Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Suicide because of Benefits Being Stopped

235 replies

StridTheKiller · 26/12/2022 13:58

Another casualty of our brutal benefits system. RIP.

www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/dad-who-took-life-days-28813953

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ToWhitToWhoo · 30/12/2022 11:48

As I understand, most benefit fraud does not involve faking or exaggerating a disability, but failing to declare income: either claiming unemployment benefit while in fact earning from an undeclared job, or failing to report household income from a partner.

ToWhitToWhoo · 29/12/2022 12:50

Cuppasoupmonster · 27/12/2022 00:03

But, kindly, employers want (and need to) make money, and we work for that money. They’re not benevolent organisations, they have to make a profit and will best achieve this by employing people who can get on with the job with the minimum of hand holding. We’re all adults and many NT, healthy, employed people struggle through the day at times but ultimately do what needs to be done. We’re all adults.

Well, you can't have it both ways. If employers should only take 'people who can get on with the job with the minimum of hand holding', then the others need to be given benefits to survive.

Personally, I think that more disabled people could work with relatively minor adjustments, especially in these days of technology; but it's not going to happen if employers are unable or unwilling to make any adjustments. And then the disabled people need to be helped by other means- unless you think disability is a crime to be punished, perhaps with the death penalty,

There used to be sheltered workshops for people with disabilities who could not be easily employed in the open market; but most of these were abolished under the Cameron government.

IndieK1d · 29/12/2022 12:24

palygold · 29/12/2022 12:22

Doesn't PIP help in other ways than just the monetary value? Might that be why people apply if they don't need the money?

I may be talking rubbish as I have no idea. It's from a half remembered old conversation with someone who applied and was awarded a tiny amount of money.

Yes it does. You can depending on the award get things like a blue badge, disabled persons Railcard, travel pass, etc.

palygold · 29/12/2022 12:22

Doesn't PIP help in other ways than just the monetary value? Might that be why people apply if they don't need the money?

I may be talking rubbish as I have no idea. It's from a half remembered old conversation with someone who applied and was awarded a tiny amount of money.

usernamealreadytaken · 29/12/2022 11:50

@JoyBeorge
"PIP is not mens tested so your income has no bearing."

This is part of the problem. @TreadLight said they don't need the money because they manage on their decent wage, but your attitude is "well, claim it anyway". Have you never heard of personal responsibility? In the very wonderful words of Jeff Goldblum in Jurassic Park; "... so preoccupied with whether they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should.”.

I bloody hate this entitlement attitude, and it means there’s less money for those who actually need it, as those who don’t need it get a nice little extra bonus. We tried to do the right thing re CB when our household income passed the threshold for the taper and stopped claiming because we didn’t NEED the money, however, with hindsight, I wish we’d carried on claiming our ENTITLEMENT so we could have give the kids more.

JoyBeorge · 29/12/2022 11:29

TreadLight · 28/12/2022 19:09

I'm feeding and housing four people with my wage, and pay the full cost for my car out of post tax income.

I only have the one disabled child and I have a letter from a consultant stating I am disabled, but I don't claim because, earning £60k, I don't need to and the money is better given to those who need it.

PIP is not mens tested so your income has no bearing.

Katypp · 29/12/2022 11:09

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 18:53

I’m not sure that’s correct, unless it includes some sort of housing benefit which isn’t going to benefit you at all. It’s going to your landlord.

I'm not sure how twisting the facts to this degree help if you're trying to have a, sensible discussion really. Of course housing element is a benefit to the claimant - otherwise they would have nowhere to live. Of course it goes to the landlord - they are providing somewhere to live.
Are you suggesting that money spent on food is not a benefit either, because it goes to Tesco?
How silly. There are some good points made on this thread but statements like this just give ammunition to people who (like me) think the benefits system could do with improving but is largely OK.

Gilead · 28/12/2022 22:12

The Car is not free.Motability is a car lease scheme. You pay the mobility part of your PIP to motability and in return you lease a car from them.

TreadLight · 28/12/2022 19:09

I'm feeding and housing four people with my wage, and pay the full cost for my car out of post tax income.

I only have the one disabled child and I have a letter from a consultant stating I am disabled, but I don't claim because, earning £60k, I don't need to and the money is better given to those who need it.

IndieK1d · 28/12/2022 19:01

TreadLight · 27/12/2022 22:36

@Lilyhop , for comparison, that is about the same as me earning £60k, after all the tax and NI is deducted, and without the free car. It's essentially a lower middle class income, and you are right. It is more than enough to live a comfortable life.

And I have to fill in a ridiculous tax return each year to make sure I am contributing an appropriate amount.

The car isn't free. Many people have to pay deposits which they don't get back. You're only feeding one person. Lilyhop is feeding and housing more including at least one disabled child. Many disabled people find that PIP / DLA doesn't cover their extra costs

notyourmam · 28/12/2022 18:41

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 27/12/2022 23:15

So being on benefits and having to live or rather just about exist on a pittence isn't quite the lark that you anticipated it to be, then. Funnily enough I didn't think it would be.
At least you're being honest about it though.

Well, unless you bother to look into the sums (which most people not reliant on benefits don't have any particular reason to do) you do tend to buy into the rhetoric you're fed over and over. I.e, the benefits system is overly generous and sickness benefits are a doddle to claim. How many threads crop up on here with people complaining about their cousin receiving more in benefits for not working than they do working full time at a minimum wage job?

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 28/12/2022 08:58

Zebedee55 · 28/12/2022 08:32

When I was at the age of claiming ESA, in the support Group, I had various minor strokes, and a couple of bigger ones.

They left me semi/fully paralysed for days and weeks - totally flat physically.

Perhaps I should have seen if I could have found a job as a draft excluder? 🙄

I have worked for the DWP, I have (afterwards) done voluntary stuff with welfare benefits, and I (and DH), are now permanently disabled - thankfully now on pensions and not ESA.

I can see all sides of the argument, and, trust me, as far as disability is concerned, it can be brutal.😗

(Maybe i could get a job as a draft excluder)

Or As that was joke that Kevin Bridges said. What do you mean you cant work because you're paralyzed from the neck down. There's a farmer down the road looking for a Scarecrow.

Zebedee55 · 28/12/2022 08:32

OhmygodDont · 26/12/2022 19:05

A lot of disabled people can work. As this man was looking to be declared too just maybe not the job he wanted or originally had. Not that many people are actually so disabled to an extent they cannot work at all.

When I was at the age of claiming ESA, in the support Group, I had various minor strokes, and a couple of bigger ones.

They left me semi/fully paralysed for days and weeks - totally flat physically.

Perhaps I should have seen if I could have found a job as a draft excluder? 🙄

I have worked for the DWP, I have (afterwards) done voluntary stuff with welfare benefits, and I (and DH), are now permanently disabled - thankfully now on pensions and not ESA.

I can see all sides of the argument, and, trust me, as far as disability is concerned, it can be brutal.😗

Lilyhop · 28/12/2022 01:22

TreadLight · 27/12/2022 22:36

@Lilyhop , for comparison, that is about the same as me earning £60k, after all the tax and NI is deducted, and without the free car. It's essentially a lower middle class income, and you are right. It is more than enough to live a comfortable life.

And I have to fill in a ridiculous tax return each year to make sure I am contributing an appropriate amount.

yes, that’s exactly how I see it as well. But I know that it is not the same as say a single disabled adult, as they seem to barely get enough to scrape by.
when my son is 18, he will have the option of going into a residential care setting. He is 14 at the moment, but I’ve already been asked a few times what our plans are for when he is 18, as waiting lists for suitable places can be long. I find it hard to think that far ahead, and think it’s more likely he will be 21 when I make that decision. Once he leaves his school setting at 19, I can’t imagine I would be able to provide a good quality life for him, or for me, and some of the residential settings might be the best for him. As an adult, his DLA is then his, and he will be receiving the benefits and I will go back into full time work (which I know will be hard after so long out of work.) I honestly wish I was at work most
of the time. I have a degree that I was not ever able to actually get use out of. I will be 40 when he’s 18 so have a lot of years ahead of me to work. He has the mental age of a baby, and is 24 hour complex care. Also spends a lot of time in and out of hospital. But the one thing I haven’t had to worry about is money, so for that I am very very grateful.

MichaelFabricantWig · 27/12/2022 23:18

Poor man

so young

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 27/12/2022 23:15

notyourmam · 26/12/2022 18:47

Me! I had that shock! I was raised in a Conservative household and genuinely believed nearly everyone on benefits was at fault and therefore undeserving of much help. And that, because our welfare spendings are relatively high, that meant we had a generous benefits system for the individual, as @Cuppasoupmonster believes.

Lord no. When I got Long Covid, I suddenly found myself with £95 a week in SSP to live on. That was it. Try going from a healthy salary to just over £400 a month to live on overnight, to cover everything, while your bills remain the same. The state expected me to live on bread and beans while seriously ill and just shrugged their shoulders. Then, after the 28 week SSP allowance ran out, I went onto ESA instead - at £324 a month. Great bloody fun that was. The financial stress absolutely worsened my illness, and has had continued impacts.

Eventually, thank god, I got assessed as having LCWRA (i.e, I'm deemed long term unfit to work), which upped my allowance to £689 a month. But that was on the strength of now being so disabled I can't walk more than 50m with any reliability. The criteria to meet eligibility for the higher rate I'm on are so extraordinarily stringent that few meet them, and it does not catch everyone who is too ill to work, who are suddenly thrown into poverty living a mean little existence on £324 a month, with no ability to improve their circumstances.

PIP is even worse. It's literally designed to deny as many people as possible, and the assessors set out to do so.

I can't begin to describe just how inhumane our benefits system is towards the long term ill. It's been utterly demoralising having to fight DWP for scraps, while already chronically exhausted.

You really do feel like you're thrown on the scrap heap if you lose your ability to work. You go from being a person who is seen worthy actual respect to someone unworthy of any quality of life. Subhuman almost, or certainly a second tier. We're made to feel like we're bludging off other people's taxes. Well, no - those were my taxes. This is what we pay in for. Life throws a curveball sometimes, and it can happen to any of us. It's not my bloody fault a pandemic happened, and someone sneezed in Asda.

Part of me wishes everyone with these beliefs had their own wake up call like this, just for a few months (cruel though it may be). Our society would sure as heck be better for it afterwards.

So being on benefits and having to live or rather just about exist on a pittence isn't quite the lark that you anticipated it to be, then. Funnily enough I didn't think it would be.
At least you're being honest about it though.

Florenz · 27/12/2022 23:13

What is the alternative? Give people benefits and don't expect them to meet their commitments in terms of attending appointments etc? No matter how low you set the bar, some people will fall under it.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 27/12/2022 23:02

Florenz · 26/12/2022 18:08

I've got little to no sympathy to people who miss or are late for DWP appointments. It's literally the only thing they have to do and their money is dependent on it. Get an early bus. Set an alarm on the phone. Make it your utmost priority to be there on time. People with jobs have to be on time every day.

Well are all the suicides enough blood for you. FFS mind you don't over do the compassion.

TreadLight · 27/12/2022 22:36

@Lilyhop , for comparison, that is about the same as me earning £60k, after all the tax and NI is deducted, and without the free car. It's essentially a lower middle class income, and you are right. It is more than enough to live a comfortable life.

And I have to fill in a ridiculous tax return each year to make sure I am contributing an appropriate amount.

Lilyhop · 27/12/2022 20:36

I currently live on benefits and I feel it’s enough to live on - for our situation personally- but also agree with PP’s saying how hard it is with a disability.
Despite one of of my four children being severely disabled, we still have to fill in a ridiculous 40 odd page form for DLA every few years, with ‘evidence.’
I get £69 a week carers, my sons on the highest DLA which is roughly £380 a month. On top of that is child benefit for 4 and universal credit.
The total I get each month is around £3400.
we also have higher mobility so we have a car that we only pay petrol for, and a new car every 3 years.
but for a single disabled adult, or couple/single without children, it’s abysmal.

XenoBitch · 27/12/2022 20:33

"If he was suicidal, it wasn’t the fault of the benefits system. if he wasn’t suicidal, a “brutal” benefits system could not make him hang himself.
Suicidal people will always have a reason.
Its sad, but nobody else is to blame for this. I speak as someone who moved across the country for a man, ended up unemployed and was ultimately left to starve. I didn’t hang myself because I’m not mentally vulnerable"

You don't have to have a mental illness or be mentally vulnerable to feel suicidal.

People kill themselves in prison, people kill themselves to escape a painful situation.

No money and no hope can drive someone to take that final step. No amount of pills or therapy could change that in some cases because it is a life issue, and not a mental health issue.
The man in the OP would not have killed himself if he was not having issues with benefits

XenoBitch · 27/12/2022 20:26

Sugarplumfairy65 · 27/12/2022 20:05

I live in a full uc area too but I'm in the support group and have been for over 5 years

Then you claimed ESA before your area went full UC. I rang the number to claim ESA, and was told it was no longer available and I had to go down the UC route.
I think my area was full UC for a year before I tried to claim.

Eventually, everyone on ESA will be moved to UC. My understanding is was that 2023 was the year for this, but it has been moved.

I have a friend on ESA who moaned he did not get the £20 uplift.. but there is no Severe Disability Premium on UC, so on ESA he was still better off even without the uplift.

HiyaCaath · 27/12/2022 20:17

ThreeblackCats · 26/12/2022 14:19

If he was suicidal, it wasn’t the fault of the benefits system. if he wasn’t suicidal, a “brutal” benefits system could not make him hang himself.

Suicidal people will always have a reason.

Its sad, but nobody else is to blame for this. I speak as someone who moved across the country for a man, ended up unemployed and was ultimately left to starve. I didn’t hang myself because I’m not mentally vulnerable.

Really? Try having an illness where you can’t really work without it meaning that you can’t look after yourself/travel/have to live in places you can’t use the bathroom because you can’t walk up stairs etc but have to because despite a diagnosed terminal illness you’re told you’re ‘fine’ then come back.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 27/12/2022 20:05

XenoBitch · 27/12/2022 16:20

Disabled on UC did get it though. That is what I was saying. You didn't get it as you are not on UC.
I am not entitled to ESA as I live in a full UC area.

I live in a full uc area too but I'm in the support group and have been for over 5 years

Cheeseandlobster · 27/12/2022 19:40

usernamealreadytaken · 27/12/2022 19:21

@Puppamumma the benefits system is hardly cruel if somebody can choose to leave their job, claim money to live on and not be required to know the actual laws around whether they are entitled or not 🙄

The ignorance in this post. I am not even going to bother other than saying educate yourself maybe before posting next time