Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset my inheritance is reduced

812 replies

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 11:18

I have very generous parents who worked extremely hard to ensure their kids were looked after. When we came of age (21) they told us how much each of us would inherit when we're turned 40. My sister asked for them to give a her a lump sum equal to her share so she could buy a house and they did that. When my brother turned 25, her asked for half of his share ao her could put down a deposit for a house and have enough cash to cover a 3 year sabbatical which they did. I haven't asked for anything as I was happy to wait till I turned 40. I started working when I was 16 so I have always been more financially secure than my siblings but im a freelancer which makes work difficult to come by and i also have 2 under 2. I'd planned to take 6 months maternity then go back to work in January but I'm shattered. My body, soul are exhausted from back to back pregnancies. I turn 40 in Feb so I was hoping to use my inheritance to take another year off, get therapy and sort my self out without financial pressure. DH works hard but his income alone won't cover us if I'm not earning.

Anyway, yesterday (Christmas!) my parents asked if they could reduce my inheritance sum as my brother 'needs it more'. He's just gone through a divorce (he cheated) and his ex-wife took him to the cleaners. His business went under during Covid and he hasn't worked in 2 years although he could get a job if he chose to. He claims he can't go back to working for someone else after having been his own boss for 10 years.

I'm devasted. My parents insist I don't have to say yes but I don't feel like i have much of a choice. I haven't stopped crying since.

OP posts:
GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 26/12/2022 12:33

Sorry but this is their money, that THEY EARNED. It is not yours by right. Or entitlement. It is their choice to do whatever they want to do with it. They can leave it all to charity if they want.

I understand you feel a bit slighted, but you could have asked for it early as your siblings did. And you say you are financially secure, so you don't actually need it anyway.

Sounds a bit like a bit of foot-stamping and 'But it's not FAIR' going on, to be honest. Rise above it. You're 40.

icelollycraving · 26/12/2022 12:33

I think I got confused with the amount and your birthday!

usedtolovenaps · 26/12/2022 12:33

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 12:31

It honestly didn't feel like i have a choice because he either uses my share of the 'inheritance' or uses the rest of his or gets a job. My parents reason that he'll need the rest of his share for himself and his children. I agree with them on that.

If I don't agree to sharing with him, I'll most likely be seen to be unwilling to chip in to help a family member in distress which is awful, you see, especially since I should be so grateful to be getting any money at all. Besides if I were to go back to work, I'd make so much money so quickly since I'm the little hard worker. Mum had 3 kids back to back and she managed!

We're fucked up.

He needs to get a job.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 26/12/2022 12:33

I think I would push the decision back into their court. Say its totally up to them what they do but that you think favouring one sibling over another usually ends up destroying family relationships and that you fear that will be the case here.

MamaFirst · 26/12/2022 12:33

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 12:25

He still has his 50% of his share but he's saving it for his future apparently. And may parents are right in thinking he'll need every help he can get if he carries on living like he is.

OMG!! All the worse!! Absolutely unacceptable, this alone should be your answer. He has his 50% end of discussion.

rosiebl · 26/12/2022 12:32

I don't understand why he's saving his other 50% but is happy to spend some of yours? How odd. If you had a plate of food and brother said 'I think I will eat your plate instead of mine, I'm saving mine for later', everyone would laugh and tell him to stop being ridiculous. Surely you just say to your parents.
"I had a think about this and really for fairness, brother should just get his own 50% share now to spend as he wishes and I should get 100% of mine. I had planned to spend mine on XYZ when I turn 40 in January as you previously promised me". It's a really simple conversation?

Cotonsugar · 26/12/2022 12:32

So much judgment on here and most haven’t even read what you have written properly or have chosen not to. I have three children and they will all inherit the same amount. I would tell your parents that they should give you what your siblings have had/will have. Your brother’s problems are for him to solve😐

Soubriquet · 26/12/2022 12:32

Just stand firm and say no. Tell them he already had his. He could have saved it like you did but he didn’t and if he is too proud to go back to work for someone else, it’s his own stupid fault

FatEaredFuck · 26/12/2022 12:32

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 12:25

He still has his 50% of his share but he's saving it for his future apparently. And may parents are right in thinking he'll need every help he can get if he carries on living like he is.

The fuck? So your brother can access a large pot of savings but instead your parents think it's a better idea for you just to give him cash?

Say no and keep it purely business like - that's how they've set up this arrangement, YANBU for saying "I've considered it but we have plans for the inheritance. If brother is in need he can access his portion".

Oblomov22 · 26/12/2022 12:31

Grow a back bone, stand up for yourself. Say no. I appreciate that brother is dealing with xxx but I myself have ....

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 12:31

It honestly didn't feel like i have a choice because he either uses my share of the 'inheritance' or uses the rest of his or gets a job. My parents reason that he'll need the rest of his share for himself and his children. I agree with them on that.

If I don't agree to sharing with him, I'll most likely be seen to be unwilling to chip in to help a family member in distress which is awful, you see, especially since I should be so grateful to be getting any money at all. Besides if I were to go back to work, I'd make so much money so quickly since I'm the little hard worker. Mum had 3 kids back to back and she managed!

We're fucked up.

OP posts:
WineDarkNo308 · 26/12/2022 12:30

They told you at 21 how much you would inherit at 40 and then gave your siblings all or some of their inheritance. Well that was pointless putting the age limit on it. Always knowing that there’s a potential lump sum coming your way will always have an effect on the mindset of you and your siblings. Your parents have said you don’t have to agree, so if the money means that much to you, tell your parents that. You’re not entitled to anything just because they said you could have X amount nearly 30 years ago, so many things could’ve happened leaving you without anything. Ultimately though it’s a handout not an inheritance and it’s their decision how they choose to use their money.

Pollywoddles · 26/12/2022 12:30

Could you not take a portion now and the balance due to you taken from the estate when they pass? If that’s not possible then I’d be saying no, your brother has brought this situation on himself and can easily resolve it.

Littlegoth · 26/12/2022 12:30

Just say no. It’s not fair for him to spend your share while hanging on to the other half of his own.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/12/2022 12:29

I come from a culture where helping family is expected and he is the darling Prince

Cross posted with you, OP - in that case double what I said about them probably bailing him out anyway no matter what you say

As for "He still has his 50% of his share but he's saving it for his future apparently" I'd doubt that very much. Far more likely he's simply blown it and is now back for more

deeperthanallroses · 26/12/2022 12:29

Oh my god so he still hasn’t used 50% of his share and wants yours instead? Don’t be such a doormat op, say this is ridiculous just give him the rest of his share if he wants money, his choice to save it and you’d like your share please!

Tropicaliyes · 26/12/2022 12:29

Wait what I am hearing from this is that your parents have 3 kids and have an equal inheritance for you all that would arrive once you all got to 40. Your sister already used a lump sum, and your brother took half and you haven’t taken anything?

So technically speaking… you have the full amount, your sister has some and your brother has half of this inheritance left now?

you also said your brother asked for his share so he could put a down payment on a house (plus sabbatical) however your now feeling somewhat guilty and pressured to take less inheritance because he is in a dinky flat that cannot host his kids who’s mother he separated from because he cheated on her?

Im sorry but I also have a brother and sister, I don’t have any inheritance (and my siblings might I’m not sure) but regardless, if my situation played out like yours I would kindly decline to take less inheritance due to your brothers shortcomings because really and truthfully he decided to take half his money early, seems like he spent it incorrectly then decided to fuck up again by cheating, leaving himself destitute and having to live with his consequences.

He is a full grow adult now just like the rest of you and ultimately he made his bed so will have to sleep in it, he still has half his money left if I read correctly so ultimately let him take what he left himself and get himself out of his own mess! As you said, your sister wasn’t asked because they know full well she won’t bite, so don’t be a push over, put your foot down and for once tell your parents it’s unacceptable that you should consider loosing an equal inheritance you patiently waited for unlike your siblings just because your brother messed up big time. I’d be telling them you all had your chance to play the situation as you wished and you chose to not “cash in” early and so you would like to get your full amount in a few years when your 40th comes.

like PPs have said, I think either way you play it, your relationship could be rocky regardless however don’t let it be rocky , with you pulling the short end of the straw and being totally unhappy with the decision to loose piece just to fix a situation your brother put himself in (especially since your not all having to loose out to help him, it’s just you).

icelollycraving · 26/12/2022 12:29

Random 50k there ^

CaptainBarbosa · 26/12/2022 12:28

I'd say no, and explain your situation and the plans you have for the money.

Your parents have asked rather than informed, giving you the opportunity to decline.

My brother cashed in what would be his inheritance from our grandmother to pay some debts.

I cashed in some of it take DS to Disneyland, but I took nan and my mum with us 😂 and I've told nan I'd rather she build memories with me and, mum and DS with the money than us just have some money when she's gone. She seems fully onboard with this idea (no surprise) and we're off on holiday again all together next year to a destination of her choice. 🤣 I'm basically fore fitting my inheritance in favour of memories, but I'm absolutely ok with this. Nan has worked all her life and she's 80 next year, I want her to enjoy not worry about piles of money to dish out equally. Money comes and goes is my life motto.

So just talk to you parents OP.

icelollycraving · 26/12/2022 12:28

I’d say you actually felt upset that the Christmas Day before your ‘inheritance’ they chose to discuss it. To make you feel like you had to clean up after your brother. As an adult, he made his choices. As an adult, you’re making yours, so you’re saying no, you are very grateful for this gift.
It won’t keep him going for long, then what is his plan?
Have you told them what you were planning? If also ask them if they would have put the suggestion to your other sister or if she’s being asked for to fund an adult man who is capable of sorting his life out.
I hope they have a will in place to determine their financial plans for any money left. Do they own a home? He will be wanting that.
His ex wife presumably got what she deserved after her husband cheated and left their family devastated, not ‘taken to the cleaners’
Are they not grateful their GC have a parent who is actually being responsible unlike their foolish son. Perhaps that is too hard to accept.
I would say they offered this as a fair way of stopping inheritance squabbles but they are happening, but whilst they are alive and they are enabling it. 40k some years ago was worth more than 50k now. 40k in a house will have grown so much in equity!

AftersomeAdvice234 · 26/12/2022 12:27

That’s a really difficult position to put you in. It’s up to you- if you say no you look and feel like a greedy bad person if you say yes then it’s done you out but they get to make themselves feel better by believing they gave you a choice, when in actual fact it really is not.

how about wording it this way?

’I would live to help DB out especially because of his situation but I do need to the money to cover maternity leave and taking time off from work so I can be with the kids while they are young. etc.

I have made these plans based on the money you promised and without it I will likely be in debt / struggle financially. I would really love to give the kids these memories of our time together when they are young.’

good luck op, I would love to know how the conversation goes. it’s a really crap thing to do to you and regardless of how well you try to manage this I’m afraid there will be some falling out but I really do not believe you should feel bad.

NoSquirrels · 26/12/2022 12:27

pompei8309 · 26/12/2022 12:18

She’s got other two siblings who did not think of that when they took their share, why would she worry about that? i assume they have a property that can be sold and the money used towards their care if needed

I’m just saying that in this position I would worry my parents were not sufficiently provided for themselves in their old age.

Unless you’re absolutely minted, and can afford to give loads of cash away and then some, even if you own a property then you need funds to maintain your property, etc. There’s a big gulf between initial retirement and ‘selling the house for care costs’ and they sound a bit naive about finances to me.

It would concern me. I’d still want the share my siblings had been given, but I’d be worried about what will actually happen in their old age.

But perhaps they are minted enough not to need to worry. Doesn’t sound like it, or they’d just give the brother more without mentioning it.

shinynewapple22 · 26/12/2022 12:27

I think you need to be honest . At the end of the day your brother made his decision to have part of his money at age 25. Do you think this decision by your parents has been influenced by your brother ?

PikachusSmarterBrother · 26/12/2022 12:26

Tell you parents what you said you hoped to do in your OP. And tell your brother to get a job.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/12/2022 12:26

They want to spend all their hard earned money while they are still alive. Everything left after they die goes to charity. To think they thought this would stop their children from squabbling over an inheritance

It might have done if they'd been more even handed about it, but the way this is being handled is a recipe for resentment - and that's from someone who doesn't believe anyone should expect money

Unfortunately, even if you say no, it's quite possible they'll bail DB out anyway, but with a side order of "unkind DD didn't want to help"
The good news is that you're financially independent of them anyway; that's a positive thing, so well done for all the work you've put into your own financial security and keep in mind that living off someone else's money isn't always the best way