanding the rules, but their sums were like a fairy tale which I was able to prove was wrong. Had I not insisted on a mandatory reconsideration my experience could have ended very differently.

Oh you poor love .I hope your managing okay now. Nobody understands how cruel the benefits system is till their in it. I'm anorexic and have had assessment where it's been nothing but lies but I'm too ill to face going through appeal because I had my relative dying of cancer. I honestly don't know how the DWP can live with how they treat people

Puppamumma · 26/12/2022 22:09

Florenz · 26/12/2022 18:08

I've got little to no sympathy to people who miss or are late for DWP appointments. It's literally the only thing they have to do and their money is dependent on it. Get an early bus. Set an alarm on the phone. Make it your utmost priority to be there on time. People with jobs have to be on time every day.

Bus in our area is supposed to be every 11 minutes. I waited 45 minutes for bus few days ago do you really think people deserve to have their benefits cut because of things outside of their control ?. I wish everyone who complains about the generous system loses their job and gets a big wake up call to the reality of being ill or desperate to working

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 22:09

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 21:30

Because most fraud isn't the entire claim itself, but the conditions, evidence and durations surrounding a claim which lead to overpayments.

We're not talking thousands of people faking it, but rather thousands of people claiming when they shouldn't have. Misalignment with timing of clinical records and continued payments, or the time at which fraud is suspected to stopping a claim is months and months of payments. Sometimes years.

In the stats I think most benefit fraud was due to UC claimants having undeclared partners?(so the “virtuous” working benefits claimants not the “scrounging” nonworking disabled) And the 4% of “error and fraud” was mostly error, not fraud?

Going to see if I can find the break out again to post.

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 21:30

Florenz · 26/12/2022 21:07

The government has no idea of the level of fraud, how could they? If they knew who was claiming fraudulently they could stop their claim and charge them with benefit fraud. Any figures are just estimates.

Because most fraud isn't the entire claim itself, but the conditions, evidence and durations surrounding a claim which lead to overpayments.

We're not talking thousands of people faking it, but rather thousands of people claiming when they shouldn't have. Misalignment with timing of clinical records and continued payments, or the time at which fraud is suspected to stopping a claim is months and months of payments. Sometimes years.

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 21:26

Funnywonder · 26/12/2022 21:07

It seems that 4% of welfare expenditure in 21/22 was 'fraud and error'.

Unfortunately, the government does not break down the 'fraud and error' component of their statistics, so how is it possible to know what is fraud and what is an overpayment?

They do if you read the detail of the reports.

Funnywonder · 26/12/2022 21:07

It seems that 4% of welfare expenditure in 21/22 was 'fraud and error'.

Unfortunately, the government does not break down the 'fraud and error' component of their statistics, so how is it possible to know what is fraud and what is an overpayment?

Florenz · 26/12/2022 21:07

The government has no idea of the level of fraud, how could they? If they knew who was claiming fraudulently they could stop their claim and charge them with benefit fraud. Any figures are just estimates.

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 20:44

Funnywonder · 26/12/2022 20:36

@YoBeaches I would be very interested in a link or some sort of direction to your evidence. Hint - not 'my cousin's friend's budgie says that Kev from down the road is taking cash in hand ...'

It's readily available on the governments website as they are obliged to report.

Fraud for 2021 was up to 3.0% or £6.5bn.

Equally underpayments are made yearly due to admin errors

It's a shambles.

hay5689 · 26/12/2022 20:44

Gilead · 26/12/2022 19:56

There are very few fraudulent claims. It’s hard to do these days. It runs at about 0.04% but that includes dwp error too.

That's the percentage that get caught I take it? I'm not proud to admit it but I claimed fraudulently for years and got away with it quite easily. It's extremely common and very easy to do. I have zero excuses because it wasn't because I was hard up, I was just greedy and did it because I could. I know so many people playing the system and winning at it I'd be very surprised if the figures are that low.

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 20:39

Cuppasoupmonster · 26/12/2022 20:12

If people were paid proper wages for genuine work (including care work in the family) then the number of people claiming would reduce

What should be the new ‘minimum wage’ or living wage, in your opinion? Genuinely wondering

I don't know as there is a lot of data required to reach reasonable and variable conclusions.

But £1300 take home for an average month with current inflation isn't sustainable in many parts of the UK with high population. And many don't work full time hours because the impact to other benefits isn't worth it.

The system does need an overhaul. The DWP itself is outdated and expensive to operate with no investment over the years.

People who can work should, and be fairly rewarded. People who can't work should be catered for to a good standard. People who take the piss should be identified and penalised. Our system doesn't do well in achieving those three things.

C4tastrophe · 26/12/2022 20:37

One answer could be spin off the unemployment benefits to a private company, make the payment transparent ( reduce NI accordingly) and let them run it, like in Switzerland.

Funnywonder · 26/12/2022 20:36

@YoBeaches I would be very interested in a link or some sort of direction to your evidence. Hint - not 'my cousin's friend's budgie says that Kev from down the road is taking cash in hand ...'

IndieK1d · 26/12/2022 20:31

YoBeaches · 26/12/2022 20:28

Yes.

Source then?

Swipe left for the next trending thread