Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel conflicted enabling their obesity/poor health.

37 replies

Marina234 · 26/12/2022 13:23

I feel like a dick for this but need to get it off my chest without upsetting my relative.

Close female relative has been 23 stone+ all her life. Now has severe hip osteoarthritis bilaterally and needs replacements 10-20 years below the usual age for joint replacement.

This is entirely due to chronic morbid obesity but the person insists it's "genetic" because their 90 year old parent had a bit of OA hip too.

I am sensitive to this and would never criticise to their face. But now they're largely immobile they ask me to fetch them cake, biscuits etc. and if I eat anything around them they want some. I feel a bit like I'm getting vodka for an alcoholic at times or cigarettes for someone with COPD, and feel really ethically torn.

It's none of my business what they eat but it does involve me if I'm being asked to go to the shop for chocolate etc.

Due to their weight they're also potentially at risk of dying on the operating table or having severe post op complications. And I love them very much so that is hard to accept.

Also they have relatives who are alcoholics and they are extremely judgmental about anyone drinking. But this seems to be the same kind of addiction.

I have struggled with my weight my whole adult life as well. So I'm not some skinny person casting judgement.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PenanceAdair · 26/12/2022 18:56

Assuming the OP isn't this person's carer...

"Controlling" (people use this word too often nowadays) isn't the OP saying they won't fetch/buy the food; afterall OP has a right to refuse to do something. Telling her that she should get it anyway is quite "controlling".

It would be controlling if the OP also tries to stop the person from getting their food another way without the OP's help.

It's not the OP's job to force-feed them or tell them what they can or can't eat but the OP gets to decide what she can or can't do for them if it goes against her own principles. I think this is OP's dilemma.

Soothsayer1 · 26/12/2022 17:23

OneTC · 26/12/2022 15:06

I stopped facilitating a friend with alcohol in possibly similar circumstances and it was the end of our friendship.

you can perhaps conclude they werent a true friend, or thier primary loyalty is to alcohol?

ZestFest · 26/12/2022 17:18

Pothoswithasparkle

That's fab, congratulations. 😊Flowers

Mossstitch · 26/12/2022 17:15

I'm an NHS therapist who has worked on joint replacement ward and agree with @1001Daffodils. It's not as simple as a weight issue but must have some genetic influence. I was surprised at how many slim people of my kind of age now (early 60s) required joint replacements, a lot of them runners/gym/sports people who had tried to maintain a healthy lifestyle. I'm not saying being fat is healthy but I've been overweight virtually all my life, even as a child eating far less than my skinny brother and far less than a lot of my younger slim colleagues, I have low blood pressure, cholesterol and resting heart rate of late 50s despite no exercise outside of physical work. I've also known people who were very slim and controlled with their eating have strokes and high cholesterol. With the greatest of respect its not the op's responsibility to control another adult's eating and its definitely not as simple as being overweight will lead to the need for joint replacements or other health issues. I'm sure the overweight person is well aware that she shouldn't be eating junk food but op saying she won't bring it isn't going to stop her and could just lead to ill feeling.

Pothoswithasparkle · 26/12/2022 17:10

ZestFest · 26/12/2022 16:55

@Acidburn

No - I'm saying that losing weight for morbidly obese people isn't as straightforward as "eat less, move more". There's an interplay of hormones to battle against as well. I'm sure that some people have illnesses or conditions that restrict mobility which impedes weight loss and fitness. Some conditions are as a direct consequence of the obesity. Emotional and psychological factors and all sorts of trauma contribute too. It's a hugely complex area with all kinds of factors and interactions. I don't think as a society we recognise that. 😒

I have complete sympathy for the OP though because she's in such an utterly difficult position. Truth with kindness is the way forward maybe. It's really hard.

Some morbidly obese people. (Important word there)

I lost from morbidly obese by... Eating less calories (not eating less) and moving more... At one point I was quite demotivated by all this "you can't do it without surgery" etc. I left most support forums because of that. Quite a few people do lose without surgery and such.

Wrinklydinkly · 26/12/2022 17:09

Just say you care too much to exacerbate their health condition with bad food,and you would like to see them come out of surgery alive. I definitely would.unless she's already lost the will to live. Or don't go at all. It's a horrible situation to be in.

ZestFest · 26/12/2022 16:57

Have a look at this - lovely chap Simon Monkhouse - bariatric surgeon

fb.watch/hFz05_5Xnz/

ZestFest · 26/12/2022 16:55

@Acidburn

No - I'm saying that losing weight for morbidly obese people isn't as straightforward as "eat less, move more". There's an interplay of hormones to battle against as well. I'm sure that some people have illnesses or conditions that restrict mobility which impedes weight loss and fitness. Some conditions are as a direct consequence of the obesity. Emotional and psychological factors and all sorts of trauma contribute too. It's a hugely complex area with all kinds of factors and interactions. I don't think as a society we recognise that. 😒

I have complete sympathy for the OP though because she's in such an utterly difficult position. Truth with kindness is the way forward maybe. It's really hard.

Acidburn · 26/12/2022 16:32

@ZestFest So are you saying that obese people shouldn't reduce calories because it's pointless?

ZestFest · 26/12/2022 16:17

Acidburn · 26/12/2022 13:32

Maybe unpopular opinion. The problem with obesity is that most of the time people blame their medical conditions for being unfit and overweight, when, in fact, it's the other way around. People who become overweight develop conditions, as a result of being overweight. We eat way too much, we snack on crap too much. But the truth is - people don't like to hear it. If a typical overweight person halves what they eat - they will loose weight, and no medical condition will prevent this for happening. But I've met too many people who are obese and keep eating crap, because they have given up. They are trapped in a vicious circle of eating too much - gaining weight - eating too much due to hating themselves for being overweight. In my opinion, the main issue here is psychological. Once it is dealt with - then it's possible to loose weight, as long as they stop eating same amount of foods.

Read up a bit more and ask a bariatric surgeon if that's the case. Yo-yo dieting re-programmes the body's "set-weight" upwards, which tends to mean that if a morbidly obese person loses a significant amount of weight then the body and brain will do everything hormonally and chemically to regain that weight. It's not as simple as reduce your calories, it truly isn't.

That said, OP, I completely understand where you're coming from. It's a terribly difficult and sensitive subject. I do think with gentleness and compassion you could explain how conflicted you are, though.

BeanyBops · 26/12/2022 16:12

I say this in a loving way.

Overeaters Anonymous is life saving.

AnneLovesGilbert · 26/12/2022 16:05

Do you live with her? Are you scared of how she’ll behave towards you if you say no? If you don’t provide the unhealthy food will someone else? That’s all relevant context but I wouldn’t want to implicate myself in someone eating themselves into an early grave, no matter how emotionally tough it might be to say no. And I do feel for you, it must be very difficult.

5128gap · 26/12/2022 16:02

This is a difficult one. On one hand I get you don't want to enable, but on the other, there feels something 'off' about using the circumstances of someone's reliance on you to try to control their behaviour.
If you refused to pick up these foods, she could presumably do an on line shop. Or could continue over eating non treat foods, so its not really going to achieve anything. Obesity isn't addressed by blocking the persons access to food, its way more complex, and needs to start with the obese person themselves. She sounds a long way from where she'd need to be to start that process.

Athenen0ctua · 26/12/2022 15:54

I would only eat in front of them where necessary, such as if we lived together or at a meal time. Then only healthy food, I wouldn't even have a biscuit with coffee if I had to offer them one. Same as drinking around an alcoholic. I wouldn't buy or fetch their 'drug' either.

mynameisnotkate · 26/12/2022 15:40

I have OA in my knees and my doctor is very clear that whilst nothing can be done about the underlying damage, the way in which it manifests can be influenced hugely by lifestyle choices and weight is by far the most important. I keep my weight healthy and work quite hard on my core and glute strength to protect my knees and keep generally fit, and it’s almost unnoticeable at the moment. I’m know it’s not always that easy and mine my get worse, but there’s a huge amount you can do to mitigate OA.

DuplicateUserName · 26/12/2022 15:12

You've left out some really important info here.

Do you live with her?

Must she see you eating?

PenanceAdair · 26/12/2022 15:12

The answer would depend on who you are to this person. Obviously you shouldn't be enabling any behaviour that is detrimental to someone's health, whether they like it or not.

If you can, don't put yourself in the position to be asked.

OneTC · 26/12/2022 15:06

I stopped facilitating a friend with alcohol in possibly similar circumstances and it was the end of our friendship.

LonginesPrime · 26/12/2022 14:28

You say it's none of your business, but it sounds like you're either living with them or their carer, and it's obviously troubling you. It sounds like your issue is that you feel like you shouldn't say anything but that it is actually affecting you too.

My advice would be to have a frank discussion with them, but be prepared for it not to be well-received. It doesn't sound like it's sustainable for things to continue as they are, so your main options are to say something or remove yourself from the situation so that you're not complicit.

If you don't want to be complicit when they ask to share the food you're eating, you could eat healthier food around them.

And if you don't feel comfortable bringing them unhealthy food, are you able to say no or remove yourself from the situation that's placing this responsibility on you? Do they have another carer or other support that could mean you could step away? Are you spending time with them socially, or because you live together or because they need a carer?

Pothoswithasparkle · 26/12/2022 14:27

You don't have to help them make their health worse, and frankly after that mother was prosecuted last week for manslaughter for her daughter...I think enabling someone to eat themselves to death is precarious legal ground now and it should be

It isn't precarious legal ground unless there is a situation of someone being responsible carer like parent and child in this case. It doesn't apply to adult, adult, if the other adult is not extremely vulnerable and person is their carer, and even then it will be different matter to parent-child.

Onnabugeisha · 26/12/2022 14:13

I wouldn’t argue about the cause of their hip OA. Obesity is a risk factor, but ultimately it is wear and tear that causes OA of joints. I agree a life of being obese is why she has it earlier ‘than usual’ but that is the thing with obesity is that it speeds up the ageing process and thus the lower average age at death.

I would focus on the fact that obesity aggravates OA of the hip and makes it worse and more painful than it has to be. Also impress on her that she can get too obese for them to even do the hip replacement surgeries. I agree with urging her to eat less and to try and stay a bit mobile. I agree with not waiting on her hand and foot with cake and biscuits. See if she can take up any distracting activities (even if sedentary) as boredom inevitably leads to over eating.

Try not to be judgemental, the causes of obesity are complex and often start in childhood.

bellac11 · 26/12/2022 14:08

I think you need to give a bit more context of why you're shopping for her, are you a carer in some way? Do you live with this person?

1001Daffodils · 26/12/2022 14:08

If you're concerned, stop being complicit. Only eat healthily around them (assuming you're eating meals otherwise together, otherwise just don't eat in front of them) and if asked to fetch something for them to eat just say no and be honest about why.

I've been obese my entire adult life. There is something that stops some people from ever being a healthy weight (honestly if you saw what I eat and how much exercise I do you wouldn't believe I'm telling the truth vs my size/weight/BMI) but that doesn't mean I just say "fuck it" and eat everything in sight. I still try to give my body the best options, and if your close relative is remotely bothered about the OA they should be doing the same.

You don't have to help them make their health worse, and frankly after that mother was prosecuted last week for manslaughter for her daughter...I think enabling someone to eat themselves to death is precarious legal ground now and it should be

absolutelyknackeredcow · 26/12/2022 14:00

So I had a hip replacement under 40. I was born with a hip problem which got substantially worse when I had kids.
I'm 5ft 11 so tall and post op there is no way I can be more than 11 and a half stone because my hip starts hurting. That's a BMI of 21 ish

Weight massively impacts joints so you are helping her by saying no

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/12/2022 13:54

Would it cause you particular discomfort to not eat cake or chocolate (for example) in front of your mother?

It's a known sabotage tactic to consume/use something an addict struggles with in front of them - even when they're trying to not give in to temptation, never mind when they aren't at that point psychologically. Just look at threads where somebody will say they've joined a gym/tried to eat more healthily/lose some weight and their husband has decided it's the perfect time to bring in takeaway pizza, ice creams, buy boxes of chocolate 'because you deserve a treat'. Or they say 'why should I go without because you can't control yourself?'.